High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21652/2013allowed

Binder Kumar v. Presiding Officer Ind Tribunal & ORS

2019-01-15Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina6 pages

!"# $ " %

&'" () *"(& ++ ,-

,.!"+/&01 +- $*+12(&01 $3&01 -

+4(& -#1--(" 3 +'" (-"0& 56 + 7+0 568+" %

&'" () *"(& + 9" :&

)+--(; *": + <* " :& + 1" )+"" "( -+- +-(%+ )+ + ++- - (#; /* //((*" #"(%* /=; / " %+- >

+ ? @ ((% * /#"(*:+".*21 #)+(*" + %

- - %/+* /#"6>&

5AB" ;++"#

AB;-*:+ -A!! /&$((% +%;( )+( 0*+ & <C(/ +"%+ - A;

!"# & + - - 0 "# 5

5AB ; "% 1 *( #+-

A !! / & 3+ !"# -- * +) *"(*.++;+ - - - A !! / =;1 & ;+( "% + #-(:B#-(: (+-& +; -/ + ; # + + 7 -8 ; : #" + --(B +4(& + +--(;"# > AB+ #-(: &+ &+# ."" 3 +0 56--(" 3 #*((*(*## =#++ (# ; /%+* /B/(>

+(*"

?*:+".*21 #*";-:*(+

>D 5 =;- ((:-(+ +4(+ 1 -:##"%&

AB #+#-(: %+( + %+" &

AB)+(# +--(1%" +%+(:?%% =;:+(# +4(; "# > +#-(: )+--(+ 1-:# #"% &

AB # + #-(: % ( (*" + %#"%&

AB=++--(++; >(* /" %+- >

;++ -*(" %; #+#* <* " :;+* / /( #" : * - * / /()+ ; /+* //(+:

"% ( + : = # + + --( ; /" %+- >

)+1%" + (#(1&: !"# & #+ ++#" *"(#+--(#+;++#"

(*" + %#+(#--(=#("( *"( #- % -+ + -(:+;%( &

AB= " + ++--(%-:#

#+#-(:

+ &--; /%( ;++("%%%;+" #%+#-(: ++--( -- ++#-(: ; /+?&+#-(: / +--(-:*/+"%#" > AB +( )+ --( - -:% + "%#"&+--(+ (+1%"; %(# " +(# +#-(: + )+; # 5+0"%"&

' #- + !"# +; -(: (* +) *"(++;- A!!

/=;1 & ;@+#+#+; A !! / ' ; (: " % + 1 + + - " ,A,#( $((%%;(&0*+ + ;,#(+-(#++;; A !! /=+1:- =-+ !"# + - + /!( +#-(: ( !"# ;- 3! /!(;++"+ #-" ;++ ((6>!#;: #+* //(=#+

=#+ (# +4(; /(*" +* //( +- >

=+ +4(+#"(( * /'+ B?#&+- ++; /# #1--(* + /'- 2 B''&0*+ ;+++:7;8-- 7;8%1 -(:* + /

'- )+; 7;8% +?-- - *+,,#(+- - !"# ;"(-- #++: +#- +(# +4(

)+ ( - * +) *"( ; :

((; 7A !! / $((% +%;( )+( 0*+ <C(/ + "%+ - A;

!"# 8 6 '+# +- ; -&+# + - A; +*+% ((; 7A!! /$((%+%;()+(0*+ <C(/+ "%+ - A; 3+,# (8 > +%%"(+# #- #*(;+" (1 +" =*.*-"*:+,% :+# (% +-&;"(##+1*"- *(

!"# -+*"/,#((/+

< + % *: + ) *"( + #-"% ;+(((;%+(#&++(+1+"%+ , ( !"# +; +-1 +* / /(& + 1 + % (*(& -((: + "#+++ ((+ %+--(+ ?%% +(# " + +"# > AB 1 *(

#+--(*:+#-(: " + +"# &

AB ;-%+(+ %+" &

AB)+) *"( (: %+(:("+ +; ;+

+ -&+; #;+ ++ + )+ +" (( "( +- "*( 3(( " + & +) *"(++( %+(:+- 3 B +0& ":+*1 :#-(: #+#" B (( - 1 #/% &-((:*:+; /## ;+ % -:#&*"+&"+ ++(%+ +:)+ -;" *(%/- #+ +;%"#* * /#"(%A- - *:

--(" %+- >

+"(( -+ ((*" + %;((#"-+ --(&*""+ ;# + */; !"# ' ;"( :,# (0 -- % + 1* "%+ &+) *"(("+ 1;&+ % 1%1* "%+ *:+ -B%# *"+(# +--(B(# 0 %(:&+) *"(++(++(#( 1 5

5AB;++#:" 1 *( #+ -B %#;+++(%((:(' +- !"# ++%;+A!! /&+"(+1 ( +

1:%+++ ; - - + / !(/;+%*"+ "++ +- ( + *:+"++ # %+:;+A!! /!(;+++(% +#( #

)+ %+ +) *"(&';"( (:+ " ,#(,+ "% -*(:; ? -(%"*#*: !"# * +) *"(

;+( % + (# # ;+" (% : + - @: 1((*(:+ %(:"

+ "( (%'((;+1*:-(%* '1; +*1&' # +-;++ %(: # ;+

AB * - + ; /#A - :+(%?-&*:#% +#-"% + <* " :& -*:+ %

&'" () *"(& +

" #