Anil Kapoor v. Ing Vysya Bank Now Kotak Mahindra Bank And ORS
!"#
$%& '&()*)+, -
", .
/"0 0
/ .
/"01 0// 2&*&+%, "2&2230 $%4 '5($%& 2%6&7&%)%)+&2 "2
00896):$4 '5($%& 22&*7+'&+% "2$:$8;<$+*$;4 '5($%& 22&*7+'&+%* $+' "20$*2)(6$4"2 $;9$==$ !"2$+9$:87%$4 '5($%&* $:&*6 )+'$; 6&7&%)%)+&26$* );&'%6&72&*&+%7&%)%)+72$3)+= 2*&%%)+= $*)'&2'&2'$%&' > 45)'&?6)(60
);&'@3%6& 7&%)%)+&2?$*')*A)**&'@3 &@%*&(5&232)@8+$;B46$+')=$26 2 *62%4 .%6&2)@8+$;.# + $((8+% ++B$77&$2$+(& (8+*&; 2 %6& $77;)($+% 7&%)%)+&26&2&)+#82%6&272$3&26$*@&&+A$'& 2*&%%)+=$*)'& 2'&2'$%&' C 7$**&'@3%6&2)@8+$;45)'&?6)(6%6&$77;)($%)+ 2 2&*%2$%)+ %6&0 4?6)(6?$*')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4?$*')*A)**&'$* +%A$)+%$)+$@;&7)+)+=%6$%%6&$77;)($+%4) *'&*)2&*4($+ );&$77&$;
$=$)+*% %6& 2'&2 '$%&' > 6$;;&+=& )+ %6& 0 );&' @3%6&
7&%)%)+&2@& 2&%6&2)@8+$;?$*%%6&$(%)+%$9&+@32&*7+'&+% 8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0&(82)%)D$%)+!&(+*%28(%)+ )+$+()$;
**&%*!+ 2(&A&+% 0&(82)%3+%&2&*% (%4 6&2&)+$ %&2'&*(2)@&'
$*.%6&0 (%.#
/&$2+&'(8+*&; 2%6&7&%)%)+&2*8@A)%%&'%6$%%6&&(5&23 &@%* 8&% $+9*$+')+$+()$;+*%)%8%)+* (%4-- 6&2&)+$ %&2 '&*(2)@&'$*.%6& (%.#?$*&+$(%&')+%6&3&$2-- 4?6)(6($A&)+%
2(&+ -- 6&0 (%?$*&+$(%&')+%6&3&$2 ?6)(6($A&)+% 2(&?& 2)2%%6$%4%6&2&?$*2')+$+(&4 ?6)(6?$*72A8;=$%&'+ C 0&(%)+ %6&0 (% )+)%)$;;38*&'%6&?2'*E)=6%% 77&$;F=)5)+=;)@&2%3%$+37&2*+ $==2)&5&'@3$+3$(%)+%$9&+8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0 (%%
);& $77&$; @& 2& %6&2)@8+$; 6& $ 2&*$)' 725)*)+ ($A&87 2 (+*)'&2$%)+@& 2&+.@;&%6&0872&A&82%)+"$2')$6&A)($;*/%' $+'%6&2*5+)+ +')$$+'%6&2*4 # 0 4?6&2&)%?$* 7)+&'%6$%%6&72(&&')+=*@&)+=2)=)+$;)++$%82&4%6&*&($++%@&%&2A&' $* $77&$; 6& :8'=A&+% ?$* '&;)5&2&' + AA&')$%&;3 %6&2&$ %&24$A&+'A&+%?$*($22)&'8%)+0&(%)+ # %6&0 0
(%45)'& (% + 46?&5&24?)%62&%2*7&(%)5& &
&(% 2A C 4?6&2&@3%6&?2'*EA$372& &2$+$77&$;F?&2& 2&7;$(&'?)%6?2'*EA$3A$9&$+$77;)($%)+F *%6&%)%;& %6&0&(%)+ ?$*+%$A&+'&'$%%6$%%)A&4?6)(6*%);;8*&'%6&?2'*E)=6%% 77&$;F4 $A&+'A&+%?$*($22)&'8%5)'& (% C4?& - C6& ?2'E$77;)($%)+F?$**8@*%)%8%&')+ 0&(%)+ %6&0 (% +;35)'&$A&+'A&+%($22)&'8%@3 (% $+' (%
C
6& &@%*&(5&232)@8+$; 2(&'82&*4-- 2 *62%4.%6&-- 8;&*.#4 ?6)(6'& )+&E$77;)($%)+F4)+)%)$;;3A&$+%$+ $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+- (%4@8%?)%6$A&+'A&+% ($22)&'8%5)'&+%) )($%)+'$%&' 4)%?$*A$'&)+(;8*)5& $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ B $+'$+$77&$; );&'8+'&20&(%)+ # %6& (% 0&(%)+ B ?$* $''&' )+ %6& (% 5)'&
A&+'A&+% (% ?& 725)')+= 2$+$77&$;% %6&2)@8+$;$=$)+*%$+32'&27$**&'@3%6&&(5&23
)(&28+'&20&(%)+
(%0&(%)+ B (%?$*$;*$''&'5)'&*$A& $A&+'A&+% &7;$(&A&+% %6& ?2' E$77;)($%)+F 2A E$77&$;F )+ 0&(%)+ %6&0 (%)*;$%&2)+%)A& *72(&'82&725)'&'
28+'&2%6& (%)*%@& ;;?&' 2'&()*)+ $77;)($%)+8+'&2 0&(%)+ %6&0 (%4%6$%?8;'+&(&**$2);3A&$+%6$%$+3 $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%)*$;*%@&2&$'
