High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/2244/2008disposed of

Krishan Lal And Others v. State Of Haryana Etc.

2026-03-09Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja8 pages

!" #"$

!" #"$ %& ' %& ' %& ' %& '

& !

& ( ) ( & & & & & & & &

&0 &0 &0 &0

D /

) * + ,, * + ,, * + ,, * + ,, - - - - + + + + & & & & ,&+ ,&+ ,&+ ,&+ 7744 7744 7744 7744 '

+!, !, !, !, ,,!

,,!

....& + !

& + !

# # # # # # # # 7 7 7 7

+ + + + & & & &+ + + +

? '

+!, '

+!, ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# #

7744 7744 7744 7744 - - - - * + ,, * + ,, * + ,, * + ,, ,&+ ,&+ ,&+ ,&+ 7 7 7 7 / + + + + & & & &

? ' ' ' '

+!,

+!, ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# #

7744 7744 7744 7744 - - - - %,$

%,$

+ + + + & & & & - - - - $ & $ & $ & $ &

& 7 7 7 7

+!, '

+!,

? ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# # ,,!

.& + !

# #

7744 7744 7744 7744 7 7 7 7 !0 !0 !0 !0

#20 2 2

2 1%,$"+

! *+

1%,$"+

! *+

1%,$"+

! *+

1%,$"+

! *+

"$ %@2&52.6 34&52.6 7744A42 8$.& . 29 BBBB "$.$24 "$.$24 "$.$24 "$.$24

*+ :(; - <<22. 2 <=342277 4. 2 8= < 6 2 3 << C3A 2

646= 4 C3 4 2 5 8269. 2 <

8=5 2< : ; %9 9 72 774. 4 44= 8 4 2 D

?789424& &2$3=.#72

2 E 2!32F 82 22 :/; %2 49 =. 72 . 2 4 89 7744G4 2.326 3 644=34. 4

2.&2 #7<8C326

( (

332+ ) ,C3.( 2 E(

F 27649 2 7 7384 7327. <49. I 23

%4 2 2< & & (?

G5= & (>/> G,. 2 &989 22=&72< F232+(( 7 789,C3 !442 22E,!F (> (

/. 289 <25 643 C32 4 H .

AG7 224=4423 3298 2726 32( :

; & 2 7 89 ,!. 7744A4 265 232 2+( ( . < 8 72 49 44 89 42

2 !32 6 2 D

?. 4=2=<<7 7H/.

AG72 82 =4423298 A 22 63232(

==26 2 . 72 774 2 72 22 42 4427A+

:>;

<7 73== 2 2. 42 34

7744A4 238<42 2!32226= 53 34723 897744,23 4

32238< 4(D

J#G =472 2C3285 34=<2 25 643 :>(; , 234473 772H(>K 8 77462 872 4 (D

J#G 2 < =7 8 2< 4 3 32 + ( . 72

( 2=49. <25 643 2C32 8 2G

632 77 744A42 :); 2 . 42 + 34 38< 42 2!32 2=772= 746389 7744A4 2.7449@3 =672 42 2!32C3= <25643 C324

2< .

AG72 2 /.

AG 7 2 2 3. <73= @3=<4 848 2789,! 8 22 :?;

6 2 42 34 72 = 23= 77285 4422

3838< <84 7744A42 :

; %

272= 322.= 4723898 8 377 72 24<J2 2320G

+4 +4 +4 +4723 723 723 723 3897744A4 3897744A4 3897744A4 3897744A4 2 2 2 2 -44= -44= -44= -44= J8 J8 J8 J8 +4 +4 +4 +4 & & & & < < < < 2 2 2 2 < < < < #322 #322 #322 #322 , , , , 732 732 732 732

4<3

4<3 72 72 72 72 2 2 2 34 J#G( -5 ) ( )

( + *2G +74 +A + < $2 -5 ?(

? ((DDD 3 )(D + < += +A + ! +A + $3=44 /AA>A (* ( 2 (/A/ M

*G(/ >.D

AG ?. ).(> > AG 34 J#G + 62 23= 2= +A +

35< ! -5 ?(/

? ((DDD 3 )(D/ +<<2@ *32 LA + -9 +=2 +A + < (((A(DA *G)N >*( M/(*G) (?.) .D >AG .D

AG 34 J#G/ + 62 23= 2= +A +

35< ! -5 (/) (D

3 ) ?/ +< 92 &6 * /?> (((A() )*G N D* M (/*G( ?.> .)/?>

AG 34 J#G + += +A #23 +A + 3@@2 > A DD + +32 *3<2 +A + &7 > A DD

?AA( ?*G > ?*G( M( *G (D2 > A DDM *G( ./

AG ?./).

AG 34 J#G> -5 ?

(

3 )/ ? + +38 ! +A + < += +A + ! ,4

2 + +38 ! +A + +38 ! +A + #24

A 2 (/ AA(D *G( +2

*G(M / +C'2

AG / .(?.

