← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13885/2017dismissed

Jagvir Goel v. Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd And ORS

2018-02-21Mr. Justice S.P. Bangarh7 pages

 

         !"#$ %& '( )"*+ ,#

$# #$   

 

    

  !

  " # $# # ',  -.'

 ///  #% &  

  "! '

(## # ) &    "

!'

( * " &#$ !'

( * +#,- & '." ! '

(!## # ) & / !'

( * +0 & '

" !'

( * +1- 2!"

" //0

  

 "#*  "

#

 #/ 4#"

 *

 

05 &

12 3#4( " )

6  "#  " ((* #   *17) # " "" #(

 " " #")# ()"

( ##    #) #  8(#*"(#

 * 

 #   #* "" # "" #  #"

*9 



  )  6            *  #" : ;   );1 #* " #  #9  6"

* 75<" #  

,!

3#3   "#   *17) #!"#5 )#* "

 * 

#

   # " #/ =# "  "" #")# ()

#  # 

#*  ## "> #94?  ) ( *$ "# 8  (   '(!@@1* #" :'(*@@1;  , <"  6    #  (    

  "



)*

( 511#

 )"

 #/ "

 =

 * "#

2# *&

( ( $# ("* #" : 2&9$; !"

" * )"

 # !" *( )*   )## # <" (  = 

 *" * , ,7   " (

 "  "  #" 

) ( ( "

 " ,(*

)!* "  '"

) #  )  0 8  

* ( *=# * 

 *  !,# # )#*  A+,@** "

#/  4#"

 *"

#=# >

 " ()*#



 !

"( ( (## )##

(8

 *> +B "6'

 #! 2&9$!

"

"  ( # % 



 !"

#$

 

 %"

$

 





&'





 

!"#"$#$" %

&#'#( ) *+

33  <""

      1#=



)B

*"

 ( #*

" ((

 )!* 

(# <"





5

( ">

( *

" ##

(

" 4

*

! 

#*$0*@@$#! (  ( " *!( (+7 5# C !" ( (# 8

+222! $0*@@$#  " "#

*

# "  

# " # #**

 * #  

) "



<"

#( 

15

## #



 "

 # %  ,- .

 /    0& * 10  "#"#$"2 * 345 -1   0   0  /    ' #  6       )/  

% */0   $7/8 0 "99%-    /   / ) 

 & *10 

: 0"99

# 1 .

 *-0  /-  , /   ' #  6    0

0

     .

  /)  0  

5)/)+ 5  / , *+   0

  $7"8;78/ * 0"99%

  .

*0      * 1 #  ,- / -0     -)*

& *10-0/)

-/ ,#+ #4   

##  *  * #

 

   !  "

6  

 

05  "  "  "#

( ) 2&9$!

"

"!" #**   (

*##*

 

   <"

#

"# " *  #

  "  "

 

"### 

 *

15## )"

 A+,@*

353 1 <"





575

( "



 

"# )(#

#"

 #

##(*

( # )8

222 " "8

2D  <" (  (

575

 2&9$!  "

"  #      "

#    

  

,75  (

"?

,75

 ## %6 1 """!13!$"2 13"6$"2 ($ ) '

)  +$, -"$"

. / $"

%"

"! 3!

#< 4

-%  0  // / # 5 )/  0     "2##$"2-/ 

0  0  //   = "

"131 > )/  ) 0345 -1  /*/  # 5

 )/  ) 0345 -1 

*   , < 4  !/ 

000 ))

/  *   * )/)+#50 ,     <   4  00   *  0 )  

  / *

*## )/)+- , * 345 

0  *? )5// 

0 

 *# 345,

 .

    * / , 

#<   4  -         )   0     ) 

"9#"$#$"-

     / *

*  //

/   # '  0 //   ,  /* 0 /   345 -1  0   0@  )## $9##$"2# 5 2(  (

*"

!"+ #".  !

C *> *? )  )!

"*  "

'**

 ,7  "

( 8

2D<"   "*#

'**

 +,!0 1  #

3!3  %  A      )/   0      !  -  

/  

)        /   ##  <   4  -  

00  0 )  

  / * *  #  !$

1/$1 "2  / 0  

)  /  ,  *0   *0 )5  "#"#$"#% /  0  *0 

,  /   * 0:B#= 

 /* 0 10  "#"#$"@ ,

0

3 04 5A   / 0  

)    0 / ,/0 )  "#"$#$"#A      /  22

   0  

  

 7  0 C-$DC :DC8-  / , 

*0 0:B#A  / 0  

) / / , *%"99-6$

1/$1 "

1$ $ '



7 ,

 

"! ,"" $ 

"! &

)$"

$'

$

8 &2 0 - 

 )  0)  "9#"$#$"- / 

 0

  0  0 )/)-



"

' ,' "

, &

 

$ /!9&$''9 !$

&$//

/

#  A   /   0   

)     A   /   ,

*%"99,/ * 3 , * %-$" $2#"$#$" /$"- 

)/)

!

8&0+)/   2

 0.

  #

8  0 +)/   &( 2&(

/ 0.

 E %  

*-     /        

        )/ /   3 ,

*%-$"  

 

# 7 B*    "

#*"(#!   

363 / "  #( #*'(!@@1% -&"

 &0   F  5     %-        @ ,.

!

-&"

:   5)/)+  )    0  @*

  )        00.

E /    % *+  )  /       /0  0      / /   0     %  *   0   // /4 )# "/ , *+)/  00 0 ) 

 0 */ 0* *0 * )   *E -&"

 )$"

/ " *  // /  4 ) 

 //     * 

)   /   0           /-0 /    0/ , * 0,   /

 0 / 

00 0 )!

78

   , E 78 )/)E 78   )    *       / *       /  0 0  * )        // /  4 )  )*-  

  */ 0, >  * /)  

)- * 0 

G     -0 *-)* /0   0 -@)/* 

)0 ) /   0  #+ @ <"**

* *## + #".   /# (

"" #

(*10E<"

"#5-57 "

 ##"*#

 1-17 ##"

"#

 C(!" #



(*10E" ##

'(*@@1!"



 ###* " 

"(    ** 4( #<" ##** *

3%3 ##*  "  !" * ! #")# () "

(  # 

#*'(*@@1<"

""#

* #

( (!" * !" # #(#

) " ( (<"  #(#( #*"*("   * "=# *" #

#    * "  )##

## !" !"

(  "*( "   2&9$!  "

"  "    #

       "

("  (

( 

()#" ##<"  #= *"#(

) ( (   )  2&9$!  "

"  #    (  # 

"#

(  /" ##(  **

#

 )

""#"( #) # 2

*"*("" ##**

 * ## *E "  !" #    *  ""

 

 ((

 ) #  #7+8++7+

# (##  (" (#"# (

-

## !" * !

# 4

## "

#(# ( # !

*)

92):# 0#$

  &//( >>)H      />  

I'

/ 

I'