High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19184/2014allowed

Dhandi Builders Ltd. v. Advisor To Administrator, U.T. Of Chandigarh And Another

2016-05-16Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih14 pages

!"# $#%&'&()* ) + ) ,!$& -&.$#'/&0&"#$ 1#"&"&# 2#'-' $3&'"$0&&'"!"4&#&"5 ,!$&6!,!$",#' 1#'7$#"' 8( 9 /8 :: 2; 4 : 9 /8 :// #'#"( 8:,!$&4$3%!"# ",#7#"&"&#<'= 8:!>##3:,!0!4:#&:"!$&6-'#.4 ,!$&6!,?&",8',&',!?!.4$3%!"#

#'7$#"' @@@ // ,&'$#',!..$#%&$#",#'#"?%&3&.?&"7#"&"&'4 ",# A-#'"& ",!" !&'#' $#"#0&!"& & B", &' %00 ?#3#4 ",# !%"' !# B#&6 %-..#$ -" 0 &3&. &" #"&"&

#"&"&# &# ,!$& -&.$#' /&0&"#$ ?!' !?!$#$ ! %07'&"#?C %'"-%"& ) .!"'<!"#654-7=& :#%" *4 ,!$&6!,4 ! '-0 'D4*

E4 3&$# 0#0 $!"#$ * 4 &''-#$ B5 F#%-"&3# 6&## 24 ,!$&6!,-'&6 !$<,##&!

"## ##$"!'4G",# !$H= 0!. %"!%" #"##$ &" B#"?## ",# 7!"&#'4 $!"#$ * 4 &' !77#$#$ !' #F-# + ?&", ",# 7#"&"&

/&C#?&'#4!'&0&.!%"!%" %'"-%"&

.!"'<!"#654 -7 2= & :#%" *4 ,!$&6!, ?!' !.' !''&6#$ " ",# 7#"&"&#4 'D4 D4D 4++DE43&$#0#0 !#3#$!"##'" ",# "#0' !$ %$&"&' ",# %"!%" ?## &$#"&%!. !' & ",# ",#!6##0#" ,# 7#"&"&# &' !..#6#$ " ,!3# !&.#$ " %07.#"# ",# ?C !" 3!&-' '"!6#' !' 7# ",# "#0' ",# %"!%" #'-."!".54 ! ',? %!-'# "&%#4 $!"#$ * 4 ?!' '#3#$ -7 &"I !' " ?,5 !%"& -$# %.!-'#' 4 D4 D<!= D<%= %"!%"B#""!C#3#"-!..54",#F#%-"&3#6&##<&3&.=4 &"#0' %.!-'# ",#%"!%"4.#3&#$%07#'!"&JK ",##'"&0!"#$%'" ",#?C!0-"&6"'D*4

E4-7 ",#7#"&"&#$",#%"!%"&"'#.

?!'!.'#'%&$#$3&$#$# $!"#$ ) D

#&6 !66&#3#$4 7#"&"&# '-B0&""#$ ! #7#'#"!"& " ",# ,!&0! !$ D4 & "#0' %.!-'# ",# %"!%"4 !$ #A-#'"#$ " ?!&3# ",# &07'&"& 7#!."5 B5 ?!5 %07#'!"& 2&$# $# $!"#$ D D4:,:',!4",#",#:-7#&"#$&66&## ",# !$4 ?!' $#'&6!"#$ B5 ",# ,!&0! !' ,&' !-",&L#$ 0&## " !$>-$&%!"# -7 ",# '!&$ #7#'#"!"& $ !" ",# '!0#"&0#47#"&"&#!.'7# ##$!&3&.&"#"&"& +

D4 ",# !$,!$!.'#'%&$#$",#%"!%"&"'#.

