High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19145/2014allowed

Geeta Rani v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2017-07-26Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!"##$%&%'( ) *

* ##"! !'% ++ #"%"%'#, -#,&.& /"!"# .'0!1!'2!'"3#, ++ #&4'2#'"&

,#&#'"(+ ,5!4%65!77!,829$!"#,"3#4#"%"%'#, ,9%'%"9!&"3%88 .'0!1 ,/!6!6829$!"#,,#&4'2#'"' :::

3# %,#$", #'#,!6 /$36 2.$!"%'8 .'0!1;,#&4'2#'"

' %&&.#2 !29#,"%&#<#'" 2!"#2 =>

= %'9%"%'? !446%$!"%'& , ,#$,.%"<#'"

!44,@%<!"#6A <4."#,#!$3#,& ' $'",!$".!6 1!&%& #"%"%'#,!446%#2%',#&4'&#""3#!29#,"%&#<#'"!'2B!&&.10#$"#2 " ! 4,$#&& &#6#$"%' '

= 4#"%"%'#, B!& %&&.#2 !'

!44%'"<#'",2#,!'2%'4.,&.!'$#"3#,#"&3#0%'#2!&<4."#,#!$3#,

$'",!$".!61!&%& ' =

/#,9%$#&"3#4#"%"%'#,3!9#1##'

,#?.6!,%C#29%2#,2#,2!"#2>

1."B#

3#%'&"!'"B,%"4#"%"%'3!&1##'%6#2&##7%'?%&&.!'$#! ,%"!'2!<.&&##7%'?1#'#%"!'"#2!"#2,#?.6!,%C!"%'%#B#

%'&"#!2

.'&#6,"3#4!,"%#&3!9#1##'3#!,2!"6#'?"3 3##'"%,#$!&#&#".4'1#3!6"3#4#"%"%'#,%&'"3# &",#'?"3<#<2!"#2

%&&.#21A"3#/4#$%!6/#$,#"!,A8/$36 2.$!"%'!'2'"3#&.10#$",#?.6!,%C!"%'&#,9%$#&"3#<4."#,

+ + #!$3#,&8 B3 B#,# !44%'"#2 ' $'",!$".!6 1!&%& %' "3# .'0!1 ',<!"%'<<.'%$!"%'#$3'6?A2.$!"%'/$%#"%#&$'&"%"."#2 .'2#,"3#2.$!"%'#4!,"<#'" 6!.&#"3#46%$AB.621#,#6#9!'","3#%&&.#!"3!'2 !'2,#!2&%'"3#66B%'?"#,<&(+

" # # # $ # %

& "%&'"%'2%&4."#"3!""3#4#"%"%'#,3!20%'#2!&<4."#, #!$3#,' =

%'4.,&.!'$#"!,#?.6!,&#6#$"%'4,$#&& #"%"%'#, $<46#"#2"3# DA#!,&&#,9%$#'

3#,#%&!6&',#1.""!6""3#!&&#,"%'<!2#'1#3!6"3# 4#"%"%'#,"3!"3#,B,7!'24#,,<!'$#B!&&!"%&!$",A

6#!2%'?&',#$,2B.62!6&$6!,%A"3!"!&'"3#,#6#9!'" 2!"#%#B3#'"3#4#"%"%'#,$<46#"#2 DA#!,&&#,9%$#'

"3#,#B#,#'2#4!,"<#'"!62%&$%46%'!,A4,$##2%'?&4#'2%'?!?!%'&"3#, "3!&1##'1,.?3"""3#'"%$#"3#.,""3!"!&3B$!.&# '"%$#B!&%&&.#2""3#4#"%"%'#,'

!'2B3%$38"3#,#!"#,83!2 1##'%6#2')

3#%&&.!'$#&.$3&3B$!.&#'"%$#B.62'"1#!'A ,#6#9!'$#%'&!,!&"3#$6!%<,!%&#2%'"3#%'&"!'"4#"%"%'

'2#,"3#46%$A%&&.#29%2#<#<2!"#2

''#@.,#

+> "3##<1!,?!&,#?!,2&"3#1#'#%",#?.6!,%C!"%'1#%'??,!'"#2B!& '6A8%8'"3#,#6#9!'"2!"#!'A2#4!,"<#'"!62%&$%46%'!,A4,$##2%'?&B#,# 4#'2%'?"<!A1#,#%"#,!"#2"3!"%'"3#$!&#%'3!'2"3#,#6#9!'"2!"#%&

