Sher Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others

  
        
  


  

!"#"

$% & '&

   

     

 

   


 

     



       

          ! "#$!

%# &''# ((( 

     

 #&''# "&&#$  ')#*&+',%# -* ',#% # ./01202.3 4*567&8+ ')#99$#!.!:

!# 9'5&##1$$&', &&9'$'##% +!*99&*'8%#$'#', ;*'# '  ' %"#*  #    8'  #%    *,;    2<0=20.= 3 4*  527  &  8+ 

  ''#9  &*+  )#;;''# "9#&;75&##>4$'', &# #%)#99$#!

,  * 
$'#  ..  3.7  #%     * 8  '99,  )#;;#  ? 3,*9'#7 $!.=@.3 '%%#A .=@. $A7! 8+ $9';#%8#*<00:

 #% '99,*99&*'8%# $9'## %%$ + # #% 9;*',2>2.

', 0>' '*8 $;#%$ 99,'&&9 2 ' *8;''##% 9$#*9%# &''# *'##61@6'%"#*#%;$ +!*99&* '85&##@"'#2<0=20.=3 4*527' #*'89' 9', #% %$ 8#*<00&''#&% *
$'#..3.7#% .=@. $8+ "'99, " 8 $' 8+

 ''#9 &*+)#;;''#3 "9#&;75 &##>"' *,;2<0=20.=3 4*5278* ;## "+%%$# ', #% &''# '$9';

*
$'#..3.7#% .=@. $9#, ' 8#*@/# &#&'# #% "'99,&',$#''# ' #*+$''#! '  # "8"# "'$'8',$# ' $#'#' ' 8$#%+%'9'B'# ' ,# '9#% 9'-*'#-*99&#&'#! ;*'#$#*9# "8  *! ';&*,#$#*' > #   ,*;!    8  '  8+     9 $#*9  %#     &''#!  '     ,'     #    ./01202.

3 4*567$'#',*'##61@68+  ')#99$# . !:

!# 9'!&&9*
$'#.>#% * 8? "* $!.66/3 '%%#A .66/ $A7 8 &%8+ "'99,8%# ''$)#99$#!

,!  # 9'  '9    '8 
',    #   "  ;  $ +!

*99&*  '8!   '  9'  %#  ',  #  >00=202.  !

%#! ';&*,#$'#',;*'#$#8*' "#8' ';&*,#'#%'9+ <  ' %* *8;''##% 9$#*9%#

 &''# "'% *,;2<0=20.=3 4*527' '99'#&'##+!#%# ! 8,8+  &&99 * #'+ &&9'$'#%#+', #&'##% ' *,; '  &',  $#''#!     &''#  $#  8  8#*  8+     '

*,;     '  ;    &',  $#''#  8%#   $#;&* #'+&$'99+'&**$# #&8+ #A89
*&;)#*'
&$'9?"''##6>>>#%20..$' #260=20..$# &''#*
$'#..3.7#% .=@. $ "8&%8+ "'99,'$$#$ ' & $''##% #A89
*&;)#*! %#!

*999 &''#$'! ;*'#!$'#"' ';&*,  #    ./01202.  3 4*  567  8+     ' )#99$#!.!:

!# 9'5&##1!$#*'!

%#!$#  '&''#"#899#  1 C  "  $#'     *8;''#  ;  8+     9 $#*9%# &''# ' ''$! ",# #*,  &9',$##% $ @

  8'%  %$!     #  8  ;'#    &   &9',! &#&'##% '99,*99&*'8%#; #$'+* ;#%) #$9;'#
#$'+3 '%%# A 
#$'+A7%# &*&##%;''',;,', 9! '9'&52#%  '&''#' 
#$'+% ,''##0/02.=>=&#$#;  9$*9'"89%#; '"$'#%#; ';# ! &#'##% &#&'#' %9$' "*$# 

9''&*!$$#',# &''#! ""#*%#+$#;;#&*&##%

( "'99,$#;;*'+! *!'#$#"* %'''##%A
;9

A9'# '
$'#23,7#% .=@. $

'9 # "  '  +  $##9''#  &#$',  %#  +  $#;;#  &*&# $$#',# ;8'#% +.=<15<@!' $#9*;#%#  '&!

