← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/5432/2011dismissed

Parminder Singh And ORS. v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2015-10-01Mr. Justice Darshan Singh16 pages

 

       

 !"!#$$% &'

(")*+ ,$ $# !#$

 

 

 + -+.+

      

+/ ) + &,  01&

 2 -  

+ ,     

              !  "     

 "

#  $%  &' (     

    

 "

)* + *,  -  

     

 "

$. -

    

 -        

  / "

)*,),  *'), 33333 )     (

   1 *       

   

    3 1

-  4

  *''4 5  "

)'

 *''%6 5

 7  86  

       , 9 

  *''%     !

          *&

:  *''%   %,           (  ).$&      )%#) 5/  "

, )%#)6                 

    $;)<        

      &;<         

    -  

 

 =       

         0  

            0                                -     

  0     

 

       ).;)<  ;*<     

 > ?

5$6

;)<  !

        @           3  !        

 A    

   ;*<     ?  ;)<         9   B 

 B   9      / ( 

   /   0  8

  -       %'

  0



    0           

         

  0                    0  

 0

  0       )%   ).#'   *     )%#)   

    

 0  0   2    !

   =   ).%,     /   5C 6     

    3 

 /   /2 "

44*  ).%,E - )7.8(( )9+ 92(" .

:(;

( )9+<  *.   ).%,    !



         

   =       

    

  0    

- 

  !

 -   

   =    0  2  0  3           0   (  )*$  (  F  == 

  !

    *,G

     =               -       0      /   5C 6   0

     C  0  

  0   

   

       .$.     )$'       

  =      C  5 /  6   *,G     

%,       

    

     )$'  0        0  

          ,).  

     )%'    

   C   $$. )$'

     

      *'.            

            /   5C 6 = ).%$    $4,  /   5C 6 

              

                 H                    0   

       !

   =     *,G      =       

      /   5C 6 

    =     H         

 

        I             3                      

   *% ).%,                & ).4.     C      /   

   =       

         H        A                   B "

%).)  ).%,    

  3      /  0           A

         *''4              ( 

 ).$&        0  !

 

  &       "

 C,.D)'D*''%D &D*''.

 )& 3 *''.      0       

 > ?

7!

   3     : ;

?===  < C(3I(  )& 3 *''.



6=

$#=!##>=2 =!##6?=   

    ;<   &  *''4 ;  "

)'

 *''%<   

  

         !

   

     

     

  > ?

< 3   E <    E < =  E  < 0  

  (0    !

   3     :8 =               

      

        0  A       C   0              =        !

    &)*        /   2  2 

  

      C   

    

    (

  =    *'',                 !



    

   -      





    

 

         

     

 /      0  /  ))     -   /    )&,      =  )$*            

       

    

    /  

     

  0    /2 "

#',.

 )..'  

                        ?

-

   

 

 :  B !  :  ?

-

       =          0   -    0 

         

              0           )% ).#'

     !

     =  !     5  

  H  

 

3  !    6       !



          A   

     *     )%#)            -     0      

        ( C /  C D/  0     C D   0   ( D0  2 -

9       -       /   

    52 6       

  

   = =  =  

   0  /  

               

A?    

    H      C   0   

   =   

   C        !?=== !?==  !?= 0             E            

E -      H   

 A           

             

 !?===  H 

  H         

@ J      0      H 

  

-                   0  /       

     H  C  ?K? 0        0         

     H           H     -          0             C  =   

        

       

       

 C  

0      

      /     !

   : *# )..'               C   0      

 0  H      0  C   0  

       

              0  /            

   C   0          (

                0

      "

 ) ).,#   $) ).%,             C   0   /                                

      

            0  0     H      

     0  /                   /          : ), )..'

  A

   

  4     )%#)    

      ))  (  ).$&   > ?

7    

   0    9    2    2           IA /  2

       

                  A        > ?

 A   7  8     3      3  9           =   ( 0 /8  /     

   

   

   0    

       

                

    

 

     

     H     

          :B!  :  

  : *) )..* A

  

    

      

    

  

-  3

   3 

   50  6  /    0 

        0         /  (

         )%   ).#'      !

            C   0     (

          2  =   0

 0 

    0    

  C   0       

    2  0         0  

             -   A 

 -     

      

      3     A   

         /   /2 "

#',.

 )..' 5 6            

  0

           /   /2 "

4%'4  )..%     / 

 

               =   5C  6  =   50 6    

   

 -  3    -     -

     

 =    

 

  

           -  3  52 6

       -  -     

 =   0     $' :  *'), =        -    C  .

:  *''&    "

)$*'

 ( F ?==

    /    0   3/    ?)  



 

             C  

  3   /  0      /    0  2  

                   )4)  ).4* 0     

             L===L   > ?

7'

11    21    2   2     

 

 H   > ?

('

).*( (@.("*( +,?

;?=< 9  /  ?C ?  

    > I        ;?==<  /   0 ?   

   I      +  E  =0= ;=0=   H       0 <        

 H              -  ?=   ;<             

    0  C <   )     ;   =!  C "

)D%$<            ).*     (  F ?==8        

  

    2("(A( (( )9+ 7(+982 B9( ) ( 9* 4;*')'< )$ // $'#      /        -            

           

            0  /       H       /   5C 6  /   50 6         I  

     /        

       

      

 0                



    L        /2 "

&.)$  *')'  /2 "

).%,&  *')'    

    

  0  H    

             0        

  B L9L  L!L     

 =     -  3  

 =            

  =      =    /    /                   )*) ;&<  (

  ).$& 

   =           

         ?=     ?=                      /    /                     I          /    

   5 6    

      /  

 0

       



        0        ?   =   0

 0         ?       

  

 

                           

              -

 

 H  H            )& /   0    

      

              

  3 

        

 ?         

      A    A   

           =     3 

   52 6   =     

      

             -            

       

         

 

       /           )    *'))                       

    

                 

  0       )& 3 *''.          0  

                   

   0 0  

          !

            

          )& 3 *''.           

   0            

             3      =    0  +

  "  

     

  

  

    ))  ?) / ?) (  ).$&           3  C @          

     7  8  =  > ?

7$ $  +.

9   

   $    ;F  )%#)<       7!   38   ?

;<      3 ;<  (    3  -

 

     



      *   5    

   0   

  9    2    2  -         IA /  2                        

? 0  A   7  8    3      3  9        

   =   ( 0 /68

    

        0 

               

  

          -        5(6           %,     *''4  

L                !   

          

  A       *.

 *''%   A (?#D)'   $'$  $'4

?

-      

            

     

 0   0  CL /       - 

       

  > ?

77

 ) *88.

*(   B  ( )  +  +.;  *()+,?

 0       C /  0  / 0  !

  



        

    

  0  H                 D         

 

   ? 

          *

8 *A()/);A*88.

*(

 B)(,? /  M===     (  ).$&   

            ? LL L L L/L L3L LIL + L9L  

      -

            

        

   0   0  

   

  -     H         0 

         

  

          3  / ?

    2  ;3/2<   !

 " 3  0      

     /  M===     (  ).$& %'

          2 2 , )     0  2  !?=== ;C D0 < !?== ;C D0 < !?= ;C D0 <

      H   

/  =

/   J



/           (  ).$&  

 *

 

   H   

 ! /             

    A?

  A    B  /  $ 0    ;     <              ).#' 0        

H 

   0  2 

 !     

         

             

   

        0 

       - 

    

   ?

       H H     0         

   

 !         8   ?    0  D/                            

    0            CL /                                  =   L                       



  0                      

        

 0      

      

      % -  '

  *;$4!#$