High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12022/2018dismissed

Jiwan Lal And ANR v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2022-02-03The Chief Justice,Mr. Justice Arun Palli12 pages

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 1

!" #$% & '()*

+&,&&-&. / ( 0(1( 2& &3&&&-.( / (4-(

()5 $ 4&6&(&7-'&7 . ( $ 61$&7-- -'&&7&3&&+. $ 2&1&8.$&97(((&-'&&&3&&7 +.$( :1(.&-4:&1$&'.&-&7-'&7 .(4-( ". & (&- 4(' ( 89 '-- .19. - ' '9 (' . 4'-9(&89'-1'-1&1% ;;;;;; .'(3-.<&&.&-(&1- . &44'&83 2' % 9. & <4(& &- &(4&'3 ,&- '>1(7 .&8& &- (< '7

*. &'( .'&(+..&+&-1-('

. ,&- '>1( '7 !?= +&( &1'-

* < .& 3&(4.'<<'< .'

=&- &('--83.4(7..4(((( .&-(&6 '<4(& .&( 8 4&-A-4(- . 7 . &'>1( 4'-9(>1&.&->1(.&&4(-+ 2' % .'

1..4(.&(19.>1&(.9 .- -&- = ?

B-+.'..'&< .41-(' % '

*+&(C'-

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 2

. '(3 '44- 14 &1- 4& 2'

% '

*+&(41&(83&(1'. .D8 214< 1 -& '&(

.83&39-+4'4( -'&9.&'>1(-<-.&8&4(-1-(' % '

. 4E 1 .&( -('1((- -& & . &(4'( '((&3&-& 49(' % '

*7.( 9&- '(89<&-.''1-94&&9&4. .C1-9< +.'.(4-1'-.8+)5 F/

! "

# $#$ " %

" !"

! &' ! "(

) !"

! & " % ) % %% !! *"

( " ) ! " ' "(

# $#)$! "

! & "

! +

! ) & , % -. "

#$ ) %

) -. -., ! "/ "( "

#$ ! "

! & 0

" % "

! ! ! "

" ! "

' ! ) 0"

) %' " ) 0' "

)

'!"

)

' ) 0

,* 1 1 !"

#$ ! "

! & "

! "

" , "/" ! 2

#$ " ) % "

3 ! (

)!" # %$ ! !" !

"/ "

! "

! +

) "

"""% !

! &" ) ( "

& ! 4 "/ "

! +

) ! !

' "

& ! "

")( 52 !"

#" $

! "/ "("!2 % "

3 ! (!! '"

! & ) 6 %6

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 3

! !" ! "/ "

! +

7 " ) "

& # $ ! "

' "

"/ "

#$ 2 2 ! "

" , ) ( "

)

( "

& # $4%% ! ""

%( !" ! ( "

' " "

"( "

#$! "

! & , "

#$! "

! &

) ! "

#$ ! "

# $#)$ 8 , ! 0( "

#$)%(! / 9 :"%)

0( "

! "

! +

' ( "

#$ ! "

! &'" ) 0 "

#$ + , ! "

#$ ( ! ! "(

") " ! "

0 "

! ! )! "

! & " !"' "(! "/ ( % ""

, ! ) " ! ) " ) *"

#$! "

! & (

% " ! "

/ ( ! ""

"( ! "/ "

"( ( !!" ! "

! &' '

2) "

% / ( ! ! 0(

"( ! ! "

! " "/ . . E4( &+ <&- . & (&- C1-9< '& 8 (1<<&G-. +9<& <'&3.4'4(&- -+83.(1'.)5 "&% & .( '&(( +. . &'>1( 4'(( .&- 8 &-81.&+&-.&(8&1'-1-('

.' !?=7.-& '<<'< .'

=7.(&4( 4'-9(&-.

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 4 (&< + '17 .+7 +. . - .& . '<4(&.&(8-<-1-.4(( '

.('&((+..&+&-1-('

.' !?=.&(8&1'-4'<<'< .'

*7.4(( .'

*+1-.& 8&9&44'&&-.4'-9(+'1 (4' .( '&((7 &( 7 . ' !?= .&( 8 4&- "8% . +- FD 1(- 8+ . 8. . '9'( (' % .'

