High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18893/2015allowed

Rajender Kumar v. Punjab And Haryana High Court Chandigarh And ANR

2019-11-08Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina25 pages

VIMAL KUMAR 2019.12.16 15:14

!"#"$%

&% '(&)*

#$% & ! "

( ! ") *+

! ") ,-

# ! ") . *+ *

" # " /# 0 # !

+1 *2 +2*1 3

!" "##4 *- 2+ +2*5 "" !

!" !! ! 3!!!# ##"

+ 37"# "/#

+1 *2 +2*18 ) * !#4 8# !

! " !#"/# :

4 # ! ! ## " ! ! 4 # 6 4 # " 4 4 ;

) *-<.,+2*-*"+2*5!# ##" "" 7 #"$ # " = # ! " ' ## ! 4!

" +2 +2*1 " ! #! " *- 2+ +2*5 ; "

4 !" ! 6 $ ! 7 " 4## ! 3" " " "

!" > , 3 *- 2+ +2*5 ! < 6 #" " # "! " 3!"4 #"" !

# - 8 ! ! 4 " " = # " ! # 7! ! # " 4 !" " " "# 25 ** +2*1 8" #

4 !+2 +2*1# ! 4!7! +2 +2*1 ! "

+1 *2 +2*1 !#4 ! #"" $ !

2* *2 +2*1 8 !#"

4## 8! !! 7"!4##! #" *- 2+ +2*5 ? 6 ;

=*551,=+2*. " !";

=*-<.,+2*-*=+2*5# 4##"

! " #! "# " !! > .

8! # !!# !# "!! 8 "#!! 48$ ###4 3 !"" *- 2+ +2*5 4!# 4#### $!

!4#4 " 4! #### $ @""! 7 4 $ !" ##"

$ #!#"+2" ++4-A # $" !".224 )=! !" "*- 2+ +2*5 4!#### ! # "##" "" 8

, ## $4! !!

# "! *- 2+ +2*5 #" !

4 " " ;

*-<., +2*-* " +2*5

! 3 ! 25 ** +2*1" !# #" "

34 " # #! " # ! ! #! " +2*- 4 !## +2*5 "

7# # ;# 4 ! " ! " < "! " ! 8 " ##!" !# +2*- " # *-%*& " C# % " !& # *1<, 34!#! ; ! "*- 2+ +2*5 #! #" !##D " "##4 ##! "

!"#! " !# @ " # " !E ! ""!# # !+.

2- +2*- # !" "! %&%& 4! =

9& ##!# "# 4# "##" 4 4 ## "

" # & ; " !# ## # "! > ; 38 !" # # 4"! ! 4 !

$4! ) B5*<4! $ 4! 4 # ! " ! ! # " #! " # ! " !# %& %& # " "#! "+B!" " !# 7 " ! $ !#! ! "

# +.

2- +2*-

##%&%&#! 6 = 84= # " ! $ ! " ! #!!#4!4 # # ! 8" " ! "! #$# #! 8 ! " #! #"#! ! ! " " #! "

!# " ! 4#!# 8"" !# ## 4! #!

# ! # " ""!# ! !7" > 3!" # $=

- !

=! 4 #*-" C# % " !& #*1<,! !##! 6 #" =!

=3 3 " !

-A $ 8 ! ! ! " .22 4 3" ! 4 !

+2 $## "#6 #" 3 ! ! 4 !""4!

# $ !4+2

44 !

$ 4 #! ! 4 6 $ 4 ! " *22 4 C# !! ! " +24 3 ." $ 44!!44 # " ! 4 4 4 !

" $ !

) *," !#4 #" ""!

) !!4 = !

= ; ! ## 4 )

$ ! *

* +

* , ?

$ ?

$ * - 86 6 * .

$ ?

$ * 3#

" $ .

. *2

! # " 4 % &##4!"#"F/F$/ ! $ ! # 4 " !# ## # " ! ## $ ## ! $#4!9>!!

=! # # "

! ## " 4 !!## # "

#4" # #! ! 3 #!4 $4 !". $/ 0 !1$ "!" 6 # " ! 8 4 ! #" 4 $ !4! # !

4 # 4$

(=888 ! 8 "

! ! ! !# # 8"!!#4 4 " !# ###"!##

$ #4! !##! ! ##4 "

"#4 ! #"!4## # $! -A##4 4 !" " # " ! !# # " =!"

# #"

4 "4 $"#!

##! !7#"

** 3 4 " #!G F

/ 4 F

/4!!! $ ##" "H$ !4"44

4##!! ""!#4" " H$ " " ( 3 ) #" " !!

$!!! !" ! 7 .224 # " ! 4 ## D## # #! " # ; " ! #!# 8$I *+ 37!## $#4" " ##"4F6 /F6 /!! " ! 8 ##7 4 ! ##!## $ 3##! #7 44""##" 4 ! ""# 4 "" !7 7#4#"/3 "C#; $ " 4 " !

!#444 ! 4# ! 4$ !##! " 4 $4 "4 34F6 /F6 / 4## !74!

