High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/879/2007allowed

Laxmi Narain v. Kartar Singh And ANR.

2021-01-12Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal25 pages

!

"#$ %&$%'

(")*+"%"+, --$..",# /$%010 2"%#"%+,34",&",#4$% $0-,&$,# 5 6

(")*+"%"+, --$..",# /$%010 2"%#"%+,34",&",#4$% $0-,&$,# '7( (2 (

(2 (8 %". "

$ %&

"

" ' ( )*+ ,--*

" ' ( .+*/ ,-0+

&

"

"

"

'

&

3 ! & $ "

" '

$ 0+0)

' 0-- $$

' $

/ 5 " %

6

" ' ( )*+ ,--*

7 8

( &

"

"

#

"

9

-) -+ 0++*

" 2 & &

" ' ( .+*/ ,-0+ 7 8

(

:

"

%

&

#

#

&

% "

"

! $

"

"

#

# 9

' ( )*+ ,--*

#

#

"

5

" ' ( )*+ ,--*

"

" &

6

' ( )*+ ,--*

"

&

&; "

# "

#

8 "

" , <

" # 7

!"

#$

%& $

'&""( ) * $"+* $,-+# .'

"

% +) $$ / 0 +

" !"

# +

1 0

'

!,

""

) )

* )0 2

0 ) 3& 4 3 # 5 3 2 &6

2 &6 3

#+2

78+9 )

*

:)

9

*

" !"

: )

"

+ 0

)

0) 0

)

) 0

6

)0

1 +

$

6 ;

*

+

) 0

% : )

0

+

""" !

)

)00

1

!

1 0 1 1 0 1 7' 0 1

1 0

1 <

6 "

# 7 =

1 0 =

1

0

; 1 )0

1

01 / * 0

0

1 0 0

" !"+ + + + 1 ) )+0 +

: )

0 0

> + 1 $

$

0

1

+00+ /

1 > 0 1

0 !" / 1

+

: ? !"

+

0 0 )0

01 0

01 ) 0

0

:

;

1 )0

) )0

) ) )0

)

1 0

1 0 !"

+ /

*

)0

:

/ +

1 0 1

)0

*

* 0

>

:

1 0 /

)0

+

1 +00+

+ /

0

)0 ?0+

+ +0 /

0

:

+ 0 )

* /

/

) 01 /

)

0

0 0) 1

1 0

0

1 1

1

0

/ /

)

0)00

1

!

!

)

)

1 7'@ A 0 ) 9 1 1

/ 0

< >

"

# >

#

? ' $ "

?

' #

"

-/ -4 0+<0

.--@7 &

&

" .

:

( 0--@/ ..- 9 &

6

&

-/ -4 0+<0

+/@7 6 & "

8

"

"

-/ -4 0+<0

A

/

&

#

' $ "

6 &

$ "

#

#

<

" 0* 0- 0++*

6

&

/ #

9

7 8

( &

$ "

& "

-/ -4 0+<0

B8 0

8

C0 ( &

C,

:

"

C.

&

9 -/ -4 0+<0

#

7:

"

"

"

#

"

" $

" ' ( .+/, ,--/

7

:

"

2

DC0

"

#

>

"

"

#

8

"

7 -

) B $

)0

1

0

B 1 1 0

1 1 )0

>

0 0

0 6

+

)B

"" (

'

$"+ '

$,-+# .'

"

% " !"

# %&

1 0

'

!, " ,

0

4>8"

)0

4>8"

" !"

#$

%&

0 1 800 C 0 1 0 0+6 8 +

@"A+ 1.# 7#

",-

)

+ ) + 4>8" )B

? +85">

+

)

)0 0

1

'

C9 +8B). 0

!@$A##@1A ,+ ' C ; +8B). 0 +

@A1.# 7#

+ ;

)

+ )

1

+

)

0

)

B) 1

0

0

D8 *C2 807 + 8B). 0 +

$@$A##@1A+

-$-

)

+) +

1

B)

0 85" >

& > 4>8"

85

& > 4>8"

D +95"'

0 0

)

0 ) )0

1 ) )0

B)' 2 4>9" 4>9!?

B)

0

" $& 4>9"+

)

1

1

$"4>9$

1 )

)

' 2

0

& ! 4>9

2B . D C

. D 8 +" !@"A7#8 ,"

+

+ ) 0 >1 +

)

B )

D8 *C

0+8B).

0 +" @"A7# "

"

) 0

1 1 ) )0 0

1

6

)' .D C; .6 + 9 +"

@"A7# !

1 )

1

0 ) ? +

1

0

) 0?1

(BC6 C

8 + 8 +" @A7#!

1 )

1

)

1

)0

1

""

1 )

0 )

01 )

0

;

. D C 2) ; . D + #B +

$@

A 7# "-

)0 )

1

? 0

2 C; +8B). 0 +

@"A7#

! 1

)

+ + *

)0

?

