← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18548/2015dismissed

Kay Bee Safal India Ltd v. Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal And ORS

2017-11-08Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mrs. Justice Archana Puri3 pages

  

  !



    

"#$  $%&'&()  *  

          !  

"   

   ) (+,-$. /'#&%$"0$'1&(2"- (+,-$. /'#&%$/.3&(2$.4&(51&-- .$'$(#) . ("(211&,,".64$(&. 23%"#$7&#1 ./."3"(8#&"6 23%"#$ .#1$9$#&#&($. . .3&(2"0#&"6 23%"#$ ..$'9(2$(#  :::::

#"

 $%  1$9$#&#&($. 1"'  &-$2 #1$9.$'$(#9$#&#&(&;9/5(&(5 #1$ .2$.2"#$2 <  9"''$2,=#1$ $,#'$%3$.= 99$--"#$.&,/("- .

'1.#>#1$  ?&( 99$"-@** "5"&('##1$.2$.9"''$2,=#1$ $,#'$%3$.=.&,/("- .'1.#> ?&(4$%/.&#&'"#&( 99-&%"#&( 4 *< <1$ &(#1$9.$'$(#%"'$1"29&($2#1"#9".# #1$ 9.9$.#=671&%17"';.#5"5$267"'"5.&%/-#/."--"(261$(%$6#1$9.3&'&('  4$%#&(@& 4$%/.&#&'"#&("(2$%('#./%#&( &("(%&"- ''$#'

"(2( .%$;$(# 4$%/.&#=(#$.$'# %#6   .'1.#A#1$4 

4

%#B7&--(#,$"99-&%",-$("99$"- &-$2,=#1$,"(8,$ .$#1$  6 #1$;"##$.7"'.$;&##$2,"%8##1$ #.$%('&2$.#1$&''/$(#1$,"'&'

   #1$$3&2$(%$(.$%.26$'9$%&"--=6"'#71$#1$.#1$-"(2;.#5"5$2,= #1$9$#&#&($.7&#1#1$,"(8&',$&(5/'$2 ."5.&%/-#/."-9/.9'$.(# #&'(#&(2&'9/#$#1"# ..$%3$.= #1$-"( .;#1$ 9$#&#&($.6#1$.$'9(2$(#,"(81"2 &-$2.&5&("- 99-&%"#&( @<C   ,$ .$#1$ 671&%17"'"--7$2(C@ @1$,"(87"'1$-2 $(#&#-$2#.$%3$."'/;  6@@6<<6@ D"-(57&#1&(#$.$'#"';$(#&($2 &(#1$.2$.#&' /.#1$.(#&(2&'9/#$#1"##1$9$#&#&($.2&2(#9.$ $."(= "99$"-"5"&('##1$"

.$'"&2.2$.9"''$2,=#1$ $%3$.=9.%$$2&(5' %/-2(#%(#&(/$6"'"

#$.9"''&(5 .2$.,=#1$ 6#1$9$#&#&($.1"2 "99."%1$2#1$ ".2 .(2/'#.&"- &("(%&"-$%('#./%#&(  /(2$.#1$9.3&'&(' 4$%#&(

4&%8(2/'#.&"-;9"(&$'49$%&"- .3&'&(' %#6<  .'1.#A4 B

''#"#$2,=-$".($2%/('$- .#1$9$#&#&($.6#1$"

.$'"&2

%#7"'.$9$"-$2(  C"(2(7&#&'9$( .#1$,"(8#$E$%/#$ #1$.2$.9"''$2,= &(&#' "3/.1$$%3$.=

&%$.%"(#"8$ "99.9.&"#$'#$9' .'"-$ 9.9$.#=671&%1&(%-/2$'$3$(#1$-"(2&( F/$'#&( .71&%1#1$;"##$.1"',$$(.$;&##$2,"%8,=#1$  ##1$  .%('&2$."#&(671$#1$.&#&'"5.&%/-#/."--"(2.(# 1$ "%#'"'$;$.5$(7".$#1"# &-$2,=#1$,"(8'$$8&(5 #.$%3$.#1$-"( .;#1$9$#&#&($.1"'"-.$"2=,$$(2$%.$$2"(2#1$ 9.9$.#&$'&(%-/2&(5#1$-"(2&(F/$'#&(%"(,$'-2,=#1$$%3$.= 

&%$. ..$%3$.= #1$2$%.$#"-";/(#1$(-=2&

$.$(%$7/-2,$ #1"#&(%"'$#1$-"(2&(F/$'#&(&'9&($2#,$"5.&%/-#/."-6"%#&(/(2$. 

4 %#;"=(#,$9''&,-$#1$.7&'$6&#%"(,$'-2,=#1$ $%3$.=

&%$./(2$.#1$9.3&'&( $%3$.=  $,#' /$#"(8'

@ "(2 &("(%&"-('#&#/#&(' %#6<<@ G$$9&(5&(3&$7#1$"

.$'"&2 "%#'67$2(# &(2"(=.$"'( #$(#$.#"&(#1$9.$'$(#9$#&#&("(2#1$'";$&'"%%.2&(5-=2&';&''$2   "0$'1&(2"- 

/25$ /.3&(2$.4&(51&--  *   /25$ 9"(8"0 1$#1$.'9$"8&(5D.$"'($2 !$'D 1$#1$.$9.#",-$ !$'D