High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/7948/2010disposed of

Devinder Singh And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-09-22Mr. Justice Arun Monga9 pages

!"#"$"%""" "$ " $&'()'*+,+(-.'/&'01'2

4 5

6"$

"- 7#8 4!

. "

" 2','&-

! #

$ !

% # ! &' ()*+ ,-.-

! &'0 ))1 ,-.+

$ ! #

! 0 3 ( + .- ., .* .3 .+ .) ,- ,, ,4 1, 11 14 13 1( 1+ 1) *- *. *1 *4 *3 *( *) 4, &' ()*+ ,-.- 0 + .. ., .1 .* .4 .+ ,. ,) &' ))1 ,-.+

5 ! 0 ( &' ()*+ ,-.-

# ! 0 ., ,. ,* ,)61*&' ()*+ ,-.-

2 ! #

! 0 ) **&' ()*+ ,-.-

%! ! #

! 0 .4 ,3 ,+ 1- *+&' ()*+ ,-.-

! ! 0 ,1 &' ()*+ ,-.-

! 0 ,*&' ))1 ,-.+

2 ! 0 ,(&' ()*+ ,-.-

$ ! 0 ,&' ))1 ,-.+

! 0 ,(&' ))1 ,-.+6 0 *&' ()*+ ,-.-

! 0 .(&' ()*+ ,-.- 0 3&' ))1 ,-.+

$ 9 : ! 0 ,1 &' ()*+ ,-.- ;;;;; "3!4 "8 5

< "

# ' /

0 ,( $ "

/%"

%=" +*,', "

% / # # / " " / #

< / " $ &' ()*+ ,-.- , " # & > " < ' ?= ?"

,,-(,--) ! )@,--( / 0 , # "

" # / . 1 /

" %" 1 """ " / "$ "

" & ! 0 )@,--( ,,-(,--(9!= .: "

31 < ' ?= ?"

2 A

31 1)# 2 "

B # "

# 0 , = " " ""

# "

= $# /(4 # "

4- $# / > "

=" ,4 $ " #

>$ #

=" > # "

.--*,-.+ / ..-*,--+9!= 4: / " " ".3"

#$# !

0 . 1 # , " &

/ #

BC B &' .-,,.

,--+ / & "

" "

# # ,*-),--)# / " * C

/ "

/ """

# / # # """

D" C "

#/ # / & " # " < ,*-),--)9!= .,:

&' .-,,.

,--+ / %

7 9 # & : #

& E

"#G 3

/# "

# # "

/ & # -*-,,-.3 / $ / 79 # 8 : # # " /

# H!

*14 ,-.4B " / #E

$ "%&%

& ! ! '

(

)*+),+)* - . - / 0 1 .# 234* ,+)*

6 78

,4+4,+)* 9 :. ( $ " %& %

;& < ! = 6 9 01"

( & 2>= 0> ?! 1@ 01 "

! &

@ 2 = ! -7 7 >6

) ,A4

6 ( +3B23

? 8 & B 2 !

.)4+C,+)* . - 7 7 > 6 D

? 8 /

7 8

.# 234* ,+)*

6 ! 6/

( G ( /> # #

# H!

*14 ,-.4 # / "

& A -1-4,-.( # "

79 H # & : / / #E

/%& /

$ " %& %

% ? 8 9 /%& /

' ,E)),+)F

& G,H 7 ?' > 7 6 $ " 6 /%& /!0 & )1 & '

8 - !

7 +)+),+++4)+),++,& G4H "

/%& / " ? 8

7 > # ? 8

1 # = 6 !7 #

I%& /

8 ' @

& G3H .4)+E,+)C 5

G*H -7!8

> 6

GFH .

D + # /> /

# = " $ / " C

B 9 CB: "

2 7 # & : / # ,.-4,-.+E :

1 ! !

2 =

" &

= "

E ! " !

.)F+E,+)E

G ) C

" # & " /># " " .3-+,-.+ / "

# " / / > // CB

/ B / #E F======

- +4 ,+)C

%& 4C

3, ! 3, !

7 > 6 2 %

! 3, ' & 7 > 6

& .)*+),+)J .

G .- / " / "

# C # @ C

" / #

%" # / $

/ $ .. C

0 * .*&' ()*+ ,-.- ..""

""" /

.*9: &' ()*+ ,-.- # "

= " / #E F8% K% & & & 23 )3 = '

' 7 6 G ., A & >

0 * .* & #

!= +9& ": >> #

/ # "

/ .1

# > ""

/" .*

/ "" /# # / #

$ "

8 "

/> " #

/ " " " "

# "

/ .* C " " "

/ $

8 H!

*14 ,-.4

# #

-4-.,-,. C # "

> /"

# .4 ""

.3 "

" !

.'/&'01'2

@ E 5@0 '

/E 5@0