Badam Singh And ORS. v. Financial Commissioner Haryana And ORS.











 

 





!"
# $% $& '

&#$($(

# $) *+
,-.
/
.  &&&  0 1


++ "
 2
/
.  &&& * #& '

&345$

# $3 ,16.7
/
.  &&&  0 1


++ "
 2
/
.  &&& * )& '

&3454

# $3

+
.* &&&

0 1


++ "
 2
/
.  &&& *


 !"#$%
%$&!"'(



&,.9
:1+ "
*9"


.

;
'

&#$($(

# $)<& =9
,. +"
*9"


.

;
'

&345$
/
3454

# $3<& =7
,-."
"
 2"


.
,& &:.9


,-."
*9"

 *
&!

$$
;
'

&#$($(

# $)<& &:&,&*>"
*9"

 *
&)

)#
;
'

&#$($(

# $)<& ?????

 %$&! 2
.
 "

*

* 

.


9
'


 7 -
&#$($(

# $)"
345$
*
3454

# $3

++
@1
 >
*

 
99*& '

&345$
*
3454

# $3"
>..
.9
7
 *
 7
. *
>.
'

&#$($(

# $)"

 

.


.

9

*"
>."


.
A+
 
B *

'

&#$($(
 # $)"
> 
9
 9*& &,.9
:1+ "
 *
1

.


'

&#$($(

# $)
*
8 =9
,. +"
 *
1

.
 
'

&345$
*
3454

# $3
17+
.
.
A+
 
9
. . 

*

.

9

#

.
1=7
C*
91



7

.
,

 2
;
. 
D.
E<&
. 
>
 +1*"
2
.


+1*
>
*&
.  "
.
+

**
-
1 
.








1*
,
$$$ 
.


17+
.
- *
9 &


*"
.
- * 9 
.9

7
* *"
>..

9*
 +
.
A+
  *
1+2
>.1
 *-
.



>..
 9
. 7
*"
BF 

*-
> 
*

#3&%&# )
*"

.  "
.

.9

7
-9

.


.


9FF9
.
++ *1+

"
>.."



9 1F=1*
* 71

.
*&


 "
8 &:.9


,-."
 *
1


*
&!

$$
*
8 &:&,&*>"
 *
1


*
&)

)#

9
'



&#$($(

# $) 17+
.

"

.
7"
7
* *



*1 
 
71





.

.9

7
7

1.
1

.
1 

 >.
7
7=
1*
.9
7
6

.
++ *1+





.

.*
12
*
.

*-& 81.
>
.
>

.
+


# $
*
+ 
.
$(
2 
.9 7
 *
*"
.  "

1*
7


 
B 

+*- .
+
76
*"
.1"

2

1 .*-
.
 

1*
.-& 
.9
. *
.
 *
1

.

*


* .

76& .

+
.
.



*
-
.

 .*

7
*+*

.
1. 
7>
.9

6
 

6 
.
A+
 &

>1*
7


*1-
.
A+
 

.

91
 "
>1*
9
F* 

.
- *
9 &
. A+
 
++-
 +
$3&#&# )


#)&(&# )"
#3&%&# )" #!&(&# 3

$ &5&# 3
*

**
#%&5&# 3

*-
.


;

*

.


*-<

BF "
  B *
. 
7> D 




 
















 "#""

$

(""




 










)





)

)*

))
  











$$"

$

"#""




 














)

)*

))
  









 "#$"

$

$$"




 



 




  



)















)

)*

))
  









 "+("

$

"#$"




 



 




  



)








*








)

)*

))
  









 "

+"

$

"+("




 
















)

)*

))
  









 "$ "

$

"

+"




 


















)

)*

))
  









 "(,"

$

"$ "



















   (++ -.




 '  

 
 /


 








 















.



))

)

 )   
 )

,"

)

 

"(,"

01

 

!

 





))

)

  )

#,"

(

) 23 "+ "

(

  ) 01 -

   ) 

!







"

,"

(

))

)

  ) 23 #,"

(

 )

))



!




 !* 01 - 

#"

(  ) 23 "

,"

(

+

 )

))



!




 !* 01 - 

",#"

(  ) 23

#"

(


)  )





4) 

!









#

"

+







 

 
 %

(++ -.

)
 



 


 



#

"

+

  






 
 )*

5  6

$"

( ",#"

(7 .
 +*
 
>1*
9
.

 .
7
 **
>.
- *

.
+1 
+1*"
9
.
 >.

6

+ 

.

9

,
#

.



7

.
,

 2&
.
1. 
7>
.9

7
9 > 2

*-G
72

*-
-
.
-*
 9*
* BF &
. 



*1 

 7*

-
.
BF 

*-&
.

-*2
 **"
.>
.
+1*
.
7 *"
>..
+1*

*
- *
9
.9
7
* *

 
 112
>-&

+2
9>"
.



1. 2
1-.

.9 * *G * *
1 
.
 
*
F*
.

72
+*- 76
.
+

.


72
B-
+

"

)
"

,  *-

.
17+

8 &,.9
:1+ "
. 
.

7
@1 * 71

*
@1
2"
+1.

@12

.
*&

12"
.
 
1*
.-
 

17 7-
9*

>
*
*

*

.
1.

72"

.  "
.
+
 
F*&
.
+

+*
76

. 


 *
 *

**
.


*-  .
72
1-
 9

.
1 9*
*"


.

*"
>.
.9

7
*

*
.
 &
.


.
1


 

#5&3&# $%
*
@1
. *"

.


.
 2
*. 

.

9

,
# 
.
&

+ 

.
 9
"
.
**
.


  

B *12

7
>.

 *

B
+.
 + .
*

 

 *
 2

.
 &
'



*
* *

 *-2& -*&+  .%$/ 01 !"'( 3 3 204 56

3 3  - 09