* ( 8 &- &( -. &( -. +.'. <&( .& (6 &4(9 . &'>1( 4'-9(8..'9'(<1(8 1 - $&9 .837 .& . 4(((( .&- 8 &6 81 . '<4(& +&( '-7 . +1- 8 &4( 2<&37 '<4(&.&(8&''4-81.4(((( .&( 8 &67 . +1- 8 &4(9 #!"

&&#$! 3( $ "'% ( &&(.&(4' '<4(& .&-&'>1-( ''-7 . D8 214< 1 -& .&( '&9'&38(-.&.E4((4&-.<&4& (' % .'

*-('1-&-4( '<4(&'1 .&(>1-84-(.&. '<4(&&<1+&(--+.'..&(8E4&- &.&.-9 .&<1+1-<&.& .&<1(<&-&&&8.&-+&-.&+1- 8&-('.&9 .89&<&6.4&3<&-.& (1'. & 4( '& 8 4&G- . - &1

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 5 <&69.4&3< . 9('* "

%7* "

%7*= .' !?=&-'<4&9.<+..4&&<&& 4(( (' @ &- ! . '

*7 . D84E1.&('& -.&.3'(>1' 54&3< '<4(& ( <&6 . 4&3< (&(4('*= .' !?= .D8 2.&( 1.'& -.&'.4&3< '<4(& .&( 8 -A-- 1- (' * "

%7 . &'>19 &1.3'&84&G- 54&3<&(.&<1 .&(<&14&--1 1(&&''483.&-+ '& 3 1.7.D82.&( 1.8(-.& & &-+.&( -. ' .9.'<4(&. '&'&<.&.+&(4&-.&<1 "-% .&-9.4((' = .'

*8 4& (' % .'

*7.D8214< 1.&('& -.&'&(7. 4&3<.&(8 <&- 81 -4(-7 &83 4&3 &<1 &9 +. ((18((&- -4(- <&C3 .-9( 3&(<7'<4(&1-.'

*.&( 84&-.&-+(&(.-& '& &- &'>1(1-('= .' !?= 9&-9. -4(7.&(8'& - .C1-9<.& . .9. '<4(& +7 . <3 (.1- .&8-4(-+..,&-'>1(' . &(13 . 1 +. (4' <&C3 &- .-9(7 <&9 .83 +&( -4(- &3 . . <-( +. (4' <&C3 .-9(7 . .9.

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 6 '<4(&+ +781(1-('*= .' !?=+1-8.'(>1' "% (9&-(.<- &694((((7.D8214< 1 .&- '& - .& -&+9 >1( 4A <<&-1< +1- <& .& 4.3('& 4(((( .&( 8 &6 .&++.9&-(9 &-.&('&9&8 &-.-.&'.4((((.&(8&61- (' B . ' !?=7 . &- ( . 2& &- .'&8&3-(9&4(9 " % .'<419.9&44- 3&(8+.-& &+&-&-'<<'< .'

*7&3< - (18((9 ( 8 E'1-- +.'. <&( .& & E'1-9 . < -7 . 45>1( 9&44- H 3&( ( .7 . 4(( (' % '& 8 6- "9% .D81.&( 1.'& -.& .&'>1( &- .&- & 8 '.&9- &- . &'>1( +&( 14.-7 +.'. <&( . 4'-9 (- ''1--7 . 1<8&4' (' % .'

*'& 86&(-((&&-<8&-'&<( ".% 4&& **@7 . D8 1 .&( <&- '& .& . 4( (' % . '

* ( <& 8 6-83.8 '&( &-+(+.+'-- (&.< ((1&' '&1-('= . ' !?= 3 (18(>1 41'.&(7 .- .+(7'&6.4(( (' % . '

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 7 = (4.'&(41 .83.4(7.3&+( 4(((( .&-'<4(-:.&(&

AABA "

5%7

AA "=5% (1&- 0&9 9&7 .( &- (' 19& .&9 '&(( '(1' . 4( & +( . E & (.& . & (&-&- .&->1(+&(&'>1-83.2& &3&& - '&(-&- = !

