High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3668/2024dismissed

Mange Ram (Siince Deceased) Through His Lrs v. Banwari Lal

2025-05-09Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal13 pages

"#"$%"&'(

) $'*'+"&'( ! )

) ,'-",.#/'+"&"+",#"&01$*-12# "0/0/'"$# 3"$#*#

,'4,$/2,5 "#6'&"'0 (7 2 839 :

$-*"& ;

39 :

!"#"$#$%&

(!) * +,

- -

. !/01& 2 !/013) 4

0%/ -

- $

- - '

5- & .-) 6!1#####5(-

76$5(

#"#8$#!1#"#8$#!0 #"#8$#!1 '

)& .6

6) !$#8$#$$&

($)

* - -*-, & + ). 1

-9 -&

(0) - - &

( 8)

" !/01 - 0%/

-: -

- '

$/!$$#$$; -

!$#8$#$$

- -

;

4 -

-- -

6 4 !$#8$#$$:

6 ' $/!$$#$$ ' <-- !"!!$#$$&

(%) &

(") :-

4 - -

- =

- 0%/ -

- %

- - - &

(>) : -

6 -- :- --

6 - - - '- :- -- 4

<-- --- - "

- ?

- - -

0 .

- 8 : -

- 6

* '

- - - - - - ;

6 ' - !$#8$#$$ - - - --- -- - ?

-- :

* +,

> -

- -- -

* ' .

!$#8$#$$

6 :

6 ' <-- !"!!$#$$:

- -

/ : -

!#&)

!/01 --!>"/ --

- '

- @ !>"/- - A:B !>"/ !>0$ !>"/--

A:A!>8!-- AB!>88@ -- - !/#>

=- - .* 1 $8#8!/"0- -- .4

$1!$!/0# -

- .4

- !/0$:

10!/01 #!#!!/0%: 2 - 3

$&)C =6"$/& 5/./0,0/'> .",'# 01" 6"$/& 5/./0,0/'

6$"#+$/?"& $,';#*/0<,66",5$,665/+,0/'?;01"8+1"&*5"< ,'& =6$"#+$/?"& 6"$/&> .",'# 01" 6"$/& 5/./0,0/'

+.6*0"&/',++$&,'+"4/0101"6$%/#/'# 01/# +0> !#&)

" '

( ) @0"'#/' 6$"#+$/?"& 6"$/& /' +"$0,/' +,#"#A ';

,66",5$,';,665/+,0/'<01"$01,',',665/+,0/'*'&"$ ,'; 01"6$%/#/'# $&"$BB 01" &" /%/5 $+"&*$"< !

) !

< .,; ?" ,&./00"& , 0"$ 01"

6$"#+$/?"&6"$/&/ 01",66"55,'0$01",665/+,'0#,0/# /"#01"

+*$001,01"1,&#*

/+/"'0+,*#" $'06$"

"$$/'-01",66",5 $.,C/'-01",665/+,0/'4/01/'#*+16"$/&

) @65,',0/'A1" ,+001,001",66"55,'0$01",665/+,'0 4,#./#5"&?;,';$&"$<6$,+0/+"$D*&-."'0 01"/-1 *$0/',#+"$0,/'/'-$+.6*0/'-01"6$"#+$/?"&6"$/&.,; ?"#*

/+/"'0+,*#"4/01/'01".",'/'- 01/##"+0/' !#&)

- - !/01 - -

- '

- !#&)

* -

- - -

4 !#&)

- * - - -

- ' ; 2- - - 3

- -- : -

* :

2,'C,3"'C,0"#4,$5*%80,0" '&1$,$,&"#1<

8!! @

- -

D : -

* :

'&/,'/5$6$,0/'20&%8*?$,0, $,1145"C<

8 2

E -

- -

!#&) " .

- - & -

F AA:**)

-- :

#1,

1,00,+1,$D"" %"$#*# ,',-/'- ../00"" ,-1*',016*$ , ,$

+,&".;,'&01"$#

/%/5E ) ; 3- '* -- - - =$. 01" , $"#,/& ,*01$/0/"# 01" 6$/'+/65"# 01,0 +,' ?$,&5;?"+*55"&*0,$"( / 1"$" #1*5& ?" , 5/?"$,5< 6$,-.,0/+< D*#0/+"F $/"'0"&<''F6"&,'0/+,66$,+141/5"&",5/'-4/01,' ,665/+,0/' $+'&',0/' &"5,;< $01"+*$0#,$"

