Harbhajan Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab And Another
0123045 6.7
"#"8" '**9
%/" '1**9
!"# *** "!
"
"#
+"#%#
!!" $ % &'
!" *** "#: " !# ,-".*%#!
/" "# (
### & "
1+ $
"
2 #& 445&
# # # "
#& "
/
"# ()*
. . & $
!"
!!$
"
! $
$
!
" 0*
%
&
" & '& +& &
(
) ) * &
!"
#
+,$ - " . . &
/
"" "!& "
0*
" ! 9
-
$" !!
&
9 & ! $
1
! 1
:
;&
$
!$&
!$ $3
!
!
&
,
!
&
+
2 ,
*
#$
# ! #
#
$ '
/
!
# ! 5
$ !& #
$
/
& < / #
$
/
&
# !
=",
$
'
,$
$
" "
" !
!
$ #$
# > #
#
!
4
1
! 1
:
;
# ! 5
$
!
1
! 1 $ "
$
!!& !!
$
# ! 5 ! $
"" !"
"
!"
"
""
$!
!!
<
,
" "
1
! 1
!&
$
"!
"
* !!
!/
#
#
,!!
!$ 1
! 1
" " "
! $ !
!!
!$
$
!
#$
#
! #
#
!
@
, !
" !!
?
0*& $!
, "
# "
# "!
*
.
:#*.;
#*.&
' &
""!
! /!
" !"
#&
# !
=",
8/
#
"!
"
& $
#$
# !
#
#
& < / #& !/ /
#
#
& ,
"!!
!
# ! 5 '
!"
)
# &
# ! =",
8/
#
& $
"!
"
#*. <$
"
&
"!
'
" ! 9
!
'
$ !
')& $
'
*.
!
& $
&
#&
# ! ="
",
8/
#
&
$
!/
#
#
&
!
"!
"
*
!
( &
"!
< /
#
!!
"
!
!
"!!
:
:(;
& $
#$
# !
#
#
"!!
< / # &
# & !/
#
&
#
&
#
>
=",
8 /
#
"!
"
"
/ /!
! $
# ! 5
#$
# ! #
#
!& $
A
, "!
"!
"
?
?
"!!:;&
"
!& " ! -
B
A "
&
!!
@ @ !!
$
"!
"
#*.
?
?
A " &
!"
!!
A
$
"!
"
"
! $
$ "
&
/
<
!
A
$
&
! "
!!
!&
/!
!$&
*
"
"!
$
:" !
;
8/
#
:""
;
"
!
:8
-;&
&
"
)) )
0* !
" !9
& $"
!/
<
"
!
!!
" !9
.=
!!
!
!
A
0#C
/
!
&
""!
!"
""
!"
" !"
<
"!
"
#*.
<
"
!!&
"!
&
'&
"
"!!
!
# ! 5
* /
" !!&
!"
)
,
"D"
!!
&
'
"
'
!& $
&
A $!
"
" !&
!"
'
<
!
" !9
$
! ')& $"
@ !!
!
!
*
/
/ @
&
<
/ #& !/
#
#
"
<
"
, ""
!
!"
""
"
. "
" "!!
A
.=
!!
!
" !"
/!
<
/
$
"
$
$" " ,
!
"!
"
!"
)
"!
& $"
&
" !
$!
B&
""
!"
*
/
'
#
!
!
" !9
-
$
"!
!
'
#
" !
(
" & '
'&
)'& & ' & & (
) *
'9 4"
81* &
"
* /
')
!
!
!!
/ /!
!$
<
/
!
/
" !
A " & $
" !
& $"
" !!
,
"
.
&
!
!
+ "
"":
8#* !!" $ % 6 #*) :;
# )
/
"
@
!
$
@
"
< /
!! " !$ !
"":
,#/#"5#%:7
!
" !
/
/
" !
!
0*
$ ""
&
!$&
!
!
,
!