$*$+$77;)($%)+4?6)(6($+@&')*A)**&')+'& $8;%$+'2&*%2&' 6);&2& &22)+=%0&(%)+
# # (%4)%?$* *8@A)%%&'%6$%&5&+7?&2%')*A)**)+'& $8;%$+3$77;)($%)+)*$;* '2$?+ 2A%6$%*&(%)+ 7?&2%')*A)**$+$77;)($%)+)+'& $8;%($+ @&&G&2()*&'4%6&+(+*&H8&+%;3%6&7?&2 22&*%2$%)+4$*(+%$)+&')+ 0&(%)+
# =# (%*6$;;$;*@&$5$);$@;&?)%6%6&2)@8+$;4 %6&2?)*&&5&+$+$77;)($%)+($++%@&')*A)**&')+'& $8;% > 0&(%)+ %6&0 (%?$*2& &22&'%$2=8&%6$%%6& 725)*)+* %6&0 (%2%6&28;&* 2$A&'%6&2&8+'&2$2&)+ $'')%)+ %4 $+' +% )+ '&2=$%)+ %6& A7$+)&* (%4 ->C4 %6& 0&(82)%)&*+%2$(%* &=8;$%)+# (%4->C4%6&0&(82)%)&*$+'G(6$+=&
$2' +')$ (%4-- $+'%6& (%2$+3%6&2;$? 2%6&%)A&
@&)+= )+ 2(& * %6&2& )* + 725)*)+ )+ %6& 0 0 (% 2 ')*A)**)+=$+3$77;)($%)+)+'& $8;%4*8(6$7?&2(8;'+%@&&G&2()*&' C 6&:8'=A&+% +.@;& ;;$6$@$')=682%)+ "I*3%) G%2$(%)+2)5$%&/)A)%&'$+'$+%6&250%$%& $+'%6&2*4
# )5);#--?$*2& &22&'%4?6&2&%6&7)+)+&G72&**&'?$*%6$% 7?&2 2&*%2$%)+ $+$77;)($%)+')*A)**&')+'& $8;%)*$5$);$@;&?)%6 %6&2)@8+$; 6& :8'=A&+% +.@;& %6& 0872&A& 82% )+ +'8*%2)$; 2&')%$+'+5&*%A&+%272$%)+ +')$/%'52$7(+'8*%2)&*/%' $+'%6&2*4 ---# 06$*@&&+2& &22&'%4?6&2&0&(%)+
#$+'
# (%($A&87 2(+*)'&2$%)+?)%62& &2&+(&%$+)**8& ?6&%6&2%6&2)@8+$;6$'%6&7?&2%=2$+%&GB7$2%&)+%&2)A*%$36& H8&*%)+7*&'?$*$+*?&2&')+7*)%)5&& &2&+(&?$*$;*A$'&%%6& :8'=A&+% $ )5)*)+ &+(6 %6)*82%)+ "I*02)1)*6+80%&&;*5 +)+ +')$$+'$+%6&24 #/4?6&2&)+%6)*(82%7)+&'%6$% 7?&2 % $;;? $+ $77;)($%)+ 2 $A&+'A&+% %6& 7;&$')+=* )* A$)+%$)+$@;&@& 2&%6&2)@8+$;+%6&$ 2&*$)'($*&4$77;)($%)+?$*
);&'8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%
6);&2& &22)+=%%6&*(6&A& %6&0 (%4;&$2+&'
(8+*&;*8@A)%%&'%6$%$=$)+*%$+3$(%)+%$9&+@3%6&*&(82&'(2&')%2 8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0 (%4$77;)($%)+($+@& );&'@& 2& %6&2)@8+$; 8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%4?6)(66$*%@& $((A7$+)&' @3 *8(6 &&4 $* A$3 @& 72&*(2)@&'0&(%)+ # %6& (%725)'&*%6$%%6&2)@8+$;($+')*7*& %6&$77;)($%)+)+ $((2'$+(&?)%6%6&725)*)+* (% $+'%6&28;&* 2$A&'
%6&2&8+'&20&(%)+
(%725)'&* 272(&'82&$+'7?&2*
> %6&2)@8+$;$+'%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;0&(%)+
# (% 725)'&*%6$%%6&2)@8+$;$+'%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;*6$;;+%@&@8+'@3 %6&72(&'82&;$)''?+)+%6&'& )5);2(&'82&4- 2*62%4 ..#4@8%*6$;;@&=8)'&'@3%6&72)+()7;&* +$%82$;:8*%)(&4*8@:&(%% %6&2725)*)+* (%$+'%6&28;&*0&(%)+*
# #4 =#$+'
6# (%$2&2&;&5$+%4?6)(6&+$@;&%6&2)@8+$;%')*A)**$+3 $77;)($%)+)+'& $8;%2'&()'&%6&*$A&&GB7$2%& ?&26$*$;*@&&+ (+ &22&' 2*&%%)+=$*)'&%6&2'&2 ')*A)**$; $+3$77;)($%)+)+ '& $8;%2*&%$*)'&$+32'&27$**&'&GB7$2%& - 6&%&2A.$77;)($%)+.4$*+%)(&')+0&(%)+
# #$+' =# %6& (%4?8;'A&$+$+$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+-28+'&20&(%)+
B $+')+(;8'&*$+.$77&$;. );&'8+'&20&(%)+ # (%4)+ %&2A* 8;& (# %6&-- 8;&* *$+3$77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&2 0&(%)+ %6& 0 0 (% )* +% A&+%)+&'4 6&+(&4 7?&2 2&*%2$%)+?);;+%@&$5$);$@;& 0&(%)+- ># (%?$*2& &22&'%4?6)(6725)'&*