?#3#4 ",&' %-" $&'0&''#$ ",# '!&$ ?&" 7#"&"& 3&$# $# $!"#$ D* D4 &"#0' .!-'# * ",#"!%"4",#$&'7-"# B#"?## ",# 7!"&#' ?!' !B&"!B.# #'-."!".54 7-'-!" " ! !77.&%!"&4 $!"#$

+ D4 '-B0&""#$ B5 ",# 7#"&"&#4 :,

D :',!?!'!.'!77&"#$!'B&"!""!$>-$&%!"#-7",# $&'7-"# B#"?## ",# 7!"&#' ,-'4 :, : ',! ?!' '#&L#$ ",# "? $&'7-"#'I <!= !&'&6 -$# %.!-'# 4 !$ <B= !B&"!"& 7%##$&6' !&'&6 -$# %.!-'# * ",# %"!%" ,# 0!""# #0!&#$ &%%.-'&3# ! .6 "&0# "&.. 3&$# ! $# $!"#$

<#F-# =4 :, : ',! %%.-$#$",!" .#35 %07#'!"& !$ '-B'#A-#" #'%&'& ",# %"!%" B5 ",#

!$?!'->-'"& &#$,#%%.-'&!&3#$!"#!$'",-'(

!" #

$ %

(

' '

) /&C#?&'#43&$#!!B&"!.!?!$ !#3#$!"#4,#!.' !%%#7"#$ ",# %.!&0' ",# 7#"&"&# 6!&'" ",# !?!$ #$##$ B5",#B&"!"4",# !$ &.#$B>#%"&'-$#:#%"&D ",# B&"!"& %&.&!"& %"4 ) ,##!'4 !6!&'" ",# $# -$#.!-'# 4",# !$7# ##$!!77#!.-$#:#%"&+ ",# !5!! -'&6 !$ %"4 + <!' #F"#$#$ " & #&"5,!$&6!,=M ',"4N",#%"9O#"&"&#7# ##$"?

%&3&. ?&" 7#"&"&'4 B#!&6 D ) D* 4 ",##?##"?'#7!!"#$#'!&'&6-" "? '#7!!"# %"!%"'4 !$ A-#'"&#$ ",# 0!&"!&!B&.&"5 !77#!.'?#3#4! '"!"#0#"0!$#B5%-'#. ",# !$ ",!"!$#%&'&?!'"!C#"?&",$!?",'#!77#!.'4",#7#"&"&' ?## !%%$&6.5 $&'0&''#$ B5 ",&' %-" 3&$# $# $!"#$ <#F-# = 4",# !$!''!&.#$",#$#4$!"#$

4",&'"&0#43&$#!#3&'&7#"&"&-$#:#%"&+ ",#%"4B# #",#$3&'"",#$0&&'"!"4,!$&6!, <#'7$#" =4 7#"&"&# !6!& 7# ##$ ! &3&. &" #"&"& * D) D4 !$ A-#'"&#$ ",# >-&'$&%"& #'7$#" ",#!!$!$>-$&%!"#-7",#0!""#,&'%-"3&$#$#4 $!"#$ + D4 $&'0&''#$ ",# '!&$ 7#"&"& ?&", .&B#"5 " ",# 7#"&"&# " !&'# ",# &''-# !' #6!$' >-&'$&%"& B# # ",# #3&'&!. !-",&"5 &"'#.

%%$&6.54 ",# 7#"&"&# 03#$ !

0!. !77.&%!"&4 $!"#$ D D <#F-# *=4 B# # #'7$#"!$A-#'"&#$",#0!&"!&!B&.&"5 ",##3&'& 7# ##$ B5 ",# !$ -"4 3&$# $# $!"#$ + 4 #'7$#"<$3&'=%%.-$#$4 ",#,&# 6&## ",#

!$ ,!$ $#%&$#$ ",# #7#'#"!"& ",# 7#"&"&# !' ! !77#..!"#!-",&"54,#?!'%07#"#"",#!",##3&'&!6!&'" ",#'!&$$#,#%%.-'&!&3#$!"#!$'",-'( &

* +

, ,

%!-!.

( /&$ 0

* +

% %

(

$ $

) & 3 4 $ % 556

(

* +

, ,

% !-! .

( $ 0 %

/ &

$ * $

% %

* +

!-!5 &

76!"

