State Bank Of India v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd And Others

















 

 !"
#$
"%&'&#(
)
**
+! !"
 (,
#$
(-&
.//"00 (!
1"2'3'

3(4 5
+! !"
&1&0
+3//0&"'
#2/#2 !&#(
6&7&!"-

+
!82#398
&'!2&%!
( 9"2:
+:

; /32!8 0
(-
#!8"2'
.*"'/#(-"(!'

#2 7
)


     
2"'"(!
)

2*
 ,"'8
3/! :
-1#% !"
$#2
!8"
//"00 (!*

2*
""/ ,
3/! :
-1#% !"
$#2
2"'/#(-"(!
#**
<<<
   

 
8"
%#7/"!&(9
%0 &7'
#$
!8"
'"%32"-
%2"-&!#2
(-
3('"%32"-
%2"-&!#2
8 1"
%#7"
3/
$#2
-43-&% !&#(*

(
!8"
#("
8 (-:
!8"
//"00 (!
5"$#2"
!8&'
#32!
&'
!8"
+! !"
 (,
#$
(-&
%#('!&!3!"-
3(-"2
!8"
+! !"
 (,
#$
(-&
%!:
*
!
%0 &7'
!8 !
!8"
/2#/"2!=
> '
7#2!9 9"-
5=

?'
**
92#
&00'
&(
$ 1#32
#$
!8"
 (,
#(
@**A*

+35'"B3"(!0=:

$2"'8
7#2!9 9"
-""-
> '
"C"%3!"-
'
!8"
7#3(!
#$
0# (
> '
"(8 (%"-
#(
***

(
!8"
#!8"2
8 (-:
!8"
3(4 5
+! !"
&1&0
+3//0&"'

#2/#2 !&#(
6&7&!"-
&(
'8#2!
D+E:

%#7/ (=
#>("-
5=
!8"
+! !"

#1"2(7"(!
%0 &7'
!8 !
?'
**
92#
&00'
8 '
"75"FF0"-
!8"
/ --=?2&%"
00#!!"-
!#
!8"
7&00'
$#2
!8"
=" 2

(-
*

8"
+
5=
!8"
1&2!3"
#$
(
&(!"2&7
#2-"2
/ ''"-
3(-"2
+"%!&#(

#$
!8"
25&!2 !&#(
(-
#(%&0& !&#(
%!:
@:
%0 &7'
!8"
/2#/"2!=*

!
&'
0'#
'! !"-
!8 !
&(
!8"
25&!2 !&#(
/2#%""-&(9':
!8"
25&!2 !#2
/ ''"-
(
> 2-
&(
$ 1#32
#$
!8"
+
#(
A**:
/"27&!!&(9
+
!#
2"%#1"2
7#2"
!8 (
'*
%2#2"'*

8"
#54"%!&#(
/"!&!&#(
3(-"2
+"%!&#(
G
#$
!8"






25&!2 !&#(
(-
#(%&0& !&#(
%!:
@
&'
'! !"-
!#
8 1"
5""(
-&'7&''"-
5=
!8"
&'!2&%!
#32!
#(
H***


+
&'
'"",&(9
!#
2"%#1"2
!8"
7#3(!
&(
!8"
"C"%3!&#(
/"!&!&#(*


(
!8"
#("
8 (-:
!8"
0" 2("-
%#3('"0
2"/2"'"(!&(9
!8"
 (,
'357&!'
!8 !
!8"
 (,
8 '

/2&#2
2&98!
!#
2"%#1"2
!8"
7#3(!
5"% 3'"
&!
&'
!8"
'"%32"-
%2"-&!#2*

(
!8"
#!8"2
8 (-:
0" 2("-
%#3('"0
2"/2"'"(!&(9
!8"
2"'/#(-"(!+
'357&!'
!8 !
!8"
+
&'
"(!&!0"-
!#
!8"
7#3(!
!8 !
2"7 &('
$!"2
!8"
%0 &7
#$
!8"
 (,
&'
'"!!0"-*

!
8 '
0'#
5""(
'! !"-
!8 !
!8"
 (,
>#30-
! ,"
!&7"
&(
3%!&#(&(9
!8"
/2#/"2!=
3(-"2
!8"
+"%32&!&F !&#(
(-
"%#('!23%!&#(
#$
&( (%& 0
''"!'
($#2%"7"(!
#$
+"%32&!=
(!"2"'!
%!:

+ +
%!:

(-
!
/2"'"(!
&(
!8"
"C"%3!&#(
/"!&!&#(:
3%!&#(
#$
!8"
/2#/"2!=
8 '
02" -=
5""(
#2-"2"-
5=
!8"

#32!
(-
!8"
 (,
% (
5"
/"27&!!"-
!#
4#&(
!8"
3%!&#(
/2#%""-&(9'
(-
'"%32"
&!'
/ =7"(!*



;""/&(9
&(
1&">
!8"
$ &2
'! (-
! ,"(
5=
!8"
0" 2("-
%#3('"0
2"/2"'"(!&(9
!8"
+:
!8"
"C"%3!&#(
$&2'!
//" 0
&'
-&'/#'"-
#$
5=
/"27&!!&(9
!8"
//"00 (! (,
!#
4#&(!0=
3%!&#(
!8"
7#2!9 9"-
/2#/"2!=
5=
52&(9&(9
!8"
&(!"2"'!"-
/32%8 '"2'*

!
!8"
$&2'!
'! 9":
!8"
 (,
'8 00
5"
"(!&!0"-
!#
-43'!
&!'
-3"'
5"&(9
!8"
'"%32"-
(-
/2"$"2"(!& 0
%2"-&!#2
$2#7
!8"
3%!&#(
/2#%""-'*

8"
2"7 &(&(9
7#3(!
'8 00
5"
-"/#'&!"-
&(
!8"
"C"%3!&(9
#32!
$#2
!8"
//2#/2& !"
-&'!2&53!&#(*


G

#>"1"2:
&$
!8"
#32!
3%!&#(
$&C"-
$#2
**
$ &0':
!8"
 (,
'8 00
8 1"
0&5"2!=
!#
$&0"
(
//0&% !&#(
5"$#2"
!8"
C"%3!&(9
#32!
$#2
$&C&(9

$2"'8
'%8"-30"
$#2
!8"
3%!&#(
#$
!8"
/2#/"2!=*







I&!8
!8"'"
#5'"21 !&#(':
!8"
//" 0
&'


 *

8"
#2-"2
/ ''"-
5=
!8"
--&!&#( 0
&'!2&%!
3-9":
; /32!8 0
#(
**
'8 00
'! (-
7#-&$&"-*

  

 

**