(O&M) Bhupinder Singh v. Jaswant Singh

  
 

      
      



 

 !"#$%&"#' (!!%))*#+ ,%&- - *-.*#+"#' ( %-!#$%#+  / 0 12/  
 / 


&%-%#+  /& *#3"+*"#"4$,5*+%-&+%*!!%))*#+ /& /*)"64$,5*+%&+%&%-!#$%#+ 

/ 
4 %$%%#$*#+"-*!!%))*#+7%&%+"- &+%"- *''&"%,%$78+%3 $'9%#+-&%#$%&%$787++% &+-7%). % !)*"#+" ")%$ * - "+ & -!%5""5 !%&&9*#5%  5#+&*5+&%'*&$"#')*#$9%*- &"#' 6*#*) :9*&)*-;"#-&+4 <+%- "+!&!%&+8=>&."5+%&%.*-*#*'&%%9%#+-*)% %#+%&%$ "#+ #  7%+.%%# "9 *#$ +% $%%#$*#+ %$%%#$*#+*$*'&%%$+-%))+%- "+!&!%&+8"#*, & +%!)*"#+"&*5#-"$%&*+"#
4 4?0!%&*5&%- 9 
4?0.*-!*"$*-%*&#%-+9#%8%$%%#$*#+*)- &%5%",%$*#*9 #+
4?0#@  *#$
4?0 #   *#$ %A%5 +%$ +% &%5%"!+- "# +"- &%'*&$  %


7*)*#5% -*)% 5#-"$%&*+"# .*- + 7% !*"$ *+ +% +"9%  %A%5 +"#  +% -*)% $%%$ # & 7%&% :   % $%%#$*#+$"$#++ &# !&+%%A%5 +"#-*)%$%%$4+ ' +%!)*"#+"&%9*"#%$!&%-%#+"#+%%-")9!)%A4/&"#$* *)#' ."+ +% 7*)*#5% -*)% 5#-"$%&*+"# *#$ %A!%#-%- & &%'"-+&*+"#-*)%$%%$*9 #+"#'+
4?0
#&$%&+ -. "- !&%-%#5%4 +% !)*"#+" '+ *++%-+%$ *# *"$*,"+ &9 +%A%5 +",%/*'"-+&*+%4/&"#$*55&$"#'++%!)*"#+"4 %.*-?"--+"))&%*$8*#$."))"#'+!%&&9"-!*&+5#+&*5+ .%,%&4+%$%%#$*#+*")%$+%A%5 +%+%-*)%$%%$"#"- *, & ."5 #%5%--"+*+%$ +% ")"#'  +% - "+ & -!%5""5 !%&&9*#5%5#+&*5+ %- "+.*-5#+%-+%$78+%$%%#$*#+%$%#"%$ +%%A%5 +"#*#8- 5*'&%%9%#++-%))$*+%$ "# *, &  +% !)*"#+"  % !)%*$%$ +*+ "# *5+4 % *$ 7&&.%$ * - 9 
 4?0 *- )*# &9 +% !)*"#+" #


#&$%&+-%5 &%+%)*#*9 #+4+%!)*"#+" +6"--"'#*+ &%-#+.7)*#6!*!%&-.%,%&4%*$ *)&%*$8&%!*"$+%)*#*9 #+ +4+%-*"$$5 9%#+-.%&% #+&%+ &#%$*#$+%9*++%&6%!+)"#'%&"#'#*#$,%&"#'# #%!&%+%A+&+%+%& #*!!&%5"*+"#%,"$%#5%4+%+&"*) &+5*9%+ +% 5#5) -"# +*+ +% *'&%%9%#+ + -%))4 A

4 .*- $ )8 !&,%$55&$"#')84+%- "++%!)*"#+".*-$%5&%%$


% $%%#$*#+ .%#+ "# *!!%*)  % "&-+ !!%))*+%  &+4 # &%0*!!&*"-*)  %,"$%#5%4 *"&9%$ +% "#$"#'- &%5&$%$78+%+&"*) &+ . +% $%%#$*#+ *- *!!&*5%$ +"-  &+ +& '+%!&%-%#+*!!%*) 2%*&#%$ 5 #-%) & +% *!!%))*#+ - 79"+- +*+ +% "#$"#'-&%5&$%$78+% &+-7%).*&%%&&#% -4"#*-9 5 *-4+%$%%#$*#+$"$#+%A%5 +%*#8- 5*'&%%9%#++-%)) $*+%$ 4#&&%5%",%$*#8%*&#%-+9#%8% &+%& - 79"+-+*++%$%%#$*#+*$7&&.%$*- 9
 4?0 *- )*# #  *#$ "# )"%  +%&%4 +% !)*"#+" *$ 7+*"#%$ -"'#*+ &%-  +% $%%#$*#+ # +. 7)*#6 !*!%&- %-!"+% *,"#' 7%%# &%!*"$ +% )*# *9 #+4 +% *&%-*"$ $5 9%#+- .%&% #+ &%+ &#%$  # +*+ 7*-"-4 "+ *- 7%%# *&' %$+*++%- "++%!)

