Manender Singh v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission And ORS
CWP-14300-2023
!"
"
MANENDER SINGH
HARYANA STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION AND OTHERS
# $%# &' & ( )))))
! "
#
# $ %
&&&&& ' & (* + ,-.
'# (
# ) "
!#
#
*++,+ (# ) # %
"" !
- ..
# ( # ( # !
..
"#! "#
/ 0+1*22,13#!
4
1++5
6 +7
2+*+*(# ) # (!
!#) #
.
" # ! (
# "
+8+,+,+* (# ) ! " #
# ) .
# (
#) "
& 9
-
)# " "#
). # #
%
"" !
- ..
#
!
"
110 "- : . / +8+0 1+0
. 8;
-
# " %
< " # *+ (
! # 7 !
!
. # .) " (
"
. 110 ,*1 #
! # -
( 100'#
) " 6 !. "
# ! " ) ! " ! # $!
(# !#( ) #= :;
% )"
#! ""'#
# <
!
>
.% ). # # . # (
# !
# ! ( )!
# !
?(
# . " ##! )
#$!
( )!
. "
# "
# #6 "
) " ) !
! '# 6 ! "# .
!
!
* * ! # (
"
# $ #
# !
# ! " ! ) # : ;
"
#
#( 6.
4 " #. # !
+2++@ '# (
)!
" # ! )
# 8$!
# !
%). ##
# " "
!
" !. (
"
# ( ( "
!!" # "
!
1+*+ #!
5 7'# ((
" ! # !
(
# "
!
" # (
!
" !
" # 8$!
'#
( #
. ) #
$ .
,+*+ # A
..
% " # !
## . !
"# "
. #
! ( )
)
"
"(
# ( ) 4 !
# ) ' - . !
!
5'-7( #
"+ '#
" # !
. #
. (# " !
"
.B- :C # "" ! " #$ !
% # !? #
.
D. 9.)
"
-E10+2)"
# - :
!
#
# .
. ##.
. :# #
!!
1 1 ! " ! !#
( #
. " #
# 5#(
/ 0 # (
7 # "B- :C #5 7!
'#
%
"" !
- ..
"
(# (#
# "
"! ! (). ) #%
"" !
- ..
# # . " ! "
.)
!
" !. : #. )
# "
.
"
# ) ! ? (
# #
#
/ 0 # (
7 # # !
(# # !. ##)
#$ !
?(
#
$! ( !"
# 4
#) "
. # - ##- ..
#
!"
( # ( "# !
..
.)
*++,+ # !
..
( )
# "!
"#
-
4
#(
"
) .
D. 9.)
( . ( "#"
# : ) #%
"" !
- ..
#
# "#
"
"# !
. 0 '# !
4 # ( - / ! # "
" .
" ! " #
( # " ) #
(# !# )A! . " !#
# (
, 9
-
)# " " #
# #.
0 7 % ). # #
# ! # !
!
!
( !
) # . "
# $ ! ! # $ ! ( )!
( # #!
#! " ! ) #
"# !
.
"
!# # ! # (
. !
# " #
#
"
(
!: " 7 %). # !,+*+ #
#
( # #
$ . ( #
. "
(# % # ) . # ! !
# .
" # ! !# ! ( ) 6 .
# # # !. ! # # "
(
3
(
" 7? ). # # # # " #
" # . ) #"!#
#
. ! #
.
#
" # .
#
"%
# ( .
!
.
! ! #
(
(
:
( # #
# ! #
# . "#. #
#
#
# ( # # ( ) ) # ."
!
"# !
.
, 7 '##
#
!
..
"
! . # # 4 !.
( ## !
"
. #
! "
! #
6 . " " #
"
. # ! " #
# (# # # # ".
!
. .
# :! " 7 %" # !
#
.
D. 9.)
# .
. : # #
#
)
# #!
#$!
# .
. :# #
#
!## - .
# !
!? !
## .
A ! ! (# #- # !: ) ! # 6 ! 4 ) A !
)
! #.
6 #) " .
.
(# ( : " #
! " !
) ! #!
"
.
% ). # # ) ! " !
! 4 ) A !
( (
# - 6 ! A !
) !#4 %"
!
!##
-E10
" +2 .
D. 9.)
(
# # . (
)!#
%
"" !
- ..
# ( # ( !
..
"#
# # "
) " "#
#
@
# . ) !
.
. "
# . " (
%). ##( #
)A!
"
#
" " .
D. 9.)
( #
( # ""! "
. # (# .
D. 9.)
""
. ) #
# # # # !
4 ) " ( # ) 6
" " .
D. 9.)
@ % ! !
"# .
#A.
"# - #. "
-E*++*0 "+@!