AG +4A3< +4A3< +4A3< +4A3< < < < <72389 72389 72389 7238927 27 27 27 -44= -44= -44= -44= J8 J8 J8 J8 +4 +4 +4 +4 & & & & < < < < 2 2 2 2 < < < < #322 #322 #322 #322 -5 >(

(

2 , , , , 732 732 732 732

4<3

4<3 72 72 72 72 2 2 2 34 J(A% +< *<4 &6 L #27 +A+ < >(*G

A( > MD*G (.) .>

AG (.

AG 34 JL(A% % -5 ??( ((

+ 2 +A + != +A +$3=4 +@8 +=+A +! +=+A +* < 2 2 >AA ?*G? (A 2 M/*G(/> >AA(DA (*GD *G

M D*G D +2 (A 2 M

*G( > M *G (.)

AG (.> ./ / (AG

:D; 2 < 86 84. 8 4 72389 27G+72 727 3 2 + ( .382437 7 2 .4 (

J#G>7232 2 897744 A42722 2<32=/ C924

AG 872 / .(?.

AG7 2248=2 < 2 J2<49<44724 4 (24.2C3 2 4 72 *4 / 24 3 23<. 2<=4 J#G(J#G 2 853 :D(;

6 6 2.4 (D

J# #G 24= <263 644= 34.6 *4 24 4 4H ./

AG8 872 ?./).

AG72

== =472722 82437 27327 2<

<25643 .7449.5 4 4 489 F847J!32 22<4-+

22<4-+

29.272

29.272 E

!!64?> E

!!64?> > > > > F....72=643 3 4 J<742 8 24 37 4 = <25 643 <73429 4 C3 46 72=27 ? 2<

22<4F

22<4F 3722J22320G G I ?

.22<3 <34744 <44274. 272 8 6484 6 6 2 <= <7 + 2 4=4 <7< 2= 3 4 . 4= =4 72=2 <7 < 72 34 8 9<3844 22<=<25643 38 8C349. 7749 C3 3 3 < 43 43J<938 3 24*@

24*@ 24*@

24*@

6 + 6 + 6 + 6 + + #3@8. ( > +!! + #3@8. ( > +!! + #3@8. ( > +!! + #3@8. ( > +!!

/ 2 !32 4

44 40 P 42 2 2 624 J<742 2 2 <424.=24234 4= J<742.

8 2. 8 2 7L48= = <73424959 2<72 2. 4 = 643 43 <42 4 449 9 6 8 228 44= 7322 44 = 442 2 83 <

C3P

6822 + <<+=6+ + <<+=6+ + <<+=6+ + <<+=6+ #. #. #. #.

(/()+!!/D

(/()+!!/D 22G@3 3=8 !324 62 2372

2< 23<222<34 74 4 6484 22 .!3244249= 643 43J<7423472 4 44222=. 4 434=62= 643 2<98<2=233Q :( ;

5 5= 3 4 J#G (D

. 2 C3 72 << 6 6

(O 2<=7 23 (92.8 4J J#G 3

32+ . 384 77 72 8 2

632 7 7744A42 72 .76 = =

8 2 22 89 42 2 !32 C3 44 74 6 = 4 32 2 C3 246 72 2 272 32320G I(

62. 73 644= 34 3 6 9 #7 37 #7G 5 <49. 34 3 3 @ 644= &2 2 , C3 !442 2 <7 2

/.>

AG 72 2 < 49.

C C324=49 2494 =62427629926 22 82= 3 C32 4 = 74 2 3 < <<243247327 2=49.722@3

4<= 9 2 2 3

C C324Q

3 23<. 4 5 = 3 C3 2 4= 4474643 3.772 H ( K723< <82628 872 ?./).

AG72 26 2< 4 (D

J#G < ./ AG7 22 :((;

62. 2< 89 42 2 + 34 8 23 2< <263

4 4 2<=72 4 (D

J#G 4 772J<49 / 2

2<2 7C324. 3H >K 2 8 47248774 74496 489774 44A42726 <7264 4 724 2<=72 4 (D

J#G 28 =72 C324 2=49.897749=3 H >K 62 < <25 643 ./ AG 72 2. <25 643 C324 2GH).(

AG72 22 :( ; 32 22.=6 C3 22 3 2 7384 7327. < 49. I 2 23 %42

2<& (?

G5 =&(>/> G,. 2&9 89

22=&72 2<Q3.27 23

294 2

7<3< 34R 2 C32 2 32 J732 2 726= 4 223324< .32647< 8<7 :(/; 2=49. <25 643

2 4 32 C3 H) ).(

AG722 32+

(

.424 44484 22

44 329 8 2726 3 2 726 ( <37 42444 84 243<H/

K 82

2237 :( ; ! C349. 6 3 < 2 86. 77472 22 7744A4 2289724944 2 2< 774 4 8 89 + 29 2. 3 < :(>; L 262 42 A 6 3 2349 J72 774A2G 8@ 2 4=2 4=4268 <74. 9 9 44 8 4829 5 J 3 72 89 <6=77272 27748 24 2J3=!32 :(); 44 7=774. 9. 4447 *+ "$ *+ "$ *+ "$ *+ "$ $"& $"& $"& $"& 2 2 2 2

D....

) ) ) ) 5 L L 275=A2 ' 227284 ' A A