← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/33776/2022dismissed

Virender Kapoor @ Virender Kapur v. State Of Haryana

2023-03-15Mr. Justice Namit Kumar23 pages



 

      

  

  

  ! 

 "#$

%"#$

 &  "  '



() 

       *+ ,)'#-'# * -.# / $/& '#+/-* -

  0+  $ -**0-() '$ /1#-* - '/)*/ -* -



1#     2/# /, #1,)  ' 34&5#++ 1,#1#678  ! 3



' 3

-3 -3 -3 9-

:7&' 3 -3 -3 9- 

:7&.1  -+#  & 1#'

'

3 - + -# # 0 + 

 

:# 

/ / /,   67 .+#  &''

3 -0 + #

 



,) /;<-0 +  =! &

1#

#1 ,)

1#   1) (# '#+/ +#  "#$

-  *# $

* /$



- #+ /# /

1# ,   > # .# //

/

 /1 3)7)

 - /   

/

1#

 /1

 ),#+8 *?3 -0.

# )-'

3!-0 +   #+3

'> 2/

1# +

/ /#

 )

3-!

-

-

=# .# / +# ).#11,  



 2/

1# # / 

  !

-

-

= 9

 ,).)

.

/> 

 !;5// ,#+ 8  !

 !  !

    9

  * / $



 #+#1/#

1

 )#> 

1#  2/ + 

 11 . @

 , .

 # 

  2/      

1#

/

 )#  11 ,2/

1# #

/

!;5/,).)

.

/> /,#+  !

3  !

!  3

  (

/ #  !  !

    3! ;5/ 

  2/ #

)   . 5 .1+ ,) /     ,) .)

5 .1+  #

2/ -

1# #

1

 -!-

-

=

/     ; - /        ##+

1#   @ 

/.



++#+=1#+#+ /@

12/ -

1# #  # 

-/ .- > 

/ -

/ 

@

'1.



 

:

 #11- /)1#+ / 

   @ 

/;  -

1#



,1#

# 

# #2/ 2# 

 7# .  / / 

       / #

+ 

11



.# /+

#

 ) .# /   '#  #  A   > #)-

1#

/

 /  #+ + #++

# .# /

1# - /   / , #1 

  

=*# ):#16#

)2/

1#

"# $

- / .- / / 

1#

1# 

# 1# #+/# # 17 /#.)- / 

 /

1#  . +

11 



! 

1#   # 

 

#

- 

 

  

 ,) .)

 

##

 "#5/ $ /#5- *#  ## 

& 1#-B -0 + -/, #1-./## / ,     

 

 

    





 !

!

       

 "#   #

 $ ! !

!

   "

"     

      !

 %

         

     

& ' 

"#         $  !( !

!

      "   ) *+(*(

" #

  

 

3

   "     ) ,!, 

!- "     .       /

 0     "   ) ,!, 

!,+ " / 0 /

0 1 2#0  

 /  3

    

     %

 "    #      2   #     '    

  

       #        , "   

 



   

"#  4 5

6

 

  !

, !

  !

(

  

&    

 6       

   

       

 "# /  4 

 

   #  !

( 

    

&   

 

  "

 "     #      7        #

 5

  

  /  .    0 /

0 ! -!

-" 

#"8 ,     .  /

 0  ""

7           #       "   #    #

      &  

) !(-   !(--"8 ! 92  + -!

-  &  

) !((, !(( "8 ( 92   ! -!

-5 "   8 ! 

       "   #          1   0  /

0  #   2    / 0  2   #   #     .    /

 0     

" #  !

6"  

&  #

 !, *!

   "        

  2    " 8  , *!

.:

  !

, 8 !

.:

!

  !

- 8 

+

.:

  !

("#     5

 6

  #       

    " 8  ( 

     !

( "# /  4  6

  ;#  5         " "# #

 "  " "   #  #    #

   

  

 #     

&   8

 

#!

