Union Of India And Others v. Ex Nk Raj Pal And Another
!"#" $%
&% '(& ))
) *
'(& ) )) ) &
! "#$ %&# '
# () (* +, - ! ,. ($ %&# +
/ )
) *
+ /
1, ,, #2 $, , 3 + #$# +, #
#
/4 757/ ' 8 3/*$ # #
( #
"
& 1 #( &&
$2,
, &(#"+
/+, #+
( 2##((2
!
, - !./0 ,$1
/2##(( ((
, ##&,
"
/9 /:9/ # 2#
+" ;/ 5< /::/ 1, #+
/ 2# ((
, +
)' )*7:
/::/ # 2#
+"2
+ ;/ 7554
, %+" ( /;';* "'*$#+
/< ## ; # =#(+ 2 "# (2"
&#(&#
, "
+
$
/2# ,
+ !
&#(># $2,&,
&(#
, ( ?)1 )1>1@A ' 1*?# , # #
"(# #
+
2##
B( ,#75C'/<C/:C+2
#* ;
1, ( &(#"+,
2# &
)" , $,, ,#, # ( 2# , #
+"(#
+ #(# +# 2 (% #$
/ +(
$
+ ( #
"
& 1 #( &&
$ 2,
, &##&,#((
, #+ &
1,
&#"
#((2
%
#
/4 757/' 8 3/*
1, #% #+,
8#&
, #+
!" #$%
$& "'
(
!" #
"
$ "%
& '( )* '+"
& '
) ' %
" # "
)
", !
" - .&
/# #
&) /&
0 , " 1 " ( + "
2) '
3 <
(
+", #+ #
##
'#*$ ( #
"
& 1 #(&&
$, 3+ #,#+(
#, #2
+ ,) $ $!
# 2"# ,0
> + &
"#F # ++ &% D &# 2 $ # +(##& +
" 2,
+#(("
+# %3G3%# "
+,
+ ($ ,
((
, #" $
#, #( #
$,
&" (
$##"
+, &"
##
+ # (,"
$#, , #"
"#
&
, # $, ("
,
&#
, &
#(
&#
# "(# $,#&=
$+"$, &( +,, D
@?
8)$&# (
# * +
!"
$
,)- .
) 1, %# ## #, + , # % & # 8#&
, #+
&4"
5
, !
!
# " !#1
" 6 +7
,
!
! !
" ""
"
,,!
!
" *
"
& ' !
,,!
!
"
8
9 :
4 # ;&<
4
*==(9,
.-+
+4
" "
, !
"
"
"= !
,
", !
" ",
!
">9 )?9 0(+@
+
" ( +#
"
*
4" ,
!
(9 + !+=
""
! !
,
!
"#
"
!
" "
"
"
"
"
!
" >9 0("+@ (!+=
!
"" "
!
"#
"
!
",
!
!
"> 0(+@ (!
+= "
"
! "
"
"" "
!
"
!
!
"# $ "%
> 0(+@A (!
+=
$ "%
, *== <B
$ "($
:
+# &
& C <8
6 B : "
<# " ,.#;
! - D# ""
,#
! !
,
&% '*+, % 8#&
&( $ , ,
(
&(# $,#2, # (
#(
# "
+, &"
##
+ # (,"
$# 2,&, 8 + 75 C % $ , $ , , # &,
%#(
+", " $ ,
#
++ (
$, # "
+ ( #
+, &"
##
+ # (,"
$2,
#(
2,# ( #=#"+75C" " #% #
&(## +" , !
