Chand & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!
""
# $%&'()"*!
"+ ,#-.,%
% /%'% ,0# #(##.,%
%1-%
!"#$% ! # % &
!"#$% %$ '''
%& ,1%
2
2#,#3#*-$##*#(##4, 2 0#5#,0#6#*-- -$##*#(##
77777 %$ (! ,%,1-,1%41%4,, ,5%$518$%,14%$ -'-%'9: %$;!< 0$) ,#(##2'$1#1#$*"== ; %,*"== $<-$#6,2'$1#'$* ,#>#%# 2'$1#1#* ,#>9(#--6'### ,6#$ ,1%*%,*%,##%1, 1%% 0$!: ,#(##2'$1#$*"=?)#-%'9: %$;!< 0$) "== $*9 15'6# $6, 2'$1#'$9(#--6 4#6%#%2'$1#1#* 11'( ,#64#%6#(93$%4%'6, %'11
,# 5-%'95%%*#$,#%9#-,1%% $%! ):#-! ):
,%' -#%'95,# 21###5#%###,#6#11'# #$%5 $51%- 5 -%$% #- $%%6 4 5 2'$1#% #$,#(#%,$6''%##%%1$ -9(, 9(1'9$ $#9#21### 2
2#,#3#*#--$##*#(###%%%- 9( 2 0#5#, 0#6#* #- --# -$# #* #(## %'95-,#,$%(,%6#-,#%##-(9%#%9( ,%$, ,%'# ) *+*,-* . ,/ ,0,#*
*1* ** . ,(
23 (-$-- "
"
!
"
* 4, $%-6 , 3'-65 -- 9( @9 , 0'15' *.
# 4-* . ,/ ,0,#* )*5-* *.
,-* . ,(%326#73(4,,#%9,-#$ ,5 (6$%' ,2'$1#(8-6 %5%#6%# '$*4,$,-%A'#(11'( ,#6
,#,#-,#--$##*#(###- #11#%-,1#19>
0'9:%$;!< 0$) "== $#-%#%'-&: B,55#(* 555*9( $#, $# #C* -$# #( 5'$1#( $'-6 ## $51%6 '# ## # 1# , * #(* 9 # 1#>4#%B,2'$1#1# ;#5 1#<D
5 , 1# #- %51 #-6 , # 5- 1%* % $# ,# , 5 % %- 4, 14
7 15'6#,5'$1#(#-,%1% # -6#( 11'(
05#11%$#59-9#-'1,3'-65 $-%'1#*4,*4,$6,#-$--$'-', 3'-65--,* * 8*) * 5-*1*(*
*9** .
,/ ,0,#* 0 9*:* . ,(
6
2( -$-- !
!
"!*,#%9,-,#11'( ,#6 ,1'1% 8-6%5$%' 2'$1#( %A'-96,$###%96#6%# '$ 6%##$%,$##-15'6# #6#' $-'$ 4,' $1#$'#$#%%*4,#%##-5%##$%, 5#>6#-%%' #%1$ $-$,#11$# #6#' # 1#$'# $#% #$$-#$ 4, , A'5% 1$(
%' 2'$1#( #- $% 2'$1# '$ 9( #--6 4#6%2'$1#1#%,-5# , 6%#'#-*,'%*$#9A'%- ,%#> 9(*# 1 ,3'-65#-%,'%&:
B #$*#%$, ,%' "?!!
!
+-#5 #$,#(#*2#2#3##-,% 0# '3#9#-,%*-$-- !
!
"!*,#%#%,-,# %#9%,5 # 2'$1# 55 % # 6%# '$ ,#8#$ 5,%#-3'-65#-%#% '-&:
B05#%,4 ,,,3'-65%- '19(#-$'% ,1% 2#-#E# 0# '3#9*;!
=<! ;< )F#--# 0'$% E5- 0$#(* 1#5 E$# -%*;!