!

"   

  "8 -+      #  2

  

  "       "#     "      !

(

 #



 

   #

      #   "      ( -!

*

     

           "   #

  "    

"       



"#    

   "                 

#      #

 

, - ,-( ,-+ !

:4 <;    

  

   , !

! -      .        - !

!$ / :

 

  2    #      2       

   /=



 

8;";    )58:

!-:>9:!

         " 8 

.:        

       #     2

  

    ;         2

 

 "#  .  

     # #   - !

! $  ?      <

9>      "#       #   2



   # #   - !

!   

    #  "         

 #   



 

 ##

 " 

 ""

   :  

  "  /

0 / 0                                

  

           

                          @ ; '# 

1

   /

##  /, 11)# 1# #  8

# 

' 3

-3 -3 -3 9-!

- 

: 7& +#   7  #

/  /



 #  # /#+/1) ,1#,1   

#)

 .

1  )  / + 

 !  

 

 ) ./#/ # 1)#+ ++ .# /  ,5= ##1 #

.# /

#+ #+#1 1(

/ , #

/ ##1 ,#+ 8 !9!   4 3



  # # 

 

+ 

11#1) #+,

 /

1##1 < + < #  ### - 0 + -  / ##1 #

 / , +# /# #1

 167/,+# +#

  &  # # 

) # 

  (

/

 / #

# 1#)

/(

/

 / # #+ #  #

1 C/11/ ,  C /+ / ,    #1 ) 5 

#,1 # 

1   ; # 

1



/ 11#

A +  

/#

#

!"#   #$% & '

 (  ) *        $!$  #$%

$++,!  # &  -( .*



)*  /0     %#1 # 

 / ##.

## 

' 3 &- # 1

+

 ,#1 ;'



1-# ,)1

1



1#  , #  /   /,

,)    .# /

1# ,) #+#

+ 

11 

 



1 #

3!

 

./#/! /, #,)

1#

    /# )  /, 1)5 .1+,)

  #*@ 

 #1,)

1# #9 !

 /# /1 ,  #

 ,)     # /#  1)  

4

/1+1

#

,)

1# 

 !

4-1 

./#/#    AB 

 

 C

     $ 

        # "  



/ #  D    2         

    #  "       7             "   ,!

!

 7 7 7 2     

  )) (  ,3,+3##3###45       6)7  89 )   (  (   

 * 

    /  

"  

     C  "      

   #  "      #    

 

         

  1$# #$"              

  

9

  #    "   

D      "    )    )     (((       ) -    

-  ) * @ /

/,  / 

1)  / ,

.# /

1# ,

.# /

/  - 1)- '# # A.# /./ + 

11



/ ,   #

  #

  9     #+

)

+ 

11 

  /#  /

#  

 44 1

 

/   ;'



1/  /    3



'#  #  A  / / , (# / 

 2 /    '    &  *  ,     -

      '#  #  A / / #

 )#  11 , 1 @#  /#

 )  6 /-   / ,

 .# / #

 ,5= ##1 #

 ./

 ) / , ++

#   +#  1  / , 5 ,)    7 #

/  / 

##1#

  1)*# ):#16#;

 ./ /1 .#,)

  +# / 

 )/

/

/# 

 ,) #1#+ D& 8 3

4 ?*# ) :#1 6# ;# #   # #  +#  - 0 +  

/ 5#+ .#

# #

/#+  /)#1

#

 , #1

 ) # &1

 8 3 - :1 5*- # #1  ) 5 . 0 D

 # )- 0 + - / ,#

  

4  ,)

4

# # +#  -0 + +  ' 3

/E' # #F   

 6##1 *   B

 

 ' # ) 7   * -

G /#

  

  E / '*6*B'7 * G- ./#   

/   . )  

 8 !

-./#/.11 .,)### :/

/#

#A +   

# .#

# # +#  -0 + 

  / /)#1

#

 )#>  #/ 

/

/ #F 

?

