High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5059/2011disposed of

Harpal Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2015-05-27Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih11 pages

!"#

$% & '( # ( )* % &+!

, -

.(/ 0( '( # ( )* % +! , ,

#(%0(/ '( # ( )* % +! 1 ,

) #

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

2$#

$% % '( # ( )* % +! - 1

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

+/4" '( # ( )* % +! 3

# /) 0( % '( # ( )* % +!

,, ,

6("*+ % '( # ( )* % +!

+) '( # ( )* % +!

, ,1

.(/ #

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

1--3

#(7%8% % '( # ( )* % +!

, /"#

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

1 +)9

0( '( # ( )* % +!

47%* + '( # ( )* % +!

- -1

1 .(% 0( % '( # ( )* % +!

/0(/ % '( # ( )* % +!

3 -

):0(/ % '( # ( )* % +!

#("7% #

$% '( # ( )* % +!

) 0( '( # ( )* % +!

#$#

$% '( # ( )* % +!

33,

;"* #

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

0( '( # ( )* % +!

;"9

$% % '( # ( )* % +!

<%70(/ % '( # ( )* % +!

- ,3 ,

#"+

% '( # ( )* % +!

(%!'% '( # ( )* % +!

3 3-1

0("9 #

$% '( # ( )* % +!

$% % '( # ( )* % +! , ,-

*%)#

$% % '( # ( )* % +! , --

#8%0(/ '( # ( )* % +! ,

.(% #

$% '( # ( )* % +!

,, -

, ) 0( '( # ( )* % +! ,1 1

, 28 #

$% '( # ( )* % +! ,

)

$% % '( # ( )* % +! ,- ,-

%/!" '( # ( )* % +!

8%%=<8 <)( !</+/=<8 !0(=<8 # !<=<8 </ 7#

$%=<8 0!

"077=<8 9 0(/=<8 </ %!=<8 09"0 % =<8

#%/=<8 #/#%8=<8 '

$%%"=<8 0( )=<8 0.%(%:=<8 #0+ =<8 /"#

$%=<8 +0<=<8 < %(/ %!=<8 (

%;%9)=<8 .(% #

$%=<8 0;+%)=<8 </!#

$%#% =<8 +)

%02

"=<8 /"#%/=<8 '

):4%=<8 +#%(% =<8 +# %=<8 %!

- / #

$%#% =<"<.=( )*9 % 4"

0 %.% =< =#%"</ #>5?5#>=( )* 9 0(/=#

<89 % <*% / :(;=<8 < (%%0!(=#

<89 % +7%#* =<8 .'% %=<8 8@<7%=<8 %! 8! AAA

%% ! "" !! /: * ""9 %)($/ B

C* %! B , %% % )($/ %(" * !

% $B AAA

" % % * "

% *( % ,- ! = %

: "

4( #%" ,

D( < /(" !" %"" $ " %< !!"

$ " - -

9 /8

= %

( % 9(" 6( % ( $%8"

: %

6( <

D( %8 * ("" ( 5 ! =

= (*"

5 ( #>= ( )*= !/ #%" >( = % *

( := *: " < " <8 . "= ( )*= %/ 7 !:(!!"

" ( "

%! " %! 8! 5 !! % % 8: * "8 ;":= ": %

=8" % ": % ( % %8 * = 6(

6( ": %

: "

D( E(%= % !/ :8 %/

/ % *:% (

!"#$ "% &'( )*+*,-. /-/( " %

( ( *: % .8 /

1 < %*

$=%!/ %""

""%

: "

= % ! % C% = "" % 9% 9("

" ! 9(" " *

! " %

("":8

! 8! :5 ($$%! ! %! =%! ! " %

$ 9(" // *:

9("7 ":9/ %C% =

" $%

9("*% *: % .8 / *: ,

/ ! *: % ( 9("

( !

$ (/ ""%/ %59("* !! %

= % % *

/!" %/%( 0+ $

1&2 3

2"2'3 "%2"$ &

2'"$4 !& "%2'"1 25 % &)/*6)*+6 "!7$ & '2724& 3

2"'

" 84!$$ % 3& '

1&2 3

2"(1 & 2"'

"2&2 942'

%*/*-)*++'$

"844 " % ) 2 2' '!$72

% " 33428 2" ' $

" 24 % $9 3

&' 1 & 2" ' &2'

3 & 2" 2''!

'( 12 & '3 '

"2&2 9 42'

%*/*-)*++ &27&249 2''!

'&2'

%& '

& 8 8!3&!4 12443349' "

2' % 2" #!%7 "

"$4 !3& !& "%2 2" #2 2" "#! :'

!"#$( "% 1

& '2%8 8!3&!4 '$

" 441 %& "

( 124 3& 3&2"

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ !& & 2''!

"&2'

%' 1

&("8

&"7 "

!"#$'2''!

% 2"'

&!8 2"' "4988 &

%3&7 2"2' $ &"

% & '

&98"%2%

% "% "

"2&2 9( " 1 '

"2&2 9 ' 4' $

" &"

% & '

8"%2%

%124 &72" '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ !& & 2''!

' $

" &2'

% ' 1

& '

"2&2 9 42'

128 ' &7 % $9 873492" ;6 7 "%7 "

8"'

2" "%2( 12 !

