← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18924/2015allowed

Parveen Kumar Sharma v. Uhbvn Ltd & ORS

2016-08-17Mr. Justice Darshan Singh13 pages





           

  !" #!

$ %  "&#'#!

(  

 

        

   )   *+)  , -   ! "   #$%&   " 

%

%' 

-  .  (  &  *&        +   % ,%"-*   ./ (/ 0/(0 %   12  (33  03 /0 0/(4 # + +       #       /4 /.

0/(4   # *  /5 /.

0/(4&  #  *    &  +* *   

 #/6 /6 0/(4 2   

 #   /5 /.

0/(4*  # +  (3 /4 0/(4 *

 &  7  * 

    *8      # +     (( 0/(4 *  %   &          *  &    &  +   &       )



&+  + )    9 + &

#+8 ! ,- :

         /4 /.

0/(4  &   /5 /.

0/(4 # ; ,- :

    (( 0/(4  ; ,- :

  +  & $   *          &  ; 2+  12    +            #    + 

 2    &  & 

#    *   *  #   &       #     

  *  #  #+ &  &                /5 /.

0/(4   )     & /4 /.

0/(</< /6 0/(4#   #   *            * 

+            && & # # +#* *   +& & #     # #& .

  &  (( 0/(4#* &&& * +&  &   *& )      *  &  &   ) #

 &   #     &+ *+* 





  *    +            *  &   &  ) &   &&  /5 /.

0/(4*   * 

 #             2      &   $               *   & #   &    & &# &  +  0   # 

&&    & &     +#  &(5= 

2   #   &      & #    #    &  7 *0/(4  +  &     *   &        9 #       &&  ) +  #&

 & +>*  &&  #    &       &           # +

     # & +  3?% &      @    @

 , 

  %  - +  (AA/ ,&   B  + C-  +   

     

  *    &      + 8   +    +

&#+   &    #   *       *      # * +& 7  &   12 2  5& #   #   

# & 03 /0 0/(4, & ++&12- 



/4 /.

0/(4*  *8 

 + 

 #     #      *      :

+   #/6 /6 0/(4  < @+#    /6 0/(4 & ++    ) & 

 &  + #&

 #+  (( 0/(4 )    # * & ++             & #      7    @ ?   & + &       

   &   +  3?%   #      2 *   7   

   #  ,- #    ++ 

 +D ,*-# +  &  &&  +  8    

 +  3?%,0-    

 

 *     *      *   &    # &&& &        #        +   # &  E+& +    @E + 3?% 

#    & &  +    &      ,*- &    *?

+  

 *   #   &  

  &   & &      &  & 

*  F   & + + * && +   



#     #      &    &&  +8  

  #  3/<3A5?%.0. 4/< 29 #         #  #  

              +

  *  +       

+    *  &         & #        2  &&(( 0/(4# 

 #      &         #

(( 0/(4    (0 4/" &&  &

&  & &+G&  

    + * 

 8 &

&   &    + *  +   $ &    #  

+

  *   &&      &   ) +    #    &  #

 * &        #  #

+*&   + &    #  @  /6 0/(4   +  *        &     #    &       +  *    

                /.

0/(4 1  C #+  & +# # *    +   &  +       &        &  * + 

  & # 



   +  + *            E  &   +     *     &  #    35          # &  +  2&  * &    &&  $ &          *       +  +

#  #  

*   & +?  +

 (/     &             9 %$  9     & 2   +       ,0/(4- 6 99 0A(D %2 0/(4 90.5A#  *  ! H5

  

 + &

&  +

       & * &      2&   &      &  #    *    +   

  *       #        7   G  + *



 #     +  #        #+  &   "   & +   

 

 &  + 

&   &   # &  +*

 *         E   + * )      &&+   +   &      &   & 7     E *& &

 +#    &&    # +   &  #   +  #



E*

 & 8  8      

    

8 

"  & # *     2 **

 #

 *

   9  E 

+   +                &          #   *   *  &  +  +     E*   & 

 # $    + "+9&(0(4#   IH:#



 ##

 &      $   + J 2    

E  %      9  &   

 & %  +     

     

