High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18484/2015disposed of

Charanjit Kaur v. Chandigarh Housing Bd, & ORS.

2015-09-02Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan,Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal7 pages

" #$%$&'()*$+%,-.$)/ $&$0(&1#

/)()(&/% /%2+2 #$&-(1$%#+2(&1 $%-"/3)%4""#$&-(1$%# $&-)#/%2

/25&-/&)2 ! 6 ! 6 ! 6 ! 6

! 8

! 8 """"

%/2/&) %/2/&) %/2/&) %/2/&) !% %+&$0#("-93$)/%)#/5/)()(&/% :;:;:;

:;:;:;

" #$<</&1/(&)#/(&2)$&)5/)()(&(2))#/%-/%-$)/- = 5$22/- >? )#/ #(/ @/3+)(9/ (3/%" #$&-(1$%# +2(&1 $%-"#$&-(1$%#(&)/%A2,#(3#)#/$<<)A/&)$ -,/<<(&1+&()(&$9+%)#/5/)()(&/%#$2>//&3$&3/<</-$&- )#/$A+&)-/52()/->?#/%2)$&-2%/()/- +2>$&- )#/ 5/)()(&/%" ,# ,$2 2/%9(&1 $2 &2)$></(&)#/ +&'$> <(3/",$21+&&/--,&>?A(<()$&)2& = 4B /)()(&/%,$21%$&)/-$55(&)A/&)(&)#/&-+2)%(/2

/5$%)A/&)" +&'$>&3A5$22(&$)/>$2(2 &)#/?/$%"#$&-(1$%#+2(&1 $%-<$)/-$ D5/3($< $)/1%? +2(&1 3#/A/E % $<<)A/&) >+(<) +5

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

5/%2&$<#/$%(&1,$2$<21%$&)/-))#/5/)()(&/%& = $&-)#/%/$)/%9(-/(A5+1&/-%-/%-$)/- =$)&&/@+%/ "%/25&-/&) C#$23$&3/<</-)#/$<<)A/&))#/-,/<<(&1 +&()$&-#$2-(%/3)/-%/()+%/)#//&)(%/$A+&))#$))#/ 5/)()(&/%#$-5$(-(&<(/+2+3#-,/<<(&1+&() /1+<$)(& B )#/ #$&-(1$%# +2(&1 $%- G<<)A/&)" !$&$1/A/&) $&- $</ /&/A/&)2H /1+<$)(&2" 4=4G%2#%)74=4/1+<$)(&27H<$?2-,&)#//<(1(>(<()?% $<<)A/&))#/-,/<<(&1+&()>?)#/#$&-(1$%#+2(&1 $%- $&-)#/2$A/%/$-2$2+&-/% !

GH-,/<<(&1+&()%<$) (&)#/#+2(&1 2)$)/)#/ $%-2#$<<>/$<<))/- &<?)2+3#5/%2&,#%#(2,(/.#/%#+2>$&-%$&? %#(2.#/%A(&%3#(<-%/&-/2&),&&%//#<-% </$2/#<-%&#(%/5+%3#$2/>$2(2"$%/2(-/&)($<5<)

%#+2/(&)#/&(&/%%()%?#$&-(1$%#%(&$&? )#/%>$& 2)$)/2!#$<(% $&3#0+<$ (A(<$%<?"

5/%2&2 ,# #$9/ $3F+(%/- $ #+2/.%/2(-/&)($< 2()/ $&?,#/%/(&&-($)#%+1#9) ./A(9) .!+&(3(5$< AA())//.%5%$)(&.A5%9/A/&) %+2) $) 3&3/22(&$< %$)/2" ( / $<<)A/&) $) %/2/%9/-.(@/- 5%(3/"(&)#/(%&$A/%(&)#/&$A/)#/(%25+2/% &$?A(&%3#(<-%/&,(<<&)>//<(1(></)$55<?))#/

$%-%$<<)A/&)$-,/<<(&1+&()%<$) GH #/ $55<(3$&) 2#$<< +%&(2# $& $(-$9() (& )#/ 5%/23%(>/-%A,()#%/1$%-)#(2/<(1(>(<()?$<&1,()# )#/$55<(3$)(& &)#//9/&))#/$(-$9()>/(&1 +&-$<2/$)$&?2)$1/")#/ $%-2#$<<>//&)()</-) 3$&3/<)#/%/1(2)%$)(&%)#/$<<)A/&)-,/<<(&1+&() %<$)"$2)#/3$2/A$?>/"$&-)%/())#/-/52() %/3/(9/- ,()# )#/ $55<(3$)(& $&- $<< )#/ 5$?A/&)2 A$-/))#/ $%-)#/%/$)/%

