← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/3642/2024dismissed

Rajni Jain And Others v. Pritam Chauhan And Others

2026-03-18Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal13 pages



   

!"#$%%  "#"&#'

!"#$()%% 





    

 $  *+ % ,-.

 /+ 

   



    !" 

!

 





# $ 000 -.

 /+1% %

 

 

 



&&' 

     ("



$)*+&*&, -.

    " /  01    !

"  "

-.

 

2

 # $ ) /



323

2525"#

*0

4

(("

$$

  

!   & %

 # $2" 5       /



     323

4"#!

#260   

      /  7

 5,0 

  



"



$'*+&*$8/ ! "

0 &9*+&*$8  *:*9&*$8  $8*$&*$, 



 -.

    

""  

"



  

   "

 

      -

      ; " 

"

 

 

 " 











 

 

 "!"  

( !" .

 

 

  -

    

  .  

        

   ;   

 " 8 %



!

!

- "

 !

 . "    "   &<"$8 "/"".

- 

0 





 ""  %

"   

1   "   

.!"





 ;

!

"



"

"



 





 !

   9 

!



5 67% 3824985#25:: ;

'&2 !<8#= !

5#:8 "&": :

#!8#2 #"%(2"("#> 389:":!

:

#!8#2#"%((2"(?"#23 58

&8#'

8#!

4"<5

%223 25< ": ;

'&25"#":23 !

@3 #23 4985#25::

<8#!

!23 '"# 5!

825"#23 #899!

:

#!8#2#"%(2"(8

& 238223 =@599<8A 23 #25 48=< #28#!89 "#"<5#82 !

:

#!8#2 #"%(8#!(> 5#B & 2=%3 4985#25:: ;

'&2 !23 :"99"@5#B

"&2":35 98#!$ 8 ,89 

!C-8 5A8"%?(!82 !(D?(< &5#B .8#85D8985#.3 @82C.38228#"%7?C(1

'2%"%(1 .5998#"%) (C(?( 18#!

'2%"%.5998#"%C(? ( 1DC(7 1 52&82 !5#23

#&

":-5998B ,5351 598#

815 22%&&B8<5#:8 "&":!

:

#!8#2#"%( 2":"82"289 '"# 5!

825"#":

%(11C@35'3@8

< #25"# !5#23 !

!485!5#'3 E& 8#!'8 3>&2#"28

5#B9 8<"&#238 >

# '

!>=23 4985#25::8223 25< ":

;

'&25"#C B5 2825"#":23 !

!%"4=": !

!5

## ;& % > ,89 

!C-8 5A8"%?!82 !(D?(?< &5#B .8#85((898.3 @82C.38228#"%7?C(1

'2%"%(1 .5998#"%) (C(?( 18#!

'2%"%.5998#"%C(? ( 1DC(7 1 52&82 !5#23

#&

":-5998B ,5351 598#

815#:8 "&":!

:

#!8#2#"%2"D:"82"289

'"# 5!

825"#":

%11C@35'3@8 < #25"# !5#

 !

!485!>='3 E&

>&223 #"28 5#B9 8<"&#238

>

#  '

!  >=  23  4985#25::  82  23  25<  ":

;

'&25"#C B5 2825"#  ":  23  !

!%  "4=  ":   !

## ;& % '

,89 

!C-8 5A8>%(!82 !7?( < &5#B .8#85D898.3 @82C.38228#"%7?C1

'2%"%(1 .5998#"%) (C(?( 18#!

'2%"%.5998#"%C(? ( 1DC(7 1 52&82 !5#23

#&

":-5998B ,5351 598#

815#:8 "&":!

:

#!8#2#"%):"82"289

'"# 5!

825"#":

%(11C@35'3@8 < #25"# !5#23

 !

!  485!  23"&B3  8 31  )  3 E&  >&2  #"2  8  5#B9

8<"&#2  38  >

#  '

!  >=  23  4985#25::  82  23  25<  ":

;

'&25"#C B5 2825"#":23 !

!8#!23 4985#25::%"4= ": !

!5 ## ;& % !