27?&2 %6&2)@8+$;%A$9&*8(62'&2*$+'=)5&*8(6')2&(%)+*4$* A$3@&+&(&**$232&G7&')&+%%=)5&&
&(%%)%*2'&2*2%72&5&+%$@8*& )%*72(&**2%*&(82&%6&&+'* :8*%)(& %?$* 82%6&2$2=8&'%6$%)+A$+3($*&*4&*7&()$;;3?6&2&5$;8& %6&*&(82)%3$5$);$@;&?)%6%6&@$+9)*;&**%6$+%6&$A8+%2&(5&2$@;&4 %6&@$+9$%%6&5&23 )2*%)+*%$+(&)+59&*%6&725)*)+* %6&0 0
(%?)%68% );)+=$+3$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+- %6& (%6& @22?&22$+3%6&27&2*+)+%&2A* 0&(%)+ %6&0 (% 6$*@&&+=)5&+2)=6%%(6$;;&+=&%6$%$(%)+@& 2&%6&2)@8+$; ;;%6& )**8&* *8=6% % @& 2$)*&' @3 %6& 7$2%)&* $2& % @& '&()'&' )+ %6*&
C 72(&&')+=*+;346&+(&4%6&725)*)+* %6&4&*7&()$;;34$*6$5&@&&+ 2& &22&')+0&(%)+
# (%?8;'$77;3$+')+ $(%4%6& 72)+()7;&* %6&2& $2& @&)+= $77;)&' ?&5&24 )% )* +;3 %6$% %6& $77;)($%)+*$2&@&)+=')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4@8%2&*%2$%)+$77;)($%)+*$2& +%@&)+=&+%&2%$)+&'@3%6&2)@8+$;7)+)+=%6$%%6&2&)*+*8(67?&2 6&2)@8+$;6$*7)+&'%6$%%6&$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%6$5)+=@&&+'&()'&'A$3+%@&+A&2)%*$+'+;3 ')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4$77&$;8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%?8;'
@&A$)+%$)+$@;&6&2&A&'3)+*8(6($*&*?8;'@&H8)%&+&28*4$* @& 2& );)+=$+3$77&$;4>J %6&$A8+%)+')*78%&6$*%@&'&7*)%&'
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
A$3@&2&+'&2&')+ 28(%88* 0&(%)+ #$+' # %6&0 (%725)'&*%6&9)+'
2'&2*4?6)(6($+@&7$**&'@3%6&2)@8+$;%'&*+%%$;9 ')*A)**$;
$+3$77;)($%)+)+'& $8;%46&+(&4)%6$*%@&'&()'&'+A&2)%*+;3 8;&>B %6&-- 8;&*6$*@&&+2& &22&'%4?6)(6&+$@;&*$+37$2%3 @& 2&%6&2)@8+$;% );&2&5)&? $+2'&27$**&'@3)%+%6&=28+'*
*7&() )&'+(&$+$77;)($%)+ 22&5)&? %6&2'&2($+@& );&'4%6&2&)* +2&$*+ 2'&72)5)+=$+37$2%3% );&$77;)($%)+ 22&*%2$%)+ %6& $77;)($%)+4?6)(66$*@&&+')*A)**&')+'& $8;%+$2&5)&?4%6&A$%%&26$'
@&&+ '&()'&' + A&2)%* $ %&2 6&$2)+= %6& 7$2%)&*4 ?6&2&$* )+ ($*& ')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4)%)*A&2&;3)+%6&$@*&+(& (8+*&;27$2%3+%6& 72(&** 2&*%2$%)+ $+$77;)($%)+')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4)+%&272&%$%)+ *68;'@&A2&;)@&2$;4$*%6)*)*+;3725)')+=2&A&'3%$7$2%3$+'+% %6&2&;)& 08
)()&+(3 2&$*+* 22&*%2$%)+$2&%@&&G$A)+&'@3%6& 2)@8+$;)+&5&23($*&)+'&7&+'&+%;3 > 6&:8'=A&+% +.@;&%6&0872&A&82%)+$:&&5)%&+'2$ $%6$9$+'%6&2*5 (638%<$*6)+$%6<$2&9$2$+'$+%6&24 #/
?$*2& &22&'%4?6&2&+.@;&%6&0872&A&82%4?6);&'&$;)+=?)%6 %6&725)*)+* %6&+*8A&22%&(%)+ (%4- C47)+&'%6$%%6&0%$%& AA)**)+2%6& )*%2)(%28A')'+%6$5&%6&7?&2%*&%$*)'&%6&)2 ?+&GB7$2%&2'&2*22&5)&?%6&2'&2*7$**&'@3%6&A)+%6&$@*&+(& $+3&+$@;)+=725)*)+ C
*%6&;)%)=$%)+)+6$+')*+%$'5&2*$2)$;$+'+;3;&=$;)**8& )*)+5;5&'4?&6$5&+%)(&'$;;%6&$2=8A&+%*2$)*&'@3%6&(8+*&;*$+' +%$%%2)@8%)+=%6*&%$+3 %6&7$2%35&+%6&2(8+*&;*6$5&$;*@&&+ 6&$2' ;;%6&(8+*&;*$@;3$**)*%&'%6&82% 6&)**8&)+5;5&')+%6&72&*&+%7&%)%)+)*$*%, E6&%6&2%6& &@%*&(5&232)@8+$;6$*7?&2%')*A)**$+ $77;)($%)+4 );&'8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0&(82)%)D$%)+!