9/& )#/ /<(1(>(<()? 3&-()(& +&-/% )#/ 5/3($< $)/1%?+2(&13#/A/%$<<)A/&)>+(<)+5-,/<<(&1+&()2 +&-/% )#/ -(23%/)(&$%? F+)$ )#/ %>$& 2)$)/" &(& /%%()%?"#$&-(1$%#$&-+&-/%,#(3#)#/5/)()(&/%#$-$55<(/-" ,$2(&)#/<<,(&1)/%A2

5/%2& ,(<< >/ /<(1(></ % $<<)A/&) $ -,/<<(&1+&()&<?(&)#//9/&))#$)#/.2#/%#(2 ,(/.#/%#+2>$&-%$&?#(2.#/%A(&%3#(<-%/& -&),&&%//#<-%</$2/#<-%&#(%/

5+%3#$2/>$2(2$%/2(-/&)($<5<).#+2/%&(& /%%()%?"#$&-(1$%#%(&/()#/%)#/%>$&

2)$)/!#$<($& $&3#0+<$"2(A(<$%<?"(&3$2/ #/.2#/ #$2 $3F+(%/- $ #+2/.$ %/2(-/&)($< 2()/ $&?,#/%/ (& &-($ )#%+1# 9) ./A( 9) .

!+&(3(5$<AA())//.%5%$)(&.A5%9/A/&) %+2)"$)3&3/22(&$<%$)/2 ( / $)$%/2/%9/-.

(@/-5%(3/"(&#(2.#/%&$A/%(&)#/&$A/#(2. #/%25+2/%&$?A(&%3#(<-%/&"#/.2#/,(<<&) >//<(1(></%$<<)A/&)$-,/<<(&1+&() = </$%<?"(&)/%A2)#/4=4/1+<$)(&2$2$<2)#/ /<(1(>(<()?3&-()(&+&-/%)#/5/3($<$)/1%?+2(&13#/A/" $5/%2&,+<->//<(1(></%$<<)A/&)$-,/<<(&1+&()&<?(& )#//9/&)&),&(&1&%//#<-%</$2/#<-%&#(%/ 5+%3#$2/ >$2(2 $ %/2(-/&)($< 5<).#+2/ (& &(& /%%()%?" #$&-(1$%# % (& /()#/% )#/ %>$& 2)$)/2 !#$<( $&- $&3#0+<$ &-/%)#/5/3($<$)/1%?+2(&13#/A/%/<$)(&1 )-(23%/)(&$%?

F+)$")#/%/,$2$25/3((32)(5+<$)(&,()#%/1$%- ) A(26%/5%/2/&)$)(& % 2+55%/22(& $3)2 55<(3$&)2 #$- >//& 5+) ) 3$+)(& )#$) ( )#/ (&%A$)(& +%&(2#/- (& )#/ $55<(3$)(&%A%+%&(2#/-<$)/%$)$&?2)$1/(2+&-)>/ (&3%%/3).

$55<(3$)(&%$<<)A/&)$-,/<<(&1+&()+&-/%)#/-(23%/)(&$%? F+)$(&)#/?/$%#$-+%&(2#/-)#/<<,(&1-/3<$%$)(& D%A?,(/.#+2>$&-%$&?A?A(&%3#(<-%/&- &),&%//#<-%</$2/#<-%&#(%/5+%3#$2/ >$2(2$%/2(-/&)($<5<).#+2/(&)#/&(&/%%()%?" #$&-(1$%#%(&/()#/%)#/%>$& 2)$)/2!#$<( I $&3#0+<$ E /$%&/- 3+&2/< % )#/ 5/)()(&/% #$9(&1 >//& 3&%&)/-,()#2+3#$3)+$<$25/3)$-,/<<(&1+&()>/$%(&1

46 (&/3)%CG/2)H"#$&-(1$%##$9(&1$<%/$-?>//& $<<))/- ) )#/ 5/)()(&/% $&- 5#?2(3$< 522/22(& $<2 #$9(&1 >//&#$&-/-9/%& $&-2#/#$9(&1+%&(2#/-$$<2/ -/3<$%$)(& ,#(</ $55<?(&1 % $ -,/<<(&1 +&() +&-/% )#/ -(23%/)(&$%? F+)$ (& )#/ ?/$% " )#/ %/25&2/ #$2 >//& %$)#/% /9$2(9/ <<)A/&) )#/ -,/<<(&1 +&() (& /3)% C" #$&-(1$%# (& )#/ ?/$% (2 &) -/&(/- ,/9/%" () (2 2+>A())/- )#$) )#/ 5/)()(&/% #$- 3A/ (& )+3# ,()# &/

