M/S Real Mazon India Ltd. v. State Of Punjab & ORS
Gurbax Singh 2017.10.26 10:19
!"#$ %"&'()*+,-$!.#$
!" !
#$ !
/%012,%3%. % &
!''('') *
+ ! !
, %
'
" -!
!
.-!+-
/ 0.01 !
! "2 34 * $! %565 / 7*$81 ,".9 '44%
+ *
+ !
%
' "! !
!
+
+
! &
!
+
*
! %53( -- ! - + -
:
.-!+ -
/.1";
& + *
-
"
9 '64<'44% =
= , !
'64<'44% ''46'44%
4543'44'
+
!
: ".9 %345'4%%/
: <1
'
%
! -
> 9"
9 - !
- !
-+
2
! - !!+
!
: .
+"!!
!
+ ! &
, <
-" ?
$ *
/
, @
31 !
- !
< -
: / 1 "!#
" - - "
-"
, @
3/*
!
!
1 !!
-+ !
!
- '%%%'4%% " -
:! " !
!
!
' ;++ "!
"
" "
9 63'4%' & A =
>
- +
.
!!
, <B !
+
! +
%<6'4%' & A =
?#
-
-
9 %4<'4%@ .$ C ! ! + ; ++
&!
- " " ! + & A =
A "+ ! -
!
!
-
+"
- 9 '(6'4%@ ! &
A ; +
< :!
. !
!!
#
: D
, < " ! - ! + ! -+ + ; "
+ %)%4'4%@ ! & *
+ !
!
- " ;++
=
+ 9 !!
-
+!
!
4(4%'4%3/
: %41
, '
& *
- '%%%'4%%"
, < @
3
!#
+
! - + -
! - . -- + 4(4%'4%3/
: %41 +& *
, < 3 ! * + "+ - * E
, 5%% '4%3 "! "
454)'4%3 /
: %%1 & *
!
!
! * /*1, '%365 '4%3"!"
4)46'4%3 /
: %'1 .
" + " - !
!
!
#
! - !!
!"""- - :! +
! - -
* !# - " !
! &
!
! - !# * - *E , %))(6 '4%3 "!
- " -
! - !
*
, % !
!
%(
*
!
! %55(
& / 0& 01 - + !
+
! - & !
" ! + &
<%4<'4%( /
: %@1 "!"2 + - +
* *E, 5@@( '4%( " * %<43'4%( /
: %31 ! & *
* > A! *
!
# ! !
! .
" "
"
4%%''4%( /
: %61 ! #
" -
, %
'" ! - *
!
- '%%%'4%% /
: @1 . ! "
+
< E
@ &!
!" " !
! ": + :* BSN Joshi v. Nair Coal Services Ltd.
2006(11) SCALE 526, " " + - !
!
!
0 ! ! & *
+ :! ! -+
+ "
+ !
!
- "
2+ + - + - "
0 ! !
& .- * 0 !
! - ! *
+ :! ! -+
+
! !
8
3 & * Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa and Others, (2007) 14 SCC 517, !
! !
! !
F -
" - !
! +
! !
! 2+
! +
! !
!
! "
:! " !" !
!
& " !""
# ! !
! !
! & * :! ! -+
=
( & :* Maa Binda Express Carrier and another v.
North East Frontier Railway and others' (2014) 2 CHN 96 (SCC) " - !
! "
!
! 2 !
! - -!
!
" -!
!
!
!" !
! +
+ " &
!
:!
%4 & !
! "
! " : +* Tata Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651, Raunaq International Ltd.'s case (supra) and in Jagdish M andal v. State of Orissa and Ors. (2007) 14 SCC 517 !
"!"
11. In Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka and Ors . (2012) 8 SCC 216 -
!
"
!
"
! " ! ! ! " " -"
/**''5%5 '41 7%5D
!
" - ! - /1!2 !%@ !
+
!
! + & !
!"
+ : ! + !
" !+ + !"
