← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/2320/2024dismissed

Vivek v. State Of Haryana And Another

2024-07-16Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages



 

           "%&'()&*+,+'-./    ))  +

        

 .)  

 

    

* 3  

 

 ))  2   4 

5

   

4

     2 4 

    

 *)  + )     / #  66666

  !"#$ 

  ))    

     '8

     



  !"! 

   

 7!"!

! ;*)33

  #$%&#%# #'( ) *    ))   

3 

) 8

+  ) 

,-./ "$  %$%'#%#'    '0  '! 1#1  1' 1$'8 1$'89:$%&

-   1 # 

!"!

 (   #   

 ,-.   ))  

    8   

           

!"#$% 

 & % %      ' (          ) 

 '

*  + ' , -  ./ )0   % &  * *   1! ( 

  .

'  ( 1"-& &( -( //  1" -  2     3         

( - *( *

 

#

 ( *.

'   & . (        -- & 

 

/  0- *(  - *     

 - ( * 

  '

 &((      

       / /         

   -(-(-- *

( '

*4/ *   * &  5     '

*     /(    *( *;( "

"

$"$ $  *  "/-         -( -(- - *( * &( /-    

 - (%(

*.

'-   -  *  * & * -*

 ( *6/   %  %

'- /   /  -(  * ( *  (6 6/    & -- -  *  

 '   (  *         * & &     (  &    %    (  

(   -   *    *45

  '(

   '

  '

    * //



*   (           * (  *      * & *  *      -  / & /     *  -

(   -

    & -- * & * *   (  *  (     -      &    -'(   -  0 

  * 45  (     - &- & /

0      & -- - !    ( - - --    7'

   8!  (   %  '  ( -

 -'  -  *   (  * & * *    -'9       ((    

'

7  &  -

 (  8 8   (   8 8  ( )0   (  8 8  :   (  8 8  :       & *       

(       -  -

 & -- /  -



 

(    -  

0 

       

1  8 8      * * (   * & 0    /  '

(&-  0

    /    &  

    /    (   -7   ./    

*  - & 0 ( ( - *

( 

- /  / /  -

* - -'   (  



< = &'   

&(0-     & -- /    -     &  .( // (= = &'  -  & ( / ( *       &  + /     & - & 0     . -    *    *( 2        & + /    - 

   * *       

 *  * / / >%) *  --  /  0 - ( '

(  * &      

98 7// -



       ? 1 <  

 ))    3  ))     

*)     ,-.   3         

  He furth her submits that the incident w was recorded in the CCTV cameras of the vi icinity wherein it is clearly visi ible that the a appellant has not actively partici ipated in the commission of crim me.

Furthermo ore, from the bare perusal of the e FIR in question, no allegations s of stalking o or giving beating, abusing, mol lesting etc is made out against the appellant.

. Moreover, appellant himself f belonged to a scheduled ca aste category a and, thus, no offence under the said Act is made out against h him.

<  

 ))   3  ))    (  (3 4 3  =

)   ) 8

+  ) 

  ) 

 ' <     )) 3 

 ) 



  )) )  33  3   *  3  )) 



'      *   ))  ( 3

   *   ) )      **

   *    *      *)   *

  *    )

  *  

     &'

'

    !01     )  3  

 *        

   +

  !"! 3    ))  :   3     3  ) 

   

         )

   %!%0#%# #'   (

   8  @  *  - 

& *   -     -- 8--   A. (2 (       *   -  / 8 /   $  "

"

$"$  *

- 8 --  - */// 8 --  -' /     @ //8 --   *  & - /(  * - -* * ( @- / 8/ 

  9  : 72  )8    & /-

- *     *  / @//8-- 

     9 #1

$$! 1!

87!

8. !" %:- 4$54&5 59@7--   :CC7 7-

-

 7  *//8--  * *  * ( &   *& (

-* ( -  (//8- -- - 8--   



- -  / (  @* &  >%) * //8--  

@-     *

//8--  B

     *

 -- &(   / /    -- - 8 --          --      .(

 & *B 

- /  /( /   -  

-    

 <  

 )  / #8 *)        ))   )  ))  33   ))   

**

$   

 3  *)   

     

) 8

+ ) 

  & -     

)   )  

 0 -(   )) 

   43*



 )      



        !



