High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19543/2014disposed of

M/S S.R Industries v. Kishan Kumar & ANR

2016-03-01Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain6 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*"+&, "#$ %$&'(')*"+&, "#$ %$&'(')*"+&, "#$ %$&'(')*"+&,-.

-. /(0)%1(#+'$( $#'#')$+ 2$+(1( 3'(,")314"+")%")#,$+ $(5)%$)#( * * * * 670 00

670 00

670 00 +$($)#* +$($)#* +$($)#* +$($)#* + (,8")'"9(,'- %:&"#$

+#,$5$#'#')$+ (0)'"0');,- %:&"#$

++$(5)%$)# <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< <<<<< -

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

#,$)%1(#+'"= '(51#$( &#- C6 &#6 +(,+#

$#'#')$+')'#(8+'##$)(#"#$4$)#":$++$%#,"##,$ )'#,"%"=+$"%A@$$)&=($%')#,$A$"+ #8"( 1+#,$+ ":$++$%#,"#+$(5)%$)#,"%)#51#')4+$#,") %"A( ($+:'&$")%,"%,'4($= =$ ##,$B@) .C ) #,$ 5=$"%');( #,$ 5"+#'$(- ==8'); '((1$( 8$+$ +"4$%@A#,$)%1(#+'"=+'@1)"=?&14?7"@1+1+#*? D ,$#,$+ #,$ ($+:'&$( 8+94") 8$+$ '==$;"==A#$+4')"#$%E ("(#8,"#+$='$ ,$ '($)#'#=$%#E ,$#,$+#,$+$(5)%$)#,"(&=($%'#(1)'#') #,$A$"+ E (-#8,"#$

$&#E

,$#,$+ #,$ 5+$($)# +$ $+$)&$ '( )# 4"')#"')"@=$E

$='$ F "+#'$( =$% #,$'+ $:'%$)&$ ') (155+# #,$'+ +$(5$&#':$ 5=$"( ,$+$"

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

$&$4@$+ ) "&#-#,$+94"),"%,'4($= =$ ##,$B@ ")%,"% "'=$%#$(#"@='(,#,"#,$,"%51#')4+$#,") %"A( ($+:'&$8'#,#,$5$#'#')$+ 7$"+)$%&1)($= ++$(5)%$)#-)#,$#,$+ ,")%-,"((1@4'##$%#,"#+$(5)%$)#,"%(1&&$(( 1==A $(#"@='(,$%#,"#,$,"%51#')4+$#,") %"A( ($+:'&$ 5+'+##$+4')"#') ,'(($+:'&$( $(5)%$)#8"( ='"@=$#@$5"'%8";$(#'==#,$)'#8"(&=($% )#,$5+$($)#&"($-#,$&"($ +$(5)%$)# 8"( #,"#,$ ,"%8+9$% + 4+$#,"))$A$"+8'#,#,$ 5$#'#')$+8,$),'(($+:'&$(8$+$#$+4')"#$%) .C 8'#,1#&45=A');8'#,#,$4")%"#+A5+:'(')( 0$&#')

&#,$&"($ #,$5$#'#')$+-)#,$#,$+,")%- 8"(#,"#+$(5)%$)#,"%,'4($= =$ ##,$B@

5$+1("= &+((?$>"4')"#') ))$>1+$?. 015#"+$:$"=(#,"##,$("'%8'#)$((,"%"%4'##$% #,"##,$+94"),"%8+9$%8'#,#,$'+)'# +)$A$"+ 1+#,$+%$5($%#,"##,$8+9 +$(5)%$)#8"( ("#'( "&#+A-@1#,$1($%#+$4"')"@($)# +4%1#A $

1+#,$+(#"#$%#,"#,$,"%)#@+1;,#")A+$&+%+$;"+%'); #,$"@($)&$ #,$5$#'#')$+"(#,$)'#8"(=A');&=($% ,1(-'#8"($(#"@='(,$%)+$&+%#,"#+$(5)%$)# ,"% 51# ') 4+$ #,") )$ A$"+ ($+:'&$ 8'#, #,$ 5$#'#')$+ $#'#')$+,"% "'=$%#$(#"@='(,#,"#+$(5)%$)# ,"%,'4($= =$ ##,$B@"()+$&+%')#,'(+$;"+%8"( 5+:$%)#,$ '=$$#'#')$+,"% "'=$%#$(#"@='(,#,"##,$

($+:'&$( +$(5)%$)# ,"% @$$) +$#+$)&,$% " #$+ &45=A'); 8'#, #,$ 5+:'(')( 0$&#')

#,$ &# $)&$- #,$ ($+:'&$( +$(5)%$)# ,"% @$$) '==$;"==A #$+4')"#$% )#,$&"($ 1)'&'5"=1)&'=- ')"";"+-$,('= 1)'&'5"=1)&'=- ')"";"+-$,('= 1)'&'5"=1)&'=- ')"";"+-$,('= 1)'&'5"=1)&'=- ')"";"+-$,('= '(## 1+%"(51+ 2$+(1( +$('%');

'&$+- 7"@1+ 1+#- '(## 1+%"(51+ 2$+(1( +$('%');

'&$+- 7"@1+ 1+#- 1+%"(51+")%")#,$+- 1+%"(51+")%")#,$+- 1+%"(51+")%")#,$+- 1+%"(51+")%")#,$+- 0 -#,$ 1==$)&, #,'(1+#,"(="'%%8)#,$ ==8');5+')&'5=$(*? ' 3$$5');'):'$8#,$+$&;)'($%58$+ #,$ )%1(#+'"= +'@1)"= # %'+$&# +$')(#"#$4$)# ) "&&1)# #,$:'="#') 0$&#') ?

