Vineet Bhatia v. State Of Haryana




 

 

 


 










































!"" 




   !"

 # $ 
%&

'

(((
)* !"

(


# $ %

" &
'

& (    Mr. Anil Kumar Rana+

*,



-
)   (

(

) 
.

# +

/+

 ( ( '

&  (

 (
!% 1"

0


2 

 )

 0
3 1

 
- ,2
& (
*

*
4 (4 ( 4
2  *
#*
$ 
5 +
567+
56
*
4  

1
$


. 1+
 
& * *(

&

-
 
8 
2  *

-
3 

9)1 
1*2* 30
  2

 :

 -

-

8- 

8 
1122
-

- )  
32
) )  

;
 *- ,
*#  1
 )


, 1* 1 
8-1
 #*
$#3- -
- *
 *

2#

 
*
 1*
 ) 0
-
1 
*
<# 10
&
8 
2  *(



* 0
-
#1

-
)  
#39 
-

-
)  


811

) ) 1
3 8
- ,
1  *0
 *

9


19
8 -

-
3 :
*
-
1
) *#*
#
1# 
 


*

*#  

+
#*
30
-
 :+
)

-
 9


:

 *

-  *
)  (

-
#1

-
)  
# -
#39 
-

- )  
- 
1
=*
, 2


8 -
-
)1
30
, #

) ,#  *

  9
3 1
) *
30
-
# ( $


#1

 # 
 9
$
 =) 1
#39 
-

**

-
)  
- 
=*
-
, 2


*
- 

# *
-
  -

8

9


19
- 
3
 *
3 8
-
)

(

$

 #1
# -
#39 
-

-
)  


<# *
30
)1
 # -
, 2




# * 1
  2

( 
,8

-
3,+
8 -#
99 2

-
9  

-  +
-
) 
)  

- 30
118*
*
 *
*

*
((
 - 30
9 *
31# (

-
)  
-#1*
3*
30
-
*  , 2*
#*
$ 
5! "
 (((











)'

&* !"" 

  +&, ,- Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No