&(+*%28(%)+ )+$+()$; **&%*!+ 2(&A&+% 0&(82)%3 +%&2&*% (%4 4)+'& $8;% $+' 82%6&2$*%?6&%6&2$+ $77;)($%)+ 22&*%2$%)+ $77;)($%)+')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4
)*A$)+%$)+$@;&K
*7&2%6&*(6&A& %6&0 (%40&(%)+ %6&2& 725)'&*%6$%?6&2&5&2$+3@22?&2A$9&*'& $8;%)+2&7$3A&+% *&(82&'
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
72)2%)%*$A&+'A&+%5)'& (% 4$+37&2*+$==2)&5&'@3 $+3 %6&A&$*82&*42& &22&'%)+0&(%)+ # %6&0 (% %$9&+@3%6&*&(82&'(2&')%2?$*&+%)%;&'% );&$77&$;@& 2&%6&2)@8+$; 08@B*&(%)+ # %6&2& 725)'&' %6$% *8(6 $+ $77&$; ?$* +% % @& &+%&2%$)+&'8+;&**%6&@22?&26$''&7*)%&'>J %6&$A8+%(;$)A&'
)+%6&+%)(&8+'&20&(%)+
# %6&0 (%?&5&24%6& 2)@8+$;?$*=)5&+7?&2%2&'8(&2?$)5&
%6&$A8+% 22&$*+*% @&2&(2'&')+?2)%)+=6&$77&$;* );&'@& 2&%6&2)@8+$;?$*%@& ')*7*&' )+$((2'$+(&?)%6%6&725)*)+* (%$+'%6&28;&*
2$A&'%6&2&8+'&2
6& $ 2&*$)' 725)*)+ ($A& 87 2 (+*)'&2$%)+ @& 2& +.@;&%6&0872&A&82%)+ "$2')$6&A)($;*/%'$+'%6&2*. ($*& *872$#4?6&2&)+0&(%)+ # %6&0 (%4?6)(62&H8)2&'72&B '&7*)% 2 &+%&2%$)+A&+% $77&$; ?$* 6&;' % @& $+'
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
4 - # 0 - ?6&2&)+2&*7&(% 2)=)+$;$+'$77&;;$%&72(&&')+=*$')*%)+(%)+6$*@&&+ '2$?+$* ;;?*, 07 -47$2$># E6&2&)*$@$*)(')*%)+(%)+@&%?&&+%6&2)=6% *8)%$+'%6&2)=6% $77&$;6&2&)*$+)+6&2&+% 2)=6%)+&5&237&2*+%@2)+=$*8)% ()5);+$%82& $+'8+;&**%6&*8)%)*@$22&'@3*%$%8%&+&A$34$% +&.*&2);4@2)+=$*8)% +&.*(6)(&%)*+ $+*?&2%$*8)%46?*&5&2 2)5;8*%(;$)A4%6$% %6&;$?(+ &2*+*8(62)=6%%*8& *8)% 2)%* A$)+%$)+$@);)%32&H8)2&*+$8%62)%3 ;$?$+')% )*&+8=6 %6$%+*%$%8%&@$2*%6&*8)% 8%%6& 7*)%)+)+2&=$2'%$77&$;*)*H8)%&%6&77*)%&
6&2)=6% $77&$;)+6&2&*)+++&$+'%6&2& 2& $+$77&$; 2)%*A$)+%$)+$@);)%3A8*%6$5&%6&(;&$2 $8%62)%3 ;$?6$%&G7;$)+*?63%6&2)=6% $77&$;)*'&*(2)@&'$*$(2&$%82& *%$%8%&F
6&$ 2&*$)':8'=A&+%?$*'&;)5&2&'+ 08@*&H8&+% %6&2&%40&(%)+ # %6&0 (%?$*$A&+'&'5)'& (% 4?)%62&%2*7&(%)5&&
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
%6&2&8+'&26&*$A&)*&G%2$(%&'@&;?, E
! "
# +37&2*+ )+(;8')+=@22?&2#$==2)&5&'@3$+3 %6& A&$*82&*2& &22&'%)+*8@B*&(%)+ # 0&(%)+ %$9&+@3
%6&*&(82&'(2&')%226)*$8%62)*&'
)(&28+'&2%6)*(6$7%&24 A$3A$9&$+$77;)($%)+$;+=?)%6*8(6 &&4$*A$3@& 72&*(2)@&'4#%%6& &@%*&(5&232)@8+$;6$5)+=:82)*')(%)+ )+%6&A$%%&2?)%6)+ 2%3B )5&'$3* 2A%6&'$%&+?6)(6 *8(6A&$*82&6$'@&&+%$9&+, 25)'&' %6$% ')
&2&+% &&* A$3 @& 72&*(2)@&' 2 A$9)+=%6&$77;)($%)+@3%6&@22?&2$+'%6&7&2*+%6&2 %6$+%6&@22?&2 GGGGGG #0$5&$*%6&2?)*&725)'&')+%6)* (%4%6& &@%*&(5&23 2)@8+$;*6$;;4$* $2$*A$3@&4')*7*& %6&$77;)($%)+)+ $((2'$+(&?)%6%6&725)*)+* %6&&(5&23 &@%* 8& % $+9*$+')+$+()$;+*%)%8%)+* (%4-- > -- #$+'