&# #,$("4$&"))#@$%$)'$%(=$=A)#,$;+1)% #,"# "55')#4$)#( 8$+$ 4"%$ @A 51@='& @%'$( ";"')(# 51@='& 5(#( ")% 8$+$ )# ') "&&+%")&$ 8'#,#,$+$=$:")#(#"#1#+A+$&+1'#4$)#+1=$( '' ,$($##=$%5('#') ="8"(,"(@$$)(1;,# #@$"%%+$(($%@A#,'(1+#'(#,"##,$5+:'(')( 0$&#') ?

@$');4")%"#+A")%)"&&1)# :'="#') #,$("4$-#,$+$#+$)&,4$)#81=%@$ :'%"@')'#'"('

'#8"()$:$+')5$+"#')")%- #,$+$ +$-#,$$45=A$$81=%@$%$$4$%#@$ &)#')1');')($+:'&$ ''',$+';,# +$')(#"#$4$)#-,8$:$+-'()#") "1#4"#'& +';,# "( (1&, ")% 8,'=$ %'+$&#'); +$')(#"#$4$)#-#,$7"@1+1+#8'==,":$##"9$ ')#&)('%$+"#'):"+'1("(5$&#("(##,$)"#1+$ "55')#4$)#- #,$ ":"'="@'='#A " 5(#- #,$ ":"'="@'='#A 8+9-8,$#,$+#,$"55')#4$)#8"( 5$+($+1=$(")%#,$(#"#1#+A5+:'(')(")%#,$ =$);#, ($+:'&$ ")% #,$ %$="A ') +"'('); #,$ ')%1(#+'"= %'(51#$ @$ +$ ")A "8"+% +$')(#"#$4$)# &1=% ==8 ') &"($( 5$+()(

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

5$>1+#-"()#'&$%"@:$ :'' $ % )# (1@(&+'@$ # #,$ :'$8 #,"# #,$ 51@='& "1#,+'#'$( &1=% &="'4 ##"= '441)'#A ")% 5+#$&#') +4#,$5+:'(')( 0$&#')( ?

")% ? &#@A#"9');+$(+##")%(,'$=%');

#,$4($=:$()"&&1)# "&##,"##,$5(#( 8$+$)# '==$%15')"&&+%")&$8'#,#,$+$=$:")# (#"#1#+A+$&+1'#4$)#+1=$(")%-#,$+$ +$-5$+($ #,$8+94")&1=%)#&="'4+$')(#"#$4$)#F 0')&$ #,$ )'# ,"% &=($% %8)- #,$ )%1(#+'"= +'@1)"=?&14?7"@1+1+#+';,#=A&"4$##,$&)&=1(')#,"# #,$+$='$ +$')(#"#$4$)#&1=%)#@$;+")#$%#+$(5)%$)# 8$:$+-8,'=$ %$"='); 8'#, #,$ '((1$ +$='$ - #,$

)%1(#+'"= +'@1)"=?&14?7"@1+ 1+# $== ') $+++ 8,'=$ "==8');@"&9?8";$(#+$(5)%$)#8$ .C# $&$4@$+ ) "&#-#,$)%1(#+'"=+'@1)"=?&14?7"@1+ 1+# (,1=% ,":$ ;+")#$% =145?(14 &45$)("#') # +$(5)%$)# 9$$5'); ') :'$8 ,'( ($+:'&$ 5$+'% $(5)%$)# ,"% +$)%$+$% )$ A$"+ ($+:'&$ 8'#, #,$ 5$#'#')$+)#,$($&'+&14(#")&$(-#,$$)%( B1(#'&$81=% ,":$@$$)4$#-'

+$(5)%$)#,"%@$$);+")#$%=145?

(14&45$)("#')##,$#1)$ G -/?

&&+%');=A-#,$'451;)$%"8"+%%"#$%

))$>1+$ ? '( 4%'

'$% # #,$ $>#$)# #,"# ') ='$1 +$')(#"#$4$)#-+$(5)%$)#'($)#'#=$%#+$&$':$=145? (14 &45$)("#')# #,$ #1)$ G -/? ')(#$"% #,$ +$='$ ;+")#$% @A #,$ )%1(#+'"= +'@1)"=?&14?7"@1+ 1+# $#'#')$+'(%'+$&#$%#5"A#,$"41)# &45$)("#')# +$(5)%$)#8'#,')#84)#,( +4#,$+$&$'5# #,$ &$+#'

'$%&5A #,'(+%$+- "'=');8,'&,-+$(5)%$)#8'== @$$)#'#=$%#+$&$':$#,$("'%"41)#8'#,')#$+$(#K H5$+ "))14 +4#,$%"#$ 5"(('); #,'(+%$+#'==+$"='("#') $#'#')(#")%(%'(5($% -"&&+%');=A 0 0 0 0 "+&,-.

"+&,-.

4",":'+