,89 

!C-8 5A8"%(7!82 !7(< &5#B .8#89D898.3 @82C.38228#"%7?C(1

'2%"%(1.5998 #"%) 8#!

'2%"%.5998#"%C(?( 1DC(7

52&82 !5#23

#&

":-5998B ,5351 598#

81 5#:8 "&":!

:

#!8#2#"%7:"82"289 '"# 5!

825"#":

% (1D(1?C  @35'3  @8  < #25"# !  5#  23  !

!  485!  5# 23"&B38 31>&2#"28 5#B9 8<"&#238 >

# '

!>= 4985#25::8223 25< ": ;

'&25"#C B5 2825"#":23

!%"4=": !

!5 ## ;& F% 

,89 

!C-8 5A8"%()!82 !(((< &5#B .8#85((898(,8 85.3 @82C.38228#"%7?C(1

'2% "%(1.5998#"%) 8#!

'2%"%.5998#"%C(?( DC(7 1 52&82 !5#23

#&

":-5998B ,5351 8#

81  5#  :8 "&  ":  !

:

#!8#2  #"%  (  :"  8  2"289 

'"# 5!

825"#":

%(1)1C@35'3@8 < #25"# !5#23

 !

!  485!  23"&B3  8 31  ,    3 E&  4985#25::

'

!23 8<"&#2":

%(?11C!82 !(7D(23"&B3

,"#9=8#!>898#'

'"# 5!

825"#":

%1)1C38

#"2>

#485!2"23 4985#25::2599!82 %"4=": !

!5

## ;& %G 8$ 

.

"

!"  

 8& ( !

"







<

 

 # $$ $+



  

 88



  

 

 "" ! 

!

   &'!



5 s 6D% 38223 '8&

":8'25"#8"

@3 #!

:

#!8#2 :&

B #&5# 8#!98@:&9 E&

2":23 4985#25::%3 4985#25::

E&

!89923 !

:

#!8#2 2"48=23 8<"&#2":23

'"# 5!

825"# <8#=25<

1 >&2 23 !

:

#!8#2 B8

"#"# 4 ;2"23 "23 8#!@3 #23 4985#25::

<8#!

!23 8<"&#28223 25< ": ;

'&25"#":23 !

:"23 = 8((1>&223 !

:

#!8#2 8

& !23 4985#25::

238223 =@599<8A 23 48=< #2 3"29=%3 !

:

#!8#2 89

#223 25< > 2@

#(D(723 !

:

#!8#289 ":59 !8 '5 59 &525#23 = 8(71>&223 !

:

#!8#2 > '8< !5 3"#

5#23 <"#23":8=8#! :&

!2"48=23 8<"&#2":

4985#25::8#!:59 !8'5<5#89'"<4985#28B85# 223 4985#25::5# 8=18#!23 4985#25::89 ":59 !23 5<5#89'"<4985#2 8B85# 2!

:

#!8#2#"%(2"(?8#!"23 !

:

#!8#2 #"%(2"( 5#23 <"#23":&B& 21 B8!5#B23 48=< #2":23

'"# 5!

825"#":23 4985#25::8#!4":52&223 !

:

#!8#2

5#2 #25"#899=  <898:5!

9=  @8#2  2"  B8>  23  8<"&#2  ": 

'"# 5!

825"#8#!4":52":23 4985#25::1'8&

":8'25"#8"

"#&# 1@3 #23 !

:

#!8#2 :59 !23 :89

8#!:5'2525"&

'"<4985#2  > :"

 23 "95'

 "<<5

5"#   8#!  3"@#  23

@"#B48=< #2!

8#!98 29=23 '8&

":8'25"#85

5# <"#23":&B& 21@3 #23 4985#25:::59 !8'5<5#89 '"<4985#28B85# 289923 !

:

#!8#2 %&2#"48=< #238 >

# <8!

>=23 !

:

#!8#2 2599!82 %"25238 89 "'"< 5#2"23

#"25'

8#!A#"@9 !B ":23 4985#25::1238223 !

:

#!8#2 38

282 !# B"2582 @523 "< 4"4 2=!

2" "9!"&223

&5298#!8#!5#'8

23 !