%6&28;&*A$'&%6&2&8+'&2F
0&(%)+
(%'&$;*?)%672(&'82&$+'7?&2 %6&2)@8+$;0&(%)+
# (%725)'&*%6$%%6&2)@8+$;*6$;;
+%@&@8+'@3%6&72(&'82&;$)''?+)+4@8%*6$;;@&=8)'&'@3%6& 72)+()7;&* +$%82$; :8*%)(& 08@B*&(%)+ # %6&2& 725)'&* %6$% %6& 2)@8+$;*6$;;4 2%6&7827*& ')*(6$2=)+=)%* 8+(%)+*8+'&2%6& (%4 6$**$A&7?&2$*$2&5&*%&')+%6&)5);82%8+'&2?6);&%23)+=$ ()5);*8)%?)%62& &2&+(&%BB $# *8AA+)+=$+'&+ 2()+=%6&$%%&+'$+(& $+37&2*+ $+'&G$A)+)+=6)A+$%6L @# 2&H8)2)+=%6&')*(5&23$+'72'8(%)+ '(8A&+%*L (# 2&(&)5)+=&5)'&+(&+$
)'$5)%*L
'# )**8)+=(AA)**)+* 2%6&&G$A)+$%)+ ?)%+&**&*2 '(8A&+%*L &# 2&5)&?)+=)%*'&()*)+*L
# ')*A)**)+=$+$77;)($%)+ 2'& $8;%2'&()')+=)% =# *&%%)+=$*)'&$+32'&2 ')*A)**$; $+3$77;)($%)+ 2 '& $8;%2$+32'&27$**&'@3)% $+' 6# $+3%6&2A$%%&2?6)(6A$3@&72&*(2)@&' 8% %6&$ 2&*$)'725)*)+*47?&2* $*(+ &22&'8+'&2 0&(%)+
# # $+' =# $2& 2&;&5$+%4 ?6)(6 %$;9 ')*A)**)+= $+ $77;)($%)+ 2'& $8;%2'&()')+=)% $+'*&%%)+=$*)'&$+32'&2 ')*A)**$; $+3$77;)($%)+ 2'& $8;%2$+32'&27$**&'@3)%&GB7$2%& 0&(%)+
(%)*&G%2$(%&'@&;?, E##
$ % & ! & ! " # 6& 2)@8+$; $+' %6& 77&;;$%& 2)@8+$;*6$;;+%@&@8+'@3%6&72(&'82&;$)''?+@3%6& '& )5);2(&'82&4- > - #4@8%*6$;;@&=8)'&'
@3%6&72)+()7;&* +$%82$;:8*%)(&$+'4*8@:&(%%%6&%6&2 725)*)+* %6)* (%$+' $+328;&*4%6&2)@8+$;$+'%6&
77&;;$%&2)@8+$;*6$;;6$5&7?&2*%2&=8;$%&%6&)2?+ 72&'82&)+(;8')+=%6&7;$(&*$%?6)(6%6&3*6$;;6$5&%6&)2 *)%%)+=*
#6&2)@8+$;$+'%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;*6$;;6$5&4 2%6& 7827*&* ')*(6$2=)+=%6&)2 8+(%)+*8+'&2%6)* (%4%6& *$A&7?&2*$*$2&5&*%&')+$()5);(82%8+'&2%6&'& )5); 2(&'82&4- > - #4?6);&%23)+= $*8)%4)+
2&*7&(% ;;?)+=A$%%&2*4+$A&;3,B $# *8AA+)+=$+'&+ 2()+=%6&$%%&+'$+(& $+3 7&2*+$+'&G$A)+)+=6)A+$%6L @# 2&H8)2)+= %6& ')*(5&23 $+' 72'8(%)+ '(8A&+%*L (# 2&(&)5)+=&5)'&+(&+$
)'$5)%*L '# )**8)+= (AA)**)+* 2 %6& &G$A)+$%)+ ?)%+&**&*2'(8A&+%*L &# 2&5)&?)+=)%*'&()*)+*L
# ')*A)**)+=$+$77;)($%)+ 2'& $8;%2'&()')+=)% =# *&%%)+= $*)'& $+3 2'&2 ')*A)**$; $+3 $77;)($%)+ 2'& $8;%2$+32'&27$**&'@3)% 6# $+3%6&2A$%%&2?6)(6A$3@&72&*(2)@&'F
6&%&2AE$77;)($%)+F6$*@&&+'& )+&')+0&(%)+ @# %6&
(%%A&$+$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+-8;& (# %6&-- 8;&* $;* '& )+&* E$77;)($%)+F&2&%6&A&$+)+= % %6& %&2AE$77;)($%)+F $**)=+&' )+ %6& (% 6$* @&&+ &G7$+'&' 82%6&2 % )+(;8'& &5&+ $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ B $+'$+$77&$; );&'8+'&20&(%)+ #4 )+$'')%)+%$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+- (% 6& $ 2&*$)' 28;& ?$* $A&+'&' 5)'& +%) )($%)+ '$%&' 4 ?6);& )+(;8')+= $77;)($%)+ );&' 8+'&2 0&(%)+ B $+' $77&$; );&' 8+'&2 0&(%)+ # (% 3%6$%%)A&40&(%)+ %6&0 0
