Suresh Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!" #"$%&%'( !)"*+, +-.
/,+"&)0,1 + '#!)"+& "!%!%'"+& 2"+&,& /! !" +- ' '#!)"+& "&3'#"'!& (4 5/
!
" #$
! %& " '()
5. & * %& & &+& !! & , - ) '
).(/ * 0!% 1& 23&,(45 - / $ ('$$ 23& ,()5 * ! -2 !5,& , ! % - (.
$ ('$$ 23& ,(/5 * 1,& , -,& , !
2 !5
(( # (''#23&,(65117 23& ,('5 !!
&23&,).5
& &
) '
).(/23&,(45
! &! *! &* ! &! ! & 44 !6 ! 8!!"
')9949)9(#9)(49)(#9()49)'/99(.9)(().)('699(9('49949)&
&!!&: !&
(';$ < ! ! *! = * )..',).(.23&,(5 - ($ ( ).(( &! &! !
>&2 !51&!).((* 3 & &*, 2(5 (' >& 2 !5)..$2 " ;)..$5 %& )25 &!&*,2)5 /1&! ).(( & ,
!
"
#
!
"
#
$
"
!
"
# < .$ ./ ).(( &* ! 23&,/5 ! (;
(.
).((23&,65 ! * ! %? " $$#( ).() *& !
!
!*% *! :& -%!&1 ,, " #$ !! .$ .) ('4. !! ! ? ('4. & ! 2% 1*!5('462 ('465 &,,%!&1 ! 23&,(.5(( ) ('$$ /$
!!! ! !! &* !
& %!&1 !! ?!
?
! : * 1 () ;
('$$23&,((5* * ! ! * !-
*! * % !! / $ ('$$23& ,()5 < !- &:&
" &* ! *& (.
$ ('$$23&,(/51!! !
+ ! &
(( # (''#23&,(65 ! < " #$ & & %!& 1 < )$ ) )..) % ! % & & & )6 &
!
!! & * !
0!% 0!
% & ) '
).(/ 23& ,(45 &!
: !
!! *! !
<&! &1&!#;, ! 2% 1*!51&!('44 & ! /( () ('#/ < !&,,%!&1 !
('$$ *!> ! ! &!* %& / ! +8 &) '# '!)"+2'%' '#% '#!)"+& )..62(51%12%!5'4 !
& , @$%&'( !
!
)
' %&'( *$+,( %&&* !
-, .)
' %&'( .
.
/ 0 ( %&1234 %&1
!
(
/ 0 ) ( %&' %&'
5 %& 6 * *
30 ( %'76 ( 288 %'7
* *
3 0 11'9 1 11':;
<
<
<
6 )=
!
!
)
1 ( ,
>
?
"
), 0 ),
)
$
,
!
>
@ "
> AAAAAAAAA '(
,0 <
B %&&
9
<C D
"
!
)
) 6 !
),
D "
"
) 9
!
-
) 9
?
!
(
!
-,
>
>
!
>
!
>
>
0 <
) <
0 >
:
'(
0 <
( D
"
(
!
( -
!
( !
!
!
!
, ,
!
* $+,( %&& * 0
@
, !
0
@
! !
!
8 E
@ F
: :!
) !
)
1 (
D
)
6 )=
!
D , )-
/
%$-
)
)
) (
!
0
. 7(
! %'7(
* %'7 *8
?
)
%&'( "
!
%'7 ( * $+,( !
!
$9
%&$
F
!
!
')
%$
/
%$
!
8 !
%8G
0H /
: ,
@
) : !
!
/
:
-, . (
30 9
)
' (
*
9
/
(
* *
( ?H(H
*
9
8!
?
)
8
!
D
,
5
9
!
?
!
8
/ 0
*
( %&'
D !
8 , D D
!
%&'( . 1 (
! ! ? )
/
0 <
0@ E % %+
&B
%+8 /
: !
!
"
!
D
;
!
/
%$
*$+,( * !
I
"
'8
/ ) E "H <
, HH
!? ) B
%'7%&'(
? /
: )
/
H G
0H
! ! ! /
: ?
/
%$
$
*,( %+$ *
"
?
H H
"
!
%&' (
! "
!
%'7 %&'( !
?
!
! *,( %+$* +
+(
%+$
! H H /
%$ !
!
0 + (
%+$ !
/
%$ !
0
! <
" ?
"<
*$+,( %&&* !
/
%$!
< 1
)
' %&'( !
E '
) 0 9 "9 =
8
(8*%+)0++!
0 :;
5" 0
* G ) ( %+$ 3B''3* / 3* 0 ) 0
%71 * 3* % 8 9 " ) 0 )
' %&'( !
