High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17725/2016dismissed

Bhogi Ram v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And ANR

2016-09-02Mr. Justice Darshan Singh11 pages

!"#"$% &

'%()'*+

!

"

+, #

% & ' !

( & "

!

)& #**+'

,#**+& -) ! " . "& / & 0/

$ ""

&

&!1" 2""!

3 0

5

6 &0& !!&0!

!& 447.44+ " ""!

!!&8

2!

9*49#:/&& ""!&0/

5 &0& 0 0

0/" & ""!&0

!&

""

& ""!& % &

0 0 ! "& "

!

0& ""!&

! !/! "

6!& & "&&

5 &0&64*49#;!

& & & 6 '65)"&

0 0

! 0!&& <& " !

" !

!!

0! 0 ! " ( &0

"& &0 &&0

""&

! #4 49#; & & 6 '6 5) &

<& "

" "

$1 !

0"

"& /. &

"

( !!&&

649499*

0 ! " .0&&0!

&&&81 &

& &

& & & "

!

!

! &!&

649499*

0 <& $0 " "!

0 " !"

=

0!!&

&44 49#; !

& >" &

!

'

&)& #*>+',#*>+& -) 0 & #4'4)" #**+& 0! ! !

""&!

" && &

&& &3 ! !/

< 0""

- 0! 0"

& :" #*>+& 0 / "

!

0 0 "<

&&

& 0 !!&"

6 "&&0 0/ ! !/0""& :

?

5

6 &0&

0 !"! !

"&8111""!&"

" !&

!

0 0 "

" ""!&"

5 1 & !

&6 '65)& 0!

0

! ! " 49#: !& "

"

0 @ &&@ 0 ""

& 4749#;

6

0

" &

2!

9*49#: /

& "! & 0 "0&&0!

"

!" ! " ! & / 0 &&0 ! "

&" " !! " &!&

& /

6!&2""!

0 & " &&0!

& A 0 0

3&& ;

!

0

!

& >0"&&0 0! !

&

&

. 3 & 5

6 &0&! & " & & "0 &" !

"

0 ! & ""

0 6&9#49#; ! <

0"&!

/& 0" &

& :" #*>+& 0 & #4'4)" #**+&

"& >" #*>+&

!

!!&8

2!

9*49#:"

<"

! !" &

6&9#49#; "

&!

& " 1 0& "!

" " ! " 3 & & & 0 !

/

0"

!/

1 !!&

2!

9*49#:

0 "5 6 " && B +

$ ! & ! & "

!

5

6 &0& 0

! ! "

& """

6!& 0 ! #**+&

!& 0 & & !

1 " ! " &8111 &

' & .& /)"6!&

"

" 5

6 &0&

0 !/ & "

!

&

"

&0"&&& & "

@ "

!& #:

#7#*4#" "1 1 !&

&

&0"& ""

!

!

!"&0"& 1 "&&0 & ! &

!

" 0

&

&

" "&&0 &0"&

&!

&!

& #7" !" !"

C&

'#*>#)# +44! &

0! !& "" 1 &&&0 1 / 0& " &0

0! !&&!

&& /"

! &0 &

&"&&0 !! 0! !& &

"

& & "

& " &&0 !& #:! " 0

!

"!&"! ! 0 0 !&

" ! 0& ! 0

!&"! / ""

"&"&& 0! &')

!&"! "

&&& ""

0!

" & "

" D') ""

& & !

& & < ! !

>

0" " %

"$ &E

'#*+:): =

& 0 "

!& #:

!& &!

F "

& ! & 3& 0

D & & "&0 &!0&

0 !!

"&

! A !

&! 3& !! & !& &! &&0 " & " !& #:" ""

& &! & && " !& #7

!& #:#7 /

!

" 3& "

&0 /

/( G"1'#*+>)# 4:>

*

3

" " D 5

1

& "1'#*+*)= :>* !!

" & 8

&!

& 0!

0& "!"

! " & 8 &&

" " !&.E

2!

9* 49#: 0! 0 !&!! ?

! &!

& < !

! 0 & & !/ "!&

<

& "

"

0 " !!

!

""

0/ #9

&

& " !& #>

!"#$%$& #!%$#%&#$"'#"

()* +,- $"$.&$ /- * 0 /123-4$!5$6 "57$!5$* 4&67! (*1

3891:

, 1* ;0< ##

"3 & & 0

0

0 0 "!

"3 !

2!

9*49#:

0! 5

6 ! " &

"

& &

"

5 $0 !

A ! < 2""!

5

6

0& &

" !& ! &

" " "&& ! / 0 !!&8 "! /

& ! &

! 0/ $ & !0 % & &0 & && & 0 ! 0! &!&!

0& "

"! !

2 /0 !&" BA " !!

0 BA &

!!&B &0

0

&" B$0& & &

H &0 ! &&0 &&!/ 0

" &!/ !&

/ !& & "& !& 1" ?

? 5 6 ! !&" & "" 0!

& !!

%! ! 0 && 0

0 " "

!&" ""

&&

" ! 0! ! &"

!&& 1"

8!" "

!

!

" "

! ! 0! ! !& / !

&

!&& " 5 6 0 !

"&& & "

&

"

& &

/ "

!

( ! &

< ! !

00 &&

#4

0& & ! & &/ ,

389 (*! "& !

&0& & !

0! 3 !

1"!

!

" & "

&0

" 0 ! !&" 0

" 0 "" &

!&"! 6!& & <

0 & &! &0 6!&2""!

! & " ""

#=

&& & !!&" ?

5

&

6 ! & &" " & & /&8111 !

0/

5

0 !& " 1"

"!&&!

0" &&0!

"0

0& ! & ""

1 &&!

" !& " %

!&& !

& &0"&! " !

" "

& & !&

!"5

6

0 " ! ! !/ &0&

0 &6 '65)0!& !& !

5 6

!& 4=4" "1 $!&!

!& " / ""

/

"& && & ! !!&

2!

9*49#:!&& !!

&& &

@ !& #:#74#" "1

3&& !& 3&

&

&"

&

!!&8 & <!

&

!

#:

+ " 2

! "0

"!

!& & !&"! 0! & 0&

( 0/" """

"!

! 1

"!&

5 6 0 & " ! !

0 " !

& 0 !

0 !

"

I !!! & &! &

#;

1"&

& A E :+>+"49## & = )3: 0 00 ! E 9449#40! " &

D ! & &

1 !

1" 0!&& " & "0 " /

"

&

& " !

& #7

"

0&& !!

< "& & !!& & 0 ! ! 49999.8" / @&&

" &0 !

!! "

& &

!

"!&! !& "

#+

!& "! " ! ! 0! !, 5 -0! 1

0& &/ ! "

! "

" ! !""&

!& " " & &!

"

0+1

&

A

/. J A

&

J