78!5 *9+ .::* 0 %

/ &

$ ) ,!" &' ,?4 ",# '!&$ $#' !# -$# %,!..#6# & ",#'#"??&"7#"&"&'4# ##$"!B3# 4#3#",#B>#%"&' 7# ##$ B5 ",# 7#"&"&# !6!&'" ",# !?!$ #$##$ B5 ",# B&"!" <:, : ',!4 =4 ?## !.' $&'0&''#$ B5 ",# $$&"&!. &'"&%" -$6#4 ,!$&6!,4 3&$# $# !$ >-$60#" $!"#$ 4 ",# !$ 7# ##$ "? '#7!!"# !77#!.' &#

D *!$ D *4B# #",&'%-" $4 B#&6 !77&'#$ !%" ",!" ! &3&. &" #"&"&

4 B#"?## ",# 7!"&#'4 !' #6!$' >-&'$&%"&

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

#'-B0&"'",!"!'",#$#4$!"#$ 4?!'7!''#$ & "#0' .!-'# ",# "!%"4 ",## #4 ",# %" ,!$ B#!&6 3&'P3&' ",# &6,"' !$ B.&6!"&' ",# 7!"&#' # '-B0&""#$ ",!" ",# $# $!"#$ &' -$# ",# "!%" !$"-$#",#%"!$4",## #4",##3&'&7# ##$B5",#

!$-$#:#%"&+ ",#%"?!'"%07#"#" -",#4! B!# !!.5'&' .!-'# ",# "!%" #3#!.' ",!" ! $# 7!''#$ B5 ",# ,!&0! ,&# 6&## !$ ,&' !-",&L#$0&##4?!' &!.,## #4 -",##0#$5#&",# B5?!5 !77#!.#3&'&?!'E&'#3#%%#&3!B.#4.#!'"-$# ",#%"

+ ",# %"!54 .#!#$ '#& %-'#. ",# #'7$#"' '-B0&"' ",!" -$# :#%"& + ",# %"4 ",# $3&'#&",#'-0"4",#!77.&%!"& !7!"54%-.$%!..

!$#F!0&#",##%$' !57%##$&6'4$#%&'&$# 7!''#$B5",# !$4,!&0!4,&# F#%-"&3#

&%#

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

* +

$ <

# #?## #"!$&"#7#"",#73&'&' :#%"& + ",#%"4"!'%#"!&&"'"-#'%7#!$!0B&"4?#$##0&" #F7#$&#""7&"-"",!"",#!5!!-'&6 !$%"4 + <' #F"#$#$ " ,!$&6!,= ?!' #!%"#$ '.#.5 ?&", ! 3&#? "

73&$# 0#!'-#'"B#"!C#"$#!.?&",!$'!"&' 5",###$ ,-'&6 !%%00$!"& 4 ",# :"!"# -'&6 !$' ?## %'&$##$"B#",#B#'"!6#%&#' '7##$5&07.#0#"!"& ",# ,-'&676!00#' ,# -'&6 !$ ,!$&6!, <3&%"& 0 !$ #0&'#'=-.#'4 + ?##70-.6!"#$-$#:#%"&+D!$",# ,!$&6!, -'&6 !$ <.."0#"4 8!!6#0#" !$ :!.# ##0#"'=#6-.!"&'4 + ?## !0#$-$#:#%"&+ ",# %""%!5-"",#7-7'# ",#%" 4&"?-.$B#'&6& &%!" & %"#F" ",# &''-# ",!" !&'#' %'&$#!"&4 ?# 0!5 !.' # # " ",# 73&'&' :#%"&' + !$ + ",# %"4 ?,&%, #!$",-'( ! &