+

1 B "

*

0 = 0+

5 )

0+ )

1

? #'7 C(7+9 +" @A##@1A

!- )

1 )

)01

1

)

=

)

1

+

0)

? +

) 0 1 "$?1

+

1 )

)

* 0

1 )0 0

1

6

+

0 ) * )0

1

0 1

B

) ) < 6

"

6

)

"

" "

@

&

9

+ $ 8

( &

?

;

"

6 # # 6

7 0

#

&

,

&

"

#

& ,--/7,--< .

& #

4

& " & ?% ?

# "

/

# &

#

<

9 "

#

7:

"

DC0 2

& &

#

# & D

2

& & &

" #

& ,--<

"

/) &

2

"

& # &

! D

6 2

"

2

&

2

,- &

"

2

"

#

$ "

" "

"

& " "

2

&

0++*

2#

#"

> 0++* #

" 0++*

2

&

D

6 & &

9

"

:

' #

' &

D

A

& " D

4/7/- & 6 & "

& D

2

" "

'

8

# &

9 # "

9

8 $ "

?

& "

/- &

(# ? &

&

& 0++.70++4 0++)70+++

,--.7,--4

B8 D0 D7/

B8 D,

: B8 D.

&

#

:

"

D

& 0++* > B8 D.7

&

#

,- & & 0++* !

:

"

0+**

B8 D4 D7<

"

#

& ,--/7,--<

& 0+)470+)) 6

" "

,- &

& "

/- &

% " ' #

?

&

2

' $ "7

?

0+<0

&

#

' #

0+/4

6

"

+/@7

' #

9 ' $ "

8 "

!&

9 "

' $ "

D

' $ "

6 #

9

6

"

&

9

&

!

6 & '

$ " -0 -0 0+<+ 2 ' #

6

9

"

&

' $ " 2#

&

& " "

# #

#

# 8

E

! "

&

2

& "

&

#

$ " # #

"

&

6 %

,

9

"

0, 0, ,--* 6 &

&

&

C 0

9

& & &

" D 0

& #

& &

'

&

(

9

9

"

&

#

8 #

0))* 6

2 9

& (8

"

&

6

9

"

-/ -4 0+<0 (8

"

"

8 # 7 " # " &

#

8 &

'

7 8

# &

#

78 (8

" &

" &

( #

$ " #

"

#

9 $ " >

$ & #

"

'

"

!

(8

"

&

%

& &

& 0++* # %

" & 9 & !

" 7

"

(# ?

&;

&

7 8

( &

6 &

#

" "

# &

&

$

&

&

6

!

"

"

&

"

#

6

#

&

"

#

#

6

"

# #

9

#

#

&

"

#

" $ 6F &

=2 6 G

$ + 0 &

#

9

& 0 > "

?: ?

0 "

?

?

>

#

0 >

0

#

2#

"

#

@ "

6

" #

&

"

#

6

"

# #

9

"

!

"

#

& &

@

! &

"

# & #

"

'

"

#

& B8 D4 & ,--/7,--<

&

&

&

"

#

B8 <

(8

"

6 &

"

"%;",02"1%",& ",#4$%<4..""#4",&",#4$%8

6( 86 ! &

" D

" $ # # "

"

# &

&

(

" ,.

#

& #

8 & #

#

6

& " 4/7/- &

6

"

:

6

"

6

8 7 " #

6

9

8

& # &

"

8 &

&

(8

"

# "

6 "

& !

&

2 6

(8

"

&

6 &

& &

9 &

'

;

8 #

9

+/@7

6

&

6

#

&

9

#

!

#

# (8

"

"

>

9 #

"

6 #

&

9

& 0+<0 # 7

-/ -4 0+<0

&

!&

! "

$ "

'

9

?

2#

&

"

&

"

B

#

&

6

&

>

9

5 #

?

6 &

"

> $ "

>

$ "

9

#

#

"

#

9 #

"

,

' "

8

?

2# #

"

#

"

#

8

$ "

! & .

'

#

"

& D

# 0 & & "

2

# & " 2 & & "

# &

! D

% " ?

#

9

? 2

8

" & #

D

6

& "

8

" " # &

'

#

$ " #

& "

,- &

"

9 "

& 0++*

&

6

# # &

& #

& "

& # # D

'

<- :

(# ? 8

0+<4

+/---@7

6 #

" #

& "

"

& /- &

8

9 & # &

8 & /- &

6

6

"

B

&

/- &

B

$ "

& 0+<+ #

"

9

) & #

B

#

& " A

"

$9 &

" ' ( .+*/ ,-0+

# "

" -< 0- ,--<

#

" ' ( )*+ ,--*

$9 &

#

$ ( 0--@+*@,--- # $ ( ..*@ !@,--)@,-0.

:

"

%

#4 ",1"%=8

(2 ( ,# C

"@

H@( C

H@(