(%6$'+%@&&+$A&+'&'4$*$A&+'A&+%%6&2&)+?$*($22)&'8%5)'& (%
0&(%)+ # %6& (% 725)'&* %6$% $+3 7&2*+ $==2)&5&'@3$+2'&27$**&'@3%6&&(5&23
)(&28+'&2%6& (%($+ 72& &2$+$77&$;%%6&2)@8+$;4?6&2&$*0&(%)+ B (% 725)'&*%6$%?6&2&$+3'&(2&&22'&26$*@&&+7$**&'@3$+3(82%@& 2& (AA&+(&A&+% %6& &(5&23 &@%* 8&% $+9*$+')+$+()$;
+*%)%8%)+* A&+'A&+%# (%4 ?& #$+'%6&*$A&6$*+% 3&%@&&+&G&(8%&'4%6&+%6&'&(2&&6;'&2($+$77;3%%6&2)@8+$;%7$** $+2'&2 22&(5&23 %6&$A8+%
>
*6$*$;2&$'3@&&+2& &22&'%$@5&40&(%)+ %6& (%725)'&*$A7;&7?&2%%6&*&(82&'(2&')%2%%$9&5&2 7**&**)+ %6&*&(82&'$**&%*2&5&+%$9&5&2%6&A$+$=&A&+%&A&'3 $=$)+*% %6$%$(%)+6$*@&&+725)'&')+0&(%)+%6&2& 08(6$+ $77;)($%)+($+@& );&'?)%6)+$7&2)' >'$3* 2A%6&'$%&+?6)(6 *8(6A&$*82&)*%$9&++%&2A* 0&(%)+ ># %6&0 (%4 *8(6$+$77;)($%)+6$*%@&'&()'&'$*&G7&')%)8*;3$*7**)@;&$+' 72& &2$@;3?)%6)+$7&2)' C'$3* 2A%6&'$%& );)+=?&5&24%6& 7&2)' ($+ @&&G%&+'&' 22&$*+* % @&2&(2'&' )+ ?2)%)+= @8% +% &G(&&')+= 82A+%6*
C 6&$ 2&*$)'725)*)+*(;&$2;3&*%$@;)*6%6$%2&A&'3)*%@& $5$);&' @3%6&7&2*+$==2)&5&'&G7&')%)8*;3$+'&5&+%6&2)@8+$;6$* $;*@&&+A$+'$%&'%')*7*& %6&*$A&$%%6&&$2;)&*%+*8(6*)%8$%)+4 ) )%)*72&*8A&'%6$%%6&2)@8+$;6$*@&&+(+ &22&'?)%67?&2%')*A)** $+$77;)($%)+)+'& $8;% 2$+3='2&$*+?)%6+7?&2%2&*%2&%6& *$A&$+'+;32&A&'3@&)+=$77&$;%%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;4%6&2&A&'3 ?);;@&%%$;;3);;8*236);& );)+=$77&$;@& 2&%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;
> 8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%$=$)+*%$+2'&27$**&'8+'&2 0&(%)+%6&2& 472&B(+')%)+ '&7*)% >J %6&'&@%'8& 2A 6)A6$*%@&(A7;)&'?)%64%6&2?)*&%6&$77&$;)*+%%@&&+%&2%$)+&' 6&$A8+%($+@&2&'8(&'+;3%%6&&G%&+% >J4%6$%% 22&$*+*% @&2&(2'&')+?2)%)+=2)2%%6&$A&+'A&+%($22)&'8%5)'& (% )+0&(%)+ %6&0 (%4%6&2&?$*+72&B(+')%)+
2'&7*)% $+3$A8+%@& 2&&+%&2%$)+A&+% $77&$;4?6&+*8(6$+ $77&$;?$*A$)+%$)+$@;&$=$)+*%$+2'&27$**&'8+'&20&(%)+ %6& (% 77$2&+%2&$*+%6&2& 2?$*%6$%0&(%)+4$*&G)*%&'
72)2% %6&$A&+'A&+%4725)'&' 2 $+ $77&$; $=$)+*% $(%)+ 8+'&2 0&(%)+ # %6&0 (%?)%6$72&B(+')%)+ '&7*)% >J %6&$A8+%(;$)A&')+%6&+%)(&8+'&20&(%)+
#?)%67?&2%%6& 2)@8+$;%?$)5&
22&'8(&%6&*$A& *$ %&2$A&+'A&+%4$ %&2%6& :8'=A&+% +.@;&%6&0872&A&82%)+ "$2')$6&A)($;*/%'$+' %6&2*.($*& *872$#472(&&')+=*8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (% ?&2&6&;'%@&2)=)+$;)++$%82&$+'+%$77&;;$%&4%6&(+')%)+ 72&B '&7*)%?$*'&;&%&'$+')%?$*$''&')+0&(%)+ %6&2& 4?6)(6725)'&'