'0 #*66#"& 0 5"-,5/#" /'D*#0/+" ?*0 ,$" ?5/-"& 0 $".%"/'D*#0/+" //1"0"$.#G#*

/+/"'0+,*#"G#1*5&?"*'&"$#0& /'01"/$6$6"$#6/$/0<61/5#61;,'&6*$6#"$"-,$& ?"/'- 1,& 0 01" ,+0 01,0 01"#" 0"$.# ,$" ?,#/+,55;

"5,#0/+,'&,$"0?",665/"&/'6$6"$6"$#6"+0/%"001" ?0,/'/'- ,+0F#/0*,0/' ///8*?#0,'0/,5D*#0/+"?"/'-6,$,.*'0,'&6/%0,501" 0"+1'/+,5+'#/&"$,0/'##1*5&'0?"-/%"'*'&*",'& *'+,55"& $".61,#/# /% 6$"#*.60/' +,' ?" ,00,+1"& 0 &"5/?"$,0" +,*#,0/' &"5,;?*0<-$##'"-5/-"'+"'01"6,$0

01"+*'#"5$5/0/-,'0/#0?"0,C"''0" %2,+C ?', /&"#/.6*0,?5"0,6,$0;#""C/'- +'&',0/' &"5,;/#,#/-'/ /+,'0,'&$"5"%,'0 ,+0 %/0/#0?"C"60/'./'&01,0,&1"$"'+"0#0$/+06$

#1*5& '0 ,

"+0 6*?5/+ D*#0/+" ,'& +,*#" 6*?5/+ ./#+1/"

?"+,*#"01"+*$0#,$"$"H*/$"&0?"%/-/5,'0 #01,0/'01"*50/.,0""%"'0*,0"01"$"/#'$",5 ,/5*$"

D*#0/+" %//1"+'+"60 5/?"$,5,66$,+11,#0"'+,6#*5"

01" +'+"60/' $",#',?5"'"## ,'& /0 +,''0 ?"

,554"&,00,55;*'

"00"$"& $""65,; %///1"$"/#,&/#0/'+0/'?"04""'/'$&/',0"&"5,;,'& ,&"5,; #1$0&*$,0/'$ "4&,;#< $001" $."$ &+0$/'" 6$"D*&/+"/#,00$,+0"&41"$",#001"5,00"$/0 .,;'0?",00$,+0"&1,0,6,$0<01" /$#0'"4,$$,'0# #0$/+0,66$,+141"$",#01"#"+'&+,55# $,5/?"$,5 &"5/'",0/' /@ 1" +'&*+0< ?"1,%/*$ ,'& ,00/0*&" , 6,$0;

$"5,0/'-0/0#/',+0/'$'"-5/-"'+",$"$"5"%,'0 ,+0$# 0 ?" 0,C"' /'0 +'#/&"$,0/' 0 /# # ,# 01"

*'&,."'0,56$/'+/65"/#01,001"+*$0#,$"$"H*/$"&0 4"/-101"#+,5" ?,5,'+" D*#0/+"/'$"#6"+0 ?01 6,$0/"#,'&01"#,/&6$/'+/65"+,''0?"-/%"',00,5- ?;/'01"',." 5/?"$,5,66$,+1 @ 01" "@65,',0/'

"$"& /# +'++0"& $ 01"

-$*'&#*$-"&/'01",665/+,0/',$" ,'+/ *5<01"+*$0# #1*5& ?" %/-/5,'0 '0 0 "@6#" 01" 01"$ #/&" *''"+"##,$/5;0 ,+"#*+1,5/0/-,0/' @/0/#0?"?$'"/'./'&01,0''"-"0#,4,;4/01

$,*&< ./#$"6$"#"'0,0/' $ /'0"$65,0/' ?; 0,C/'- $"+*$#"001"0"+1'/+,5/0/"# 5,4 5/./0,0/' @// 1" "'0/$" -,.*0 ,+0# ,$" 0 ?" +,$"

*55;

#+$*0/'/#"&,'&01",66$,+1#1*5&?"?,#"&'01"

6,$,&/-. D*&/+/,5 &/#+$"0/' 41/+1 /# *'&"& '

?D"+0/%"$",#'/'-,'&'0'/'&/%/&*,56"$+"60/' @/// 1" 80,0" $ , 6*?5/+ ?&; $ ,' "'0/0; $"6$"#"'0/'-,+55"+0/%"+,*#"#1*5&?"-/%"'#." ,++"60,?5"5,0/0*&"> !#&)

-- ,#,4,$,D ,'& ,'01"$ %"$#*# 86"+/,52,'& +H*/#/0/'

/+"$

8 ; 3-

* :

;

* 9 4 -- --

- :

- '* ' -

" . : - ' G H - - -

- -

-4

: - - - 4 - - :

- "I -

- ;

* 9 4 -

- '* '

- 9 4;