&#( ># $ #, &# & ,#, ##
(
#
&"
"(#
1,
&(##
D
, 8
9 :
4
;&< 4
*==(9,
.-+ :
, " $, ,, # "#
%3G3%, , &#(# "
#(, #(,+# "
+,
+ # (,"
&&
&#(( 2, #, #
+,
&" ((
$, & ,
&"
2,#
! % $, ,, , #(#+, "$ ,# 2, #
# , $ , && = ( $ ,
, # ,# +
#'* +# $#,
"
# = (+,
# # "
+ ,
+ # (,"
" #% ( $, +% 2"
=#
+ '#*%3G3%, &&
, "( $# &# $, "#3
$, $, &(#"#
(
& % ( ! % $#((, +#& # &&"#& # # , + &&
$#
&( ( &H
$,+
&(# 2, , +# %3G3%, &&
$# = (=#
+ "(# # - , #"
#
# "(#
/5 > ,##"# $,
#( +,#+, &( '*,# , &#
#(+ ( , &&
( #*, "
+#&& #& &&
"(# $"
&" &
!
&#( ># %3#3% ,
2, # 2,&, ,2 $
&&(
,"
+
(
* +,
# , +$ "# #( = (
&&(
!
&#(># $ # +" + "(#
# "(# $#, , #"
&
#(
// , $+, "
&#(,( ,#, &(
,#%
&
"
&#( 8#"#+, &&
"#
$,,
&" (
$, $, #"
2((
,#% # , #'#*$, !
&#(>#
# #+ &&(
/7
! % $#(
&(#
#$,#"# # +, !
&#(># +((2,
( (# 2),# 3
. +, I.
!
&#('!(#
*$7557JI( .
#( &( I
/;
1, + $,#
2
"
2, "+ % &( $2, #, "
+ ("
+,
, " $,#+ # ("# "
&#( 8#"#
"#
%3#3%,, #(,$,#
&#"
&
"
,"# -2, "
&#"
#
,#, 2## "##
! % $#(
"
$+", +#&#,# $2, , # &##( 8 3 +, $# -, +$, $,, (("
+,
#F (#& $ %3#3% , #&% ," + "(# $2,
$,)"# &&(
,#, + #, 2## = (+,
, "
# #&,2##
&#"
,
"(#
/E #
$#(
#,
+", & $2, , !
&#(># #(( &
"#F
#(
&% # &
#(&, &F$#&(#( # # , +, $, , "( "
+ # +"
&#( &,= $ , % ( (&F &,#
& & &$ 2, +"$#, ,
&#"
&
! % $+,
"( "
+#( (#( $,
"#
&&(
=#
, +$, = , # ("
#F
/ (#& $#, 2#&
#( 2
+ "(#
#
&"
+"#& +"(#
)#( $+, # "(
&,= #, #
+# ("
#F (#& $, !
&#(># &&
$( #&&($,#, # #,
"#&
+# , "# , ("
+# (, #" $#% # +&
(#( , = #&%
&- , +$
& + +"(# 2( ##(( #2 ((&&( !
&#(># $,##&%
&#"
&
+" # ++ &% &##(
& & & 2,
, 2(
#(+ ( /<
@2 $2,
#%$,)
8#& & +, $#
&#"
&
"
&#( #
"# 3"-"
0"3,
3-
05"!
//0
134 05"!
! $$ !
6"
2# 05"!
# $ ?)1 )1 &#(
>1@ A
' 1* /4
& #(,##, "
# ("
#F (#& #,
&#"
"#
" +, &( '#*
&(#
@?
8)&# (
#* +
!"
," - !
&#( ># $,#"
2,&,,2 $ +
$
(
, " $ "#F ("#
0 + $ ,
&(## + (#2 D
'#* ,#
, # ",#, & 2## = (+ + $
+#%#
2
%3#3%,
1, , , # "
# , ( %
, "
&#"
&# , @2 $ , # &# %
& %3#3%,
$#, +&
(
"$ ##(( #( &##
#(, !