%%'#%#'>  (

   8  @       (   /  *  / (9/8  /-

-45 1

7-

 -      ( + D   /    -    

 

  4 /5      -  /     - 0

- ( & ( - / 9/ - 

- / 8 - -  

?     /  -    & 

?:

   0 * & */(+  D /  E  *  

 -  1 87  1

 7-



-  $"" $"1  -/ & / &  -

 

:1 # //(  - 1

7- 

 ( 0 *    -

  (    @ &   / &  - 1 87 1

7-- / 0 - 

 + D  /     - - 



  4 / /5



E        ( /   / ( /-

-45 1

7- - -E  -  /

      / &   - // -        /  - -

7-      8 *  -/



  - * 0 -  / -  

1 @ &   B

& -(  

*  / (  /-

-45 1

7-    -   7/   / ( /-

- -45

1

7-    -*/ &  -  // -          /  -  -   

-45 1

7-E - - /  / 

-   & 

     8* * - / (



  - * 0 - 

& / -  @  *  ( * 2 &*

  - /  (   8    * &   - 0   -   &( - - /- (-  -  - - /- 

$

         -  -   45 / ( /-    4 

   592- & /-  

      -  1  1

 7-    /

 / ( /-

-45 1

7- 0- ( *     (

 &-   *      -  -- - /  - -- *  @ -   0 * + D /    

  4

/5 



  4 / /5 -(  -    -  /       -  *  

   -     -    

  %    /-    4     592-

& /-    -  0-  -  / (   *      (  

(   0 -   %- - 

/ 8

(+ D / 4     &5  

  ( - 

  0- -/

 7/  *    & -   

*/ - /

/ *F 4%57/ *  /  ( 9/8

 - -

  :1 #    /-

-45*   &  -      -    @ -

 @ 4:& 7 - 57 7-1

 4%%5 -  / -  *  (  0  - (

-  2  -- - -E  * /  

-45   -

   @ -  @  4:& 7 - 57-1

- -E /  - - -

  ?   - /  - ?   -   &? - 

?   8*  -/ /

 -   - *  0 -    / -   ?   % %     /*

- ( (2 &9- -

& /  

  -8   / /-

* &-&(-

 /-   -  2 4%%%5 7/-  G

  - ( 

  / -  1 415   -    @ -  @  4:&  7 - 5 7- 1

H9  2- & /-    G G (

    / -  1    -    @ -

0 @  4:&  7 - 5 5 7- 1

H  - /   0 -

/   /  *  

/ ( 

  -  : 1 #  /-  

-45 -     -

   @ -  @  4:&  7 - 5 7- 1

 -/-  92- &/ -   *  -  - / ( *  - /  *    

   ( / &  -    -  1 91 475   7-  B

 &     -- -

    2-  - 

-/-  92- &/- 



* -  /    &

/- -  --  / * 1

7-? "

 )   3   )

   ,-.  ?           3   

 3  ))  * * 3  )   3  

 3 3    ))    ** 

 &'

  !01   3 (  8    3         * 

 (  )     *) ) *              )   * -  3 *

  (  3  ) 

3 

 ) 

         ?

 (  3 3   3  3 3     

3  (* 3    



>      >



 3     )

 (*) 

 3 3 ?

 -*)    )     =)   * ) 



*

 3:

  3     3   *    

   /  -    *   3   ))  

         

   !"!

 ))   

  *)  

3*     

  )

" ))     ))  *   3        3



     3   ** 

             

    !"!  3(   8  (       3 3      3

       3 

 

  

     ))     ?             

 ) 

  - 3  (  3            *    3

     ( ( *       ))   8    ))    3  ) 

    (      *)*   

 3   



3     

  )     ))  

       

) 

 2

     

3 

  ))     

 

3  :

:    ))     



*   *  !



  *  + +

 *   

      

 * 

   3 3 3         )   

 ( ( (  

3  (

 % 3 ))           ) 

 @& # 70(   #%#'   $   A ) 3+    B+/ A )

 B+/