Amar Ujala Pubications Ltd v. Hsiidc Ltd And ANR.




    
  

 !"#$%"&'('#)*+,+   

!" #$%&"'( )*" " #$* +*% % ,$-""*.$'

%"  .$/%" !"

**0* #1*$"
#1#" #$&  "*'

$'$#"2* )3*%1#$'*$"%   *  -.

+ /


 ..
  -.

+ /
0
1   .

*%*$" (- 42$'**1- $526'0#!"*6 /#"2*1*" " #$*( ($4  "" 6'0#!"*6$'

%(7 %2 '**17 %(-$0 - $5 6'0#!"*%6 /#*%1#$'*$"8#(( (+ 0*4559 6'0#!"*6 /#*%1#$'*$"8#(( 222 

 ..
3+ 4 5 + '**5

 *""*#/

#"*$"'"*' %"6 6$ $'

%" 

% "*:1 #" 8#(;6  2%*  ..6  .$'

%"   <%""*6  9   9% 

#""*'  "#  "2* 1*" " #$*  

!" #$%&"'(,"2**%1#$'*$"
#1#" #$(=2* "*$"" 0*1 !*#/"2*

#""*'% "*9%3%(6;6;

:(2**/"*6/#

5***$"6'"*' "2 8#0**6 69%*$"**' $"#*"9**$"2*1" *%( 2 !2%*"%# ""2*"*%$'!#$' " #$%#/"2*

#"*$"% %#"2*1,*$"

%!2*'

*(#9*0*6/#"2*1*" " #$*6#9 $5"#*$2$!**$" $"2*!#%"#/ !> % " #$69%%*0*'9 "2'*$'$#" !*'"*'-*1"**6   6 "#'*1#% ""2*'' " #$ !#%"#/"2*1 #":% "*?3%( (;1*%>(*"*6 "

9%!#$%" $*'"#11#!2"2 %
# "( &*$*'!# /#"2*1*" " #$*%  "%"2" $*%%*$!*6"2* 5 *0$!*#/"2*1*" " #$* %"2"$#"2 $5 % $' !"*',"2**%1#$'*$"

#1#" #$%"#92"*"2*!#1#$*$"%:/!"#%"2"/#*'% %#/"2* 1 5$*''*$'(@ "2*6*0*$"2*! !

" #$%"#

%" /,"2* 1 5$*'

'*$'9%$#"/ $ %2*'( =2*""* %1*$' $5% $!*,6 ( &*$*'!# /#"2**%1#$'*$"
#1#" #$%  "%"2" 9 ""*$%""**$"#$*2 /#/"2*
#1#" #$6!#$"#0*" $5"2*!

 #/"2* 1*" " #$*69%/ *' $!26 (@ "2*6*0*$"2*'#!

*$"3 "15* A#/"2*11*##4*0* %"2*/!"#%"2"/#*'% %#/"2*# $""2"

9%* $5'*$'*'( "6 $!%*"2*1*" " #$* %%"

55 *0*'0 B0 B"2* $$* $92 !2"2*'' " #$ !#%"#/3%( (;1*%>(*"*2%**$ 9#4*'  # "6  "2*,  ,  #0*  "2*  !#1*"*$"   "2# ",  <%""*  $5*6 9  $ "2 % *5' $' / * # *!" #$%($'6 $ "2* *0*$"6 $, % !2 *1*%*$"" #$:# *!" #$ % %/ *',"2*1*" " #$*9 "2 $"9#9**4%/# "#',6"2*%*%2

*'* "9 "2,"2* "2# " *%$'11#1 "*#'*% $ !!#'$!*9 "2 9%2

*1%%*'(@ "2*62*%  "%"2"*/#*% !2 #'*%*1%%*'6"2*1*" " #$*%2

 %#*2*'6/#92 !2/#

!# $ !" #$9

* %% *'9*

 $'0$!*( &*$*'  !#  /#  "2*  1*" " #$* %  5** * "# "2* !# %* % 55*%"*', *$*'!# /#"2*
#1#" #$(*%  "%"2"% $!*"2* ""*2%**$1*$' $5/# #%"% C,*%6"2*1*" " #$*,20**0*$ '*1#% "*'%#*# $" $*%1#$%*"#"2* 1 5$*''*$'$#" !*'"*'"2 -*1"**6  (*"2"% ",62*%  "%"2""2*1*" " #$*%2

#0* !#1*2*$% 0**1*%*$"" #$ #$59 "2

$*!*%%,'#!

*$"% $% 11#"

#/ "%!

 9 "2 $"2*" * $' !"*'#0*(!!#' $5 ,62*%  "%"2" *"

"2 %1*" " #$*' %1#%*'#/ $"2*94*#/"2*%""**$"'*, *$*'

 !# /#"2*
#1#" #$(#9*0*62*%  "%"2*
#1#" #$*' *!"*'

"#1%%"2*$*!*%%,#'*%9 "2 $%1*! / *'" *( =#92 !26 *$*'!# /#*%1#$'*$"
#1#" #$%  "% "2" /"*//#' $5$#11#"

$ ",#/2* $5"#"2*1*" " #$*6 "2**> *'

#'*%%2

*1%%*'9 "2 $1* #'#/* 52"9**4%"2**/"*( .$"2*94*#/"2*1#% " #$%4*"!2*'# "#0*6$' $"*%#/"2* %""**$"%'*, *$*'!# /#"2*1" *%6"2*1*" " #$%"$'%' %1#%*' #/( =2 %
# " %%$5 $*"2""2*!#1*"*$" "2# ",%2

!#$% '* "2*""* $"2* 52"*$*%"6$'1%%!#1*2*$% 0*#'*%% 5$ $5 *%#$% $% 11#""2**#/69 "2 $"2*" * $' !"*', *$*'!# /#"2*
#1#" #$( #9*0*6 " %'*!

*"2""2 %#'*%2

$#"!#$%" "

"*$, *C1*%% #$#/#1 $ #$#$"2** "%#/"2*!%*#/* "2*1",6/#6% $' !"*' #0*6"2*!#1*"*$" "2# ",%2

*C $*"2*!#$!*$%:5 *0$!*%#/"2* 1*" " #$*6%" !"

, $!!#'$!*9 "2 9(

46) 55'   6%7"  0'94 :77 4; 5 6%7"

+,+

8 ) 2*"2*%1*4 $5:*%#$*' D<-:8 2*"2*3*1#" * D<-:8