High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18482/2019dismissed

M/S Chopra Gas Agency v. Union Of India And Others

2019-07-10Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa4 pages

! "#$%&'(($)*+,-

*././+*'

*'$0$ +/++1/((+1.%*'$

*$&+1*+.$ " 2

" 2

'*$*+.

(%/45(0$%(4!16,(.*'.%*&*././+*'

787878 787878 787878 787878

! *././+*'9"#$%&'(($)*+,-!(:'(4(%($/4*1 .%*/+$.(+.;'/.&*././+$**</+)=0($%/+).%*'1*'$1(.*1 > (+1 ?

! ++*@0'*$ A (+1 ! '*$&*,./6*4-! /$$0*1 B- .%* '*$&+1*+.2/+10$.(+ *.'4*0: '&'(./+ /:/.*1(+1;%*'*B-.%*&*././+*'%($B**+1/'*,.*1..'(+$*' ,*'.(/+ )($ ,++*,./+$ /+ (60' .; .%*' )($ ()*+,/*$! +(:*4-!"#$0&'*:* ($)*+,-(+1"#$(C ($*'6/,* *('+*1,0+$*4;041$0B:/..%(..%*&*././+*'2($ )*+,-%(1B**+(44..*1+A > /$()*+,-;($.%*/'$.

($)*+,-/+.%*.;+(:'(4( ;('1$&*'(./+).%*($ )*+,-!&*././+*'%($,'*(.*1 ,:&4*.* /+'($.'0,.0'*(+1%($ (4$*:&4-*1(+0:B*'&*'$+$ ;($)*+,/*$('*2 +./,*1;*'*(44..*1(.$0B$*=0*+.&/+../:*!/+04-(+1

0)0$.D *('+*1,0+$*40'.%*'0')*1.%(.&'/'/+&/+. ./:*.%*&*././+*'9($)*+,-%(1B**+,(44*10&+..'(+$*' ,*'.(/+)($ ,++*,./+$ (+1 $0,%1/'*,./6*;($104- ,:&4/*1 ;/.% ./$,+.*+1*1.%(.B-6/'.0*.%*/:&0)+*11/'*,./+$ ,+.(/+*1/+++*@0'*$ A(+1 !.%*B0$/+*$$ /+.*'*$. .%* &*././+*' 9 ($ )*+,- ;041 B* 0'.%*' 1/40.*1 . %($ 6*%*:*+.4-B**+(')0*1.%(.+&&'.0+/.- %*('/+)#+./,* %(1B**+/$$0*1&'/'./$$0(+,*.%*.;/:&0)+*1'1*'$(. ++*@0'*$ A(+1 $0B:/$$/+%($B**+:(1*.%(..%* (,./+.%*'*$&+1*+.2'&'(./+/$0+C0$.!0+(/'(+1()(/+$. %*&'/+,/&4*$+(.0'(4C0$./,* *('+*1,0+$*4'.%*&*././+*'%($B**+%*('1(. 4*+).% *'0$(4.%*/:&0)+*1'1*'$(.++*@0'*$ A(+1 ;041'*6*(4.%(..%*)($,++*,.

/+$%(6*B**+1/'*,.*1. B*.'(+$*''*1/+&0'$0(+,*.('*2$.'0,.0'/+)&4/,- **14*$$ . B$*'6* .%(. /. ;041 B* $4*4- ;/.%/+ .%* 1:(/+ .%* '*$&+1*+.9/+10$.(+ *.'4*0:'&'(./+/:/.*1..(<* &4/,-1*,/$/+$(+1(4$.'(:*('*2$.'0,.0'/+)&4/,- +$.(+.

;'/.&*././+1*$+.4(-(+-,%(44*+)*.$0,%'*2$.'0,.0'/+) &4/,- '.%(.:(..*'!$0,%'*2$.'0,.0'/+)&4/,-%($+.*6*+ B**+&4(,*1+'*,'1 ./$+.*6*+.%*,($*:(1*0.B-.%*,0+$*4.%(. ;%*+.%*)($()*+,-%(1B**+(44..*1/+.%*-*('!(+- ($$0'(+,*%(1B**+%*410.($'*)('1$(:/+/:0: (:0+. ,+$0:*'$#'*2/44$(4*$ %*)($()*+,-%(1B**+(44..*1..%* &*././+*'/+.%*-*('/+.%*.;+(:'(4( /44.%*-*('

D!&*././+*'9($)*+,-%($*+C-*1(:+&4-$.(.0$ %*'*;041B*+1/$&0.*.%(.(:'(4(.;+/+.%*4($.:'* .%(+.;1*,(1*$%($)';+ .;041B*B-;(-+*,*$$/.-(+1 .$*'6*.%*,+$0:*'$/+.%*.;+(:'(4(.%(..;.%*')($ ()*+,/*$;*'*(44..*1/+.%*-*('D /(B/4/.-*(,%)($ ()*+,- %($ . B* 4<*1 /+. (+1 .%(. .! (. .%* %(+1$ '*$&+1*+.2/+10$.(+ *.'4*0: '&'(./+ /:/.*1 (+1 /. /$ ;/.%$0,%BC*,./6*.%(..%*'*2$.'0,.0'/+)&4/,-;($'(:*1(+1 ;%/,%%($.'(+$4(.*1/+.%*/$$0(+,*.%*/:&0)+*1'1*'$(. ++*@0'*$ A(+1 ?

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

*././+/$1/$:/$$*1 E

F E

F ! ! ! !

" " " "

.* %*.%*'$&*(</+)#'*($+*1

*$# %*.%*'*&'.(B4*

*$#