((1-1-('= &-('B .,&-'>1('7 !?=7 +-83&+&--&-

* .418'414(&<37 -4<&-1G& &-&( (-&&-<<'&2'H@119&< (.'&( . (.&-(4.&9&'>1-.&->1(7.2& .&( &- &6 4(((( . &- &- -& .3 & &'1& 4.3('&4(((( .&->1( 1..&(8'-- .& . ( .& '- '<4(& &<1 &- .1(7 . &'>1(4'-9(.&&4(-+ 2' % .'

*&(8..'9'(4('8-(' % '

*& 1 - &.3.& -+48&9

B?=B

&39'.&9.&'>1(4'-9(&-.(&- + 4 +&( -(<((- 83 .( '1 - - -&- =

* .83 14.-9 . &'>1( 4'-9( .&( '-- .& . &- . '5(.&( .&( &&-3 8 &(- < . &'>1( 4'-9(---&- ?

!4&((-

@7. 7.&- .4(<&3&(8-'&- .&8&4(- &&(.4(.& -+48&9

= +.'. +&( -(4(- - - -&-B @

H-'-.4(&&-.(4-&1.( .& + C'- . (&- 4(& - (4&69 - -&-

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 8

= ?

B+.'..&(+8<419-83.4(.(& +4

'& $ 61 $&7 &- --& -'& & &44&9 . (4-52& &3&& (18<( .& . (& + 4 - & . (&' . 4( -(( 8 -(<((- & . 1( &( . 4( .&( '1( (&- <&& '.&9 . &'>1( 4'-9( + . &' .& . 4&3.-&(.&->1(&-.&.&'>1( 4'-9( (&-( 14.- 83 .( '1 83 -(<((9 . & + 4 - 83 . 4( &39 '.&9 . &'>1( 4'-9( .&+.(9&-.&(8(-83.214<1 -&

"(14&%.&(' % '

*'&81(-&(&.(&&-''1--4'-9( +..'.&9.&'>1(4'-9(.&89&83 .'1( 1. (18<( .& . ' . 4( 89.4(((( .&->1((<((&(.4(((( . &- +&( &6 & . < &1'< &+&- ( 83 '-9 &4& G&<'.& H!* -&-

( 9&-( . '<4(& &- >1( . .&( &91- .& &<1 '<4(&+&(-13-- +&(<&-&&&8.4( &- . &- +( . -(81(< <&C3 '<4(& &( + &( 9 ' &44'& 1- (' ! ' !?= (18(&&( . &'1< - '<4(& &<1 2 & &( . 4( & ''-7 -(4 - '<4(& .3 .& &''4- . (&< &- .1(7 (&- &' '& 8 &- &9&( . 2& . 7(.('.& .'9'(<-

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 9 2' = "

% . '

* & 1 - &( 4(((( . &- (&-(-13&6&-.89& .2&4&3.'<4(& (&-( -('.&9- +. . - '<4(&7 .'7 . 4&3 ( 89<&--(<((.+4 @ .(4'&'4&'-.--&- ?

! 4&((- *!

@7..&((18<-.&(&< +&( 4&((- . & +. &- 4&( + 89 9 (' % '

*&-.&1.&41'< ('

% '

*+&(.&-..&(-&+1&+&-( . &' .& . (& .&( &((&- - -&- ?

! 8 . 214<1 -&24'&,& "%

?&- .4& .C1-9<4&((-83.('1.&(8(&3--- -&- ?

.1(7.&'4&'-.(&--( && .4 !

.&9 41(- . 4&-9( 8. . '(9 4&(&-'-9.'(7+.&.(&.-.&. <& & .&- ( (>1&3 '- 83 . 4'4( &- -+ 83 . D8 214< 1 -& '&(

&- . 4&3 . 4( '&<9 &4(9 &'>1( 4'-9(-((-(<((& + .&+&--+83.D8 214<1 -&&-.(4' '8(&(<&-4&&*H? .C1-9<.(&+4(<&&&8&.(&' .4(&(.3.&&&-3(&'.&9.&'>1( 4'-9( . + 4 - 83 . 4( 8&9

