High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/235/2023dismissed

Pd v. The State Of Haryana And Another

2023-09-149 pages

!!"#$#%&'()

& *+

, , -+

,

,

...

, / +

#!$

%&%'(%() "

" *!+

+(

"

!-.+/

%'% (%(%!"

)/0'%0.1

"

1"

+

FACTUAL BACKGROUND ( 2"

"

&

(% 3 ! $

+)44(5

(%

(% 3

6 "7 8 "

$ "

"

"

+

"

"

!

" "

8

6 "78 "

"

"

!

""

"

! * 9

$

8

"

" 8$ 8"

: "

2"9

;

""

! "

! :#"

" +

"

"

!

<

$

"

6

$$"

8

8"

$

$ " +&%'3/)/('% $ " $ " +33&)&)4%''

9$ " 6"= $ 9 7

8"

"$ !

#

"

+(

$ ! -

9"

8 $ $ "$

6

$ 9 8

8!"

+(

8

"$

"

""" $ 97

8"

"$

""

!"

$ !

$" $$ 8"

" ,

> " !

!

+(

$

8 8

"

!

"

! "$

!

9

"$ ) ?

"

8

-. !+'0/

('%3(% 3

4 34(%)&44%0.1!"

6

$" $$

"

1"

+

+(

"

-.8 !"

-. 8

$

"$ "

"

!

" $8 8 ""

!"

"

8

" 0/ $

! ?

%4% (%(% 8

"78

!"

$ 8 $

"

"78 "

$ " +&'(3'04%&3

"$ " $

"

$

8"

$ "

8 8 ""

$

"$ $ . $" ! 8"

1 9 ""

!"

!5 "9 " #

8 "

@ 2 " !

"

;8 $ "

8

" "

$

@

"

"78 "

$

"

;<8 "

8 ""

! "

! " ! 8"

@

8 $

"

" $8 !"

4 "$

%'% (%(% " "

6 "7 $ -. 8 !" . $"

$

$

"!

1 ,

"

"!

!$

"

8 "

$ .

9" ?

%(%)(%(%

6 "7

04 11 8 *"

!"

1 +

8

9 5 $

"

+

!$"

!

7 $"

?

%)%)(%(%

#"

"

"!

8 " $$ ?

$ 8 $"

!

7 $"

"

5 $

"

+

?

(4%4(%(%

"

8 $

. :$

8"

8

11 $ "

"!

"

/)118 " "

1 %&%'(%(% ' 1 "

/) 11

$

8 "

$

(%/11 ' ?

"

$

!

)/0;(<'%0.18 $ "$

!"

! $ "$

"$ 0 .

"

7 $"

$

&8"

/

8

) )11

" "

"$"

! "

8 "$ "

"

"

"

8 "

"

"

& "

$""

"

"

1

$

"

"

8 8"

"

+(

" " , 3 @

1 !

"

8 $

4 $

"

!" "

-. 8"

" 7

$ .

"

$

8 "

&

(% 3 -. !" "

%'% (%(%

8

"7"

"$8

! !"

9

"

"

$

"$$"

"

.

" !

"

"

"

"$ 8"

"

8"

9 ?

"7 "

" "

8 ,"

"

"

.

" !$

" #!$

B $1

% @

!

1 8

"78 $" "

8"

8" $ "!

"

9$ " !

"

"

! 8"

8 $ 9 " "

8 7 "

9$ "

8 , "

"

#$ 9 "

"

""

$

" #!$

B $1 !"!

# $%& '(

$ "$

$"

"

" "

" "

8"

"

9

7

,

8"

9

"

"$ +,, , 0

C

! !

!

8"

"

!

1 "

!"

.

"

"

8

"

!

1

" $

"8 " " . 8 "8 " 8"

8 "

"

( B $ 1

"

" "

8"

! ""

< *! 2

B $ 1 "

12# 3 4 , ! /')5 ,66 9"

!* :

< 8*!2

B $1 7%89::%8 7!9$ 4 , ! 19% ;/ 5 ( , (' " 8 $ 8"

!

8

1 8" !8"

9"

! * 1: 99 8"

!8 ! "

# $ % &' #

$

% & ( # # )

'*+!

,

#

-

$ % &! . ,

/

/ /

/ /

-

/ / / / /

,

# $0

/ /

#

$ #

&1 #

$

" -

-

- -

0

-

$

- & 2

$

-

)

"

" "$ "7 " "$

8 "

!

"

-.

!

"

"$

!

8$

.

"

8"

$ " !"

! "

-.

"7$

8

"

""

"

! * 9

8 $

+(

8

$$"

9$ " "

! 7

$ #

"

! 8"

8 $ 9 " "

8 "

04 11 *"

!"

1 +

8 "

$ 9

8 8

9 %(%3(% &

$$"

.

8

$

$$

8 8" !"

8"

7 C/

!"

!

"$ " $" $ "$"

9"

!$ $"$.

7 $"

! -. ;>7 < !"

$" $$ !

$" 9$ "7"

!$ "

! "78"

8 9 "

8 9

" $$"

"

+

"

;>7

<8 8"

$$ 8"

!"

" "

;>74< 8 !"

8

"

8" "

" "

$

"

"

6

"

7 $"

$$"

4 .

"8 8"

"

7 $

4 $

"

!"

-. 8"

"

8 "

"

6 "7 " $ 8

"

$ $ "

+

"

" 7

$

6 "7 "

" !

8 7 $"

9 8 "

- "

"

"!

.

"!

! ?"

$ 9 8

"

$ 8 $ 8

.

"

$"

!

-.

$" $$ ""

"$

"

-. !

"

$

"

-." "

!

-. !

""

$ $ "

' C4

$"

?"

5 $

"

+ 8 $"

!

7 $"

"7"

7 $"

"

#$ 98 "

" "! $ # $"

"78 8 "

!8 $ 9 # "

" $

"=D "

!"

-. 7 $"

$

"

8"

"9

"

"$ "7

" $

$"

"

$ 9 " "

" "

"1

"$

"

" "

"

8"

"

"7" , 8"

"

- "

"

+(

$$"

'%0.1 + ,

0 .

"8 " " $ "

"

! ! 8

""

"

! 1 "

"

" "

"

.

" 8

$ "

!

""

1 @

" "

"

" !

"

"

! 1

8

"

"

"8

9 1 C "

$ "

! !$"

9

#!$

1 " $"

"

,

$""$" ,

,

,!: !3<!9'(/

#E C 9"

!6 F6+ C

F6+