← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15456/2024dismissed

Union Of India And ORS v. Jc 275674h Sub Sanjay Kumar Mohantha

2024-11-28Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

  

          

   !"#$%&' 

  !$%$(%)#$%&' 

      



   !

" # $% %!&! '(&)  



 *&  +,*  --

- .

  +,* - --  - * ,-+ ./0 % 12 2 

2 4

4

*

6 % 12

+3 +782



- .

 /    &1 -,1

2 :

* * )6

+23 2/

;-2 ,6  +

+2+ <

'

=- )3

42

>+ 

& .-

842>



:2

244:+

0)1(020)34!$(%#    ? >/

 @@

5

2 1241 - 8-

1 8-

+ 

 2 :2

,+

78

@

 > ,3

:2

A<

45 42 +

< 4> 842>

:2

?8+ >* -1 /3

:2

1

 5

42* 

> 1

 5

5

2**24

C   2,2

?8

4> 842>3 1:7

2**24 :2

> .2

:2

-

 54

2> :1 *

?- 582

+42/  4 7+3

 54+ 3 .5 42

>+ 

& .-

1 81244 25

?8

)

3 .82> 244:+ 7+

+2+ < * 27

= 28+ 1 25   

  

     

   







 

  



  

     

   



  

 



         ! 

    



 

   

  



 

  

    "        

  

#

 

 

 

   









! 





  









 $ 

! 

 



# 

  

   



   



  

          

 

   

    



         

  

 !"

  $ %&'  

(  ) 

*  #" 

 %%&'  4 7+ 25

 2)3 42

>+ 

& .-

< * 

+2

54+ 2,2

2 :

*

.5

 %5!%) $5167 $(!1 "5 8+ >2D

5587 2+?-+82

:

* 5-4

2

+ > :11

.5244> 7 E7

>>.

+5

43

44+

>/3 * 24

2,3

.8> 4 +3

>>.

8>.22 +5 2.4 1>

2>

>2 +8+3 / 2**  -*

4 > 1

-2.4 1

24

-2.4

28;- >3 8*4

 1

?-+,>

! F.4 *=

4+

+  " , 

(  )  3

* +

- .

,!!

0

472 2, 2*1

7 +8 = 28+ 1 25  %()    

 #  #



 

#

 *    + -  .

    

       

   



 #



  

#

 

  

  



  #



 

#

   /    



%0#  !  $        

   

     #

  

  

#

    



 

 1  

2   3

 )

(4%5  )

6/77,2   89-

-  ) 

  

     

  



 

 

    

#

  

   

  

  

7   



 

$ 





  

#

 

 

 

    

 

 

 

#

:2 ;<2 &,-=

-  >      

       

 



    

            



     / 

 

     

   )



   

 

     

 

 

 

 

     ,2 (- #-7 









# 



# 

 

#

     







  

 

#





   

  

  



   

      





   

 

#

:2 &, -= ,#-7      

  







   

  

?

 



  

 

#







 

 

?



 

  

# 

 

#

:&,-= ,# -7 



 

 



  # 



 

 6

     



 

#

 



  

# 

  

#

 @

A 

 $ 

      :&,-=B  ,#

-7

    @

A   





    /77  5C

@

,@  3

 - %%D51  

+C

 3

 



8 4 ( 



 #   9

 



        $         #          



  

'

C

8 7

2+ ,'

) 2.7 = 28+ 8*4 1-,1 * +4/ 3

24+

>>.

8>.22 +5 2.4 1> :181

 =

7 -* 1-,1

-81 2.4+ >>.

724++ >/3 / 1

, 5

@

 14

, >

>>.

8>.22 +5 2.4 1> :1

24+ :1

;-2 ->

> 3 >* 274/

2

+3

++4/ 8

22

.8>

2

?

1  

2   3

 )

(4%5 )

6/77,2   89-



- > 3 1-,1

->*

,

/F/#

*1/ 824 > 24 1241 >>.

+5 2.4 1>

*8244/

2,

.8>

44+3



8 2.-

.8>  :1  % 7 1-,1

5-

->*

+ 2



88-

-.

;- 4/3

12** + 2 )



3

->+

;-4

78

>>.

+5 2.4 1>  >* 274/3

7

+:>

;-2 5

/F/#

+

>*4/

3

>2

+ ,+3 -* 842>2

4+

87

% 7 528

8 8-> 2

2 +2

78

84 4/

- G+3

:11



 7 E7

;-4 ;-2

78 +6

2>



"

>2/3

 1 5-

8*4'

) /

24

4/

 > 288*2

>



.8>

8 ++ 7 27

 :1 :181 1:7

84-++ /



1> 5 4 + .) 5-

+ 2

5 >2/

-.

;- 4/ 84-++ +3



78

2> 24   

- 5 >+824 *

14+

8-4+

 127 .