&#(># $
(+,
#%+ #, $ , , "( "
+ , # + (&F &,#
& &##( & & &,= '*$ 2,
"#
&#"
#%
,#, , #" ($
&#"
&
+"# &
#(
&+#"( , ! % $
2##(
#
, "
&#($,# +#2 ((+"
##, 2##&
#( #
&#"
, #
&#"
# "(#
/9
@2 $# +'#*$ &( ,#,#
&
#
+"# #,#%
&
, 8 '#* #
( $ & %
, "'#*,#
(
$,
$,) &#
% 2 ,#
, +, "
&#( # $ # 8#&
'#* )&( $ ,
&
&#
#
, #((+"
#$
,
,
+, &#
# = (+# &
#(
& +#"( , )#( $
&(#
# +"
+"(#
#
$
&(#
#
&"
+"(#
,0 0 0/,7 $ # -
0$ 1! ,$# - 0 8
" $ 0# /6
1, ( #
& (+, +, "$,# ( #
1 #(+#(
# &# ,#
/2# %#(
+ #&&+"
&#( ( 2#
+" $ # ,#%
(#&
(2 "
&#( &#
# &"( +, "+,
, )$ ,, %+
(#/9;+,
(#+, " $/:4/2 +#%# ( ##&
# #&,$
/ 2# (
#+ ( .- E
"
" !
"
, !
"
,
!
!
!
" ""
"
,,!
!
" *
"
& " ! /:
) = ( $#
,#, (#& (#&
#
1 #(, % &
8)&# (
#),.26"$1 0)"$/29# $" $ $1"
$1 0#$2,&, "5"-88
- :
&#"
#
$2##"3(#&
(#& $ # , 8(# + (#2 "#
$ 2#
2# ( &# ( 2#%#(
+" 2# #(&# &# ( 2#
+" #,#%
(#&
(2"
&#(&#
$
&"( +, "+,
, #
#
, #+ $ , # % # "
# #(, D &#(&& +,)# &
#(( $+, #& ( '#*#
!
&#(># 2#( ,#75C 1, + , ,$ ),.26"$1 0)"$/2'#!
;#,80 <# 8(#+(#2"#
,#+#( %#(
+" #&&+,
&#( #
&(# #(
(
( ,#,
75C$,
$ %#( ( +" $, # & "
75C
& #( $, ,,
$ " #% ,##&&+, ( '#* #(
, ( $,, ++
#
, " $2,
$,
%#(
(#( # #
( $ , , %#( ( +" 2#, 3 = +, %#(
( # (
7/ > ,##"# $ +, ( %#(
+"
2, , #("
+# ( $,"$,#
&(#
,)
+"(# $,
$ , ,, ( ( ,#75C
1, + $# ###(&((# , $, & "+
(
75C$ &% +
+
%#( ( +"
&
&,$ &% +
+%#( ( +" #,
&
$
2, , ( #(
,",#
&
!
&#(>#
( ,#75C$2, $ "+,
8(# + (#2 '#* "#
),.26"$1 0 )"$/2'# !
;#,80 <+#, ,
, (
75C 2,
$, ( 2#
" #% ( %#(
+"
"#&#(( $, ,#
%#(
+"
$, (#
+D& $+("# , ,#
"
-
+" $, ,#%
(#&
(2"
&#(&#
# -&"( + "+
$,
$, +" $#, ,#,
%#(
+" +&
,
8(# + (#2 '#* "#
),.26"$1 0 )"$/2'# !