:

#!8#2 &''

!5#23 5599<"25

2" "9!"&223 &5298#!123 #4985#25:: 3899 &::

5 488>9

9"

8#!5#H&=@35'3'8##"2> '"<4 # !5#8#=<8## %

?

#'

23 '8&

":8'25"#5 25995# ;5 #'

2599!82 %G 8, %

 "" ! 

" !

 .

5 625 23

:"

'2:&99=48= !23828!

'

:"

'98825"#2"23 ::

'22382$ 8 38223 ,89 !

!> 85#B 8 5A8#"%?(!82 (D?(1 8 5A8I#"%?!82 !(D?(1 8 5A8#"% (!82 ! 7?(1 -8 5A8 "% (7 !82 !  7 (1(%)!82 !(((1<8=A5#!9=> !

'98 !8

#&998#! "5!8#!#"2>5#!5#B8B85# 223 5B32":23

4985#25::% > 382!

'

:"4 <8# #25#H&#'25"#

285#5#B  !

:

#!8#2  #"2  2"  895 #82 1  28# :

1  <"2B8B  "

'38#B 23 #82& ":98#!2"8#=235!4

"#!&5#B23

#!

#'=":23 4

#2 &52% '

382525 :&23 48= !2382899

#& '"!

">285# !"#> 389:":23 8>"

!

!<8=A5#!9=>

'98 !8 #&998#! "5!% !

38223 !

:

#!8#2 >

285# !#"22":&23

#82  "  28# :

  23 &52  4"4 2=  2"  8#=  "23

"# @523"&2!& 4"'

":98@!&5#B4 #!

#'=":

4

#2 &52% '

382  52  5  :&23   48= !  2382  8#  8!5#2 5< 5#H&#'25"#  23

>= 

285#5#B  23  !

:

#!8#2  2"

<85#285# 282& E&823 &524"4 2=2599!

'5 5"#":23

&52  4"4 2=  8#!  #"2  2"  5#2 :

 5#2"  23  4 8'

:&9 4"

5"#":23 4985#25::"#> 389:":@"#B #25

'"<5#B5#35 :8 "&% :

2 5  :&23   48= !  2382 23  !

:

#!8#2  <8= A5#!9=  >

285# !  #"2  2"  '

 8#=  #38#'

8<"&#2":'"<4 # 825"#:"<23 "::5'

":!

:

#!8#2

"%(D2"(78#!:&23 5

& 8#"!

2"23 !

:

#!8#2

"%(D2"(7#"22"!5 >&

8#=8<"&#2": #38#'

< #2 ":'"<4 # 825"#5#:8 "&":23 !

:

#!8#2 "%(2"(% B 25 89 "48= !23828#"!

@8 89 "5

& !2"

4"

5223 8<"&#2":'"<4 # 825"# '

!5#23

"::5'

": :

#!8#2#"%(D2"(7%:2 5:5'825"#23

85!8<"&#2<8=A5#!9=>

!5#:8 "&":23

4985#25::% 3

#="23 "!

" :8 235 "#9H9 "&2 <8=  !

<  :52  8#!  # '

8=  5#  23  :8'2  8#!

'5'&< 28#'

":23 '8

<8=A5#!9=89 "> 48

!5# :8 "&":23 4985#25::%G ,

"  /  7

5+0!



4

(( "

$$-.



< 

  

( !

  

"





" 



. 



 



 

"



$'*+&*$8/ ! "

0 &9*+&*$8/  "

0

 "!





  

 ,$ ( !

"



-



< <= "

>  

.2 

  

 

!

! 

  

  

  



   -

 

 

  

 ( !" 

. -





;  ,& ( !

 ! ".-

-."   

+9 

?

 

  

.

" 



  ,8 ( !" 

  "  . 

  + %

"  !   -.!. 

"./  7

5:0 !

 !



 "

. 





"



 

+$

 

/  7

5'0

".!"

!



 

"  !

 : 

 



$)*+&*&,/  7

5)0

"  !

"

 

"  

 

  ' ?

 "

 !

 ) ( !

 ".

-.  "



 



"  

 

"

  

( !-

  

 "



  

.

-

 



 5

  

"



 ( ! 

 !

"".

