High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37207/2021dismissed

Raninder Singh v. Income Tax Department And ANR

2025-09-03Mr. Justice Tribhuvan Dahiya16 pages

!"#$#%#&## ##% # !'( ) *) + # , - .!

/0 1' 2%3 .3 /0

5 , - .!

/0 1' 2%3 .3 /0 # , - .!

/0 1' 2%3 .3 /0 #( 6$7 )", $1#%#&#

!"#$%

&!' ( $ #%!)

*"+ (

,# $1#%#&#8")

- # #!

# (/

01.22 .2.3 ! # 45.(#( 3610$#7( ( 8%# 2.

.2.39 5!) , * (//+ 3.#23 .2.2 # !)!), :( * 35 .2.2(;

133<=.2.234 .2.2 > )! 835 .2.2

!) # !)=?# @# $# 7@ ?

8% # !)#=: 9?$#7:

?8%!

01.24 .2.3 (/

01.21 .2.3!# 45.( ( !)# # )- 2.

.2.3 !) , * (// + 33 .2.2(//+ 32.< .2.2 # !) 35 .2.2 !) # !)@ ?

# !):

#!###(/

01.22 .2.3:

?# 02 .23A!#(# , * .11# : 936A3 31A31135335A351360366 #: ($#7:(8%

: 9 ? !

# # > ## !#) # #

!#) # # !" '( " $B:@% C =303$3% # 02 .23A" ! = , = ! ).6 ?

! - # !#

) = # , # !

- # ).6 ?

! # ## / " # - # 9 02 .23A /## ##

.233 # # # !)? #: 9$: % ( !) = # # )!# # ###

) $>%$.5 2A .233!)( )# : > 9 9/$> /%?# ( # ? 9 $(?

% ##

) # (> )# .5# ? 9($?

(%! : > # #)# # B ? .5 2A .233 # ( ) # > !- ) #

# (#: 9$: %(?

+ ? 34 .233!)> /?#(?

.233(:

$: %(?

+ ?

5 #?

$: %( # =A< #:@351. # ! ! # ( : ) > / ? # (?

( # .5 2A .233 # ( > )99 ( . 34 .233# > /?9 ( 0)## ..

.233 # # !) ?

$: %(99 ( 4 ) # # : ) > / # (?

9 ( < #3< 2.

.23A =A<#> /?#(?

9 ( A ; ! #

# # ## #"C#

## !

.11 # : 931A31135335A351360366:( .4 .231

!)# (//+ 01#.3 .231

!) , * E 8 # .1 .2359 0

!) =:

?!#( !)# (/

3<2A. .236 F .

)# @ ?

!# ## # !) =:

? " )# : # 7directorate of enforcement was also seized of the matter with

+ regard to the subject matter of the said complaint pending before the court and that the subject matter came within the ambit of FEMA, 1999 and the applicant Respondent No. 2 was the sole authority to administer the said law and for the purpose of conducting investigation under the provisions of the said act the documents attached with the complaint are required to be examined which are on the judicial file of the Court'.

!) 35 .2.2#F # !)@ ?

!)!)# (// + 3. # 23 .2.2 !# ? , * 2.

.2.3

8 : # !" #

F ! !) !)@ ?

!=( # # :# #!)>/ # :#!) #

H : !! #: # > / # # 9 # # 9 # '#

) .5#( #21 36643.

.226

9 .5 $3%

9 # $

% )#) #(# # ( 9 !)(#9 )(

## # # 9 ) # !) (

! #! #( ' ##

)

! ) $

## ## 9 !F#(

# )# !

) # $.% :

#3! (! $% ) ## (E $!% ) # !!

# ##(E $% ) #

) !

# # #

!) )

# .5 ! ) ) ) =:

?!! ( #

@ ?

E- ) !

! !)(

: # F !) (

$.233%5((101 < &!' ( #

) F @ ?

F /

.# ((3A# F!') '( /

;

)

( # ## ( " # ##@ ?

