High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14070/2023disposed of

Arun Garg v. State Of Haryana And Others

2024-09-06Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary5 pages

!" #

$%&'()*'+,-,(./0121 345.6%47 1111'&,&,(.'4 8'4-5- 9&%&'():%4;%.%%.* &<'4- 111='->(.*'.&- ?@ A B?C D?#" EEEEE 4'-'.&/ 413F<,-<'G9'&<,H3*I(+%&')(4&<'>'&,&,(.'4 41$5-<;%.&9%<%4%.H336:%4;%.% EEEEE ?#"J C 1 K<' +L%,M )(4 M'*,+%L 4',MF54-'M'.& <%I,.7 F''. 4'N'+&'*H <%- F4(57<& &<' >'&,&,(.'4 F')(4' &<,- (54& +<%LL'.7,.7 &<' L'&&'4O(4*'4 *%&'* 11 >%--'*F;4'->(.*'.&P(1 1 1 K<' >'&,&,(.'4H Q<( 4'&,4'* %- '*,+%L

)),+'4 (.

11 R )4(M &<' :'%L&< $'>%4&M'.&H Q%- '.&,&L'* &( 7'& M'*,+%L 4',MF54-'M'.& )(4 <,M-'L)%-%L-(<,-*'>'.*'.&-H&(Q<,+<&<'4',-.(*,->5&'1

1 K<' -547'4; () <,- 5.M%44,'* *%57<&'4 ((N% S%,.H F(4. (. 012122H <%I,.7 F''. >'4)(4M'* .(.'M>%.'LL'* <(->,&%LT.*4%>4%-&<% 3>(LL( :(->,&%LH P'Q $'L<, (. U11 H &%G'. &( F' (.' () &<' &Q( 74(5.*- &( 4'N'+& &<' +L%,MH ,- 5.&'.%FL' ,. I,'Q () &<' N5*7M'.& () :(.VFL' &<' 95>4'M' (54& ,. DWXYZ [Z\]

WZ Y^C \X_\ _` \aXZ b H Q<'4',. ,& Q%- <'L* &<%& &%G,.7 &4'%&M'.& ,. ->'+,%L,&; <(->,&%L F; ,&-'L) Q(5L* .(& *'>4,I' % >'4-(. &( +L%,M 4',MF54-'M'.& -(L'L; (. &<' 74(5.* &<%& &<' .%M' () &<' <(->,&%L ,- .(& ,.+L5*'* ,. &<' 7(I'4.M'.& (4*'41

.+' &<' &4'%&M'.& Q%-

U09U

#$ ! $% $

% " $

%% % % $%

&%' ( ) * $ $ ) $ "

" %! " )$

$ $

% $) % $ * % ) $ $ ! )$

) * % + $ %

, "

% % + % %' -

$ $ " % "

% % *

% * % % %!, %" %' ' (%" $ %

% %! $ $ % )!

% $ $ .

* % /% $

% 01234516 74385 9:; <34=3 => ?3@41 A )$ $

" $ % "

% ) B % $%

" $ % &% &

% & " * % &% C $ ! $ ) $ $ * % $! % $ -

% & % E " $

"% % " &$ *%

C% % &$ "F $%

" E % "& E $ % $%

" &$' I$ %) $

$ %& *'J (% $ * %!

% KL M1NO1:5 9:; 7P1PQ => R1NS131

)$ $ * -&% $ %

$ TU &% "

V % & $ E%

%%* $ ! $ ) $ % %%

% $

W(UG! $% &$ ! $ $ $ % " &% $ % ) * ) % " $ %& " $ W*% %

$ * ) " $ %& " $ % ) ' / $

$ %

! $ ) *%

% % " $ -IZ'

X !

%X'' Y'

!" #$ %& '()* + & , * -( - ( .

& / !( / ( .. * .

( .! ( .& -( . (! / !* - !! .

( !.(

! ( (! / (. / ( . * & -.( ( / / ( (0.

! .( & .

( $1$ / .( 0. .

,&. &!. && .

( ( (! 0

&. ! $ .

/& / 0

! 23 456787 9:3 ;<=<> 5? @=AB=8= * .

-(.( ( & /.&! ( , & ! !. .! $1$ * -(.

( &.* ( .

+C - ..& .

/ / 0! ( .&* ) ( !.. ( ( (&! ./.! ( .0.& , (0 ' .

.. * (&! ( &.

& 0.

( ./ ( .

)./.! !* . (-.

!.&& D.! ( ( , (&! .

( +CE%CC, * / -(.( &. - &! #.0.. F ( )! / (. .

4=67G=H ;78I6 9:3 ;<=<> 5? @=AB=8= =8J 5<6>A: K * 0.

( (

.! .

(&!

-.(! .

* .&& -( ( &./ . '$ L( 0.. / /

!.& .

&. (/ .

/..& / ( -&/ , / . &* ( &E.

. (0 ! &.&& .

/0 / ( &* / .

( ( &./$ C/ ( &. &.! .&* . -&! & .

!. .. ( .

!.$ L( (..

! ! -! .! .' ( .&.. -(.& !&.

-.( ( & $ L(

*!.!! O$N$ M 1 ,LMN $

" # !

$ % &

& " #

& *

! +

$ ,

# #

- &

& * . !

#" $ ," "

# - # ! +#+ & $ 0$

2# ," " 34546 78 9:;<5= >?@ A5B C:=D5E5 F5GG5 H (

# * I

! !* / $ , ! & "

I( &"

+ "

& "

" !( * *

& I $ K ! *

"**

- #" " ! * " !

& & (

& *

& & "

& +

*/$ + (

(

*# " * $ (

*+ "# $ % L5ME5B 3N;GD >?@ 34546 78 9:;<5= O ( ,

#'' + # &

& ! * "

-"*

#+ !* ! &&

& P*

& , +(

& ! &

&" ( QR% "+

& , * )"

$ S "

& &

" # T

UUV, $ T0UU0(

$$UUT

!" # $

% & '

( ) &

)

* +

& ' &") * *# ,*

% '- & ' )- * + "

." '

& '

/ )

*' *

" 0 %

* " && & * 1 / )

"* & ' / ) /

"* * * & '

))-' "

0 23 4# ,* &

* - & && * * & )- * " *

* '- &"&

* )" -

/ " )- * + # ' * * & ' % &

* *

" 0

* " % & " # ,* /)

% " * &

& -

)

"% & "- *

" '

' *& # #

& "

* &"

* % * &"

## *)-

# ,*

)" *

* & & * && ' % / *&

/ * # 5# 6

-# 7898:;<8=><8?@A B=>CD EFGEHGIEIJ #K * * &(L

M N * *& ) M N