← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13921/2017dismissed

Parvinder Pal Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-02-07Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages



    

!"#$#%&'&() 

!*+&($#* !,-&(./  #"&"&(#* 0#*'1' -"!"#!*2!(!!($ *'  #'3($#("'   

  

*#'#(") *!,$#+-&(.//&,,(4$+%!"#*"/#3#"&"&(#* * !*$##3-,!"/4!$+%!"#**#'3($#("'!($ 555    67

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

&+#-%&#"&#'%"E@4 "/#*#*#("%+#*#$1($#*"/#$#&(&"&(F-"!"#G1($#**"&%,#"/# ('"&"1"&(($&!4"/#*#*#("!:#(!=,#""/#C1*&'$&%"&("/#&./ 1*"&(+&#8"/#$#%&'&("/#-13*#:#1*"&(  - @&( %!'# "&",#$ !'  4 /!$*! -/!/!>!*& -H &2!:&"! +#*'1' *#'&$#("4 /&"*!$1*.!!I$*-!(./!($ "/#*'8/#*#&(&"8!'/#,$"/!"!3#*!"&+# -1.!*!%"*2*#.&'"#*#$1($#*"/#D3#*!"&+#-%&#"&#'%"8&"/!

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

*$&*#%"*'*#'3($#("4 "/!" *#'3($#("  /!$ ("/&(. " $ 8&"/ "/# *#%*1&":#("  #:3,2##' =2 *#'3($#("  @4 "/!" ( #A3&*2  "/# %("*!%" =#"8##( "/# *#'3($#(" 3#*!"&+#!(>!($1"'1*%&(.!.#(%2(E4*#'/%("*!%"8!' !,,""#$"':#"/#*1"'1*%&(.!.#(%2"/*1./#"#($#*&(.4"/!"8*&"8!' (" :!&("!&(!=,# !.!&('" !( 1"'1*%&(. !.

6@7    <  E &( %!'# "&",#$ !' 0&>!'/ +#*'1' -"!"#  !*2!(! $#%&$#$(!'!,' @EE&(%!'#"&",#$!' !C##+ H1:!*!($ "/#*'0#*'1'-"!"# 1(C!=!($"/#*'$#%&$#$(BBE 6@7

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

8/#*#13("/#(#81"'1*%&(.!.#(%2$#3,2#$ &"' 8( #:3,2##' !($ "/# 3#"&"&(#* !

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

-!,&!   - 1$.#  /#"/#*'3#!>&(.B*#!'(#$ ) #'B  /#"/#**#3*"!=,# ) #'B