$ +    * 

% (0&  7  & + (A35  IH

*  *$  *  & #    &

   

      @     +     &  # +    &  J  " 

   @   9    +   %  <,(-     H   &  + * +&   ++   &  *  +# *  K J  *  H  +#  && 

 *       +  + #J ((     &  '     (A /0 (A50 &+  $*'   0( /3 (A<(     *$ & B      &  & ' 

    C    '    

  (A<( *+   

&

# *   #    *&+ 

    * +  &    & +  *  ++  '     & 

 &  * 

#    *++'  ) #    &* ##   

  0( /3 (A<(#   &  

 * ' 7   F& &#* &    # ' &&  * + &  

  &   +8 

) # &+8   *

# E   ,E +     + #  +    #+   &9 &#- 2   E&  &  *  E  * E  

& +  8   * *   & "??  +  2& E *        &

 &  $ &  *  *&   9*        * &   (A /0 (A50#   +      

**   &  

 #  E   &   &       (0 2  +  &   *   + *           *  

#& % &&    #  & + * E +&   # & 

&    *#   #&

#  #  

           + &  ) 04 /3 0/(4 # *&  

+* 

+  &

*& *  &  ) &

*#   &   # *& #   &     #

  *       & #   2  

  /.

0/(4 *    & +  # #

*   &

)     *   *  & &     *  *  #        $ & #     +  3?%   #            

     *   

 #    * E *

)  &&+ 3?%,*-&  #  #       

 +

       # +

   &     && #  *   &  +   #      

      (.

@ +  3?%,0-      &    +  #  * 



* 

*    # &&& &   & E+& +   # &&&  &   &     &  &  &&    &  E+& +    & #   



8    @E + 3?%,0-* # *?+ ,- ,*- &   & &  +    #   &





  &   &  &   &   +     & +    

   

) &   &  E

 E *  &*

)  * #   && 

&     #     &       * & #  #

 * ) +  #



+ & #    & 7 *0/(4+ 9    +#  

+ +# 9 # $ #    $ +  

 #   *      *

 & $   +  &   +    +   *     &    +    &   +  9           &     #

$ &       +    # &

 # (3 # &       *  

 & $   *    $?    &     &  &  *& ++    

+ " ++ &&

8 + &   & +   +  

> #      &+  &

  *  &     &  &     &   #      &    8     #     +  

) 

 !7 ;2    * # * 



   

# *&&  &# 

   ;:

 &&&   #    *    & & # &    #   *  #; )  8   *

  &       &$ #* + #  

 #  E     8  #        

  &             #  L F&&M '       * 

   &&

              

 &   &   H     J #    

  8  &     

  *    

 #  & &&       *  

 #  #    &   &

#   & 

#+ &&  + &   #    *       *  + 

 *   &    

&# 2     & *  :     * +   *# ++ + # & &  (4   & * & E   

?  +     *    &&+ 

 #  # ?

+H&&CJ + &&  #  #&

#J     **  )  *  &   +# &   & 8           #    C *

 C* #   #  &    

  * & +   +    



       #      +  *        8  #  #    &

#  

 + # #

&+   

     &&    *        &

 + *+ + # * 

   + && **&

* E 8    

 *  E  C  *      +             + +  &     &   #  9  #

    #     $ &  #+  &  +  *    

    * &    

 &  #+ 

 # * # &* &     & #

              

 !!" "

#$% & !     & !   &%     ! "'& !  (!

!(%) )!$&& %!!)$& "'$(&( ( &&    !  &    ! ($!   *! % !!((( 0/(4  (6 98 

     

# # +     4////G?  &  &    #       E  2   +  & 

#      & 

   $     +  $ &  +    *  && &  L+& && & *

#&   & M*  & # 



#   & &   #+          8 & & #+?+* # # +    $  *     #     

 *   #   2        C      + & # +#

   &++ 9 E?

   #  +$ E & * &  & # (5 1   &++     &     (( 0/(4 ,%E ?<-    * 

+   *    * 8   )  *& # #

8  *& +& E &  G&    

)   *   # E#& & && &  & + #     #

    N(0 =    &  && 

 

        / -  0  

 !" #!

$