High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/24783/2012dismissed

Satpal Singh Dahiya v. Huda & ORS

2016-09-26Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan10 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH CWP No.24783 of 2012 (O&M) Judgment Reserved on 11.08.2016 Pronounced on 26.09.2016

CORAM:0 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA

! %

& ' ! % TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA, J.

()! ( & * % * +, -.

+-//0)12*%"

& " * % % !* "

!* %%! 3 +, /+ +-//4/5 -/ +-/+0).2&

$! %& % * ! " ! " & ( +- -6 /66- * ()! ( /, -, +--, 7-8 /+ +--," !

,% 3 !0 *9 2 /6:, % * % *$

# ! %

*!** "

%& ( "

%%!%(7%%! ' &* !

%;< 7%%!" ;<

7%%!&* 5/ /+ +--:

% !

3 % < "

" %&$! * ! %& % % ;< 7%%!" "!!!* * % % % " !* "

!* %%! &* "! ! # * *% % !* " !* %%! +, -.

+-// % &% !3 * * &! +, /+ +-//4/5 -/ +-/+0) .2 ; !

&%%!&!

&% =! % * * % !* <* % * ; % ! % !

&*&* !

"* & %&* &!! !%> ? ++> +5@' ;&* !!

" $ @( !**<

! " # !

" &

"$ @( ;% @ ( !! "" *% %" !* " !* %%! & /, -5 +-/- " %& $ @ ( & !! *! %!*" !* %%! !&* * "

! ! % & < $ @( &% " *% %!*" !* %%! "

&" * * !!

*& % * &!

% % !

* *% %"!*" !* %%! $ @( %!*"

!* %%! # %&

$ @( & !! *

%& &$! ;&* !

!& %!% !

*" ! ; % !! !! >!

@ * % 3 /5 -6 +--/ 3A ? /-+58%+---03

? * =*2$ *% 33A? /1851% +-//0@ % 2!/.

-6 +-/1

! & '! % "! ** !*% *! "

&%% !

; &! ! & < ! !

!!*! "&!!% 3)!" !++.% 3%;%" % ** < B $! % 3"&!!*!&!%!!%" !% "

*%*! %$! %!%$! '" &* !

!* %*% " 3% &

#%%! * ! "&! % !!%!

# *

! ! !!

! ""#$"% & ! !

& " ! ! !

'( )

! &!

& & !

& ! !

!*#+ '!

, !

-)*

./+0 # < % & ;< 7%%! %!!

&!!)/ * & ;< " "$ @( "

! < &* !&%* ! !! !*%% 8--.4 & # "

" " & ( *

! %! &* ! " !*%% % * ' +8 -8 +--8 # * !!

* * ! #" ' 0 #2 # ! &* * & & $ @( # *" & *!*!%! " & ( 7%%! ' -:

+--8 % &*'B

>% ;< 7%%! %! & " !! &* !% > <" * %!%!*!%!! &!** %

! %!&*& % !% !*!%! # ;< 7%%!!%!* ! ! % &*

!"* *%!!%&* & ;"! <

02$ 0@( 2 "&) *%

!! %4! &* ! # " & !!% 3! ! !% !" !& ;< 7%%! # % !& ;< 7%%!"% * !& %% *

%" !&*& $ @( %%! ;!! !% < %* ! &!!& $ @ ( !! % %%! %& ( !!

! %! &* %%! # & %% * !%%!% ! &*& $ @( %!%!* !%!!%> <!&!! "&! !% !

%* $ @( # *" %" '!12!

! 4

! 5!

3 67!& !

&"%%"8"

! !! !

9 ! ! !!

! !

5 !

% ! ! !!

"%& ! & !&!! ! & !

'( )

! &!

& &

!*#+ '!

, !

-)*

./+0 !$ % !%!

%* $ @( " & !

& "" C!!%&* !%"&

" "&!!! " !%!!%!

%&* ! !**%!!!%! %!

# %!

!% "!

* !! %%%!

" # %!* *%" % * !%!<! &)*% !*

# 3% !

!! %& ( "

! % )* ! % * &&*&

$ @( % !**% !%!!!%! % & < !

!!*!"! % !*

" %% *%" * # % "&&&$! %* % "

; !% "! ! *"%* *% %" !*" !* %%! # *! *% %!*" !* %%! $

@( !! **& !* "% %"!*" !* %%! & !! * &! %!*" !* %%! # % !%$ @( " & %

;%! **

* $ @ ( ! %!*" !* %%! # % &%% *%"% *%& !<!**< &!!!

" &! # ! ! & !

@ * Chhattar Singh's case (supra) "

*! # "* %(> !* *%<*% ** & & %*&CC*! %%!4%%!% > &%! *% %!*"

* !

" % !!

&* *$ %* %* ! # %! !

! & = " $ *& 3@anak Singh's case (supra) " !&

; %!%!

! @ *" ! ;!**% & * !**< ! " "!!" & *@ 0 2!* % %% !*" !* %%! # !**// -8 +--- * % %"!*" !* %%! & *@

&% !**5- -6 +-/- ! %* %"%!*" * %%! %"%!*" * %%! !%& * ; % * & " & *"%%" !%% *!

!%* *% %& @ &$! ;

%!!!*! 3 ! !!! * ( ""!%" ! "

! % *& < " % *!!!**& !

* 3 !* %!%

; !%

! D&*3 & %" :'

&,! ! !!!

! !

& ,!

! ! !

;

!< !

! ! 4

!! !

& ,! ! ! '

&,! & !! '

&,!

&! 0 B !& "&& " % * # " !

* * 26.09.2016 (TEJINDER SINGH DHINDSA) JUDGE √ 4 E4? √ & E4?