#

).# /# .52/1

/#A +  #    

   "

   /  !!-"  ;

  "         "

 



  

" 

   

"    <),- 42:/ 8   ; 2   ? D;

 ?# !  # 

   "    

       , "     E   8 

  " 6

  /

   > " #  "        /  !

! %"  F  /F'   

  =

  ?#   !

* %/

7  <:'

    " ""  

 " - - * !(-.:     ( !

*      ) 

     "     ),:=.

 0 >  

      )-+ 

  

     

 "   #              /     

            "       #  "   8        (%,/'" /$  "   

 

 

7            6

  

  



# 

; 7 7 7 7 , 

          ! *!

!

         "

  ""



"    ):

  =

 ?#    )!:)      

" 

     2

 

   "  "     # #   

       , "   /   !

* %/

7  <:'   # #           



  "   2     2   "     

    "  2  $

+ !

!

     " ;       

  #  

    ;

 ; ?#

 

  "

        

  " "

#:   )       )-  +         "#  # #  "  

   2  !

*/

 

;                                  

   "#2



"   

& ;

"       #     2           

" "  ""



 

   7    * !

!

$ 

          2   #           

     "

  ;=:

,!!:;D<:!

!

        "     "   8   "    + !

!

     G: D   # 

2 

  

     

         



   

     

 "    

2    

" /86/> /   "  

 ;

 "   

   

  

  

     ;

 3  %3



'

?



     

     

"#2



"   

 &      "   "   " 

;   

  

 "         F #        

"   "   

 

 

     

  ""



 ""  "

    "    " 2

 " * $  !

!

 "  

;

#

          

 #    "

  ""



   ""   

  

   2 F #         

 "   #         

 

  

 

 ;=:

,!!:;D<:!

!

    

 "/"

 

    

   ) !@  /     "        !- !

!

  

   

     )

  #   "       + !

!

   

      "   " +!!

!

 /  #   

 (!

!

           

    ;=: ( :;D<:!

!

    "        

 "  

    #  

   

"    #  !

!

      

 "#  # #   "  #  "     

   " 8 ( +* ( +.:   #  "

 

- 

.:   / #      #  "    "  

     (%'"   /  "      8     :     "  

 

"  "     #         "  #      #    -$ !- !!

!

 ;

 4 " 

  

           

 "             # " 

;        )      .  

  

   2



  

      + !

!

8     2  #   #     2   #   #      #       2

 6 

       !  !

!        G: /" 

  

          

   "    

 "   



          :

  )   " #     .    )   +   

    ;  

      

 "     

   ""            "   

    .

      )   +

  

     #     

 "

 # 

 "

  / 

    



     

  "   

   "     

   #  

# #

      

 !

* 



  =

 ?#    ," /86/>/ 5     #  7 

     

 

   .  



)   +  

     "       

       "      

"   #   "

 ,!

!"" 

  @ ( $ ,!

!

     )   +   "    #          "        

 "   #      ""



"   )  C-  "

  

7   "  

     

  - ,!

!$     #  #  2 "      4 2"  

   #  

    #       2

 

   " "      )   +     

  

"  $ * ,!

!

; 

 9<

    ,!

!  "

  

 

    "   " !+ ,!

! /##    2          "   "    

 " 

  ,!

! "   / 7; +



  / 7; 

      ,!

!

         # " 8          =.

 0 >  



   # "8 - 

.:/ 

   

     8 !    " 

!

!   4 2   7#

  "   #  

      #   (!

!

    6    

  # "8 !

     !

!

              

     ,!

!%/

7 /:

' 

9< )  -** - !+ "

3

!

!   =.

0>  

C  1 /  6

 9     F     G:  

 

 

      

      #  "   2       :;# "#  8   :/   6

  9   

 

      #    

   

 (!

!



