High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/21882/2013dismissed

Rajinder Singh And Others v. Guru Nanak Dev University

2017-05-03Mr. Justice Harsimran Singh Sethi13 pages

!"#$%%" " &"' ('"')*+*" , - . !"#$%%" " &"' ('"')*+*" ,

" " /#%"/ 0*

"%,"1%% "0/"'2 0*

"%",1%%

3 %//""

%'",",, % 1*244", 25%,"%" 4%"4")$ 6'"7$"4%('"')*+*"

0/""

")$ ,"/%, 07$"

24%%," "%, 07$"4%%1/* ,""%// %"'2%'21 22',,"%'/ '2 4%" - . ) 8'% %

*"/'*$,,2 22',4, 0 7$"%"'$%"""'/ 91"

% "%%,"/1,, 6'"7$"4%('"')*+*"

0/""5%""

, 6'"7$"%",+*"

' 4%%" *27$" 72"27$"5%:%$%", "/ 6'"7$"4'21%, 07$"922 %" ";, 07$"%" "%:%$%","/ 4'21%, 7:'*7$"

4%%1 22',1

,"/ "/%07$"#%"4" '2 "/ %+*" ","/ $"%7$"$,"/

'24" "/ < 22"/ '2 "7:'* 7$"07$"0,"% '2 ,"/ %, 07$"*2 '12=2% $ 72"2 4"1.

>1 ,"/ "//$6'"7$"%"'$% #"$ // % 1 " ?'/?/" .

> 1

,"/ %"'$% 2 "/ /$ % 6'" 7$" 1

25%2$12 8'2 244%,"4 "8'"%* ":,"422,2/*2@72"2 7$"$%%*$097$""8'" ":," %%*$3%2"$"*2@72"27$"$4""8'" %* < " :," 6'" 7$" 0 "% '2 4"

"/ 1 2".

%",+*" ' #2?'/?#"$ // " "$ "

,"/ % , 0 7$" 1' " / " %

%'2/$),27*'22

4 '2/1

"/1 4%%4"" ","/42'1 /$% '2 "/% " ,"%4/ '2.

>, 07$"4"1 221 ,"/%"'$%#"$ //%1 " ?'/?/" 6'"$".

> 4 " ""'/ 1 *"/ "/ % , /") 0$$"*$2 ,"/?"'"% '/ '2 %4",%1 2

" / #%"/ 2"'2,,"$1%2

%," %%,""2$12 ","/ %, 07$" ,"%'/ '2 9 % % * " % " #"$ // 4 ' " % % ," "

,"/ %4*"

%#"$///9 % '2 4%%4"'18'2 /1 %+*" /$%2

4'21,,212% ,"

*%",""%// %" " % *'$%1 22',1 %'/ '2 4%% ,"* ","/%, 07$"1 .

> "/ 6'"7$"%1 /".

> "/6'"7$" %1 " ; "0/"'2 2"'2,,"$ "%'*"

%%"% "$'%%,"4'212,"/ %1 %///% '2,,"*1 % # /$%2

4%"1 %:$ '2

;

4"/ ,"* ","/ %, 0 7$"1 4 .

>/$6'"7$"%"'$%#"$ //%1 " ?'/?/"%".

>1 22 ',1 """'/%"'$%*"/9%% //4%22$%'"-. .1 % ," !"#$% 4%%4/ ; . . . 9 %* %" % '2 " % ," 4% %"

%*$%"'$%%24"2', < 5%2 8'%" ""1 %'"

4%%"%," 4%"6'"7$"4")$4%% +*" 2$ 4'2 1 2 " ,"/ % ,

07$"'"% '2%%1 "/'2% "

%4%*" "4'2% 1 22'"%4 '24%%/: "',,"*21 %# A "#%"/%"2',!'$/""%

! " # $%&'()%*+, -.'4%"%0,:'"4B /2"' %%*4%%",""%//

%*1

22','"% '2 9 # $$ '," % =$%'" 022%1 C')43% %2%%",4" 1" ","/%, 0""D" #% %8'"%"8' " :," ","/ '" % 2 '2 '2 . < % + D" # C1""

5%2

"#"* '2 - 4"/4 -- 0,"%4// 22, 0""

4" 1 22 ', 1 " ""'/ 5% ", 4% % 8'"%"

:,"4"2$12 ","/% , % %22$ 2 %" ,"/ % $"' % //%"'21"",*4")%,"!'

/,2 4%42$12,""%/ "/ % // '2 -- 5%0,:'"%2%%", 4"2$122,"/ "%, #

" "/ '2 -- %":,"'2%*1$"% , %/%1 "%'18' , 0""%1 %4 '2 -- 4%%'2 1/

* "%*4%%" "%//94 %2'"

" & '

( ) * + ) *

%,% %%

! ! "

( #$ -%%,.