0 ) 0
?
!
)
'# & !&* ! #( * !! ! ! +&!! :&!! !*&, @ 8
E &$11171
E $ 7
E !
!
!
E $ 7 !
,
,
8
E $ 7
I I
I
E
!
E &$1 1171
"
# <! !! !
(6( ! 6. !*& !! *!! 6.; !(6 ! ! 117 /( ;
).(/23&,('5 !! *!!!
*! <
!
:& * %!=& %! &" /#().(.& () (( ).(. * * ** &!1 7 !
!* :& ;
( ).(4* &!
&&!
& ! & ) $ ).(/ ) '
).(/
*! !&&
&!
* !
& !))#%&< &! & !&)4%25A ! &! &!
!!!! >&:* & ! 3&!
! ?&:*& !! ?!
? << ! !! &! &!& * & 9!! ! !! & &!
* &* B*! & %&1 +8 &)2'%' '#% <1(';( %;;( & * & & :& *
% ! % :& & )6('46 ! !
*! &* * & & !! ! * &&! &! " '()&*+& +& ! 6 '
).(/ # '
).(/ " &*& :& & %&
!!
! ! &!
*! " ' () * %& ! &!*! " #$ * !
:!
& ! *: *!
* ! !!! < !
!! !! & " #$ * !! * 0!%
) '
).(/&!
*! * & - &* !& " !- ! /.
(.
('';
23&1#9/5 = * (';',$.!!('$','.
3&1,#9()/$ )6(!& ! * 1&& = * (''.! &
!
! !! ! &!).((1&!&!! &)..$ : 4 ;
(''/ ! *
! /.
# ('''* % *& ! * %?" ()6;6 (''' (/ '
(''' ! * " #$ (/ / )..( * & C,
@ G ( )
E
!
&
7 ! ?
!
(
!
) %%% 9
G !
!
# < & ! *! < &*&!! )4 A ! &!! 3 * !
*& & &!! * %& ) + 1=%+2 ) #,+/%'>) '# '!)"+)..;2)51%12%!5)(;!
* &! ).((1&!&&& *
& **
%& ?1"+/%'>)2/! !" +- ' '# '!)"+ %?" ));))../ )) (( ).(.!
* &
!! &* 0!
% !3! !
! &! &!
! !! &!
* * !! ?!
?<?!
?<< &,, ! 3!& < & +& * <!! 3($ ! & &
* & * %&5 !+/%'>) '#!)"+& 2/! !" +- ' '# '!)"+. ).(#2651%12!5(#! & &:& * B*! & %& **!! & & & & )..) !
*! !! *! * ('$$ < 3 (6 > '():& A
B 2&5 * ! 0! % 3!
!! A &!!
%&3&1#9) 1
/( ;
).(/ 3&,(' ! :&&!!!! ! * ! !& - 6/ * !!
! *!!&! * &&!
**
< ! &! & * !! &!
*!&&
! *& :& B 2&5 !
& &!
! & & !
< & * &+& 0& :3B B & !&#;, &!
*!
*&!!
& !&
! ** <!! 0!% ) '
).(/&!
*!! *
& *!! !!!!
&!
! &!&! < & @>!D *! !!!! &&&!* &*& 7 &!* * <! & & 7* 3 &
)6! 3 !
* &:& J3
) H K !
& & * *! !
< & * (6 ! !! !& *& &!
*
&** !
!!! ! !! & ).((&! *
&!
*!
!! & * & 0!
% ! !! *: * 3 !*! !&)4%25 A ! &! &!
& *!
*& &
* ?!
? <?!
?<< 0 * 0! % & , @ 8
117%77< (! < !
!
*, 5( ?,84 5
!
I
8 < (! < !
" !
@
@ ,
G !
< (!
! @
! ,
!!
!
< (! < (! @
@ ,
( ?,84
!
5 *!
5 B
<
8
< (! < @ ,@
@ ,8
5 *!
5 B
< #
@
@ ,
! 9 !
!
< (! !
D
5 *!
5 B
< # %!&)4 !!
! & &!
!
&!
!! & 3B * !! B !! !
* *!! !
* & )42)5('46 < * 7 0!
:
% *& * & *&&! !!
* & 3&, (' 3&1,#9) 3&1,#9) ! *! *: *
& *%& (/ / )..(2 & &5 * & = * !- ! 3&1,#9/
:& ;
( ).(4+& * ** & ! 1 7 > ! * " &* * !
& !&*& &!
!! * ! 9**&< * &!
!! ) '
).(/ & !! !!
0 & !! !
!! :& * * * !! * %&
5 "*+, +- .
&,'%!
? 9 E ?1*! E