Krishna And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

 
   
   
   
  
 
 
 
 



 ! !"#$#%& 

 ! !"#$#%& 

 ! !"#$#%& 

 ! !"#$#%& 

'(#$)%%* )!($ ! # #%!($ +$ ,  ! (-%%* )!($ !$.%*!% $

/&01/,
','/
/&01/,
','/
/&01/,
','/
/&01/,
','/   

(!$!% & /(, )2334*5" !4

( )!.! # #%!($ /$, #2. 44(-%

','/4 ','/4 ','/4 ','/4 )! .! # #%!($ (! )! (!$#*!% $   +#336! 1)(( #$ (#"  ,%!. 47))5!8!!%"%5#" !*#%"$!(!6#$ !(!*5#*! * !* 9:

;2%*!(,!" #%9 (!*7# ),!" #%9:  )!%*#%!%3
*!4

< ($)( = )!
0>%*,!" #%$ ?@?:@?

 )!(A$" 4 ?

< $)(  = )! (A$ " 0>   3#"! ,  #% ,*(4 #$ (#"  ,%!.  8- )! **# #%3,!$$#%$2*6!4,%!. % 9

%*$!% !%"!* $2

!(3# ! #A.(#$%A!% )!- #3!*"(#A#%3..!38!(#%6
9;  

7)#")7$*#$A#$$!*%9 ? :8- )#$
2( ! # #%!($4 %*: (!.(!$!% 3-3*6!*#% #$ (#" #34) B%*.! # #%!(9#$3*6!*#%

#$ (#" #34(#*8*)!-338!3%6  )!$A! A#3-%*)5!.(-!*

( )!#$$2%"! 7(# #% )!% 2(! "!( #((# (C2$)#%6 )!(*!( * !* ; ; .$$!* 8- )! #(!" ( !%!(3   (#$%$4 (-% D(!$.%*!%   E 8- 7)#") )!#( ..3#" #% ( )!#( (%$ !(  #$ (#"  #34,%!. )$8!!%*!"3#%!*

  %8(#!

4 )!..3#" #% #3!*8- )!.! # #%!($ ( )!#( (%$ !( 7$!(3#!(*!"3#%!*5#*!(*!($* !*?? ;%* ; ;82  )!$#* (*!($7!(!$! $#*!8- )#$
2( #%
//9 9  ;*!"#*!*% 9 ; % )! 6(2%* )  )! $#* (*!($ 7!(! %%$.!B#%6 %*  *#(!" #%7$#$$2!* (!$.%*!%   .$$ (!$)(*!( .(.$4 (!$.%*!%    )$ .$$!* )! #A.26%!* (*!( *!"3#%#%6 )! .(-!(   )! .! # #%!($4 #% !( 3#4 % )! 6(2%* )  )! 2 )(#F!*"."# - #$ (#" #34,%!. #$;:?7)!(!$ )!(!(!  .(#$%!($ #% )! $#* G#3   .(!$!%  %* )2$ #  #$ 3(!*- 5!("(7*!* !

!(!%"! )$ 8!!% A*!  % (*!( .$$!* 8- )! ,2.(!A!
2(  %

?  .$$!*#%
D
#5#3E:

?#% )!A !( H#%)2A% "%*# #%$ 9  .(#$%!($ #% %*# %*  )!($I )  % G#3 $)23* !J"!!* %2A8!(   #%A !$ A(! )% ?

K 7)!(!$ ,%!.  #3#$ 3(!*- 5!( ..23 !*$# )$A(! )%?

K#%A !$ #$3$8$!(5!* )!(!#% )  )! ,%!.  #3 #$ A$  $!%$# #5! G#3 $ %2A8!(   "(#A#%3$   *#

!(!%  6%6$ (! 3*6!* #% #  %* )  )! .(#$%!($ #% )! .(#$%$   33 5!( (-% )5! 8!!% "#3#  !* 7# ) .(#$%$ #%A ! "33#%6 $-$ !A (A 7)!(! )!-"23*AB!"33 #5!A#%2 !$  )!#((!3 #5!$%* A#3- A!A8!($% 7(!6#$ !(!*.)%!%2A8!($%* )2$ )!-(!7!33"%%!" !* 7# ) )!#( A#3-A!A8!($%*(!3 #5!$%*#3-8$#$ #$3$8$!(5!* )  )! ,2.!(#% !%*!%  #$ (#"  #34 ) B 5#*! 3! !( 9? )* (!C2!$ !*  (%$ !(  A#$")#!52$ .(#$%!($ #%"32*#%6 %!   )! .! # #%!($4%A!3-4(*!!.$% $)7(82 2   "%5#" $%3-  "%5#" $ 7!(! (%$ !((!* % 9  ; #% *#