+8+

>+824 =2> 2

>2+3

.8> 4 +

-*

2> :44

 +>+ 127

+-

/

-2

2)3

2

84-+ ,

< % 7

>2 +2

544:

,-+4

42+ +:

12*  HI-+ '%42 

)3

J H( 4> I  8*4 H 

5 3

:

+ > :11

>

2.7 8*4 :11

> 4 >

>/3

25

4> >+824 =2> 2

>2+

//#



12413

 .82>

8 ++ 2.-

>  1> +6

:11

>

 .82> 2** ++

:2

+ >2

2, % 7

+ > 528

+3 :11

82-

=-

 -*

3 +6



5

44>

2D *4283

//#

287

1>

>2/ 84-+



:2

;-4

78

>/

-81 :2

.82>



2++

,21

8 :11

+3 ++ 244/ 8+ >2D +24+ 8 7 8+ 24 818D3 8-42 4/ 2** 2 2+7 3 1 -,1 >*4/>

2 >+824 81 ;-

74 .48D 812

8

8 5

.82>

8+ % 7 5

>*4/> 524  -42 4/3

>2/ 84-++ ;-2 -*

53

-.

;- 2**  4 > 2D *4283

:2

 24 :+

,

78 +

.8> >2

 4/3 5

>*4/+ 81 ;-

2, 2**  4 > 2D *4283

42+

84-

+ >2 8+

3 /

+ >2

 1. 4 >

4

>/3

27/

2

8  -42 4/

-.

;- 287 +8 6 -*

5 +- 8-

:-4+

2- 244/ 42+ :44 84-

+3

287 -*

.82>

8+

5587 82- 8

8

:-4+ 24

 !:7

+27-

= 28

*

.82>

8 ++ 42 +

,2 +3

472

2, 2*1

 >*-,

+2+ <

= 28+ 1 25 0 % 

#

 7

 )  #  

   

 

 



  %(%%% 

#

 G@

  ,3/%-    



 7 .

  %&   2  ,H* -  

 

  

 3

 

 '  

 G @

 A   



   

#

    2  

@

A @I *

2     %%%  >  

 6

     2  

@

  A      

      1 

2



       

    #



 

#

   

  

     

  !  

    

 

  

  



) ,) 6 )/&-

  

  





   

 

!  '

 

2+

8

724

> 2**  4 > 2D *428

 .82> >2+

>

8*4

! F.4 *=

4+

+  " , 

(  ) -  .

@ +3

> :181 1:7 ++

 .+

4 +

>/3 ++ >2D

4>

 5

3 2

42:

?-+,>

->*

8-

:2

;-4

527- 2.4/ +:+ 7 27

 &1-,1

->*

.-2.4

42+ 7+

.-

->*

.82>

* !:7

7+ 2++-8 ,

7 27

8, 4/

.-

->*

2- 244/ ++

+-/

+3 ,2, 45

+27-

,3 1 -,1 >*4/>

2 .48D 812

8 82-

8

81 ;-'

)3

>2/ .82>

274+

 >/

43 .82>

8+ 8+ 24 8 52>4/ / % 7

:2

2+

>+824 *

:44 >+

:2

24 .82>

1

.82>

C !:7

2+ *

2)3 84

.

8 ++

 /*+ >

127 .

8 ++ = 2)  2+4/3

7+

.- ->*

.

4+ *

2 ,7

:,12, *

>+824 .2 +3

= 28+ 2) 

*8-- 4/3

+

,

44 >+

+







;-4 8+ 24 8 52>4/ /  4/3

2++

.8>

78



@

% 7 1-,1

2+

'

) 88-

:14

78 .82> >+ +5

4

23

=*

>2 +2

472

,-42

:181 >2D



'

)

*28 23

 ., 5-

;-4

-813 F



++



78

.82>

;- 83 428D

=*

>2 +2

,-42

+

2

84-+3 7

5



'

)

88-

*28 23 ./3



-

>

?-+,>

*=

4+

(  ) 

*  #" ?

 

 % ,!!

3 /04 :1

2

>2+ = 5

553

+:+

+  -42 4/ -

+52 .4

,1 .82> 7 +

D ;-2 2** 

55 >2+

527-



(7

1 :

2

42:

>2+

7 +8 >2D

2

=* -42

42:



>3 =* -42

42:

>3

>2+

7 +8 >2D

-

5

5

7 27

+5

4

3 

  

4

>

D  +:>

>2+ -

3

5-44 8>*4>

*4 -

+

*87 .2 5 /3 +42/ 4281

5 3  5 2** 

553

>

7 +8

& .-

+



-55

44,24/

-*14+

7%02 !#!$5167 $(!1 <

25 >213

5

>

:

*

:1 .

72

2.73

2>

>

+  >*-,

42

& .-

>2 2 255 >+

  24 ,:1 2**482 )3 5 /     -

- .

 

-  - * ' 

  K 11

*2D ,6 + 0 # 6 11

* 2.4 # 6