* -: - '*

( =!8*

/+/"'0+,*#"/#01"+,*#" $41/+1&"

"'&,'0+*5&'0 ?" ?5,."& $ 1/# ,?#"'+" 1" .",'/'- 01" 4$& G#*

/+/"'0G/#G,&"H*,0"G$G"'*-1G</',#.*+1,#.,;?" '"+"##,$; 0 ,'#4"$ 01" 6*$6#" /'0"'&"& 1"$" $"< 01"

4$&G#*

/+/"'0G".?$,+"#'.$"01,'01,041/+16$%/&"# ,65,0/0*&"<41/+141"'01",+0&'"#*

/+"#0,++.65/#1

01"6*$6#"/'0"'&"&/'01" ,+0#,'&+/$+*.#0,'+"#"@/#0/'- /',+,#"<&*5;"@,./'"& $.01"%/"46/'0 ,$",#',?5"

#0,'&,$& ,+,*0/*#.,''01/#+'0"@0<G#*

/+/"'0+,*#"G .",'#01,001"6,$0;#1*5&'01,%",+0"&/','"-5/-"'0 .,''"$$01"$"4,#,4,'0 ?', /&"'/0#6,$0/'%/"4

01" ,+0#,'&+/$+*.#0,'+"# ,+,#"$/0+,''0?",55"-"& 01,0 01" 6,$0; 1,# G'0 ,+0"& &/5/-"'05;G $ G$".,/'"& /',+0/%"G4"%"$<01" ,+0#,'&+/$+*.#0,'+"# ",+1+,#"

.*#0,

$&#*

/+/"'0-$*'&0"',?5"01"*$0+'+"$'"& 0"@"$+/#"&/#+$"0/' $01"$",#'01,041"'"%"$01"*$0 "@"$+/#"#&/#+$"0/'</01,#0?""@"$+/#"&D*&/+/*#5;1" ,665/+,'0.*#0#,0/# ;01"*$001,01"4,#6$"%"'0"&?;,';

G#*

/+/"'0+,*#"G $.6$#"+*0/'-1/#+,#"<,'&*'5"##, #,0/# ,+0$;"@65,',0/'/# *$'/#1"&<01"*$0#1*5&'0 ,55401",665/+,0/' $+'&',0/' &"5,;1"+*$01,# 0"@,./'"41"01"$01"./#0,C"/#?', /&"$4,#."$"5;, &"%/+"0+%"$,'*50"$/$6*$6#"8""(,'/'&$,2,'&,'&

*/5&/'-$6$,0/'20&% 10',01 ,'"$D""$#< ! 8*6$"."*$0I2,5,,0,&/'% ,$,;,','<

!E 8*6$"."*$0!)I,$/.,5%3""',J 1,$0/<

/%/5))(

"+"'0 6"@ *&-."'0# ,'& ,'/?"' "%$,D 81,1 % *'/+/6,5 $6$,0/' $/1,'*.?,/<

8*6$"."*$0 ! ' $D*'8/'-1%1/'&$,9*.,$< ! 8*6$"."

*$0 !! 01/# *$0 "@65,/'"& 01" &/

"$"'+" ?"04""' , G-& +,*#"G ,'& , G#*

/+/"'0 +,*#"G ,'& ?#"$%"& 01,0 "%"$; G#*

/+/"'0 +,*#"G /# , -& +,*#" ,'& %/+" %"$#, 4"%"$< / ,'; &/

"$"'+" "@/#0# /0 +,' '5; ?" 01,0 01" $"H*/$"."'0 -&+,*#"/#+.65/"&4/01',5"##"$&"-$"" 6$ 01,0 G#*

/+/"'0+,*#"G 1""@6$"##/'G#*

/+/"'0+,*#"G#1*5&?"-/%"',5/?"$,5 /'0"$6$"0,0/'0"'#*$"01,0#*?#0,'0/,5D*#0/+"/#&'"<?*0

'5;#5'- ,#'"-5/-"'+"</',+0/'$ 5,+C ?', /&"# +,''0?"/.6*0"&001"6,$0;+'+"$'"&<41"01"$$'0 #*

/+/"'0+,*#"1,#?""' *$'/#1"&<+,'?"&"+/&"&'01"

,+0# , 6,$0/+*5,$ +,#" ,'& ' #0$,/0D,+C"0 $.*5, /# 6##/?5"3/&"(,&,'5,5%81;,.5,5<

/%/5 I ,'& ,. ,01 8, J ,. ,01 8,1* $# % ?,$&1,'8,$#<

/%/5E 0/#,#"005"&5"-,56$6#/0/'01,05,4 5/./0,0/'.,;