%,/ 0 %,/ %,/

( 1.2 #$

3 #$

" 4 %,/

56 7 7

1%%

! + 8

(

& %% #

#$ %,/

! & ' %%

%%4

%%"% "'2"2',!'$/"" # / # ! " "0# %&'.)(*$0 '1. #20 # ! " # / # )%&&1*'3 %4 / #+" ! " #5 #0 6 57 8%&'.)%*'(' /8! " "7

9 '4.()"+2 "*%%'-:+5,,90 ! " / )%&''*-"+2 " .%;

%%**"$%

","/"'24%%","*2/4%" ),2 ","/4%%4'21,,212 - 9%2 "'2$ #5 #0 6 57 8 $ '," %0,:'"4B /"4%"%# 5",'" 4"' /$#%'29& %5",'"*2#"* '2 -< 1 2'$"%", ",E("',0F E("',3F,",2%

4 "4"5",'"'12 #"*// 5%//,%,",2

*//'<?-? ;? ?

,'"'

'2 % '2 #2//4' ""$ 2$12

"%2$ ",E("',0FE("',3F #%'29& % '2 ",,/%, 5",'"*2 #"*("99$,"/28';? ?

-? ? 4 ,'12% % (B /$ % '2 2'$2,("',0("',3 #%'29&% '2 4%% 4 "/ 4% % ,",2 , 1 % //5%," %# 5",'""2 $',%

/ '2%"1 :,$% ",4//2

%22$94'1/%%2'$%1$*" ,"?//''%"1'%# % 2 % $" 4%% 4" / #%'29&% '2% :1 "%//94 "$'%2*%*1 22'"%2 '294%2 '"

: 0 $ & ;"* '

;"* 0

'6*

0 $ " " ' ;" * 0 "

) * *

(

/<.<%%% %,= " /<.<%%% 0 * 9%,=:=#**1,>

* %,= (

?0 1

1-<.<

- %%% 0)*

* 0)* *

!""# !$%#&' !""#$$ ("

)

>9 :9:9: &

# #

%/-0

# 0

# 0"

)

%/-#!

(

1 # ( 0

# 0 !

(

/ ! ! 0

/<.<%%%

& " 4

( 0

0 !

(

9%% %"4""* '2 " "

,"/%, 6'"7$"@07$"@7:'* 7$"%7$"$,"/ %+*" ,"" 5% '22 /

"%"2'. < 4 ,$"$,,"*2% '222G"/ '2 "7:'* 7$"07$"H4%%$*%8'2 /

,"/%, 07$"4%%41%"

1 ,"/ "/6'"7$"%1 " ?'/?

/","/%1 21 %#"$// 0/$4%'24%%4'2/2 ""5%" "

///1$1 4%%4%.

>,,/ %, 07$"4'211 4 """'/ 5%4%/'% #5 #06 57 8 ',"4%"%22$4/%/ '2:,$% B "1 2'$"%"("',0("',3, % " " =" // % 1 / % '2

"/'2 2' ," "/ % , /") 1 " ",,/%, 07$"422

22%, 07$"1 4 ,"/422 5% ," %" %* $"* 9 % ,""$* %/,2 " 22',%*0/2

%"4" "* '2,"" ,"/4"/'"% #"* '24%%/

.< 7*%'$%#2 //4'/.

"% % ," ","/ %/$ 4*"%24 1 %//'1 %&%22""*4%

'2"$"$2 ","/ 6'"7$" 07$"1"$,"4% '2 %'!1(*"/ 4 % // ' % ; , *212 " 0 7$" "1 22',1 " "'/ %%"1

4 " ?'/?/"1 "//$6'"7$"5%" %$*212%""" "/% '2*212 %%"4" *4%%%1 22', "2 "/% '2 2 /

4" ', 9 !'$/ "" # / # ! " "0# '," %1%2E

4 5% !'$/ "" ! "

# $ '," "2 ', 1 % '2 " % ,"

) % !'$/ "" % :+5 ,,90 ! " / )%&''* -"+2 " .%;

4%"4%2%%""'2

'*"2"12',,2%*"1 22',*"12

24:$%4%*"94 '"%"%2%% '24%%","*2%/4%"),2 "

,"/ 4'21,,212 "*"

%,"%"%*1,' $"

*$ ,"!'"%/%*1,"/"%*% '/ '2 1,,2 ,"%,"/

5%" " 1 "2 $',%" %!'$/ 1* %2 % %," % "$% 1 " "

,"/%, 07$"%1 %'/ '2 ; 8'2

%4","/ 8(%&'. )

* %%",)$@" I