High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/18927/2015dismissed

Tata Teleservices Ltd v. Kulwinder Singh & ANR

2015-09-11Mr. Justice R.P. Nagrath10 pages

! "

!"#$"%&'( #$%&'( )* + , " )

- *

."/ 01 *+ )* " " * ++ * *"+

+ 2 )+ +3 + )* ) ++ +) 2 " )+ "

" 4 ) * *+ ,-. /* 01 2 3* 441 "5

). 6*. #4* 17+ '12 /-+ 41* 2 3*5

2 " " " 5 ) 6 3 + )*+ ,

"##$"#% &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

)' %$" + $"$"(",

" - $% -. / *"

!") &(- -"$, " % $ " "" " 0"" " %0 $". (". +0"$ " #% % (0$% # 1 % 0$% .-% . ) % $ (", " " 2 "##" % " (" "%0! 3 $ "-$% -. #"4 "!% % !

"##$"%) #. 0 -. #% " $ #% $ -. #" " " %0 %#% " 5 " ( %0 ( #%$ ! $ (". - "$$#"- % #" 6 ( %0 " #%- ( " - 0"( " -% " #"

" - % " 0 . "$ " "!( . " ! ( "!( % -" %0

$ "" % - #" -.

8 #% % #% ! #%# $%"!7$ % "##$"" % +0%%

"00$8 4 "##$" 0% $%(#"% %0

", 0% ""( " (" "!%. " 7 " !"% " ""( $ "!8 ' $%#. %0 ( %0 #%- ( (% "-% " - !% #"0% %-"% 300% (" 0% $%$"% 6 #" 9 0% %( (% ( :% % $%( # % 0% $%$"% 7 /*"

;"!%%#!

&(-

"(" <

"##$"#% &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

) ' %$" $% 0% #% 300% (" 0% $%$"% - %( (% ( 0% "( %( # %

0%0 $%$"% 7 7 /*"

24""

;"!%%#!

&(- &(-

"(" <

9 = 6 !) ' %$") $% 0% "##$" &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

) ' %$" $% 0% #% 300% (" 0% $%$"% - %( (% ( 0% "( %( # % >0%0 $%$"% %# 7 7 /*"

24""

;"!%%#!

&(- &(-

"(" < :% ' # % " > %0 &(- $".) ?"- *!" $ '

%.)

" !" )" $"%0(" *%, ' "" -$ @. $ ) &% " "-", #" %#"

" ",

# (" *%, ' "" -$ @. $ %#" %( #% > 0%$%$"% 7 7 7 A%"!

24""

;"!%%#!

&(- &(-

"(" >> >< :%0% "##$" &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

) ' %$" $% 0% #%

6% ". %

" $%( # % - "0 %0 "##$" % #"$#"$%$"%#%$ !

%( #% 0%$%$"% 7 7 A%"!

;"!%%#!

&(-

"(" > ><

"##$"#% &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

) ' %$" $% 0% #% 300% (" 0% $%$"% - %( (% ( 0% "( %( # % 0%0 $%$"% 7 7 A%"!

;"!%%#!

&(-

"(" <

"##$"#% &'(" #

) '" &""! *!" $% &&"#

)' %$" !%! $" " %0 "##$" " - #% $ -. #% 0% #% %0 > % > " % 6 #% $%%0 $"

" - %-?$ % -. "##$" "!! " #%" "$"% - (" # -$ , % #(%

: 300% (" 0% $%$"% 6 "( % $$ 4 ") 0%) %0 %#% " "##$"% % - $ % ( " #% - $% C %0 *!" $ '

%'$ $" 0% % 7 7 7 A%"!

24""

;"!%%#!

&(- &(-

"(" < 2 ) " %%4 "

'##$8"/ 09

7 )

0; <+ *1'=2.> '. #". % " # (".) -0% # -% !

-0%".$% ) (", " "##$"% % (" *%,' ""0% (%0 # % " ("*%,' "" " % " ?

$% #$ %0 ". (" "! % " %00$ % $%(#% "- "." % 0 " ("*%, ' "" ""%% "?

$% (" " %0 #%#. # 5$ ", # % "% "

" =%() (".) -. %0$"%) $" ( %0 ", #

#$0 $% #%% $% "% "'

%. '0 " "##$"% (" -$% % (" *%, ' "")%#".% ""##$"% " %, ?

$% %0 ". $% "( #

4 " "##$"% (" % " (" *%, ' ""

- $% "

" $ "$ #". % "##$"% % 0 -0% " "() "! 0"$ " " %0 #

"##$"%) #% % $ # " !% ##%%0)% %##%% %) $ #% % ) " $" (". -) " $ #". (". ##( $ "( ". %$ (" % $ $ $ #". ("##%#"#%%0%0 $ 0"$" !% " " "$%#.%0 $ "(%! "$%#.%0 $ %$ (" % $) 0 ".) % "$ %0 #"% "##$"%D - (". 9 ". #". % "##$"% % 0 " %" "(-0%""."!%0 $%$"%#%$ !D $ " $%(( $" ". %$ ( % "( $ -. 0%( ". #". % "##$"% % % #".) %

"- $ % #".%# #. % > "() " %" "( " #.) 0 ".) "- 0

-$%

) % "0"$% %0 (" *%, ' "") " $% $ $%$"% #%$ ! - #" % "##$"% $ ("" , "##%#" ",! % "$$% $$ ("$%0 # 6 (" *%, ' "" ")

! $% $ %0 $%$"% #%$ !

-$% > ) " #" "(# % "$ " "($"- ( %0 # " # " (#"" (" + "- .%0.#".% "##$"%%$%%#"!%% 0" (" *%, ' "" $%$"%%0 # "!% "##$"% " % $%(#. $%%0 ("*%,' ""% #% $ $ " % " %$ (-0% 4 "("*%,' "") "0%" $%$"%#%$ !)%0 %#% " 5 ( %0 ( $ #%$ ! $ (".-"$$#"-% #")(". 0%( " ( %0 " #%- (%0 # " !% #"$%$ 0% %-"% " $" #" "$ " " "!( % ( %0

# ) . " ! ( "!( " (" *%, ' "" " #" " "" ( %0" 0 "$%#.%0 "( %"$ %0 #"$%$ 4 #"0"%"$ "" "!( -$% E ) (" *%, ' "" ") 0 # % % " % ". %00$) $ # < 2 )* " *

+ , %%4.#1" 6 %%4.:1 .$1" ;+ " 2 " '<<%&'( +" %%4.$1" " + )* +

)+ " = +* +

)* 4 "" + "

5 + +"+ +*%>(%&'( "" + "

"* "

)* )

+ +" %%4.#1"

* "+

, " )"

2" " " ) **+,-./*01

23*% 47*( .6*.#4*17+ '12% 47*($ 2 " 4 * %%4.#1" "

) .:1.$1"

*" "

* +

)* ) )* * "

++ " ""

+ %%4.#1" 6 *) )* 2 )* +4 ") !3*3*12

3*?+=@*5'+ C >) " 4 * ) *)" +4 3 + ) " ""

2 * 3 + + 3 + ) ) * +,*

2 " 2 "

* + ?