Ramanand Pulavarti v. Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd.
!" #$%&'('( !$%$)%* #$%&+,((
-.-%-%#)/-"-!01 ((( 0101$% ! 2 ! ) %#1-3)// $) 1%4 1%-%* 50#( ((( 6$%# %0 & 75
(
!"
#$
%
'
()) #$
%
+ !",
#$
%
-.
/& #$
%
$
8(
0 *".$ 1
$
"2".
%$
3
'", +#4 151
1 ".$
&..
3
$ $$
#6 '0 .
,
%%$
$$
22 $
*% ".
22""
" '. 1 $
+, "'.
72 11 $ ..
%$",
2$ * 2
* 2"
$
*".$ $ 2 ." !2$$ "
.0 8$
"*
2"
$
9-**) #*$.6-%9: "
%$
.
;
# .
,2 6%$ "
,$
0 .
% $.
$"% "
0
.
3 2
< ; "$ 2 *
2 ." "$ 3
& $"
$ =
.,.
"% '", "$ " 2
3 "$ '0 2 ..", 2 ."
*".
* 2"
$ 2 ."
%"
* % $", ."2"0
"$% .$ ".
$
$ $$ '0
22 ", "
*% ".
22""
**% " '. 1
+ 7 #%
.
22 $ % %"0
>.",
,,"
"2 ,$
$ $$
*".$
,$ .$ "
.
"2 ,$
$ "'. 3
"2 "%
"* =6%"
**"%
."2"$ "
2.0 =.
>"%
#$ ,
!
"%
$ "
,2
0
< '0 ,",
2
5 %
# $'
'%" "
,2 6%$
/' 4 /$
",$
< "%
=.
>"% ,"
",
"
"
6% 2"
( $
!'3.0 #"%.
# %""
2$$
"% ",
=.
>"%
"
2" "$ 2"
6%"
.
.*
=.
>"% &*
1
3"" > 2 /7 *"..$ 2$
2 "
8$ "
.
* '2"$
",$
*
2"
< ?
". '", 2"
" "%
$0
$0
%2 "
'", 2"
.0
%%
*%
2 .
0
$
.0 . ",$
"2
2 =.
>"% 2"$
<
* ,$ .$ .
%.
/' 4 /$ 2"
=.
>"%
"% .
$0
$0 2,2
""
'.","
%
2"
=.
>"% $"$ *..
%
**"%
$*.:
.& '2"$ " 0
%"*"% "%
$0
$0
2 0
"$%
2
% $
**%
"2".
2 ." *".$ $;% 2 ."
"
$$
22 $
% %"0
$
..,$ $% 2 ." (0 * '2"",
+ 7
" 3
$
22 $ *
'2"$ "2 ,$ 22 ",
$
3 3
'
,2 .$ "
.
.%$
."%
"" %"$
" #$
%
&
'(')
*!
+,- .
%!
/00
1 # #$ # % & '(') 2% 3*)
1 1
, 4, 56 &
'(') %% 7 % 3'*
5
$;% 2 ."
*".$ .0
2.0
$ '2"$ **"%"
"$"% .
,2
=6%"
%"*0
3"2
+ 7 3"$
%"$
.0
$", ".
,
*".$
'", 0 2".
% $
.$
%."
"%
$0
$0
"2
22""
**% $ %2 ."$
"2 %
"$$
,
"%2'
$;% 2 ."
.'
. .0$ %
%"
2", ')% 2
2 ." 3
"$ $"%
" .,..0
* %'. '", 2"
3.
2$
$0
$0
* ,$
)""% %"
" %"
"" ,
"
. @ %
"$$ $", ". "2 ,$
$ $ ** * 0
"*"2"0
*".$
' %
.&
""
*".$ 1
$
2""'. #%% $",.0 ,$
$"2"$
1
$ "
.
'2""
'"$ , ,
2".
.%$
% $
#
"$$
0
3
% "$$
*".$ 1
$
"2".