8 ##

'# ! " #

$.233%5((3 .5!9 !) ( # !) #! ! # !) :

? .11#: 9 36A3 31A 311 353 35A 351 360 366 # :(

###

) > !) )# :=> 9 9 / ?#( #? 9#> ) ! :##7!#

: ##

8 ?

) # !# @ ?

# # # #= C# !F# # # - ! 9

35 .2.2 2.

.2.3 I , #/

.# ((3A# F!')' ( /

;

#$%# ## ## #!)@ ?

were found sufficient, and the E.D. was allowed to inspect the file, by recording as under: + .J# # F! ') ' (

4(3A ! 3

;"' < /

: # / #

!# # !F # , # ( : !) !

) #!E* 8( ") ) * K )# ## ## ( # $%!## L3

* + $3 !) + 306 /

=::

4 30 .221 % :

) #9 # # # , )# #$/

<! % 9

)!)# #

. ) # ## # # #

! @#? # C #

# 3< 999 999 3A J ! #

4(3A(

# # ## # )

>@ # @?

)

( #

###) #)#

> # # .5#( G

H! #: >/ ! )#!) !

) !

#9# # ' # !# !) :

? ! !) > /

# # ?

9 # ! ( ! " $ %%9 #? 9 ! #: )E .A# % .5# - ( 9 ! # # !) # : 9# 0.# ( B#:

9# # ( A1 / # .A# 9

))# !!)B#: #

G9) 2- ; ;

M$3% #

9 #)#) # ) # !)

! #! #

! ) $

## # # 9 !) ) ) # F

$.%:

#3! !

$% )

## E $!% )# !!

# ##E $% ) #

) !

# # #

! ) ) $ % H

! )

)#B#: !

! # ) : #

)#)! !#( ! #9

# # !"

)

()# ! #)

A5 #B#:G H .A$3% # 9 ) 9 B # :

) : B#:# ' B#: ) )#

* 9#!#( A6 12 999999 999 # .A$3% # ? 9 ) GK L) ) # F H ) : 9 # : ### ! ) ! ) G $

## ## 9 !)H & '(

% )% %

* % +,-./

0 %

(

( %

( ( %

:# !)B#:

! .A$3%# 9

! #!)B#:

# )#9 !# F # ) 9!

)

# ) ! !)B#: $: !) ( % 1.

999 999 999 )

!! # .A$3% # 9

)##B#: ! # ! ) 9 # :

( )

! )F!

)# ! # ) # ! 9 # # ( # !)( )#( # 52 999 999 999 :

)! ! "# (!

! 9

) ! # #

) ! #

9 # # ! ) +)! # )# )B#: # .A$3% # 9

) ) ! !) ( :! )(

.A#

% .5# ! # # ' # # !

)# # # 7 %% %

(

-./

1+8 ! ## !

% # ! C# )

5 #! ## ( )C)##) " # )#!

!# ( # #!" #

## #

! #) ? #!" ! !) I!

! 9 #!" ! ) !

#C!" !"

F ! # # # - :C

) " !#)

)# # # # ) I # #C8!" ' C # #!" !# # # # # ) # # ! ) ! !

# #

: )#!!

# !

#!# $2 ( %

3 (

(

( '

:##

) $: !) ( % .

) ( B # : # " !

)

) B#: 9 # # # =- #

:#### ! # # !# !):

? ! !)?=@ ?

# # : #!# E )#) ) !F !)

# ? 9 : # : >/ #! :

? : ## ) ##

# .5# ? # #!F## !F!! # # ! " # C ) ) # #

" !

'#! !)#=@ ?

## #

!"9 #

$ %% !) ) ! ) ! )

: !# @ ?

#= !# !) :

?# # #! @ ?

) !) - : ##

@ ?

# !#

#= E

! )

)#! # /$1#%#&#0 "%

) *) + I"= N=+ I!

N=+