""
* /
"
/
0"
$
" !9
!
+*
"
< <
!&
"!
"
/
!
!!
!!
/
.=
!!
!
* /
.= "!!
"
!"
"
!
!
<
/
!
& $
!
"!
"
*
/
" !
!
!"
)
" /
!
!"
*
/
" !
$
/
!
$
1
! 1
<
/
/
$ ""
"
"
.
!!
"
!$
<
!
!
"
! $
!
" !
* /
&
'
#
!
!
" !
/
!
"
!
*
!/ /!
$
/!
"
"!
!
$
:" !
;
8/
#
:""
;
!
$
" !
.
""
, !"
/
9
" !
!
0*& $
#$
# ! #
#
&
(
# ! 5& # & < / #&
#
! =",&
!/
#
#
! $ '
,$
E
"!
!
) % !
-
# + /;< #
# # /"!*
"
&
) >%-
# %& &
#
(""-# "/- " /"! %! $!
!" ! !-"
! //%#" :"# #)# =("" "/- " ! " /"!
!"
)
,
"D"
#&
# ! = =",
8/
#
& $
"!
"
!
#*.
.
!"
$!
" !
(
*
!
"!
"
A .=
!!
!
#*.
!
"!
A
&
& "
! / .
.=
< <$
"
"
/
$
"" " !
&
,
"
!
!
""
# . --
/ @
! "!
<$
!
$
$
" !
# " !
! &
"!
:" !
;
" !
#
)
""
%#)!"""!( $$""!8 "# #? "<!"/ &:- !0 "#: "! * ! "/ " !"
!" < :"!
" !
"
!" #&" &% % " $ . "": >%& -
# . %%! !8"# #)!":-/" $ / //%"/" ##!!" ! " $$""
"! ! ( %- - " !" &!!" $ ! - !!
! ( / 8"# # / "/!* " !%!$%-"## # $!":-" $ #" <!
!":"!
"#/"8" " !"::"/ !
$!""8 "/"-" <! ":!
"#*
/
"!!
A
<3/!
"":
,# /#" 5#%:7
!
!
''
! " *
"
! !
" !! ""
""$
%
" ! % "
% !
!"
" ! % "
% "' +!
% ! "
&
!
!
! " ! " "! "
" " % "
% "
"
" " !
''
''
"
% "(
"
! % !! "") " !
"
,& ("
%)& "
"
'
'' "
!
" -.%/
01 !2
341! 2 3 5 66
?
?
3 7 ' # 8 " '
, '' " !
9'' '
!:
: " !
;& &
% '
%
"
% < ./''
% %
%
% ! % %
%! "" ! "
!
6 .:6/ / 9 ''= # 8 " '
%
7.:/'' "
% ! " '
!: %
!
"
% '' !!
% " !!
!
6: ?
3 :66 ' > # 8
" '
% " " ! " ! 2 3
! "
%
"
" ""
" !! """
!
" # 8
%"
"
! !
% "
" '' ? ! % < '
!
"
! 2 3
" 6 +% '
8 * +" '
;
!!
!
'
!:
" !! ! !
% 2 3
!
2 3 ! " '
!: !!
"
''
!!
%
" % %
"
,
<3/!
!
",
! "
!
"
$
? #
!
" ,
!
"
"
"
'' !
!
" !
% %
% "" ) !
.
%
!&
!
% && % %
'
% ( % % )
-%'
% % &
%%
!
%
!
# / % %
% !!
0$ - -
%
%
!&
% 123 % % %
%
!
"
(
) "
@ @
% ! % !
! " %
"
" !
""
"
% !
"
" = " ''
"
%
! ! " % !
! & "
%
" +! ' " '
*
" %
! " " " +! ' "
' +!
" %, )
$!
!!
"
" "
!
!$ !
%
!!
A
% %#!1) @ 5 "# (7 %
9 B
# ,9 B
/!
%?9FG#
%?9FG#