- "

-"

      

   

 

 "



 !""



! "<

 

 "



  

.

( !-

. -



-.!. 

; < <= "

>  

.( !-



 



 !-

-."   )$ ( !-



"  

! 

"



 -



  -" <"

   

";   "    ( ! 

" 

!

"

 

    "

  

  ".



 )& ( !"  



<

  !



  

"  7 ;   "!

(   

 "

 ""

"

 

  



  -. 

 > 6-"

 

      (   %

) 5 8#!8#!8< % %-%,82=84891(7DD , (J  8B3@ #!8 ,388#  ,5#B3 %  8<  8##8  ,5#B3   8!

 >=  +

%1  (7  

, (J  823&4825  ,&>>8 

!!=  5  >=  +%

%    % % 3

,4 '589   4&2=  "99 '2"  + 1    ,  (J  8#!  8<5

22= - #A828##8#% % 8 =8< 8<89,83 > %1 +8@ 89!, (?% 9 

      !"  "

    

 

-

 

" .

 

!

  



 " 

 ( ! 

 ".

  

"

?

   "-

 "

   "    



<    

 









.

"





!

 

" 

( !

-

 

"  

 

"  





" -

 





"

-



-. < 

  4

(("

$$?

   "-

 

" . -  

"  

 -

 

"!(   

   "

     "  "

 

"

   

 

 



-.

> 6-"



   (.&<%

2381C"+82

.5 3#8    % % 8#H&#!8 @8<=    %1      ,  ??(J .&98>8#!3& 8<!8 3,38<8 %8<

5 82 +5<52 !8#!

#% K(((?1  !

'5!

!  "#  %7%?  + $  D)7 LJ 8>8 > 8<!8 ,35"9  % % "352#2 45

 %1(

5 59 J,5"= # 4899=,5H8=8 8!38# %-%5&48<8

!!=  % K77?1!

'5!

!"#7%D%?+ $DDDL

  89H

28#!"23

 %

<38#!8#!"23

1?

5 59 ?7(J8B>5,5#B3 % 3#58#!"23

1? 5 59 ?% $* (



-  -."

 "

  $$ @



 



 

 ! "-  

7

 "



;

< !

"

" !

"  



4

(("

$$( !

""

    

 "

  "  ".

 

" 

 



- " <  



" 

-.

  -  

"

   

 "  

".

    -









- 

   > 6-"

7  

  .&9!

4,5#B3 8238#58 % 5A8<,5#B3 8=891(D ,?7 $&



  "  

"!!

""

"   

;   "!

"

"  

  -

-."    "



" 

 "  = "

< 

 !

> 6-"

7 



  

  

"

"   7 ;   "!



 ""."  

(("

$$ "   

 "  



"".!



"   <  ! 

  (           "  

> 6-"

(

7 

"

"  7 ;   "!

 "



 

". ;

"".     

4

(("

$$  5  

5 6D%  B8!

 23  :5 2  8 '21  52  5  @ 99 

!  2382 95<52825"#5 8<5;

!E&

25"#":98@8#!:8'28#!&#9

23

8< 5 482 #29=8#!&# E&5 "'899='9 8152'8##"2:"<8 B"&#!&#!

 !

- &9 ((":23 :"#"# &525#B8 4985#25::%#23 '8

"#38#!14 & 89":23 4985#25#!5'82

238223 4985#25::

'985< !238223 '8&

":8'25"#8"

5# '2"> 1@3 #!

:

#!8#2"%( 282 !E&8 995#B@523 <:"23 :5 225< 1 3"@5#B35 2& '"9"

>=2=5#B2"

B8>23 &524"4

8#!5#2 :

5#B@52323 54 8'

:&9 4"

5"#"

23 8< %G $8 (

 %,% 8<8 @8<= %-%.%, #23598#!"23

 5 59 

> 6-"

7  

"

"  

 " " 

 



  !



  "  -.

 

! 

-

-."   !! < 



  



   



 

 -

-.

"  

 !

;

  ". 



"  ! 

;   "!%

!!







 ""."  -  7 ;   "!

 "  "

 

 "  "



 



   -

-."   $, (

                !  !