%$
:'.
."$ $ & %" $""
'0
% 3
@",
& '
2"
$
$ 2 88 " " ,,
9:
*0/;!
%% /3;
"%
..
&
?
2
&" % $$
2
@ " *%
. 2@
' ..0
$ $"%.
".
",$"
"%
..,$
%%$B
.0
'$ .0 "2 ''.
$
% %
%."
**"%" , $
%$", %%$B
$"%"
6%"$ ,"
"", % % "%"
'"0
'$ "
"$%
2". "%
..0 ".
"$2""'.B
** * *$2.
.,.
<
$*% %
&
%"
'%
.,..0 2
"0 ."@
>
$ $
,"
"", 22 % "*$
6%"
&
1
$
.
"$$ :'.
< 1 "
2%4
=!
'(*'!
) %% >'> #$ &,
,!
"
' *".$ 1
3
$ 22 ", 2""'.
!"2"..0 % )$,2 $$ ".$ "?
% "
@ & '('> 2% ';*
:'. "$
""
$
"%
22 "*$
A",
6%"
&
1
$
1
+7 *
.0
$"
3 "**"%" *$ '@ %% !"%
*".$ " ..,", 22""
1
+7 * "
*
+7 "%
$.
2 $ ..
&
*01$%++
&
7* 22"",
%"
1
0
"2
22"$
&..
..
$2$
,".0
5
..
%$$
" %% $",.0
"$$ "$ '%"
..
$ 0
" 2 "*
22"$
@ &.$,
6%"$ ..
$ $".",%
22""
%
**%
"$$ * 2"$
"
.$", 0
**"%
2 .
02
.
2
!
2
*"%".
"
&$
..$
.
2
!
2
20
..
%"
&" $", 0 "$ '%"
0
22"$
22"$
"
%
"''.
0 ,.%
0
2, %0
**"%
%
2, %0
**"% ..
.
$2$
,".0
..
%$$ " %% $",.0
=6 ."
>
%"
C% 2 0C 2 0 '
$0 "%.$
*"2
%""
"$"
"$.B
' C$"% C ."
*"2 2
*"2C
' $",
* 2"
$
""
%.
* 2 " %$ "* 0
22"$
0
2 .
0
."'.
.0
%
.$
"* "2
1
22"$
&..
& &0
6% "
2.
. %
.
%"2".
"%"
.$ %
%"*"%
""
&0
%"2".
% 6$$
+7 "%
%"*"%
""
"%
1
+7
22"$ 6$ %"2".
$"
3
**"%
> %" $""
"%
2"
$
+7
"*"$
$""
"%.0 2 ."$ 7 *
..
"2
22""
& " &
**% %"
. %"
&..
.$ 3"$
,
"% .0
+7
22"$
*.%$ 2
2 ." ."% 6 %
#
& " 2 < '(() 3!
+,- % ''0 "
D$,:
(%
$.",
*%
&
D$, (%
$2""
+7 **"%" "* '%
$
. *.*"..$ 3"2
"$
%0
%"*"%..0
% $ $2""
$2$
* $2$
,".0
.
0 * '%
%"*"% 2 ", 0
3 ,",
" ,",
"
%$$ ,"E :'. # 6
'
%0
%"*"%..0
"2
22"$
2 ".
3"2
2 ." ?"
2
3"2
"$
"*"$ !"2".
' "
& 2 6, +9 =8
%#5#5*;';05'(*A
*A(3'('($ :'.
":
."% % .
.%$ 1 "
2%4
=! '((/ *!
+. '() "
' :'.
2
.0 " 2 )"*0",
3"2
+7 ' 2 .
2 2$ "
&"
,$
"
*%"
",
<
7 21 B " ? '((/ '!
%
%!
';;
' :'.
+7 "$
.,.
*"%"
"%
.