!(!%  #3$   (-% #%"32*#%6(*!!.$% $)7(%* )!(!A#%#%6 .(#$%!($7!(!%  $)# !*8!"2$! )!#("$!$(!.!%*#%6#%) B%* )!(*#$ (#" $ ( (#3 %*# 7$% .$$#83!7# )2  )!.!(A#$$#%  )! (#3
2(  #$3$

9 8$!(5!* )  !(3#!( (*!!. $%   $)7( 7$ (%$ !((!* (A #$ (#"  #342(26(A  #$ (#" #34) B% ?%)#$(!C2!$ %*$#%"! )#$"%*2" 7$% 6*#%G#3%* ) ,#($ !(
)#!

#$3$"% #%!*#% )!$#*G#34 )!(!

(!4 ( )!$!"2(# -(!$%$)!7$ (%$ !((!*  #$ (#"  #34(#*8*7)!(! )!(!#$!%26)$."! 1!(%!* "2%$!3 ( )! .! # #%!($ )$ $28A# !* )  )! ) B #3 %* (#*8* #3 (!    *#$ %"!   82  

 BA$ (A ,%!. 7)#")#$ 2%**#

#"23  ( )! A#3-A!A8!($ 5#$# 4 )!(!

(!4 )! .(-!( )$ 8!!% A*! ( )!#( (%$ !(  ,%!.  #3    #$ 3$ $28A# !* )  )! (%$ !(  )!.(#$%!($ (A%!G#3  )!("%% 8! *!"3#%!* % )! 6(2%*   5!("(7*#%6 %* #% )#$ (!6(*  *!"#$#% (!%*!(!*8-,#%63!2*6!  )#$
2( #% )!"$! H/%)(13 H/%)(13 H/%)(13 H/%)(13+$ ,  ! (-%I ,  ! (-%I ,  ! (-%I ,  ! (-%I

DE
1

)$8!!%(!

!((!* %(!.3-43!(%!*"2%$!3 ( )!(!$.%*!% $)$$28A# !* )  )!*!"#$#%#% )!"$! /%)(13D,2.(E /%)(13D,2.(E /%)(13D,2.(E /%)(13D,2.(E#$% ..3#"83!%*)$ (!3#!*2.%*!"#$#%  )!,2.(!A!
2( (!%*!(!*#%(# ! # #%D
#5#3E (# ! # #%D
#5#3E (# ! # #%D
#5#3E (# ! # #%D
#5#3E :

  9 :

  9 :

  9 :

  9 # 3!* $ H!

H!

H!

H!2A% "%*# #%$ #% 9  .(#$%$I 2A% "%*# #%$ #% 9  .(#$%$I 2A% "%*# #%$ #% 9  .(#$%$I 2A% "%*# #%$ #% 9  .(#$%$I    #$

2( )!( $28A# !* )  .! # #%!(  7$ (%$ !((!*  #$ (#"  #34 ,%!.  5#*! (*!(   )! #(!" ( !%!(3   (#$%!($4 (-% * !* ; ; 82  !( )!( *A#$$#% $)! A*! % ..3#" #% ( $!!B#%6 (%$ !(  #$ (#" #34) B6#%%*%)!((!C2!$ 4$)!7$ (%$ !((!*  #$ (#" #34) B%   ;  )5! )!(* 3!(%!* "2%$!3 ( )! .( #!$ %* !( "%$#*!(#%6 )! (!$#* " $ %* "#("2A$ %"!$4 A   )! "%$#*!(!* .#%#% )  )!(! #$ % 6(2%* ( C2$)#%6 )! #A.26%!* (*!( * !* ; ;#%7)#")"6!% (!$%$)5!8!!%6#5!%8-(!$.%*!%   *!"3#%#%6 )!.(-!(  )!.! # #%!($

: %5#!7  )!85!4 )!.(!$!% .! # #%#$ 2%* 8!*!5#*  %-A!(# %*)!%"!4 )!$A!#$)!(!8-8-*#$A#$$!* )26)7# )2 %- (*!($ "$ $   D','/E D','/E D','/E D','/E                  
 )! )!($.!B#%6@(!$%!* &

!$@ )! )!(!.( 83! &

!$@