         &          #  #  " - 

.: %8 7     2 '  !+ !

!

      #        8 ( +* ( +.: %8

 

2

  "

       '      #   # " # "8 -    # "    #      :;#     # "8   #        " #  " "    = /2 0#     

  

 "       # 

 #       :;# 

 

 # " !     2 "     " 

!

!  "  #     #2   "    "  #  "      #   

       8    =  

   

  

"  8    #  

" "           #    (!

!

   

           

  5 

 #  



 "  



    2"" !    " 

!

!

    :6

  ;#       

!

 

      "

 # " 

" " "   #  

   

  " 

                

 

     :;#       2 " " 8 !        8        " 

!

!      "    "

 #  " 

         

     8    #    7    

  "  

   " 2 "# "

"   

"  

  

 

     :

;#          2 " " 8 !       "  !

!

 

          

 D    "   

             

 " < 

   % '

"     

 "@ * /    "   ##

    - *!

! %/

7 /:!'     )   ""     #  " " 8 

.: %8   '  "    4    

       #  "#       !+ *!

! %/

7  /:'  ##



  #   " "

# 

"# # #  

 0 



   



         #

  " "



" "

   2

  "  

 ; 

  "    / 7;)" 

  

       "  #   

 

 

 

           "   8 +         2 

   

"   "     

 

  :"

 

      #  # 

"  #     

     #  

 ?#  /

    

  

 

  "     

        ):

  =

 ?# 

       

 "    

 &

          E    "       

  2 "#   

"# 

        !) 

  

 =

  2              #  "  

       

 "    

 &      E     "        "

 

      "  

                       "  #  

      

              

   #  @ /

/,+ / 1 +.# /  

+) /)/  

+

 

 )#>  ./#/./ .

1# .11 

 '#  #  A  ./ ./#1 5#+ 1   #

 ,5= ##1 #

-   . 

#  .# / /   D# / +

/ +   #

 +

   ,#1  ' 3 &-1

1



1#  , #  / # #

/#

#1

+  ,#1,)# #+  (

/  , #

/  /  

/ +#  

+

 ,#1 ' 3 &



7 //1

1

  #   

/  6 /,  -# #) 11#F  # &  1 + .# /     #

  + 

11 



  .# /

1# (# '#+/ .# / +

 ) # &1

 8 3 - :1 5*- # #1 ) 5 .  0 D

 # )- 0 + -  #+3

>)



1 #

3!

  -

 ./#/     # ! 

1#  +#    5 .1+    2/ # +   .

 , @

 ,)



   .

/@  # +#

1  @  1# )+

2/#

#

/, #

,) 

  # /#  1)   

4

1+1

#

,)

1# 

 !

4 ## *

/ + 

 11 



 / , @

 ,)     *#  $

 .# / '#  #  A-  #+

)

+ 

11 

  ### &    ++

 )# >    / 5 1   E7# :

11G ?

9

3-4 -!

-

=# /)

3- -

-

=#

/ )

 - !-

-9!-

= # / )

 2/) / 1 , #  1   *# ) :#1 6#;# # # /)





 '# /#

.

 #,)

   - *# ) :#1 6# ;# #  

/ /# 

 ,) .)

 D& 3

4

 5#+ /)#1

#

 )##

 # &/)#1

#

 )#>  / , 5 ,) *# ) :#1 6# ;# #

 1 + .# /

/   ./  . 

 8 !

# /  #+#  

 ###  :/ A + 

/# 

 



 /,#

 

4

 ' 3

/'*6*B'7* ,) # # +#  -0 +  *  1

/ .

1

// . / / 

/

 ) #>   . 1) ++.# / 7#:

11- /#

11) #

/+ 

11.# /

1# -,))#+ /

 )#  11  ,-

@  ) /# 2/ .# /

/

  /   #

 + 

 11 .# / '#  #  ,>  1)5 .#+

11) / /).