(

% ((( ((( ((( ((( ((( ((( +% .!0 *

(

= .0 $

> .0

.0 1

? @

(

) $4 .&C#?&'# :#%"& + 73&$#' ! #0#$5 B5 ?!5 #3&'&4 ",#73&'&'?,&%,?#!##A-&#$"&"#7#"!$%'"-#( + =& %

(

$ $

1( 2

) 3&'&'4 ",!" ,!3# B## '#" -" !B3# !# %.#!4 7#%&'# !$ &%!7!B.# !5 0&'%'"-%"& B!# !!.5'&' ",#&"#"47-7"!$7#!"& ",#%"&#'&'"&B.5',?'",!" !!77#!.-$#:#%"&+% ",#%"?-.$.&#"",#,!&0! "",# !$.5!6!&'"",'#$#'",!"!#7!''#$-$#",# %" !5 -.# #6-.!"& !0#$ ",##-$# :-%, !'4 ",'# !&'&6 -" #3&%"& 7%##$&6'4 -$# :#%"& * ",# %"4 !6!&'"",#-!-",&L#$%%-7!"' ",#7#0&'#' ",# !$4

!.."0#"4 0!!6#0#" !$ '!.# "##0#"' /&C#?&'#4 :#%"& + "!C#'?&",&&"''?##7.5",'#$#'",!"!#7!''#$B5 ",# !$4 ,!&0!4 ,&# F#%-"&3#

&%#

!$4 & #F#%&'# 7?#' -$# ",# %" $-B"#$.54 ",# %"!%"4$!"#$ * 4?!'#"##$&"B#"?##",#7!"&#'& "#0' :#%"& + ",# %"4 B-" ",# $#4 $!"#$ 4 ?!'"7!''#$B5",#!-",&L#$0&## ",#,!&0!#&",# -$# %" ",# -.#' #6-.!"&' !0#$ ",##-$#4 B-" & "#0' .!-'# ",# "!%" " ?-.$ B# !77'&"#4 !" ",&' >-%"-#4"# #".!-'# ",#"!%"4?,&%,#!$",-'( &

1( 1

. 0

(

' (

1( 1

(

& $ $

$ ,

) .!-'# D '"&7-.!"#' ",# 3!&-' !%"&' ",!" ",# F#%-"&3#6&##0!5"!C#-7",#7#"&"&#B#&6.&!B.#"7!5 %07#'!"&F !%&#4$&'7-"#'B#"?##",#7!"&#',!$!&'# !%%-" ",# !..#6#$ 7# 0!%# ",# %"!%" B5 ",# 7#"&"&#4 !$ " B#%!-'# !5 B#!%, 3&.!"& 73&'&' ",# %" $#' 7!''#$ ",##-$# :&6& &%!".54 %.!-'# ",#"!%"4!$"!573&'& ",#%"4#!B.#$ ",# F#%-"&3# 6&## <&3&.= " .#35 %07#'!"&4 3&$# $# $!"#$ ) D4 !%%-" ",# $#.!5 ",!" 7-7"' " ,!3# B## %!-'#$ & %07.#"& ",# 7>#%" $4 %.!-'# &"'#.

73&$#' ! #0#$54 B5 ?!5 #7#'#"!"&4 " ",# %"!%"E7#"&"&#!6!&'"",#'!&$$#4"",#,!&0!4,&# 6&## ",# !$,&'!-",&L#$0&##,!"&',?4",# !-",&L#$ 0&## ",# ,!&0! #F!0&#$ ",# $&'7-"# !$ ,#.$",#.#35 %07#'!"&-7",#7#"&"&#"B#->-'"& &#$

-",#4 ",# $# $!"#$ <#F-# =4 ?!' #3# 7!''#$ B5 ",# !-",&L#$ 0&## !' ! !77#..!"# !-",&"54 ",## ?!' !77#!.4 B-" .5 ! #7#'#"!"& '-B0&""#$ B5 ",#

7#"&"&# & "#0' %.!-'# ",# "!%" 4 !5 -",# !77#!. #3&'& !6!&'" ",# '!&$ $# ?!'E&' " #3&'!6#$ -$#",#"!%"4'#%-.$B#%07#"#".&#/#!'"-$# ",#%":0-%,'4%.!-'# ",#"!%"7'"-.!"#'",!"",# $# 7!''#$ B5 ! !-",&L#$ 0&## ',!.. B# &!. 8#!&6 ",##B54",#7!"&#'B5!&"#",!$#F%.-$#$!5 -",#!77#!. #3&'&"!5