"## 9-5- > ,*. J/ 8# 3 K 4 ## 4 # !# ! 6 # D " ! 3 3 !# 3?7"0!"C#" F6 / 9 " 6 > ?

!## !# F3 #! %86 &!*5.2/F

" 86 ! *1.+/ !

@ # %C# # & " ##! $## "# ##4! " " 4!#;L M #4 4449>9> !# 8

"$# !74!4F6 /4!" ## "# ## F6 / 3 ! ! 4

3F6 / 34!

$ 3 4 8 4 " ## !4! ' # !"4### 4 !! ! " #! " 7!

!" #$7! $4"#"C## ##! #7 " 84 # ! $"## ! " # " ! !# 4 ## 7 # !! # 3"!4

4##" 4!"

!"! #7C## 7# # ""! #$ 93 # ! 4 F6 /F6 /6 " #"E$E4#6 " E $ " # > 8!!6 6 !

' C#N 6 6 !

H C#"" #6 " # ! "4 !7 4! # 8$7! " #$ ;8C# H C# !

C# # *, ?" . $ 7 4" " " 4!4 #! # 3" 4 4"!! !! !!4F

/F6 /"4! $ ! ! " $ ! 7 3 4 # # $ " +2 4-A # $4!

"" 7 3 # #! ! ! !

+2 $ *- 3 ! !#"

!## $+! " ! # " ++ +2 " 4

/F6 /4! #4 "#!# *.

!!# ##4 3 ! ! " !#

! 4 " " ##"!"! *B 8 #"4## "7"#!#+2*- 8"#7!

4##

!!G" !6 !4 " !4" 34#####4!" # #" " !# 6 4 # # !""= "7 4 " " # ! 4""!" 4#!4#! "# ##4! ## #! " ! 4 "! *< 4 !" #!!=+2*- " !!4## #"" # " ;

*-<., +2*-* " +2*5 $ = # ! " ! !# " !#

"" " "#!!

! ## 3"7 ""# 7" "# "D "## "!#"!+2*.! "#"4 # *5 8 ###4 *1 4 " 4 8 " !"##4

"!" " 4 !" 22 $213 * 8 !## " ! " ! " #!!44" 7 4$"4!! #4 $ $ ! 8 !4 !8" !"B<" 4 ! 4 ! 8 / !"."#! ! # #

" ! !6 ## # 3 ! "

" !#!#4$# #""

!#! " !#" 4! 4!" " ! 3"8 4 ! 4 4

!"#!4" !$"# " M #! 3 ! ! 4!!

4 #! + 84" ""!""8!##! 4 ! " #! 7# # " #! ! 84#!4" ! "4 !$ $ 4! 7! 4 !! !#!!$"!"! 3" "!" # " $ "! #

"#! # 4 8 " ! ! " .22 4 4 $" " 8$444 7!" '

4 #

#7" 47!4$ !" !!4#" 474 7 ! 3 "#4 #! ! ! " ! 8 ! 4 # #!=!!$!" 8 #!

#!" 474 !# 3 # !"!4" ! "# , 3! #!!# $!

# ""!#7!" # # 3 4 #

, !# " ! " # 4! #!"4 "4 ! 3 4## # # " $ "!# !# 4 " ! ! 4

/! 874!4 !##9

> 8/ "" !"!"# ## $7 ! 4! 4 !!# 8" $ ### $!

# 8!## " 7 # ## " 4 ! 4 3 " 7! " " ! ! ; ! 8 7! " ## ! !!# $ " ##

! "

#4! !#4#4 ! #! !"7! ##"""!"" # "#!"! - 3/#

! !"7" 3#7

!# ""! ! " "

"! 3 #! "

! 4 #

## $## *- ! $C## 4C## " ! @!!!

" "

## !

!# !# 6 $ !

3!"# #!" 4#

37 "4 4H

!C#H C# ##"#! """!"" " 3# 4 #$ " 7# !4## 4C###

7!6 " # " H !###! C#" "#!# !## 3 !# # ! $ 4 4 !#

>33 # " 7 ! $ 4## #! # "!" 4! "# "# 4 ! $ 3 ! # #" ## ""! "" 3 "# $ 8 C# # ! !7 ! 3!"! ! ! " ! 7 4! ! #4#!$46 < 3 ! " #! " !"4 ""!!"4!#" # 7 $D "##" 7"# # ! $ 8 8 !/ 4

3" 8 !

!!$"" #

!# C# ! 7 ! ! .22 4 $" # ##!#4 #!

" 4!!7! " "

!# ! ##

"#!!

8 4 " "" != !

! 4 ! ! !=4 4 "" 7 " "7 3! # 84 "# #".224 ""!! 3 # 4 " .22 4 ! ! " "! # $"### 4!" 4 # C " 4 # 8 $ " ## 4 #$!"# "7 7 4 " !! 34#4 ""!" C ! !!#"

#"# " !"" ! O #! 4$# !! # 4 # " # ! # " " ## #! " 8 4 # ! 7 4#!!!" 3 !$" # )4 ##"#!!"

! #

? # = 8"

. 4 " "# " # #!J #4"##4 #! !K ! # 4 4 " ## ""!