"
- #
G /1:
+" " :!
+ + + ! :! #
"
!!
:! +
=
!
+"! +
!" !
!+ -
!! ! ! + * + G /!1
-!
!
" -!
! - 2 !
! !
- +
!
+ " !+*
" G / 1* !
2!
"
!
! !!+
! !!+:! "
#G
/1 !
+ +
! " -!
! - ! + * + ! !
! !
- !+
"=
'4& * -
! :! " ! " " -2
/1E ! !
+ +
G " ! !
+
!
! + H !
!
+ ! -
+
!!
!" " ! HG
/1 E ! ! " 2
-
!
!''(8 %'
!
! !
! "
"+
! + 9 !
+
! " ! !
! 2
! - -+
+ ! - +
! "
!
+ ! ! !
!
+
-
!
!
" + !
* &A
> ! .-* " " !+ -
+ - ? -
- "
8 7.
The terms and conditions contained in the notice inviting tender and award of contract have to be examined having regard to the fact situation obtaining in each case. No hard and fast rule can be laid down
therefor. In the present case, the decision has been taken by the respondents keeping in view the overall interest of the public. It has been authoritatively held that in tender or contract matters, interference by courts is very limited. Power of judicial review will not be invoked to protect private interest at the cost of public interest or to decide contractual disputes. Interference is permissible if the process adopted or decision made is malafide or intended to favour someone or the same is so arbitrary and irrational that no responsible authority acting under the law could have arrived at it or it affected the public interest.
6 . * @%)/'1
!
-"
!
!reads thus:-
3 % &=
"- ! !!
! !!
! + ! +
+ ! *
! ! !
! !
" - :::::::::::::::::::::: '
+
- ! !+ !
! + - #
-
-
! " +
!
+! + + & *
*
- & !!
"
"! !
+
!!
+ !!
: + + - 8 5 * "
+ !
! & A +- #
-
-
! " +
!
+ ! + +& *
%4
!
! -
"- !
- !
-+
2 ! -!!+
!
:.
+ " !!
=
!
9 '%%%'4%%
<
-" !
/
, @
31 !
- !
<" ! "
!
- '%%%'4%% /
: @1 " -
:! " !
!
!
' ; + + /'1 " '
"
*
+ " < "
9 4643'4%' & A =
>
- +
. %'4@'4%'" >
<& - "
!!
, < *
+0 !
+
! 9 '(46'4%@ ! & *
; +
< :!
. !
!!
#
:
, < " ! - ! + ! - + + ; "
+ "
"-
@
3
" !#
+
! - =
! -.&
/
: %41"! - +!
* - *E , 5%% '4%3 "! "
454)'4%3 /
:
%%1&!
- : * " 4)46'4%3 /
: %'1 .
" + " - ! - -
* !# !
" !
! '(46'4%3 !# - " ! - * - *E , %))(6 '4%3 & * '(46'4%3/
: %<1 + !# -
- !
9 4@4<'4%3 & "
+
* !
- !
!
- '%%%'4%% /
: @1
' !
!
%(
*
!
! %55(
<%4<'4%("!" +& /
: %@1&
" ! - +
* - *E, 5@@( '4%($ %<43'4%(/
: %31
!
"- & *
*
> A! *
!
# !
! - & "+
9 %643'4%( -" "
'
!
!
!
" 2 "
!
- '%%%'4%% !!
-
+ :* + +
+ #!!
-
!
9 4'%4'4%( !
" *E , 5@@( '4%(+
- + " +* 4(%4'4%(/
:
%)1 9 4%%''4%( /
: %61 "
"
%% D
! "
- !+ - !
!
!
"
&
! & 2
" !
!
!
% + "
!
!!
! +
!
"!+! !!
!! ! D + "
+ " !
!
!
+
*
2 +
+ 5/%012,%3%6 2&7 5, %8%6 2&7 *+,-$!.#$ I-B E# -
J ( E J (