& $ 2" "9 <!"42 2$4 %

3& 3& %$9

!"#$'

2' %2" #!%7 "

&#(2'8&& & "

!& &( 3

4' &2'

% 2''!

' 1

& '

"2&2 9 42'

)**= 8" $ 4

& %( 128 1' $ 2" %

"% % $9

!"#$ ' $ 2" 8&& "% ( "49 " %2& 2" 2

" $9 2"4 8 %!4 '

' 772''2" - 3& "

'8"'2% & % 2''!

' &2'

% $9 3

&' 2" 3& '

33428 2" 2" 42 &% &' 3''

% $9 772

$9 128 '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ 1' 2"42> % " 3& ),+. 772

' $

" "

% 8 8 !3 &!4 ' 1' "49 33428$4 244 ;6 "'

2" 7 "%7 "

128 87 2"

$ 2" &7 +/*?+==6 "% 8 8 !3 &!4 ' ' "

2' % 2" #2 2" "#!' 8'

2'"

24$4 &

& !& &2''$

" "

% 2"3&&3@- &% &

"2&2 92' $ 2

"" $'2' &'

&32"

3& "

2' 32"2" '

2''!

'3&27 82 "

%' 8"'2% & 2" "% 8"'

& 8"'2% & 2" '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++(

32"2" 1 #!%7 "

2'"$4 !& 2" ' 8'

' 1 44 ' 2"'

&!8 2"' 128

" 2''!

% $9

&"7 "

!"#$%

%+*+*)*+B 41 42% %1" $9 2' "$4 !& 2" '8'

&3&

2" & '

& 2"8 )**? 2''!

% $9

!"#$ & 2' " 8"'

24 '

"2&2 9 $ 2

" & '

&9 8"%2%

% ' '83 % "

&2 ' 124 &72" '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ B % 3& "

1244 2

% &'"' 2

% $9 '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ 8"8 & 3& '

2& 8'

&"7 "

"% &

&( 44 '

1 24 ' & 3& '

2"'( 1244 $ 2

&2" 2"%2 2%!449 & 2" & 3& '

8382 9 "%

&( % 82'2" 1244 $

A " $9

&"7 "

2" & '3 '

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++2" 42 411283&

42"

!"#$( 2"84!%2" 2"'

&!8 2"' 2''!

% $9

" 2' 2''!

244 "( 2"

&27 &% &' 3''

% $9 "$4 !& 1244 8"

2"!

"%"3&7 2"&&

&'2"1244$ %"

6 2 2'3&9 % &&

2'2 2" 2''!

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++( % 3& "

3&3'

' "%

& 2'

1244$ 2

"2" "

1' 33 & "% "

1244 $ 3!$42' % " $'2

$9 %

% +**?)*+6 " '2% "

(

1244 $ 2

% 3& '( 1 33'

"2&2 9 42'

% */*-)*++ & '!33& '

"2&2 942'

%*/*-)*++ 7A

& 3& '

2"' $9 )6*?)*+6 &

&( '8&!

2"9

& 3& '

2"''&

%3& ' 1244$ 844 % &3 &'"4 &2" &2"%2 2%!449 & 2" & 3& '

8382 9 "% &2" 1244 $ 877 "8 $9 +**/)*+6 ' 8%& '

& " 4 !& &2" 842"+)()B6 "8 ( 2 2'

% 4& "!7$ & $# 2" &

% $ 24 % "8 ( 3&8 '' &2" 2& $# 2"' 2" 3 &'" &

&! & 3& '

' 1244 A "

&49 ) 7"

& &2"2'8734

(44 %

1244 $ 87342 % "% % 82'2" & '3 '

"2&2 9 42'

%*/*-)*++ 1244$ A " A

32"2" 1 41&3& '

'1 44' 2"'

&!8 2"'2''!

%$9

!"#$ '2%% 82'2"1244$ A " $9

&"7 "

$9-**=)*+6 / 2" 8'

2' 88 $4

&' 2" 44 1&2 3

2"' "% 2' "$4 !& ( $

7 "

%1&2 3

2"' 44' &8""

%1&2 3

2"'79A2"%49$ %2'3'

% 2"

&7' $

; '

' 34289 & 4 2"

& '

& 2""% % 82'2" A "2" 2'8'

$ 33428$4 44 & % 3& "

'( 2 2' '! '

1772

&%$9 3& "

1244$ ''2'

%$933&3&2

& 3& '

' &7

&'""

4"%

C 4 & D %97 %! (*8=" ( " %! /%"%! * !

/ %

8 =

= % (*"

5 ( #>=( )*5 *:"" %" ( "=%%! %"

%""* *: % ( ?( 7

$?/ %

% D! : $/ % ($$ ( 4 # ( "=

( = (*/ %

" % *: % .8 / *:,

= 6( " !/ 8 =

:= %"" *

9 %

(% ! 9 / % % C% *

$ = % ! ! ":

/ %(":9

8 (*"

( #>= ( )*= !/ #%" >( =

" = % ! !/ %"" ":%%!%%* ($$

8 9("* *:% $ /%(" May 27, 2015 Rajan ( Arun Palli ) Judge