*"#+"7%$"-9"--%$ %)%*&#%$5 #-%)&+%&%-!#$%#+- 79"+-+*+ +%"#$"#'-7++% &+-7%).*&%7*-%$#*!!&%5"*+"#  %,"$%#5% *#$4 + -4 +% - "+  +% !)*"#+" .*- &"'+)8 $%5&%%$ *&*-+%B %-+"#,*)"$"+8+%*'&%%9%#++ -%)) 7%+.%%# +% !*&+"%- "- 5#5%&#%$4 7+ +%  &+- 7%).

4+7%)%'*)*#$,*)"$ %"#$"#'-'",%#&)$"#'+%*'&%%9%#++-%))4A

4)%'*) *#$ ,*)"$ *&% - 99*&"-%$ *#$ &%5*!"+ )*+%$ & +% -*6%  %#*7)"#'+"- &++5&&%5+)8*!!&%5"*+%+%%,"$%#5%%


$%%#5% +*6%# 78 +% $%%#$*#+ +*+ # +.7)*#6 !*!%&-"- -"'#*+ &%- .%&% 7+*"#%$ "# &$%& + -%5 &% +% )*# 
 4?0# .*-#%'*+%$787++% &+-7%). # +% !&%9"-% +*+ +%&% .*- # $%#"*) "# +% .&"++%# -+*+%9%#+ &%'*&$"#' &%5%"!+ 
4?0 #   ."5 *9 #+-+*$9"--"##"-!*&+C")%$%%#$*#+*!!%*&"#' *-C 4*$9"++%$"--"'#*+ &%-#+%$5 9%#+-4#*9%)84 A

  *'&%%9%#+ + -%)) $*+%$ 4 A  &%5%"!+ 
4?0."5"-#+%7*56-"$%+%*'&%%9%#++-%))*#$ A &%5%"!+
4?0#   -4+%*$9"--"#  +% *!!%))*#+ # +% *&%-*"$ +&%% $5 9%#+- 7%)"%- *#$ *)-""%- +% 5)*"9  +% $%%#$*#+ +*+ "- -"'#*+ &%- .%&% 7+*"#%$ # +. 7)*#6 !*!%&- ."5 .%&% - 7-%B %#+)8 5#,%&+%$ "#+ *'&%%9%#+ + -%)) ,%# +% *$9"--"#  "- !&%-%#5%"#+%%-")9!)%A4/&"#$*# -.- +% !&%-%#5%  +% !*&+"%- +'%+%& & +% %A%5 +"#  *'&%%9%#++-%))4A

 !*&+ &9 +"-4 +% $%%#$*#+ *")%$ + 7&"#' *#8 %,"$%#5% + -. +*+ +% *))%'%$ 7&&.%$ *9 #+ 
 4?0.*-&%+ &#%$++%!)*"#+"% &+-7%).*,% *)- %)$ +*+ +% 5#$ 5+  +% $%%#$*#+ .*- #+ *7,%0 7*&$4"#*-9 5*-4*++%"&-+"#-+*#5%4%$%!-%$+*+% 6#.-#)8 #3*7"4.%,%&4- 7-%B %#+)84%*$9"++%$+*+ %*$*!!%#$%$"--"'#*+ &%-"##')"-#+%%#$&-%9%#+


A

? ."+ &%'*&$ + ! &5*-%  -+*9!  !*!%& *#$ # +% *&%-*"$$5 9%#+-4A

+A  % &%*$"#%-- *#$ ."))"#'#%--  +% !)*"#+" "- &%)%5+%$&9+%-.&#*"$*,"+$*+%$ :$ )8*++%-+%$ 78+%A%5 +",%/*'"-+&*+%4/&"#$*+*+%.*-,%&89 5 !&%-%#+*)#'."++%%A!%#-%-&&%'"-+&*+"#-*)%$%%$ *9 #+"#'+
"#+%%-")9!)%A4/&"#$*#+% $*+%-"A%$&+%%A%5 +"#-*)%$%%$  B %-+"#  )*.4 9 5 )%-- *#8 - 7-+*#+"*) B %-+"#)*.4*&"-%-"#+%!&%-%#+*!!%*)&$%+%&9"#*+"#
#,"%.+%*&%-*"$$"-5 --"#4
"#$#"))%'*)"+8 &"9!&!&"%+8"#+%3 $'9%#+-*#$$%5&%%7++% &+- 7%).."5&%B "&%-"#+%&%&%#5%78+"- &+ "-9"--%$ %5%97%&

4

  ;

*9%#$&**"#> D  $'%