"



 5

(( 6((% 3

5 = 28#"23 "#@3=23 H&!B< #2":23 5B3 "&25 #"2 & 285#8>9 %#8#84495'825"#&#!

 !

- &9 ((1   8  4985#2  '8##"2  > '2 !  5#  482%  35  45#'549  5  @

28>95 !8#!38 >

#'"#25#&"& 9=:"99"@ ! 5#'

23 (7!

'5 5"# 5#8E &!3<8! %8238822" (7+83"

((%35

45#'549 5 89 ;4985# !5#8 '

#2!

'5 5"#":235 "&25#, H89 98

+2!% %8 598# '38#2 

+2!1() ((,D)@35'3 @8 8B85#:"99"@ !5#8!38  8!BB8@89 %;5 8#A+2!% (7 D,(?)%3 8#24"25"#":8!38  8! &48 5

;28'2 !3

5#&#!

$ (% / !"#"2!

<52# '

8=2" 98>"82 "#899"23

8B&< #2 8 @ 8 5#'95# !2"8''

4223 ">H '25"#":23

998#2

238223 :": '25"#":4985#25# ;

'5

":

4"@

&#!

 !

D &9 ((!

'8##"2> 4& & "#9=5#

'2":"# ":23 !

:

#!8#2

%#"23 @"!

123

4985#238 2"> '2 !8 8@3"9 "#"28289915# ;

'5

":

4"@ &#!

 !

D &9 ((!

%#!

!123 9 8# ,5#B9 &!B '2 !235 ">H '25"#85

!>=23 844 998#2

>= 9=5#B"#23 !

'5 5"#":23 5 5 5"# #'3":23 8<

5B3"&2%"@

1@ :5#!238223 !

'5 5"#":235 "&25# , H8998

+2!%K, H8998

+2!% %8 598# '38#2 

+2!%1() ((,D)$() ?,5 ? 5 !5 '29="#  4"5#2%  #  2382  '8

1  8#  84495'825"#  @8  :59 !  >=  23

:

#!8#2

&#!

 !

D &9 ((!

 2825#B238223

4985#2!5 '9"

!#"'8&

":8'25"#%3 '5 59'"&23 9!238223

4985#25 2"> >5:&'82 !8 52!5!#"2!5 '9"

8#='8&

":

8'25"#8B85# 223 5 '2"I  :

#!8#2

2"23

5#% # 2382  >8 1  23  5B3  "&2  38!  "45# !  2382  23 &52  '8# '"#25#& 8B85# 2 :

#!8#2('"<48#=89"# %3 E&

25"# '"# 5!

!>=235 "&2@8 @3 &'38'"&

5 "4 #2"

'5 59'"&25# ;

'5

":4"@

&#!

 !

D &9 ((!

%3 "&28# @

!23 85!E&

25"#5#23 # B825 >= 8!

25#B  2" 

89  !

'5 5"#  "#  23  4"5#2  @35'3  38!

'"# #29=3 9!238223 4985#2'8#8#!"23 4985#25::

2"38

#'

8 9"2":!"'&< #2 8#!

#& #25

38 2">

&4!82 !> :"

!5 5!5#B23 &52 '3 !&9 4"4

8#!B5

4882 4"

5"#2" 8'3

5#'9&!5#B4985#25::

%G

( $+

" !! < -.

> 6-"

7     ""  #"$     $: 

 



 

  - 

"

 ;  !







.

6

    

 >  





 







! 

 "

 ""

-

"

  ".

"





-.

- " -.



 A



<    !



 





 

"





   







"





   

 %

  B

 # 9 $,

 "

.

"

  

 ""

 

"

 

"  

 

 !"  

#  - 

!  ; "

" - 

  .

 



 .

!

""C 

  



-"  



.  -" <"

-   



"" "





  !

-  5



" $' (

 



 

"  -."

 "

 %

 

-."

 "

 "!

"!



  " !

" -



 

 "  > !



 -

  

" 

 

C

 



  ! "

 



( $)   ; ".

 

 

  

 



 ".  $9   "  /0."      -.

 /+

   8'3()1  C"   $)*8&*&:

 =

 < 2

   =

 -"