2$77&$;"&$+)+=%6&2&@34)+($*&$+$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0 (%)*')*A)**&')+'& $8;%$+'%6&+;32&A&'3$5$);$@;&4$* *8==&*%&'@3%6&2)@8+$;4)*$77&$;%%6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;4?)%68%%6&2& @&)+=$+3$':8')($%)++A&2)%*4%6&$==2)&5&'7&2*+?);;6$5&%'&7*)% >J %6&$A8+% '&@%*'8&%+;3%6)*4)+%6&72(&**4%6&A$%%&2 A$3@&'&;$3&'$+'&5&+%6&2&;)& 72$3&' 2A$3@&2&+'&2&')+ 28(%88*
%%6&%)A& 6&$2)+=4+725)*)+?$*2& &22&'%@3$+3 %6& (8+*&;4 ?6)(6 (+ &2* 7?&2* + %6& 2)@8+$; % ')*A)** %6& $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%)+'& $8;%4)+($*&
C %6&$2=8A&+%)*%6$%%6&%&2AE$77;)($%)+F8*&'%6&2&)+*68;'@&2&$'?)%6 2& &2&+(&%%6&A&$+)+=$**)=+&')+8;& (# %6&-- 8;&* 2%6& 7827*& ')*A)**$; $+ $77;)($%)+ 8+'&2 0&(%)+ # %6& (%4%6&7?&28+'&20&(%)+
# # (%($+@& &G&2()*&'4%6&+2&A&'3$*725)'&'8+'&2*8@B*&(%)+ # =#?);;$;*@& $5$);$@;&+ $(%4%6$%?8;'@&%6&6$2A+)8*(+*%28(%)+
+ $(%4?6&+%6& (%?$*&+$(%&'472)A$2);3%6&2&?$* $77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+-%6&2& ?6)(6(8;'@& );&'@3$+3@$+92
)+$+()$;)+*%)%8%)+ 22&(5&23 '&@%* 2A$+37&2*+08@*&H8&+%;34 %6&2&6$'@&&++8A@&2 $A&+'A&+%*
- %)*$($*&)+?6)(6%6&725)*)+* (%6$5&@&&+ $'7%&'%@& ;;?&'$*72(&'82& 2')*7*$; $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&2 0&(%)+ %6&0 (%)+$((2'$+(&?)%6%6&725)*)+* %6&
(%$+'%6&28;&* 2$A&'%6&2&8+'&24)+($*&$+3%6)+=%6&2?)*&)*+% 725)'&'8+'&2%6&0 (%)%62& &2&+(&%%6&72(&'82&%@& $'7%&' 2')*7*$; $77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%4 +72(&'82&6$* @&&+ 725)'&' %6&2&)+ 0&(%)+
(% 725)'&* 2 72(&'82& $+' 7?&2 %6& 2)@8+$; $+' %6& 77&;;$%& 2)@8+$; 6& (+%&+%)+ %6$% $77;)($%)+ 8+'&2 0&(%)+ %6& (%6$5)+=+%@&&+A&+%)+&'&)%6&2)+0&(%)+ @# %6&
(%28;& (# %6&-- 8;&*4+$77;)($%)+ 22&*%2$%)+ *8(6$+$77;)($%)+')*A)**&')+'& $8;%)*A$)+%$)+$@;&4?);;@&%%$;;3 A)*(+(&)5&'
%)*$($*& ;&=)*;$%)+@3)+(272$%)+4?6)(6)*$(AA+ ;&=)*;$%)5&'&5)(&?6&2&%6&;&=)*;$%82&4 2%6&*$9& (+5&+)&+(& '2$ %)+=)+(272$%&*725)*)+* 2A$+&G)*%)+=*%$%8%&@32& &2&+(&%%6$%
*%$%8%&)+*%&$' 5&2@$%)A2&72'8()+=%6&725)*)+*4?6)(6)%'&*)2&*% $'7%)+$+%6&2*%$%8%&& &2&+(&($+@&A$'&%%6&:8'=A&+% +.@;& %6&0872&A&82%)+ 6$2$%7 $+9 "8A@$)#/%'57 $+9 A;3&&*+)+4 # 0C >+%6&($*&)+6$+'4%6&72(&'82&4$* 725)'&')+%6& (%46$*@&&+$'7%&' 2')*7*$; %6&$77;)($%)+ 8+'&2%6&0 (%08(6$72(&'82&6$*@&&+725)'&')+0&(%)+
(%0&(%)+
#%6&2& 725)'&* 2%6&A$%%&2*)+2&*7&(% ?6)(6%6&2)@8+$;6$*@&&+5&*%&'?)%6*$A&7?&2*$*$2&5&*%&')+ ()5);(82%8+'&2"&$+)+=%6&2&@34 2')*7*$; $77;)($%)+ );&'
