High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14149/2017allowed

Rajbir Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2020-10-07Mr. Justice Sanjay Kumar18 pages

!"#!$%&%"'( $ ")!* +,

-)%*.%'/+ 0000000

1 +!. !"#*2''3" +!*& 0000 .

( 45

0 ..6

!" # $%&'

(

) # *

+,( # -

.'-2678*,0 (

,, , / . 0"

$1 2$ %2$-

0 3 4 , ,, 4 56 7 $1'57 $88&5 9 $88&97

6 ,) 22& $868 ( : 0

4 ;

* (, , %8 2$ %2$- 6

% ,) ( : 0

, , "

< = 0

( 0

(, >4 28 2% %2$- "

< = 0

: 0

, ( , (

< = 0

$$ 2% %2$- 0)", = 9 6 ( ?# %$ %2$- ( " 3,,

2& %2$-

,) ( : 0

$2 %2$-

) = = %6 $2 %2$- = , " 3,,

(?"

= 0 > =

* = =%6 $2 %2$-( " 3,, ( # &6%2$- '$5'7 $88&( 3

", ", , 3;?%&6'-?%2$-(

3 .

2$ $% %2$- 9 , () ( , $'

2% %2$1 ( " 3,, ,

( ,

3;?&6%1?%2$1(

3 .

$2 %2$1 ( ) (

(

,, @( (?"

= 0 , (,

%2$1 " 3,, .

7 ,: 0

>4 ? *2 %2$1 '$5*757 $88&

,@ ()

, (,

$$ 2& %2$1 %2 2& %2$1

, (( >4 =

, , , ?@,

, "

< = 0

(@, ? ,

3( 3;?112%?%2$1 >4 $'

%2$1 ?# *2 %2$1 $6 2& %2$1 " 3,, (, ( ? # *2 %2$1 ( , ,( )(

,( , * ) " 3,, $6 2& %2$1%2 2& %2$1%$ 2& %2$1%& 2& %2$1

(

A ,

,A , ( @,

, ;

: 0

(, 6

" 3,, (?"

= 0 ( $6 $$ %2$- ) $% %2$- ) ,

, (

3 21 $% %2$- .

(?"

= ,2% 2$ %2$1 ( (

, %* $% %2$- ,

@ @$- 2$ %2$1( ,$'

2$ %2$1

, ( B 3,, 7 $- 2$ %2$1 2% 2% %2$1,) ( , 2% 2% %2$1

" 3,, (?"

= 0

< 0

, 96

( B , ;

( , $2 2& $866

" 3,, B> # '$2- %2$- 0 &%2&--&-1&-6 &1$&1%$%2?0>3 96

- " 3,,

(, ( (?"

= 0 ,C , ( 6 " 3,, @ '$5*757 $88& , , %& 2& %2$1 $6 2& %2$1(

3 3;?112%?%2$1 , " 3,, 9%& 2& %2$1

, # &2 %2$1 '$5'7 $88& ( 3,, ?,?

, ", ", ,

( $'

2- %2$1 , $'

2- %2$1

( (?"

= 0

" 3,, , 9 %2 2& %2$1 ( (?"

) ,( ( ?@,

,) 9 @ ( ,9

(

3 ) " 3,, , (

(

,( .

$6 2$ %2$- , ( ) ,

( .

, ,$1 ,

6 0

B $$ 2% %2$- "

< = 0

() ,( , ? ( "

< = 0

? 9 "

< = $868 ,"

< = $881 ( ,

, , , , >4 $'

%2$1 ?# *2 %2$1 " 3,, 9 , %& 2& %2$1 9 $'

2- %2$1 (

0 ,2& %2$1

3 0)", = 0"

%6 2- %2$1 ,

, 2'

%2$1 , ()

3, @

, @ ( @ %6 %2$1 = - ? @ , .