B?=B

+&( -(<((- 83 .( '1 - - -&-

*<(.8314.-9.&'>1(4'-9( '7

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 10 ((.4('&8&+-4.4'-9(1- 9&8 (' % '

.19..(&+4-((8-(<((-. (91- 5<&&&8373+-<&444&&-C1-'& &(+..&3 .'9'( (' % '

*& 1 - . 4( .& '-- .& .3 & &'1& 4.3('&4(((( .&->1(7.+7(&-&<-( -(18(&'+ .4& F4.3('&4((((D<&-83 .D84E1-4<1.3"214&%+. .D81.&('&9'&3.-.&.+-4((((1(- .' !?=.&((&< <&9&(.& 4.3('&4((((1(- 2' ="

% '

..2&<&'>1(.&- &--&+(<<&-1< &694((((+.'..4('&((83 '-9 &4& G&<'.& H!* -&-

*7 .& &<1( &69 . 4.3('& 4(((( . &- &- ' . 4(((( ( &67.(&8(1(9 .&-.2& .& . &-+ &( . 4(((( . &-7 . ( & (4&((7 &- (1'. 4(((( (4&((1( .(8 &-8.& .+ 2& . 7&(8(-&8.4(((( .&->1( +&( &6 83 '-9 &4& G&<'.& H!* -&-

*7 . 7.4(((( .&-(&-(-13&6&-(&<((. 2& <&'1<8&'( . 7+.&.(&.- .&.4.3('&4(((( .&->1((&-(&6&-.1(7 (&&&8.4('-.&.3&(4(((( .&->1(

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 11

( & &( &(4' '<4(& ( ''-7 ( (4' ' (&- .(4-(.&.'<4(&&<1+&(-13-- &-+&(<&-&&&8.&-+('1-9.4( - (18(&& (&< ' .&( 8 <&- . &' .& 1 & '<4(& &<1

( @*7B7@=7==!

BA5 & &<1

( H H7 @7==@ BA5 <&C3 .'<4(&.&(8-(81(- '14-+.. &'.&.4(.& - '1-('

! ' !?= .( &'((1 '(.+.&.'<4(&+&( -13 --7 &- . 4( .& '.( ' . (&<7 +.'..3&&83' '((7.('-'9'3 4('8-(' % '

*&(9(&-.1(7&( . '9'( 4('8- (' % '

* ( 1 -7 . -<9 ' &4(9 4-- 1- (' % '

* '&86-

$ 61 $& . (9. . &'( 4&-- . +(&<.&(.<3'--.&.2&&'>1-.&- .418'414( 1G& &- (-&&-<<'& 2'H@119&< .&->1((3<1'.((&&'. .418'414(&-& '(.4&9 <+-('&-7* <+-('--9&- ('H#H@7119&<&(4.&31 4& .&'(--.(4& &91<&(-83.(4-( &- + & '<4 &9< +. . (&< &( .( ( & <4& &' 8 64 <- +. -&9 +. . '&( &(9 1 . &'>1( &- &'. . 418' 414( &- ( . (&A( &1.3+.(.8(4(-'-&811G& .&- &'>1-7& .&98(-2&

CWP No. 12022 of 2018 (O&M) 12

( & (>1 . &8 -('1(( &- + &+ (1<<&G- 4&& *B* - 4< 1.3 "(14&%7 (4' '&3& .&9'--.&.'&(.&-7.4((& (18(>141'.&(7.4.3('&4(((( .&->1(.&9 8&67.89& 4&3< '<4(&(&-(-('.&9- &- &( '(-9 .& . &- >1( ( 3 <1'. ((& &'..418'414(7+.&.(&.-.&.(& '&(7.(&.&( 13-('.&9-(89&>1&8..'9'( ''19(' ="

*'&-89(7.4(4 <( -(<((& &- .'7 . (& 4 ( -(<((- 2' . (4&69--&- = ?

B.&(84&((-.& (&-<(7+ - -&39&3.(&<&-(&<(&''-93& <-

&9 -(<((- . <& + 47 & 4-9 &44'&(7 &3&(<.(&< & .+4(-(<((- 2&1(>1 &3(&-(&'&- "

02: % 2 "

,,%

&- ..(4&69A&(- (A ..4&8 (A