;#,80 <+
#(&# ,"$ # "#F #
8(#+(#2$
++ &% , ( $,
D& 2(
#
%3#3% ,
1, #+#
#
+", +#&"$ ,#+, 2 ( 2#+
#
$,
$ , 2###((
2
++ ( 1, +, #+&&(
#(#F
$ +", +#&",#& # "#F
&#"
#2#
,
$ " + , % , )$ 2, $, (
&" #(
,"
) ,
, )$ ,$ , 2( ,#%
$ "
( ,#%
(#&
(2 "
&#( &#
$, ,#
)#( $#, #
=#,
%#(
+" 2#
1, + $2, , ),#
,"+" "
,#%
(#&
(2"
&#(&#
$,$#&&+ ,
## ( $#, ,# $, "
# ( #&& , "
( (2 "
&#( &#
$
$, (2"
&#(&#
$&# ,
%#(
+" 2,#
, ++ &
&" &
7;
2$ &# # % + &
$, # " #, #, # ( +", " $"
( ,
(#&
(2"
&#( &#
, ) #( %#( # #"
(#(
$
, #( # ( $2,&,,#
&(#
,)
# "(# #
+#& ,#( ,#75C$
+#&,#, & "
+ (
"+, # 8(#+(#2$
&#
75C$2,
$#
+,
%#(
+" 2#
#
1, + $ , "
, ,#% (( &, # (
F ,
&"
(
+", # ( #$,&#, "$=# #(
&" #(
2, ( '#*$,,
2
2, ( $, ,, #, ,#&
"#F " #% %#( +,
+"
$ , , # ( # -
( +"
#,#%
(#&
(2"
&#(&#
= ($ # # ,#$ , # ,#
+" , " , $ #
( # ( &# # ( #&# , "$#2# ,
, ( $ 2,&,, 2 "+, # 8(#+(#2$,
&#"
(
2
7E
, " $# #(+"
#($,#, #(# , (
( 2
+ 7< 75/E$ 2,&, # & +, % & 8) ),.26"$1 0)"$/2'#!
;#,80 <
7<
1, ,, D
#
@?
8) &# (
# ),.26"$1 0)"$/29# $1 0# '#*2# #
7< 75/E @2 $ "# +#& $ , , ,
+ + &#
,
"
( ,
,# ,# ( &% ++ & # ,# ,# &% ++ & 1, #
,# + #" (
8(& &% ++ &
&#"
#
, % &'#*$ 2, $## //, +$##2, +,#
8#&
, #+ $#
&(##+(#2"#
, ++ &$,# +, (
#&&+, #
& "+ (
(2 75 C$ , # & " + (
&#
B75C# +, , #"
++ <5C (#( ,
+& ++ &+,
&(##+(#2$ , , , #( "
$
2
, ( $ &% # +& +, D
+, # 2"
"#
$, $ "
$, &
" +,)$## # &++ # 2(
"(
3 , ( 2,
&#"
, "#F + % &'#*$,2,, ( 2,
&#"
= , # % &'#*
D
# #
#
"
"
!"
!
"
"
"
!
"
,
!
4F " A
"
"
,
,
9"
$ " % , ," "
# 4 F "
"
5
!
"
"
#
! #
!
,
", ! ,
!
"
"
, "
1 & 2
++3 & +
1 ("
& "
(
& ( "
& 3 ""+
&&
"3
&2
"
& 3 3 & &2 ( & F
#
9 ?9,
#
,
!
!
"
"
,
"
# #,#2# , & # +, #
&(##+(#2#
8), % & '#*$#&,$,
&(##+(#2
"(
%3#3%,
% , 2 &
&(## + (#2 "#
&'#*"#F ,
&(##
# 8(#+(#2 "$,
$, 8(#+(#2 "$#"#
% & '#*#("#F ,
&+
+%3#3% ,
+ ( &&
$ $ "
$ #( ( &&
$,## "
F, # 2"
# "#
$# ,#$, +(( &"( $# (
$
&% #$+# $+
(# # (#&,
> ,# # "# $ 2 , "#F + # &,#((
, #+ #, #& +
/$
, #(
F #
&(##$ ,# " + , #
8(#+(#2"#
),.26"$1 0)"$/2'#!
;#,80 <$, ,
2
+ , + (#( $ , ) &#
#+ 1"#7"##"$/ , 2 ,( % & "#
1 #(&&
7:
1, "
$##
( #
1 #( &&
$"##
# #++"
;5
+#( 2,#(( #(&#'*$+#
;)
) *
< ;) ) &< F#%
, 2
0#8
."$/=0
# $ #= 2
00 8 0
3-
#=