Sheela Kataria And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others



    
  

  
 

 ! "# $ %&'

( 

"%&%)&* $ %&'

 

 


   
   

   
+'

,- + .
 .. /

,- + .


/-       !
" 
#"$"% &'" (# !)!"*%

*+%""",# !
""

#!"

% +%""" !)!"*% &'",# !#"* "!"'#" "% &'" !
#&"$+" % &'" !- "$"% &'"" !


#"#"% &'" ( .
 //// .. /

 0 #  '*"$  $"

    #  "  ,      (  " $" "$ $"

# '' %%$( #*' " 01234205(#"""+&$%# %# *"  *" ($"'6%#%# '$

."*&"

*(  (#6 *' 4 #  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" ('(**  ' %    *")   $%    #  $" "  (
'020(#  #"7$"" ""' "  '6%  #"

*"  "  *$  '%  4208 9#"(  (  #  (    "  #  :'  (  4208:; "  '"$ '" #<'(4208:%# #"""' 40(4205%

 

&,#("="' #"(%#"#*" " ."*&"

*(#*&" *'#(%# #""  #"#*" %'&(#"**"'#

"'6  '       # "  '6  '%  0531 9#"((#'"** "#:'(0531:;# '$ (** $" %"#"."*"&"

*(  (# *&" *'%# #""&"*"

*( '$

*" ($"'6        


     



                   

  

! "

#

 $%#"

                    "   &  $%#"

'

  ""

 "'        ( )#   

  *  "

# 

"  "

  #' #

 '  ""' "

$%#"
+ 8

#" "& #,%#"# "#'"*(#  *" # #"& '' #"

"#" ##"&'#" #"* $( "

 &# (##*" ,022(, "

#"

'' "#(''("

#342 6"" *" (#.*> %" %# "') (  #  *"  *"  #  "  #  ''  "

?"'    # *" %,#'##"& *" # #

 #"#*" 6 ("# 

 

#"&  "'6  #  *"  *  (  &  (    #  &"

*  1 !&%"*' #"# #"& ' "

#"''(&  '$"%"$'# "%# *" #*" (#*" ,"

?"' #*" %,#"%# '   ?' #    *"     "'6%  # #  $")  #  $ 

('"9; @

    "    $  #  #"  #    "*   7A.4224B.420C  (  #  7%  '#"**   # "'6'  %,#'#," $ # #" $"

80254242#*&"(#& '9";="'

#"( ,
'

 "    #
-  )". #.'$
/ 0/1     

  2     &" 

   
C

(#"& #,%#"&,( '*"B(#*' " 01234205(#"""+&$%# "'6 *"  *" ($"'6#*&"(# *'9";="' #"( 3
45# $

 ""     6   7"  

 &"'            '   " 

' ( !

   "#

     !

&  ""

 



! "'  

"   
!

&"

  #'    '  ""'  

 *                   "

  8'  


9&

( !:#

 "   

 "  

  *

  ;   

    

'    "   "    "

 "   

     " '   %#"      & '   "  #  "'  %#"  

 

        '    "   ''       

 
0!;  "       

  *

    "&

!  ##

"# 

 < 

    #



    
B ##"&"*(* "9=.

04; (#"#'' ) *" (#*"  &,(#*'9";" "*$(#& '9"; 5 #%#" "& #,%#"# ."'6 *"   # "  '" *>#*" "$"#%#*"  *"

(

($"'6   &"

*."*  1!%&!

2%"

" 3 *45&6 !)895!!5%&!

%2 : 1"& $ *%)&! :

2%"

; 4545%& "!

3 #  *"  '*  ""  (  #    #" *") # $%"&*(
'0209";",**"% "'#('*"B(#*' " 01234205(#"""

+&$%      #  "   $  '$  '$** # %#("'("'(''= ""

"#

08(# *%"(( "&%"(# # #  '' %',#("="' #"( ,1
4 



"  ' 
4 # # 

'1/ "#'6
-

"         //  
              "    '# # 

    

4 

       ""

     % '"
 4

   ' .    

'  '   *"

  
=# 

 '

'

         "

  . 

#"

" .

  
 4                    '              '     *        # "#

<



 
4 

 * 

'# '  "    #    =>

$

"  -$

<

?   @
 A.  )

            
+ 02   "

  (  #  "  '%    $")  "#'

$ '9;%#"#*" ""$") (#"  *'" # "*> %"*>"

*%" %" &"

*(("'*" #" *'76*%# '*(#'"" %#"#*" " #  ."*    &"

*  (  ("'*"  #  "   *'

#'",**"" $$ %#& (
'020(#:'(4208:&,(#*' "

01234205  7"*%    &"*  $"  (  "*  *"'#

"'6'   #:'(0531:%## %("%(#*" % #%'"** ,#  #  & *   .&  #   *'  %  #    "# '$***",(*#" #"#"

&  $

"&*(
'020(#:'(4208:%*' "

01234205%'$**'"'" "*" "#"

 #"  #  "      #%  ""    .