#$1,$&(&1#,#,$252)/-$2</%0,()#)#/#$&-(1$%# +2(&1 $%-$&-+5&#(2$20(&1"5/)()(&/%#$-$55<(/-%$ -,/<<(&1+&()+&-/%)#/5/3($<$)/1%?+2(&13#/A/(&)#/ ?/$% )#$2+%)#/%>//&3&)/&-/-)#$)(),$2 #$1,$& (&1#,##$-)$0/&$<<)#/5$5/%2$&-A&/?)#/5/)()(&/% &)#/5%/)/@)#/<5(&1#/%)#$9/$-,/<<(&1+&()$<<))/-$&- )#/%/$)/%)#//&)(%/$A+&),$2%/)+%&/-2)$)(&1)#$)#/%&$A/ #$-&)(1+%/-(&)#/<(2)$<<))//2 2)$&-#$2>//&)$0/& )#$)(),$2 #$1,$&(&1#,##$2)%(30/-)#/5/)()(&/%$&-$2 2+3#"2#/3$&&)>/#/<-%/25&2(></$2%/1$%-2)#/-/3<$%$)(&

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

&) /<(1(></%$<<)A/&)?/)$&)#/%-,/<<(&1+&()(&)#/?/$% (&)#/<(1#))#//<(1(>(<()?3&-()(&23&)$(&/-+&-/%)#/4=4 /1+<$)(&2$2$<2)#//<(1(>(<()?3&-()(&2/&9(2$1/-+&-/%)#/ 5/3($< $)/1%? +2(&1 3#/A/ <$)/- (& )#/ ?/$% <<)A/&)+&-/%)#/-(23%/)(&$%?F+)$&)#/>$2(2$$<2/ -/3<$%$)(&3$&&)2+2)$(& )(2)#/5/)()(&/%723$2/#/%2/<)#$) 2#/#$2>//&A(26</->?

(),+<-$<,$?2>/5/&%)#/5/)()(&/%))$0/+)$55%5%($)/ 5%3//-(&12$1$(&2) #$1,$&(&1#2)%(3)<?(&$33%-$&3/,()# <$, #/%-/%-$)/- ="&&/@+%/ "3$&3/<<(&1 )#/ $<<)A/&))#/-,/<<(&1+&()+&-/%)#/-(23%/)(&$%?F+)$,+<- &)3$<<%$&?(&)/%9/&)(& ))#(22)$1/"</$%&/-3+&2/<%)#/5/)()(&/%,+<- A$0/$2+>A(22(&)#$)#/(23&(&(&1)#/235/)#/5%/2/&) 5/)()(&&<?$2%/1$%-2%/+&-)#/$A+&))#$))#/5/)()(&/%

#$-5$(-(&<(/+)#/-,/<<(&1+&()")#/$<<)A/&),#(3##$2 >//&3$&3/<</- &2+55%)2+3#3&)/&)(&"</$%&/-3+&2/< ,+<-2+>A())#$))#/5/)()(&/%(2$,(-,$&-#$2)#%//3#(<-%/& )2+55%) ()#%/1$%-)2+3#2+>A(22(&#$9(&1>//&%$(2/->? )#/ 5/)()(&/% $2 $ A/$2+%/ <$2) %/2%)" ,/ -(252/ )#/ 5/)()(&$&-1%$&)<(>/%)?)#$)()#/$22/%)(&)#/5/)()(&/%$2 %/1$%-2 $55/$< $1$(&2) )#/ %-/% 3$&3/<<$)(& 2)(<< 5/&-(&1 $-'+-(3$)(&(2$3)+$<<? 3%%/3)")#/&(),+<- >/5/&))#/ 5/)()(&/%)/9/&%$(2/2+3#<(A()/-5%$?/%>/%/)#/55/<<$)/ +)#%()?

/$%/3&(-/&))#$)()#/5/)()(&/%/2)$><(2#/2)#$) 2#/ ,$2 3#/$)/- >? )#/ 2$(- #$1,$& (&1#" )#/ 55/<<$)/ +)#%()?,(<<3&2(-/%#/%$55/$<))#//@)/&)#/%$55<(3$)(& %%/+&-)#/$A+&)5$(->?#/%2?A5$)#/)(3$<<? C /$%/+&$></)3&2(-/%)#(2$25/3)+%2/<9/2$2)#/ (22+/A$?%/F+(%/+%)#/%$3)2 #/5/)()(&/%(2$)<(>/%)?) $--+3/ +%)#/% /9(-/&3/ (& )#(2 %/1$%- >/%/ )#/ 55/<<$)/ +)#%()?

#/ 5/)()(& (2 -(252/- (& )#/ $>9/ )/%A2 &2(-/%(&1)#/$3)2)#/3$2/",/,+<-%/F+/2))#/55/<<$)/ +)#%()?)-/3(-/)#/$55/$<$2/@5/-()(+2<?$2522(></ G 8 H G 8 H G 8 H G 8 H G

H G

" ! ! ! !

)/ #/)#/%%//%%/-)/5%)/%JG /2.

H #/)#/%%//%%/-)/5%)/%JG /2.