,
..0
22""
"%"
.0
.$
%
"%"
"*$
.0 "*
3"" 2 ' '*
"%"
.0 "% 2 ."%
0 3"2
""$ 7 '"% 2 2
+7 & '
%
$$
3
'
.%
%"
..,$ 2
%"*"%
.0$ 2
%"
%. 2'",
$%" "
%.
5
7 & & 9 "
#
'((A!
/ %% >>'
' :'. " 2
'
".
$ &
62""
$2"
"%.
*% ".
$
"%"
E
1
7 11 +9 " "1 + '((0 3!
%
%!
)/*
:'. ". "$", 2 22"F$
""
+7 $
,( 4
""
%
22"$
" 7* ,",
"
,", %0
2@ 2
**"%" "* 2
,",
" ,",
. "2 '% *"6
G,",H
$ G/"% H 2@ %. 0
&
"" 7
**"%
",$ 3
.*
$
2@ %"*"% 2
2@ 0 %"*"%
'
"
%
,.",%
0 *%
$"
$ 3 ",$
"2
.*
,"
"
"'"."0 ' %"
""" 7
%0
2, I
$*"$
2 " #%J
*$
%.
*
2 " 2
%0
'",
#%
*
2 %0
,
2 "%. &"..
$"'. 0 % .
2@", %0 2
.",
"
%
,.",%
'", 2 '%"
"
**"%
%
'%"
**"%
%
.0 '%"
", "
""
$" " . ,$
" $"
3 $"%.
",
"
%
,.",%H
*% % .
2
,
& '(*( '!
%
%!
*'' " :'. ". $.",
2
."$ $ & ..
&", "%" .
" "20 "'"."0
2 ."
2@ %"*"% 2 3"$ .&
2@
"%"
.0 ."'.
> *", %"2".
2 "
0 @ & '
%"
"" $ 2@ ..
**% %"2".
% *$
.0
"2
22""
&
&
""" K"%"
% "*$
,"$
"% $ 2 "
<
.0 "* 3"" 2 "%
3"$
$ 2 ."; ""
2@
"
"%"
.0
22"$
.
,
2
"", & "%
"
"
""
0
%$$
"
K"%"
2
.$$
"*$
7* ,",
" ,",
%0
2@ %"*"% 2
"
"
""
0
%$$
" 7*
**"%
",$ 3
.*
.
%0
2@ %"*"% 2 2 ."
"" ,
. "2
$
*%
$2$
%
%H
7 +1 69 : ,
'(*3
>!
%
%!
/// ". $.",
2 " :'.
' %0 2 ."
#.
,
"%. 2
2@", %
%"'$ 20 %0
$% .,,
1
+ 7 ' $",
'%
%%"
$"%.
. "2
7 # %
B < '(*>
'!
%
%!
') :'. "$ '
' "
' 2 '*
%"*"%
,.
.. *
*".$ .. 1
+7 $"2"$
7 6 & " + # '(*)
*!
%% *(3
:'. # 6 $.",
,$
& ", "
3 ' &
22 $ %%$
'
*
", "
3
2,",
) " 2,",
%$ %0
*".$
1 $
+7 . "2
22"$ %
&
&
'"%
3"2
$2$
*
' *".$ 3 % ,"
..
$",
"* '"% 2 $
**"%" 2 %$ ' "* '.$
2 A",
% 3
% "* 2@
2@",
"2 $ ".
'
%
*% % .
)$,2 $$
$ :'. "2".
# .
5551
"",
! %".
8 ""
%"2".
".$ & + #$ < + "
' "2 .0 '%
$
%".0 2
*.*".. 3"2
2@
"2
. 2".
"2
" '"
7
9 =
#
'(*>!
*;
%% *A0 3 & "$
$"
$ 3 & $2"$.0 ",$ ..
=6%"
' =6%"
$ ' % $"
,
%
'
.
$0
$0 **"
", "
.0
" 6%"
%"
"0
*
"%"
+ 7
2".