+>+

%# B3#' "3# 4#"%"%'#, $<46#"#2 D A#!,& &#,9%$# '

$'",!$".!61!&%&!'2'&.$32!"#"3#,#B#,#'2#4!,"<#'"!62%&$%46%'!,A 4,$##2%'?&%'%"%!"#2;4#'2%'?!?!%'&"3#, '"3#$'&%2#,#29%#B"3%&.,"$6!%<"3#4#"%"%'#, &##7%'? 1#'#%" ,#?.6!,%C!"%' B#

B.62 1# &E.!,#6A $9#,#2%'"#,<&"3#46%$A%&&.#29%2#<#<2!"#2

3# '6A 0.&"%%$!"%' 1#%'? #,#2 1A "3# ,#&4'2#'" !."3,%"%#&!&,#?!,2&?,!'"1#'#%",#?.6!,%C!"%'""3#4#"%"%'#, B#

%&"3!""3#$!&#&,#?.6!,%C!"%'B#,#$'&%2#,#2%'1!"$3#& !".,<'"3&%'"#,9!6"%&$'"#'2#2"3!"'6A'!$$.'""3#$!&# "3#4#"%"%'#,3!9%'?1##'$'&%2#,#2%'!&.1&#E.#'"1!"$38,2#,&2!"#2 >

B#,#%&&.#2?,!'"%'?""3#4#"%"%'#,"3#1#'#%",#?.6!,%C!"%' B#

3#&"!'2"!7#''1#3!6"3#/"!"#$!''"1#$'&",.#2!&! 9!6%21!&%&,2#'A%'?""3#4#"%"%'#,3#,9#&"#2,%?3"1#%'?$'&%2#,#2 ,,#?.6!,%C!"%' .'2#,"3# ,#6#9!'"46%$A%#<#< 2!"#2

''#@.,# +> %?3" "3#4#"%"%'#,.'2#, <#<2!"#2

''#@.,# +> 3!2$,A&"!6%C#2'

%"&#6#,#6A'!$$.'" $#,"!%'!2<%'%&",!"%9##@%?#'$A;2%%$.6"A8%8"3#$!&#"3#4#"%"%'#,B!& "!7#'.4%'!&.1&#E.#'"1!"$38"3#&!<#$!''"2##!""3#,%?3""3# 4#"%"%'#,"$6!%<,#?.6!,%C!"%'B#

%#"3#2!"#&3#3!2 $<46#"#2 DA#!,&&!"%&!$",A&#,9%$#!&!<4."#,#!$3#, "B.62!6&1#!44&%"#""!7#'"#"3#&4#$%%$!9#,<#'" <!2#%'"3#4#"%"%'"3!" '#<%" ?'!B!& ?,!'"#2"3#1#'#%" ,#?.6!,%C!"%''"3#2!"#$<46#"%' DA#!,&&#,9%$#'$'",!$".!6 1!&%&%#B#=

/.$31#'#%"B!&$'#,,#2%'4.,&.!'$#""3#

++ 46%$A 2!"#2

''#@.,# +> /.$3 !&&#,"%' <!2# 1A "3# 4#"%"%'#,3!&'"1##'2%&4."#21A"3#,#&4'2#'"!."3,%"%#&%'"3#B,%""#' &"!"#<#'" 3#!$"%' "3#,#&4'2#'" !."3,%"%#&%' 2#'A%'?" "3# 4#"%"%'#,"3#1#'#%",#?.6!,%C!"%'B#

!&&.$3%&3#62"1# 2%&$,%<%'!",A!'29%6!"%9#,"%$6#&!'2)"3#'&"%"."%' '2%!

,"3#,#!&'&,#$,2#2!19#8"3#B,%"4#"%"%'%&!66B#2 %,#$"%'&!,#%&&.#2""3#,#&4'2#'"!."3,%"%#&;,#&4'2#'"' "%&&.# ,2#,&,"3B%"3",#!"%'?"3#4#"%"%'#,"1#,#?.6!,%C#2B#

#"%"%'#,B.62!6&1##'"%"6#2"!66$'&#E.#'"%!61#'#%"&#<!'!"%'? ,<"3#2!"#,#?.6!,%C!"%'"1#,#$7'#2B#

#"%"%'%&!66B#2%'"3#!,#&!%2"#,<&

6.$7A 3#"3#,&4#!7%'?;,#!&'#2( #&; 3#"3#, #4,"!16#( #&;