High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/1864/2021allowed

Amrik Singh v. Joginder Singh And Others

2021-09-09Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

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

G56&9$1."$02&$3&0404.5&"$'5*$.5$'$3&"G6'9$ .1$02&$3&0404.5$149&*$8&1."&$0246$K.G"0,$I$'H$.1$02&$+4&;$02'0$450&"&60$.1$(G604/&$ ;.G9*$8&$H&0$41$6G8(&/0$0.$/&"0'45$/.606,$.5&$H."&$.33."0G540J$46$:"'50&*$0.$ 149&$02&$;"400&5$60'0&H&50#$L45/&$02&$5.5[14945:$02&"&.1$*.&6$5.0$6&&H$0.$$8&$ *&948&"'0&$ '6$ 46$ 8."5&$ .G0$ 1".H$ 02&$ &'"94&"$ ".G5*$ .1$ 9404:'04.5,$ ;2&"&$ 02&$ 3&0404.5&"$2'*$'9"&'*J$149&*$246$;"400&5$60'0&H&50$0.$02&$/9'4H$3&0404.5$'5*$.5$ H&"406,$8".'*9J$02&$/.50&506$.1$02&$/9'4H$3&0404.5$"&H'45$02&$6'H&$&+&5$45$02&$ 6&/.5*$".G5*#$$$ $ I5$02&$3"&H46&,$1"&62$;"400&5$60'0&H&50$*.&6$5.0$"&UG4"&$HG/2$.1$ &11."0$ .02&"$ 02'5$ "&64:545:$ .1$ 02&$ 6'H&$ 8J$ 02&$ 3&0404.5&"#$ I5$ 02&$ 3&/G94'"$ 3"&H46&,$02&$4H3G:5&*$."*&"$46$6&0$'64*&$;402$948&"0J$0.$02&$3&0404.5&"$0.$149&$ 246$;"400&5$60'0&H&50$.5$."$8&1."&$02&$*'0&$14]&*$8&1."

&$02&$0"4'9$K.G"0#$$I5$ /'6&,$5&&*1G9$46$5.0$*.5&,$5.$1G"02&"$.33."

72&$;"40$3&0404.5$46$'99.;&*$$6G8(&/0$0.$/.606,$;24/2$'"&$'66&66&*$ '0$Q6#DC,CCC^[#$$RJ$;'J$.1$4H3.6404.5$.1$/.606,$3&0404.5&"$62'99$39'50$>_$0"&&6$ .1$ *&/4*G.G6$ '5*$ 3&"&554'9$ 45$ 5'0G"&,$ .1$ '5J$ +'"4&0J$ +4`#$ %&&H,$ -H9',$ \G9H.2'"$ '5*^."$ -960.54',$ 45$ 02&$ +4/4540J$ .1$ 246$ "&64*&5/&$ ;2&"&$ 2&$ 46$ "&64*45:#$ N9'50'04.5$ 62'99$ 8&$ /'""4&*$ .G0$ G5*&"$ 02&$ 6G3&"+464.5$ .1$ 02&$ /.5/&"5&*$a460"4/0$W."04/G90G"&$=114/&",$;2.$62'99$:4+&$'$9&00&"$.1$3"..1$0.$ 02&$!-K7$.1$2'+45:$/'""4&*$.G0$02&$39'50'04.5$.1$02&$0"&&6$'6$3&"$02&$."*&"6$ .1$0246$K.G"0#$ K.G"0$8&9.;$0.$&56G"&$/.H394'5/&$02&"&.1#$I5$/'6&,$02&$3&0404.5&"$ *&1'G906$ 45$ *.45:$ 6.,$ 948&"0J$ 46$ :"'50&*$ 0.$ 02&$ Q&:460"J$ 0.$ 39'/&$ 02&$ H'00&"$ 8&1."&$ 0246$ K.G"0$ 0.$ "&3."0$ 5.5[/.H394'5/&#$ N"..1$ .1$ 39'50'04.5$ 8&$ '96.$ 1G"5462&*$ 8J$ 02&$ 3&0404.

5&"$ 45$ 02&$ Q&:460"J$ .1$ 0246$ K.G"0,$ '9.5:$ ;402$ 6G33."045:$9&00&"$1".H$2."04/G90G"&$*&3'"0H&50,$0.$8&$39'/&*$8&1."&$0246$K.G"0$ G3.5$"&/&430$02&"&.1#$ $ +R;+R;*+*!# # # # # # C.%:1#S61T.P# !"#$"#"$ $ $ $ $ $ $ U:2T3# # b2&02&"$63&'E45:^"&'6.5&*c$ $ )&6^%.$ b2&02&"$"&3."0'89&c$ $ $ )&6^%.