+*+*++'# 6 ! # " # F
"
#$%&'%#( )
#$%&'%#( *+ ,-. /
0
0 *+,-.) 1
/
+
,) ). 2
) *+ ,-. ) #(%''%#( 3 )
*+- ) -
3
*+ ,-. ) 4
2 5
/
+
,) ). 2
) *+ ,-.) -
2
6
0
+
0
! % ! !
$
; !#A. "# - 9 / + " +2
2
!
+*+1'# 6 !# " # #$4
7 2
0
4 + )
0 6
# 0
"
%$ 0
2
0 #8 9
/ #(,#.
)
3 #( :
#8
2
0
0 ; )
3
!!"# $! %&"' ( )
*
!$+# $%
%,%< -
)
.
!$/# $$ +" < 0
+ 1** 02 % ,3%+! ! $104 56 5
! $72 $!$ #= 3 2 ( 4
5
8 0)
! %# &,4 > ) ?&@
4)
5 *
0
6 4 )
?? 4) , . 1
4 ) :
@% 4 )
5
4 ) , '##%'%#&.
4) 2
/ 4 )
/ '&$
)
33 7A
B
2
0
4)
2 C
2
4)
; -
4 )
9 *
4)
4 )
4)
@#
0 )
)
-
4) &$ DDD DDD DDDDDD &(6
0 7 A
#% ) 7, 9 . 2
#%
2
A
@'
*
>
? ? : 0 2
3 ) *
) 9
4
9 ,'%'&.))AE) FF@ ) ;
4 )
G
0
;
;
0
( 3 +$8 H ?$8
)
('%#= 0 9
7
3
*
) 2
/
1
2
G 6
0
0 0
2
0
1 2
9 7? /
H (%DDD DDD 3
@@
4 7
)
2
1
1
2
"
2
?
? #F
9 9 #8
3
4 + )
0
4 + )
#8 9
4
'% / #8 9 0 4 >
0 ) ( 4 : , . #8
4
! 2 "
#) !
##$
; !# #! " !
! !
#-
; !#A. "# %
C) .- #. " 5
4
9 G
! + 90 ,,% 6 4 " " #
#
# # " #
"
(# !## # ! + ! !
#A. "#%
C) . - # . " F( )
*
+ !$+#$% %,%# '# 6 !# " # '& 3 -2
+ 4 ) 0
'$ >
)
4 ) 0
,
H,)) =#@&#. ?&#
0
'$I 3
8 B
2
4) >
2
&$ @$
2
4) ?
)
'@ 3 1
3 B )
@
H,)) =$8 &$ &(. ?&$
/ ,: . 4
4
&# #' '%%=3
/
6
/ ,: .
&# #' '%%=/
9 / -
/
/ / / ,: . / &(:
/ ,: .
&# #' '%%=
/ ,: . / 3
? '$ ) -2 9
> /
-2 ? ?
,
. '( 3 * B ) / G ) 0
H,))&&#(. ?( 6
0
? , 9 40 G 9
6*. '=/
*
0 4 2
)
2 '8 3
2
4 2 'F /
5
7 % ). # :
" # !
!. ! (# # ! !
# .
..
"
"
#
. !# ) " # ) 6 '#
#
.
# # "
# ( #
. !
( ) . #
"
.
) "
#) # # (): ## " # "# ".
!# ) )
"
+ #&& *
#)
- !
# #
!
: "# ( . :?(6! " # . # . !
! !
(# ). # !
"
. % # !
# !
# # . :(
# "#
#
? !
# 6
! # ( .
. . #
"
# ( . :%#" # # "! .
D. 9.)
(# # #
". # # #
. "#
! ( ) A
" #
(# # # #
" . !
.
. # ? # (
# # #
" !! # (
# (
. ! # (
#
#( (# !
# ) ""
. # %
#
# !
. #"
(
!#
# "
!
.
. # !
!
$!
! '# #
"
( )" ! # (
: "
# # "" ! (# #
!##- " ("
!
"# # 1 % .# !
). #
! # "! !
) ) #
) #!
# (
) "
# !
" # %
"" !
- ..
( # ( # !
..
# !
4 !
" #
. .
# ! "#
!
) )
" ( 0 / A. # # ( ) ! ) #- "
#
#A. ! ) #- "
#
) # .
(# # A. #
)
: "
6 4 , ? # #
-
)# " " #
! #
#
## !. )
!
& & @ # # #
" "! . # #
# # !
) # ( . # # ) ! " ! ) # .( ## !
! " !
.
#
) '# (
#
#
"
# ! " ! #!
(# !# !
..
# ). ?
##
(#
A
# !
. #
)
(
# !
" 4 "
#'-. #
.
% ! #
.
!! # !
..
" #
) !!
!( ## .
!
?
# # $ ( ) !
# ! ! . "
#!