# 4 ## " # # 7!( !#!## !#!" "! ! " C# # $## ! !##7#" 4 (! #$#!G4$ 7 ## 3

$4!! "#! !# 4 4 ! C#$#4 ## # # $ C! # 3 #"""! "" #"##"# *2 8 =!

=3 ##!"#"! !! " C#

! #" ' 4 # # 4 " # ! " !G 7 " 4!

! $ !"#.2A <.A!!4 *22*.26 8! ## $!4 !!6 ## 3 ! " 7 6 # " # 38$ # "

#! " #!!4 ## #

** ?

" # !# )#4! !

C# " ! 4$ !# ! ## ;! "! !# "! ## $!! 4! "" 4 !""!!'! *+ " ! ! !G9

>"4# !

!# GM ; 4## 7

GM ;G

!G !G !# !$## @ 4# !"" G

"" 4$ 4 " G /#

$" @! 4 !# "4! 4$ " #D!!# D # 44$ "4$ 3" # G

==##4$!# 4$ G *, 3 D ! " !#

! % &G !# ! % &G0 ! " 4 4## " 4# ! "" " 4$ !# 4## 4$" ! *- @C##G# !"7!

6 3 ! " " ## %C#& 4 " ( ## 3! 4 " 0 3 /#

! G " ! ! 0 8%##& *.

3 !"! #" ## # 6 !!!# ! # ==4$" ! *B 8 !G # !6 4 ! 4 7! !N "

!G!#G #G #G'#4 "##"4 3 #!6 4 "!#++BL++< " # " " #

! *125" # ! *1<, !# ! 4! " " # @ ! " 3! M !# ! #6 $ " !4$4!

""!G""!#"# ! $!#" " N"DL#N "!##"9 >9> " N , "

## " G # " %" 7 # 9P G>&N " #4 ! ! " N44!" !

#"7 #%+2*1&* *+2*1%*& *N8 +2*1 *+2*1%8& *N ""

##!

!# !# !

" ! " G F /!##F / F )) / 34 # " ## ## " 4$ " #

!"76 " # $

#4!!44"#"# !$""! #

7 "" 3 ""!

# # !87!!G4## # # $ 4! ! /#'! 34### " !#

*5 )4 " G F3#/ " ! G # !##F0##/F3#/" 8"! !# !"! "

! $ " #! 4 " 4 ! 7 ! " 4! # " )8 ! $ *1

# G

" 4# !! #!# " 4$ " "# " " !N # L

!N!"!4!!"##!44! #$##4 3 # ! ! ! ! ! " !G

N ! " #G#!N ! 4! ! $ N !6 !4! =#)! #4! !##/#M 4$"G 3

$4 " 4! # !

"# ##N!! !

N!"! !! # ! G4 G#N #! !N "# " "" G# "" 3 # !6 4 "" " $# G# " 4 "# ! N!# !" #" #$ ! ) " # 8$$4#"4## $## !6 4 4 4$ #$ 3 "" " !

" 3 7 # ## $ # 34##! 7! # # #" !""!!" ! +2 3 # !

!"!! 7"" ##!"" ! $## ## " 7 ## ! #!"!!

N4!!

# ## = " M / 3 #!6 44F? / " M 4 ! /# '!""

?/7!# !!! ## +* " ! !" " 7 4 4$ ! # $ "" !" 4!

4##" 4$"!!6 44$ " !"! ! " # 3 $4# 6 " 4$ # 4$ $4#4!! "

!# # 4 " " " ++ ## " "" 4 6 $ =4G"!"#

" G4= G#! !

""!#4 =4# #'!4 !## $= 4 " !" 8 "" ""!

#!# !#"#! !"

# 3 !""! 3 ""! !# "# !!# " !"4""! #!# 8" 4$44 "

= ! +, 3 # !## !# !4 !!#$44 !$!#" !"!

4#4$" $4 !

8 ! ! +- 8" " ! = #

G!$##"7""! ##" ##"7 3 # # !!###4$" =7! 3"!"! "6 " # +.

3 # #"4# # ! #C ! $4" ! +B 3 # # 93 # 44 3!= 4># 8 4 "#! 4#!!$ $ " # +< 34""##!##!##F3##/ # ! 44$4## $#=

, ! " C# 4 4! !! ## #"#*2"4! !6 ! # " 4# !G"# !# GM ; # " ##$!#" #"4!"!! ! "#4$ %& $ 8=! " !# !/ ! " " 3 #"# " 4 "

"/#M 3! ! ! ##" !

# #" "!" "4!! $ ! 34##$ "! 4$" # ## #"""!!6 /#M # +5 3"=

#! ## ""!!! !"""! @ "6 ! " ! 4 4 @ !"! $ 4$ ## 84##" ! 4

( "

!#"/#

#4 +1 )4

4## !#! 8# " !" "! # 4!

(#"! "$ +1 3"##!#*5% & "!! 4 " "! "4 !

! +* 2* +2+2 " (# 4 " 4 "#$#$ ? " "#! 6 7 4! "### !# 4*5 $ G #