F< ;< ,3'-65% - 9(,#-$'% ,11$-
, #%%'51 ,# # $# $%'6 # 2'$1#( 8-6 % 5'$1# 5% % #-5%##' 0'$,#%%'514#%19#9( ,#%,#,1%% ,$$51# # 11'( ,#6 , 3'-65% -9(,#-$'% ,1*, -%$ 94 , #-5%# #- 6%# '$%4#%9'6,,$ ,'*4,$, ,#%9%'93$5# $%-#9 ,#6 $,% ,G90'15' %1$ , 2'$1#%#%#%,##6'%1%%* , '$,3'-65% ,%',##>, %5#4 , *#$ ,#-$'% ,1,%$,3'-65% ,% ' , 3'-65 , 0'15 ' #-06,#-%% 0# 5#$,# #-%,#- %* "=+?
0"!)
, *4 -,##$ ,0#5 (6$%' ,2'$1#(8-6 %5%#6%# '$#-,%#5*-% A'#11'( ,#6 '%$,%#' $51#%#11'( ,#6*,6' 6# 11'( ,#6%,%#5#%% A'- ##-5%#A'#%3'-$# '$ %'$,11'($#-5$'-11'( 1%#,#6 ,'%*4 -,## $#$%'62'$1#(# $##9%,62'$1#(%##$ 6%##- ,'%$# 951'6-,6'-%4,$,####9 #-5%# A'#%:3'-$# -% $6 , - $94,6%##-#-5%# '$* % $, #5 #$,#(#* 2# 2#3#G% $#% ;%'1#<*9%-#%'-&:
B4 ,#9*$#9,-,##6%##$ %,$##-15'6# #6#' $-'$4,' $1#$'#$#%%*4,#%# #-5%##$%,5#>6#-%%' #%1$ $ -$ , #11$# # 6# ' # 1#$'#$#%#$$-#$4,,A'5% 1$( E6%#%,1$%%'%'#(1#6 ''* #-5%# % , 1$%% 1 56 1#$'##$%* %%'61#$'#-% 5#>6 -$%%4,$,#11(6#'%1#$'#$#%%
#-3'-$#*,,,#-*#11%%1$ $ --'#%%'#% '*,%#(#9#- -%$% , 93$ , '* , #$, % #11$#*,6,%#-96#%#%6' *% -- $1#%*1%#- ''%*% 5*,5# %15'6##%5 #$% 4,$,5#(,1-#46,946%# #- :6%# #$% , %#- #$% ,# 9 #11- ,-6,#, 8# 1$'-, 1%% ,%%#55-%$# '-,$$($*!
)*#6%##'
0'$,1$1%,#9#11-%1$ , $%' ,2'$1#(8% %5%* , $%'$,3'-65%%5#-,# 1# 5,# %#-3'-65*#%$, #5 #$,#(##%%0>,# 0# '3#9#-,%* ;!
=<" ;<! !*,#%#%#>,%#54,##$ $%' #2'$1#(%6%##$
#% -,##1# 5, #$,#3'-65, $#% / H#1;%'1#<,#%9 '-9-'-#9( , 0'15 ' 9' , -%$ 94 # #-5%# '$ , 6%# '$ 4#% 9'6,,$ ,',3'-65% E#6 $,% ,G90'15'#%$%--#5
#$,#(#*2#2#3#G%$#%;%'1#<4 - ,
; 1'%# ,' , *,%#-3'-65-%#( -4#9-61$- ,%'
%A'(*4- -#(5,1% 41
%5%%- $#5#'5- ' , #$,#,41% 1-6#-3'-$#%$!
""4,'#(5%#(*, *$#'% #$#6-(#$$'-6%'%
%#'1%, '#%6*,41%-%5%%-
<! # % & = <%$ = !"&8 !"&8 !017(2 *) ,- - ,> *+ 4? *,
.
@ ,?
- > *: @ ,?