1,$#15;,

"+0,6,$0/+*5,$6,$0;?*0/01,#0?",665/"&4/01 ,55/0#$/-*$41"'01"#0,0*0"#6$"#+$/?"#1"*$01,#' 64"$0"@0"'&01"6"$/& 5/./0,0/''"H*/0,?5"-$*'&# $"#*50 54/'- $.,#0,0*0$;6$%/#/'/#'"%"$,'"%/5

*$01,#'64"$0/-'$"01,06$%/#/'0$"5/"%"41,0/0 +'#/&"$# , &/#0$"## $"#*50/'- $. /0# 6"$,0/'G 1"

#0,0*0$;6$%/#/'.,;+,*#"1,$&#1/6$/'+'%"'/"'+"0, 6,$0/+*5,$6,$0;?*001"*$01,#'+1/+"?*00"' $+"/0 -/%/'- *55"

"+0001"#,."1"5"-,5.,@/.G&*$,5"@#"& 5"@G41/+1.",'#G01"5,4/#1,$&?*0/0/#01"5,4G<#0,'&# ,00$,+0"&/'#*+1,#/0*,0/'01,#+'#/#0"'05;?""'1"5&01,0< G/'+'%"'/"'+"/#'0G,&"+/#/%" ,+0$0?"+'#/&"$"&41/5"

/'0"$6$"0/'-,#0,0*0" 1"80,0*0" 2/./0,0/'/# *'&"&'6*?5/+65/+;</0# ,/.?"/'-0#"+*$"6",+"/'01"+..*'/0;<0#*66$"## $,*& ,'&6"$D*$;<0H*/+C"'&/5/-"'+",'&06$"%"'066$"##/'0 #""C#0?*$;,55,+0# 01"6,#041/+11,%"'0?""',-/0,0"& *'"@65,/',?5; ,'& 1,%" $. 5,6#" 0/." ?"+." #0,5"

++$&/'-0,5#?*$;7#2,4# '-5,'&<35

<6 ( G 5/+; 2/./0,0/' +0# 1" +*$0# 1,%"

"@6$"##"&,05",#001$""&/

"$/'-$",#'##*66$0/'-01"

"@/#0"'+" #0,0*0"# 5/./0,0/'#',."5;<01,05'- &$.,'0+5,/.#1,%".$" +$*"50;01,'D*#0/+"/'

01".< 01,0,&"

"'&,'0./-101,%"5#001""%/&"'+"

0&/#6$%",#0,5"+5,/.<,'&01,06"$#'#4/01-&

+,*#"# ,+0/'##1*5&6*$#*"01".4/01$",#',?5"

&/5/-"'+"G

'*'5/./0"&5/./0,0/'4*5&5",&0,#"'#" /'#"+*$/0;

,'& *'+"$0,/'0;< ,'& 01"$"

$"< 5/./0,0/' 6$"%"'0# &/#0*$?,'+"$&"6$/%,0/' 41,0.,;1,%"?""',+H*/$"&/'

"H*/0;,'&D*#0/+"?;5'-"'D;."'0$41,0.,;1,%"?""' 5#0?;,6,$0;7#4'/',+0/'<'"-5/-"'+"7$5,+1"# 8""(6,0,'&90"+1,$6"$0;%80,0" ,'C '&/,80,

##'<

) /%/5 (

)E8) ,D"'&,$ 8/'-1$#%8,'0,8/'-1$#< !E8*6$"."*$0

)E,'&*'&5/C ,5,.,0/5%@"+*0/%"'-/'""$< ,5-,'

"&/*.$D"+0<

',.,+1,'&$,,%80,0" 9,$',0,C,<

$/./',5))<01/#*$01"5&01,0D*&/+/,55;"'-$, 0/'- 6$/'+/65"# 5/./0,0/',.*'0#05"-/#5,0/'-,'&4*5& 5;/'

01" ,+" 5,45,/&&4'?;01"'#0/0*0/' "'+1/'

'0*5,;%8,;,C<!!

$/./',5 > !#&)

- - - '- * J J

* - :

- -

- - - :

- !! 6

!$#8$#$$

6 ' $/!$$#$$ "

-- ; <--&

(%)

<-- <--

6 --

;

- - <-- 5 -

-- !$

4 -

- :

4 <--

<--

- 4 -

-4

<--

( (--

!1 : 4

' - - - -- - - :- - - * - - -

- :

* -

!$#8$#$$

6 ' <-- !"!!$#$$ ' $/!$$#$$ :

!"!!$#$$

- * +,

- - 0%/ -

- !% :- - - -

- -* 1# - -

- !" :

-- - - +,

!0 :

- &)

--- 39 :

2 $'*'+"&' ! )

) < 4

5 K 5 < - K 5