"
"2
.2
**"
%"
.0 .
@$
* $0
$0 %"
""
"%..0
" '" !"2 .0 '%
$ 2@
"2 + 7 #% = 0
%$
&"..
*..
"
2'"
""
+ 7 "%
.
%
"%"
."'"."0
' 2 ."
%"..0 ..
2 %
"%
2 0:
'"
7 4 % 1
#$ &
%#5#5'0*;05'(*'
(*(>'(*)
'
2$ 0 2
1
+ 7
%"*"%..0
"%
. "2
22"$
$0
$0 *%"
",
!"2 .0 '",
$
$"% *%"
*% $ $", 2%.
%"%2% ".", " % 0
"
.
."%"
.
"%
" $0
$0 **"
<
?
". .0",
"
:'.
1 #
'
..
" "$ ",$ $"
$ 3
0 . "
<
6%"
2".
% $
0 &
"%
3 "
.
2 2 0:
**" .0 6%"
*"$
,
%
", $"$
6$
*"%".
$%""
2@",
"
.
2,2
' "% .%@$ %"*"% 2
'." 6 '& .. *"%".
%"
$2 $ "
.
2 2 0: *"%".
**" % $ 3"
%..0 *"2$ " 6%"
$% ", " ."2"$ . ,
%
0 6%"
$%""
2@",
"0 * 0
"%"
.0
.$
+ 7 #%
5
7 1 1
, 4,:
0
.. @", 3
%"2".
%$", """$
1 $
+ 7
$%."$
A",
D$"% ( 2'0 ..
"$ $
=6%"
0$
*".$ .
'* :'. A "$
#$$""
.
7$ $ =6%"
A
.
*"%".
"
@0 2,2
", 0
3
' :'. 2
$","
$ %."
.0 '."
1
+ 7 #% ", %"*"%
$2 ", : %"
.
2 2 0:
**" . "2 ?
". .0", # &
5
' 2 $","
**"%"B %"*"% . "'"."0 2 '." 2 ."
1
.0", "
.& ."$ $ & '
$"%$
""
%." *%
.
2".
.%$
% $ "$ "
", 0
$"
$ 3
%"
.0
.
*"%".
$%""
2@", ;%
A $2"$.0
=6%"
2" &*
1 $.0 "*"$ /7
,"
2 " $ " 0 %"*"%
$"
$ 3
..
$",
%. '%
0
"%. .
% $
0 *"%".
"'"."0
.
2 $0
$0
"
. "$.0
."2"$
=6%"
;% A" %"
.
2
'." $
#$2"$.0
.
/' 4 /$ 6%$
'& " 2"
=.
>"%
"%
.
$0
$0 2,2
$ 2 ." 2"
=.
>"% "%.$$ %
**"%
$*.:
.& $""
".* **"%"
"$"%
.
$0
$0 2,2
"%.$$ %
: ;;1* !<=$1 1%# ;-)/0># %
%
"%"
.0
.$
+ 7 #%
1
"$$
""
$ 2
2$ 0 .,.
3"2
"2 ."%
$ ' ". 6%"",
& 1
$
! A",
%$
, %"%2 %"
'
%
2""
".
"3"0 &
*"6$
2.
..
&$
62"", *%
.",
'
$"%"
"%$ "%
"2 .
**% .
,
. "2 '
$
.0$
"2
,$", *"%
"%
3
.
*$
* %
""
0", 22 ",
$
3 3
%$", *
"2 '
%
.&
"$", %." *% %"%2%
&..
"
.& ."$ $ & '
$"%$
"" 2
"$$
""
*" "
&
"$$ 1
$ % 6%"$
3
2 ."
#%% $",.0 ..
&$ "2 ,$ &..
"2 ,$ 22 ",
$
'0 3 $; "$ 3
& %."*"$ ".
..
%$
%% $%
.&
+,((
" #$%
% " '( %