&%#!-",&"5"!''&6 &!.&"5"",#'!&$ $#,!"B#&6'4&"$# &#'.6&%",!"",# !$%-.$!''!&.",# $#$!"#$ <#F-#=4B5?!5 !#3&'&-$# :#%"& +

",# %" ,# %" ,!$ ! .&0&"#$ #.#3!%# &# " #!B.#",# !$"#"#&"!%"!%"&"#0' :#%"&+ ",# %"4 !$ " ",##!

"# '" #F#%-"& ",# !6##0#"4 $&'7-"#'4& !54&"#'#",#7!"&#'',!..,!3#"B#$#"#0&#$& "#0' ",#%$&"&' ",#%"!%" 8!""# & &''-# %! B# !!.5L#$ 0 5#" !",# 7#'7#%"&3#4 ?,&%, ?# ##$ " # # " .!-'# * "!%"4?,&%,#!$'",-'( =

D $ 9$ ,

*19$1$,

!7 A (

) B!##!$&6 %.!-'# *#3#!.'",!"&",##3#" $&'7-"# B#"?## ",# 7!"&#'4 ",# 0!""# %! B# # ##$ !B&"!"&"",#,!&0! ",# !$,&'!-",&L#$0&## &#:E ",# !$ ",#!6-0#"",!"&'B#&6!$3!%#$ B#,!.

",##'7$#"'&'!%%#7"#$4&"?-.$0#!",!"#3# ! !?!$ #$##$ B5 ",# :-7#&"#$&6 6&## ,&# 6&## ",# !$4!'!B&"!"4',!..!.'B#!''!&.!B.#B5 ?!5 !77#!.#3&'&-$#",#%"">-'"",!"4.!-'# *

-",# #3#!.' ",!" #3# ",'# 0!""#'4 ?,&%, ",# $#%&'& &' !.#!$573&$#$ &",#%"!%",!3#B##'$#%&$#$4',!.. !.'B## ##$ !B&"!"&,## #4",#'-B0&''&",!"! $#7!''#$B5",#!-",&L#$0&##&'#3&'!B.#-$#:#%"& + ",# %"4 & !%%#7"#$4 ?-.$ #$# ",# !B&"!"& %.!-'# -6!"5"&'# ",#%'7#%"-' ",#7'&"&4!''#"-"!B3#4",# $# #$##$ B5 ",# !-",&L#$ 0&## ",# ,!&0!4 & "#0' .!-'# ",#"!%"4$!"#$ 4%-.$#&",# B# !''!&.#$ B5 ?!5 !77#!. ?!' &" #3&'!B.# -$# :#%"& + ",# %" ,## #4 ",# .5 !$ &#3&"!B.# %%.-'& ?# %-.$ !&3# !" &'I ",!" ",# #3&'& 7# ##$ B5 ",# !$ " ",#

$3&' <#'7$#" = &' " %07#"#" & .!? !$4 ",-'4 ",# %'#A-#"7%##$&6'!#?,..5?&",-">-&'$&%"& %%$&6.54 ",# ?&" 7#"&"&' !# !..?#$ !$ !' ! %'#A-#%# ",# $#4 $!"#$ + <#F-# )=4 &' '#" !'&$# 4 ?# ,!3# .5 $#"#0&#$ ",# &''-# !' #6!$' ",# 0!&"!&!B&.&"5 ",# #3&'&4 7# ##$ B5 ",# !$4 -$# :#%"&+

",#%"4#%#''!&.5",#!77#!.'&# 'D !$ D *4 ',!.. ,!3# " B# $#%&$#$ '#7!!"#.54 ",## #4 ",#'!0#B#7.!%#$B# #",#.#!#$:&6.# -$6#!'7#'"# ( S.J. VAZIFDAR ) ( ARUN PALLI ) ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE JUDGE 16.05.2016 Rajan Reportable