"!
(
(# !
/
# # .
D. 9.)
#
!# # - !
.
# !
. # $ !
# # " # . :
) '#%
C) .- "?
# (
( #. ";
) 02 6 !!&#$$
%&% ##-
!
. # ! "#" !
(# #
) # #!
!
.
!
. # # '# " # A. " # %
C) .- 6 !# F3 A
)
G 0 G J,#FF(.())'(=K3 0
) ) H,)) '(8. /
,#. ,'.
'#
3
0
* / #F8F
6
,#.,'.
,#. ,'.
2 G 4 7 E
4 J,#FF=.())$&8K )
0
3
H,))$@'. / ''( / &'
) 0
0
L ) J,#FF$. ( )) (8@K > 2 G 0! 3 1
3 )G 9 J,#FF=. & )) &F$K
H ,))&F8F. F6
2
1 ;+7
JA/B @F=
#F8( #= & #F8=K 7
2
)G9 , . 0
7
3
2
#= & #F8= 7
9 G 00 3-
6* G;
J,'%%@.#)) &@=K E
H,))&$F (%&@. &@
#F=( 4 ) #FF' 3 #F=( #FF' ) 9 G J#FF#,#.))#&8K
G
:
)
0
2 3
0
G
4 > E
F##&F$
H 3
H ,. > < ,.
> /
3 2
<
3
,
1
G 02 3
0
2 3
/ B 0
B
B 6
M
7
@ 2 # ## -
!# #!
"#
.
) ) (#
# ( # ) " !: " #. '# "!
"
! # # ( ! " "
("
# ) " "#"
. "
# '#
. # ) "" "
# ! ( # !
.) #
. '#
!! ) #
# . !
#
" # .
"
( " ! "
. # !
; #
"
+0 )"
) .
# . "
!
'( # !
! #) !
. #. (# (# !##
#
# )
A )%#
!
(#
( !# 5
7 #!
"A. ! " !
.# !!
"# !
. +
.
D. 9.)
#
!# # - "
:
# !
. # ! .
. :# #
) )
#$!
'# " #
%
"" !
- ..
)!: # (## #
!
..
! )
#$ !
'#
(
) # "#! # !#
"# # #- (
:
" #
) "
6 6 .
" " ! !
'# ! ! ) #
!. ! (#
(# (
( #
". #) ) ! .
.
!!
" ! . : # #
!!
# "# ! 8
# "# ! # . " # ( #-
!# 6 ! # 4 ) A !
! !#
. (# 6 # ) " #
(# . "#H
"!
" #. # !
!. ! (
)!
" 6 . # # " #
C ( A! # ? ( ) . ! !) .##
) .
( # !# ( ) "
" . H # . !. ! . ! !
. ( #"
# 8 (# . # )
!
. "
# # . #. #) # !"
# % . (
"
# . ##) #
.
(# !
) !
(# 6 .
!
!( ) # . )
) #!#
.
!
.# (
# !## .6 .. ) # . .
! !
!# # # 6 )
: "
!. * #. . # - !
!
"#"!#
!!
"#
*++,+ (# ) #%
"" !
- ..
( # ( #
2
!
..
.) #. " "#
# - #
. # (
"
) .
D. 9.)
C ?
)
") ! "#- #"
#(
##) .
#"! !(
!) # - # (
)"
. ( ! 6
# # !
.
.
# # " # . # # .
D. 9.)
#
# ! # (
)
# . ( .
" " !
" # # !#
( ) ! )) #A !
!- "
(# . A !!
) ! " A !'#- "
#
(
#
# . " (# ( #-
#
!
! # # ( #
)A!
" ) " " " .
D. 9.)
) #. % ! (# ) # 4 !
# A. " # %
C) . - # $
; !# (
# ; !# ) # - ?.
(# (
( #! !
'# .
*++,+ ( # ( # !
..
. ) #
%
"" !
- ..
# )4
2+*+* +8+,+,+* # ( - / ! .
#
C !
!
# ) '#
! #
# ! A #
) !
.
9#.)
) !
.
"#
) " ! ! ? " # !
*+ # ! .
D. 9.)
#
-E10+2 (
# # . # #
# #
. #
""
. # (
"#
# # ) #
# 1 ? " # ! # #
# #
"
#
(# !# # . # !
. )
# " ! # !
- # ( #
)A!
) !
)
( .
D. 9.)
> # .
D. 9.)
( )
) " "
. 5( # 6 !7("#(# #
"
. ( " "#
,+*+'#
" # ! !
!
. !( #
"( .
# " ! "! " !
"#
0 ? .!
##
"
.# "#
C .
# . (
)
# ( #
#
)
!
.
"
! ) " "
#"
+' & (. # * " L E## :
8
I8/ E##
) I8/