1+11)



  - #

 ) . ++ .# / ##1 #

 

4

+ 

11

#

 )/1), 5 1.# /

1# 2/ 

1 +.# /

/   #  ,#

- ./#/  ,  # ,) ,   ,) ( G,1### :/# / 

D&3



4 

, -  /) / ,   ,

# 

 # 1 #+ /#

 5#+,

 /#

.11( G,1'

 

7 #

  / /   / -

+

 /, 

11

 )#> 

@ 

)*##1 

  # # 

 

 + 

 11  

 

#1,)

1# #1 #+,

 #1

 0 +   # 1

   / /   * / $

 . +   ##

) ,#1 ,) 1 *# 1 '#  < +-0 + -#  

;  -' 3 - 3 -3 9

:7&.2/

-* /$

 

 5#+  ##

) ,#1 ,

 / 1 *# 1 '#  < +- 0 + - ./#/ . # # #  

9

2/

-/  ,

 /#

#

  3 

 # 3 9!

- /   . # #  

 ,

 ) 

/#

/ =  2/

  1 

#

 2/ ( G,1 '

  

 # *   :0   '  

  ; ( 0 /     5$!%"9  *

 ,<1- / /1 

     ##





"   #  ""

    

    # "       





2/# # ##  

   " ##    

 

   /   #  ""

 

##                           "

  

 "   

&      ##

 / 

  "  

   "   ##

     #

"

         " ""

      " " ##



    ##

   



:  #

 " " 

#"#   &    

           #

  

" "   #        #  

  @ 7H';



 

'   =25 #$,9"*

1,!- /( G,1'

 

/1  ,> # ""

 

 

   

      ""   

   #  "      #  ""

   

  :  





   

"   "   

    

    ""

 "" 

   #"       

    "

  "     D  

   2 

#

 

  "  

     "

  

   "

  

 "   

#    

         "       #                   

 " 

   

  "                

 "   



#      

  "   .    

 

@

 

 

#

/ #1   .# / +

## 

' 3 &-# .

1,

   # ## -./#/  H*1,"> (  -     

: %'  %!'  %'  %,'  % '  5<9 23   

  3  

                       

 

   (   

      -  )   3    3       

         

3               

  3  

      3 

       %('    

1 #

 '

,    

' 3 &- /# 

 #

# #. / / #+/

 '

,  

 3&# ,A

##I 1

 

, #.# #+- /+#  

/.## I- /

- /, >

 ./#/#1 



'

,  

 3& 5.) /,

 #+/

 

,1 ,#1-# / #1#

1 .# /# /

1 # 

#@ ))- #  

#@

  #+ # # /  6 / / ,  >

  1 

. / +#  

 )

/





=# )

/#

 

, #.# #+  



## ## 3 & /#

#

##. / /#+/  / 

 3 &#

,

  / #  ,A

#  # /# ##  2/#

#

/#. / /# ## +##+/

/  

 /   ) #1  / , +    * #1 

/  

 7#  ( .- #  # /1 /

## ./ 1#

 

) / / ##

)# 

   -  /  

/  +#   5#+   ,#1       3  &7"# $ - /#

/,#

#/

. ' 39 &/+ + 1,#1

 /#

/ 1#+ / /# ## #

 

) .  #+ ,5



   

##+ / , ##  ,)1

1

 / #

 #  .11  ##+ /  #1 #1,1    

/ 5#+ #

# / 

  +# )

11+  #J# />  

 ./  /

+)   



  

 

 

,#  

 - /

- /# 

 # 

 #1#

 # 5 ##    34 &  .11  39  &  8 +

# 

+ + 1,#1



/

# /,# * #+1)- ## #

 

( .-;#, )#+





/ +# #1 

 5#+   ,#1    3   &-#  #

/#+   /# ,  /11 ,     @ #

## / # 

/

 

 ! 

   ' D/ / 5#+=   H=8 D/ /

,1  H=8