@ ,( , ,

, ,

, ;

( - ? )

3 , 96 ,)

>@ @ %%- 3

3 ( ?,) ?,) , , ( '$ $88&

'$5*7 "

" 3,, , , , ( , ()

, ()

,( ,

,, 57 57 3 57 ) 4 , $1' $88&

> , ( " 3,, , ( , ( , ( , , ( , (,

( ) 4 , ( B0

3 -/*.%'/+9&0. !"# 7'-)'3" +!*& : 7'-);< $2% ( , $8'%

'$ $88&

$2 , C B0 (, ,,

(5$7 57,( 4 5%7 , , ( 57,(,)

,5*7 ,( ,

, B0 (, ,,4 , ( (

( 4 , ,( "

3 '$ $88& / * .%'/+9&0. !"#*2''3'" +!*: 00 0%9%= ><

0 ? @ 9 ( 9 '$5*7 (

,( C

, ,( , , ( 0 ( , (

, ?

( "

3 ?*%5=,.*@'$+,*8 '$+2 ,*&'

6=', %& *%$ ."'!@ 9&0 +! %''$%= "88%&&%"'!* '3

*%'$%@= .!$*! *2 " "9!*'8!' , *2' !9!="@8!' '3

'$+2 &!@* 8!' ,+'3%/*+:;;

00 0%9%= >A<

0 ? @ )

@ ( ( >, ( '$5*7 $88& 4 9 ( 9(

? .

,( > " 3,,

( (?"

= 0 .

( 4 (

B ( , ,, 4 ,( >

) , (

()

?@,

, (

, , ;

- ?

$% . (, ,,4 ,( ? >4 $'

%2$1 (?

= 0@,

, *

( >4 = 28 2$ %2$1

, (

28 2$ %2$1 , 9, ( .

" 3,, (

@ 4, (?

= (

) * ?, 2$ %2$1 , * ?, , ( (?"

= 0

,(28 2$ %2$1 >

, ?@,

+= , "

", = @, 28 2$ %2$1

, ( *?

, (,

2% %2$-

@, (

()

$* ?@,

, (, (

@, $- 2$ %2$1 , !

(

() 0 ,

()

( B , ,( (?"

= 2% 2% %2$1 = ( (?"

= ( , @ ( ,, #( (?"

?@, @,

(?"

= ( 0

( "

< = 0

( , ) (

@, , ( ( $6 2$ %2$-( , > , >4 $'

%2$1 " 3,, 9%& 2& %2$1 >4

$& ,

, ( ) (

6 ,) >, ( *2 2- %2$- "

< = 0

$86-%2$' (

4 , 9

(

$$ 2& %2$1 %2 2& %2$1 (, ? # *2 %2$1 ,, " 3,,

, " 3,, ) .

( ,

( ,, ,) 9@ 9 .,,

3 9 9

, (

3$6 2& %2$1

3;?112%?%2$1 =

" 3,, 9 ?# *2 %2$1

9,( , ,9( )

3 " 3,,

4 , .

( (?"

= " 3,, ? 96 ,) (

( ;

(, ( ( (?"

= 0 , ,,4 , ( " 3,, (

>( ,, ( " 3,, (,

,( (?"

= 0

( (

) .+8&+!*9&0 *%'$%@=.!$*! *2 ""9!*'8!' "#*2''3 " +!*&:B ;

00 0%9%= ><

, : 4 ( (

$- , ( B0 -/*.%'/+57

( (, ,, '3+%*.%'/+9&0. !"# *2':B 00 0%9%= >AA< * ?, , C

= ( , ,( ? ,

>, '$5*7

(

, , > , ( >4

, , ( " 3,,

(

) ,

, , (

$1 %6 $2 %2$-) ( ( $2 %2$1 (

3 3;?&6%1?%2$1

( * ?, + ?&%*?

%2$1 ( "

0 ( , + %'

2& %2$1 , $2 %2$1 3;?&6%1?%2$1 9 () ( >4 $'

%2$1 , , " 3,,

) , , (

, ?@, (

(

" 3,, ) ( '$5*7 $88&

3 , , (, @ , ( " 3,, , @ ,

@ ((

, ,

$6 ( )(

, (( 0)", = 0(

, ;

- ? +,(

> , (

=(21 %2%2 5 ,7 : ;

) C !C# ;

( !C#