"*&"

*(#  *" %#(("'*" # " *'%"#"  %"&*( ?'& '$*"%"$"

 #"#'' %" '# "

& ?'&#'$*"% $"("&%#"# *" "" "*'$(#*"*"*"  #'$*(#*&" *'#(%#*"

'*(##""

**") #"

&" $% #$ #&(
'020(#:'(4208: " D%%*' " 01234205



00 7'*    &  (  ,#  &  # "'6  *" %    #     '' %  #  #"   "'9;(('"9;9";%# ,##
" '$ "

*,(#"'6 *"  *"*#&$( '$*    "

*  ,#  &  #  "'6  *"     #  .
"%#$"),**$, ,##"$ (# & '  :

*=7#'"(  

!" # !$  

%&'())* 
*& &$")"*(# "'6 *" # # *'"'#%#&(  *> %#=' (#"

&, ""

*,% "#"

*%"# #"'$" '$('#

#
"("""%#,* "**# .& $ # *'9;#(%='"&"='"* ''$"'%"$'#"%'''( #"<  = "  $  (  '$"  $  $ %  # $") #*6 "%'""  #
" ='#6%#%# #"""$(."* &"

*((#"'6 *" %$" '$"



#
"(""" ,&%  #  "

&  ='   "   "&"*"

*#' (#'" 04 #$%#*" '*(#"  #"  '9; " # '' %   &,  (  #  & '  "    7A.4224B.420C%    ' "(#%,# #'*"$(*"9; =$9;(#*" %($"'6%#$(
' 020(#:'(4208:",**"*' " 01234205%

'#" $"

 #"#'' #(%#



*" '*(#"#""$" "$ $"

# '$*,## '9;"$"

# ,9"; 08

# " %# # '$"#"& $"

# " " #*%&( '$"

# " "%'&(#"

&%'#"'6

*" " '*" %#*"*" " "*'$(#

&*$"'& *"'# #76*%,# #"

& ?'&'$*"##" $"

'(#   (  #  "'6  *"   "#    #   .
" *"*%#" *"'" '$'""*> # #(%#6*(#"

&%#"%#"'6 *" " # "*",**"&"

*( .& #6 *' *"**#"

& " %"(# #,% "'' %" # '&( ' $"

#  ? '"(# #'$"# #"* '"#7$")"$" "$# "

& " #  01 7'*"*,##" " #*"

"* &'"+"*%"""#",# ","*(#*'

9"; "'&' "(# " #"& #*#*'9";*)* .'"**  0@ *"*"*#("'(#"

&%#7  # $(" ""","# '#  ? '""%("%(* #

(#"#'' %#"$ *") "*'% ,#'#"" 9";%*)* &#*.'"** 



0C !&%""*(""1(#*(*

# #,%&"* #"# #"&'& #"$( $ '$"," "') #"0331%#%# #'*"$(*"9;=$( #*" %($#"'6"# '$'$** *&"#'" '*"$ ($#7 0B #(('(#"

&%#"%# #"

$    "''  #  &"*  (  #  *"'#  (  #  "'6 '  %" # #""# ($'#"**  # &"* (#*"'# (#"'6'   05 #%#7"*'"* " +,#!!

-./ ! 0! / 123/3!4 56

     7#!+&

 *)

%#"

* #

"*,#$*""#",#*&" ""

"#(#& '9";"="' #"( ,3
B" # ' 

" "     

'

       "    <    #'< 

  ( 89:#### 4!

3;#!   5 #5
!  !# 33 <% 5=3

!&&! . ;>5!  ;

  #     21.          !35#

!&#5#;5.31 ;

%  !!

% #     21.&  !  5=3  3  #  5   ?)@A 89:###! 5 #5
5 41! 5 3! 5& 13 # 

  55&    5#

4  # 

3

 55 3  5=3!  /54!&  3  #  5   ?)@A 89:###

55# ! 1!4#  !!# # 5=3

# !;5.31 ;

%

!!

%&#43&# #

# ! ;3 <&&#

53!;#!/!!!!& 1 /35.#  A

 

03
4 '$/0/1"

           

 " #"   

   #    "      .'  # 


C# #



     0/1

 # 

        

4"

"    

$

'   #$/ 0/1 '= ;
00/ 

"

' '  8$%#"                  

    '      

"

   # ", #

+ , +
=#' &"'      #        $  /           '    $ ""

! #'       

 $  /           $

'                  $ %#"8 '  "#' $  7          

3         # 

  " 

 ", #

+, +




1/
4"

$ 0/1 $7

3 "  

   $/
4#'' $7

3



&    $  /
 4          # $/  #.  '




4  



  

"  #              "        $  %#"   "

<#  .'  '



B " #$/ #   $%#"  "   *  '   "

'  , #   +,  +    '

  5 53!/3;

5 /3/!
8./# !!!3// 9



  

  #  

       =D

$

"    

  '   $ /0/1    *   " <"

 $%#"    #

   

 #

", #

+, + 

 '

#& ' ,



+

 4      '      '    

!

   '    

    $  %#"  .'     &      $  /          0/1 #$'#" #' .""

 


""

    " '

   
-  #'   ""

       

      !


4  #" '

  ""

 

      !     &"  $    

3
E  

 #$ %#"8 '  "

 "

  #      

   

                   



4# #   "           "

   #             & "( ,BC'

C-D78'9 4 '   $ /0/1 ,   *+   " <

 '#"                

        

      #  " , #

+, + ' 




BC'

C-D78''9 4 ;
! '#
4 $/'#   #  

 



' 



  '



BC'

C-D78'''9 4                  '#
 4

# #'      #  "  , #

+    ,  +'   # 

  *     

 #  " 
+ 5&1:

"$ "

%2 475!

%)"4 03

"($"#%#7( $#,% #"$ '$**(&*%#6   $

,#'#(%#"$ $ ,#'( @2%222D.

"'#(# (#,#  #$,## :.

5#

 !# /  (

# !# 

+ ($ " # ""* "#
"''  42
'#$"'"*(#"  ' %#%"**#   "*'"9;%("%"*" 9;  (

=.. />

  =/-  >

 

  )"& # 7 47 "

!; 1?5&6 " 1!%& $ '

!

% 7 47 "

" ;%"418:

'

!

%