8+'&2%6&0 (%@& 2&%6&2)@8+$;4%6&7?&2*$*&+*62)+&')+ (;$8*&* $#% 6# 0&(%)+
# (%?);;@&$5$);$@;&?% (;$)A%6$% 2'&()')+=$77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%4 %6&2)@8+$;?);;@&5&*%&'?)%67?&2*$*(+%$)+&')+0&(%)+
# $#% &#$+' 6# (%4@8%+%$*725)'&')+(;$8*&* #$+' =#%6&2& )*A)*(+(&)5&'+ $(%4$;;%6&7?&2*$*&+*62)+&'%6&2&)+$2&A&$+%%@& &G&2()*&' 2')*7*$; $77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&2%6&0 (%6& ;$+=8$=& 0&(%)+
(%)*=&+&2$;)++$%82&$*8+'&2%6$%
(%4)%)*+%+;3%6&$77;)($%)+*?6)(6$2&%@&'&()'&'4%6&2&$2&%6&2 72(&&')+=*$*?&;;6&72(&'82&*72&*(2)@&'8+'&2%6& (%6$* $;*@&&+$'7%&'%@& ;;?&' 2%6&7827*& ')*7*$; $77&$;*@3 %6& 77&;;$%&2)@8+$;8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 (%
6& (%?$*&+$(%&')+%6&3&$2-- 4$*$A&+'&' 2A %)A&%%)A&6& 0 (%?$*&+$(%&')+%6&3&$2 4$* $A&+'&' 2A%)A&%%)A&6& (%(8;'7**)@;3725)'& 2%6& '& )+)%)+*?)%62& &2&+(&%%6&725)*)+* %6$% (%$+'+%)+%6&2;$? %)*$*7&()$;*%$%8%&6&0 (%6$*$'7%&'%6&72(&'82&4$*
725)'&')+%6& (% 2')*7*$; $77;)($%)+8+'&20&(%)+ # 2%6$%7827*&4?&+&&'+%%=%%6&'& )+)%)+4&)%6&2$*725)'&')+ 0&(%)+ @# (%28;& (# %6&-- 8;&*&+;3+&&'
%*&&0&(%)+
#$+' =# (%4?6&2&%6&72(&'82&$+'7?&2 %6&2)@8+$;6$5&@&&+725)'&' 2')*7*$; %6&$77;)($%)+4?6)(6 ?8;'A&$+&5&+$+$77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ %6&0 0
(%
0)+=;& &+(6 ;;$6$@$' )=6 82% )+ "I* 3%) G%2$(%)+ 2)5$%& /)A)%&' $+' $+%6&2.* ($*& *872$# 7)+&' %6$% $77;)($%)+ );&' 8+'&2 0&(%)+ # %6& 0 0 (% ($+ @& ')*A)**&')+'& $8;%8+'&20&(%)+
# # (%$+'%6&2)@8+$;
)* $;* 5&*%&' ?)%6 %6& 7?&2 % *&% $*)'& %6& 2'&2 ')*A)**$; $77;)($%)+)+'& $8;%)+%&2A* *8@B*&(%)+ # =#%6&2&
)5)*)+ &+(6 %6)*82%)+"I*02)1)*6+80%&&;*.($*& *872$#7)+&'%6$%)+($*&*A&*8@*&H8&+%72(&&')+=*6$5&%$9&+7;$(& $ %&2 );)+= *&(82)%)*$%)+ $77;)($%)+ 8+'&2 0&(%)+ # %6& (%4%6&+;32&A&'3)*+%% );& 2&*6$77;)($%)+4@8%&5&+ $77;)($%)+ 2 $A&+'A&+% %6& $77;)($%)+ &$2;)&2 );&' )* $;* A$)+%$)+$@;&
2%6&2&$*+*A&+%)+&'$@5&4%6&?2)%7&%)%)+)*$;;?&' 6& H8&*%)+ )* $+*?&2&' )+ 7*)%)5& % )* 6&;' %6$% $77;)($%)+ 2 2&*%2$%)+ $+$77;)($%)+ );&'8+'&20&(%)+ # %6&0 0
(%4?6)(6)*')*A)**&')+'& $8;%4)*A$)+%$)+$@;& 2%6&2)@8+$;
> 2'&2'$%&' > 7$**&'@3%6&2)@8+$;)**&%$*)'&$+'
%6&A$%%&2)*2&A)%%&'@$(9%%6&2)@8+$;%'&$;?)%6%6&$77;)($%)+ 2 2&*%2$%)+)+$((2'$+(&?)%6;$?
-
C 6&7$2%)&*%628=6%6&)2(8+*&;*$2&')2&(%&'%$77&$2@& 2& %6&2)@8+$;+ 2 82%6&272(&&')+=* $:&*6 )+'$;# 8'=& 825)+'&20)+=6);;# 8'=&
- A9 6&%6&2*7&$9)+=I2&$*+&', &*I 6&%6&22&72%$@;&, &*I