M/S Mangat Rice And General Mills v. Pswc And ANR
!"#!$%&%"'(
)& '* %$! '+!'!, - %--& . ! % %"'!,& /!,&0&
0'1 23 ! ,!4"0&%'*",5", %"' '+ '" 4!, . !&5"'+!' & ( 67
3/ 3
/ 3 7
! "
#$% &
'
( ) "
" *" ) +++ ,
-" ./ !
0+
) )
1 +++23$.)
"
) ) 4 "
5 )
)) !" 6
-2- 7
"
8!
")
.&
)
+++ !
! " 2 9 !
:(
6 & '
, ;6&'9/ "
& " "
! )
77 !) ) ) %# *"
( "
++7!) ) )7%7*"
$ 1 1
"
.& 373% !) ) ) 2< *"
1 "
"
( 77 !)
$ 373%!) ) )2<*"
72% !) ) ) +%+3 *"
) '
#227*"
.6&' )
=" ) )
6&'
!
7*"
0
)
'
! " ) !
) )
) " +< *"
-
.
-3- - ! )
)
!
++ ! ) 1 7<+2$. )
>+?
" 2++2 ! )
-".% - 77 ! : ! !
"
.
) !8 "
: 2 ! +<<#! = @")& )
! " "
327
) " ! )
)! )& 1 0#<7
!
)&" %7%
"
)
! 8"
)
)! & 0+3%<+.&.''.% & 1 0#<7! )&" &
! )&"
"
! ! +#73
= @") & ) 8")
++++2
!8 ! "
: 2 ! +<<# 77 ) !
0+ A "
8! :
-4B" )& , ! ;:B &9/
&
" 5 " !
( ! = $ ) ) = & "
& " 3,/ )
"
! "): ! "
& " )
77
= $ ) ) = ( ) )
+++ & *"
" +++,
-"./ ! ! ) )= :B & ! 1 +++23$. "
!
0.= ) :B &
! " +? +2? !
"!8
)
B
!
. ! !
"
)
'
! "
:B & -
++7 !) ) )7%7*"
" $ 11
)
( '
!
" "
:B & "
)"
.
-5-
373% !) ) ) <27 *"
( "
:B & :( ) ( ! ( 72% !) ) ) +%+37 *"
"
)
!!
" "
! )
+. !"
"
.
1 " ) " .
) " , /!
;9 1 32#+3*"
1 ,%7C)( )/ 1 7 ,7C)( )/ :
2% ,%7C)( +3*"
2%*"
<3#2*"
,+3*"
1 / #%<+3*"
11
"
*" 8 ! 6&'"
*"
B" ) & ( 8 )
)
+7%*"
6&' :B &"
-6- ! ! !
.& +#7+# 8
! " "
D "
"
*" .! !
! & " )
+++ "
! (
! 8" "
: "
"
! ") !"
& " 3,/ )
.! !
"
& " )
'
" )"
)
)! ) )= ) )
" ! ) 8" "
" 8"
! ) ) !
.
" ) '
) ) )
- ! "
!
.
"
.
"
) !
&
) )
-7- " "
" )'
"
+2+2 )
" ) ") "
( " 37+2 ) : C"
"!
*" ( ) !"
8" %3+2
0 !+2
"
"
) )
#+++2
"!
*" = !+2D )
- +++
) "
! & *" 6" )
! "
! ( "
8" "
! ! )
!
-8- & '
"
E *" +++
) "
! ) )=
.& "!
- ! "
.
!55
.
!(
*"
"
) !"
"
( !! ! " )
( " !
( !
. ,:B &/!"
! "
!"
*"
! "
)! *"
( " ) !
) "
)
. ! "
! ! ) 8 1 "
) "
"
! !
) ) "
: +%2 &&! '
) ))
)! '
* )
-9- !
"
" "
! )
0+.
& *" "
! "
& " )
& " 0 "
.
!
" # $ % & $ % & " ( ) !
) ) ) % $ !
-10- ) "
* % # ) +,,- .
) ! "
"
- )
!
& F
" " F "
" !
F "!.
6&' "!.
" " "
"
)
)
( ) )
"
*" ! ) ) *"
)
*" " ! ) ) ! "
*"
!
" ) ! B &"
!" "
! !
)
!
"
"
) !
"
! !
"
*" ! )&"
-11- " "
"
*" 8" *" ! ! " ) ) &" ")) ! ! " !
)
" ! ( "
, / !
"
)
"
! ) 8" ! ! ! ) ! , / " !
"
! "
7?
! +7 ! !
! *" ) "$!82!,9 (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ)
B ( )$ G $0 B !
G $0