' A
;9 8D:

 A' $#9*; #%  $*9'"'#!     +    A 8##   9 A  

  ;  &#''# $#'*' +.=1>51<;8' ' #*,  4$*'"  '*$'#!  *'#  #  2><.  #     8'  #%  ?  # <===E1@6E)  #  1<    200<.=1<    !  8+   #  '& ;*%#;
;9 8D:

 # ,$ + # "! $#9*;#%$*9'"'#;'; &#&'##% "'99, '&#'##% 9''&*

' $ 99,8+ "'99, #*,  
#$'+ "'*'##2=0.010<.=@>! #  '& $ ,  # #8A*';,'A / ;  $ +!  *99&*  '8  %'9    &&9'$'# *
$'#/3.7#% .=@. $%#  $;#% 
#$'+%#; 9''&*#>0.0.=6. 

''$ "9#&;$ +

%%'$ 4$'',     &#   #%  )#99$#!  ##& ,  ';'   &&9'$'##% +!,' !&&9 &% ' )#*#% ''#9 '$#!$ +4$'', &# #% )#;;''#!  $$&"'#.206.==2 

' #$;#8$ 99,8+  
#$'+8+%'9',)C#12/0#% .==<!  99# 8+ 9
',9*,#% ')#*"' #  01..20..  '9 ',  '   #  .206.==2 &8+  &&99 * #'+! #','9##% )#99$#!##&

) ,>.0>.=6= *& 9

+$ 99, ;8%# '"''#$ 8+%'9',? #=/2#%2002   ';'#.10/2006 

'# $ 99,8+ ;

$ +  8%#     #A89 
*&;  )#*  8+  %'9', 
&$'9  ?" ''##6>>>#%20..!  $'#260=20..! 8+ &#&'##% "'99, $99*&##%'9&''#*
$'#.. 3.7#% .=@. $%#$'', '9#% 9''&* 6  9', #% #8"'##% #A89
*&;)#*' 8#"#260=20..! "'99,'$9*', &''#%'99,*;8#%&''#*
$'#..3.7#% .=@.  $  8%# 

  ''#9  &*+  )#;;''#  3 "9#&;7 4$'', &# #%)#99$#!

,!# 9'!#*#% !<00 &''# "8$'"'$#;;# *,;2<0=20.= 3 4*527 '9 '9$9';&'',#@=&#&'#'$9*',   #%     &''#    '99  &',  $#''#  

'  $#;;#

*,;     2<0=20.=  3 4*  527    $ 99,  8+   &#&'##% "'99,8+%'9',&&98%# #' "9#&; )#;;''#3$ +7* 8# 9'4$'', &# #% )#;;''#* .=@. $ &&9'$'#%#+#% ';&*,

*,;  "  9#  8  &%     '99  &',  8%#   &&99 * #'+ ' #*+$''# =

+!&' 8',&&9&', $#''#8%#  &&99 * #'+,' *,; 2<0=20.=!  &&#$      )#*  #% 
*85 '"''#9  ,'5$*;5 ')#99$#3 )7!:

%#$'#',;*'#' %"#*#% +'&**$# ' *,;

* &##'$ "',8'*!#8 $'# "8%'98+ &#&'# ',"'#*&9'$9*', # &&9,' ' *,;2<0=20.=! ' 8'%#;#"', &&9'$'#  %#  $'#',  ;*'#!  '  '99  &',  9#,  '   &&9'$'#%#+8*'99  ')#99$#!.!:

  &#$# $'# *'# #61@6 #%
;9 ? #% '99, *99&*'8!9#$  '9:

! ''$

,!# 9'

'%"#*#%;$ +"'#./01202.3 4*567     8       ,'   '  $'#',  #%  ;*'#   ./01202.!&&9*
$'#.>#% .66/ $8%# ''$ )#99$#!

,!# 9''9'8
', # ";

$ +!*99&*'8 8&% ''99&', $#''# ''#! #*,  ' '&''#!$ 99,',*'# #61@6$'#'%"#*#% +!*99&*'85 &##@"'#./01202.3 4*567&8+ ')#99$#!.!:

!# 9'5&##1 .0

8'$&9! 8'8+ &''#!'  '&''# *
$'# ..3.7#% .=@. $ '99 &', $#''#8%# $#;&)#*%#$9'##% '9#% 9''&*! %#! ;*'#$#*9# "8$'# # &9! 8'!' &&9 8&% ,'  *,;   2<0=20.=  3 4*527 &  8+

''#9  &*+  )#;;''#  3 "9#&;75&#  #  > 4$'', &# #%)#99$#!

,* .=@. $! ' &',$#''#9#, ' &&9'$'#%#+*',

 &$+  #%     &&9!  *$  $'#  #%  ;*'#  '  '99,9    # *'89 .. ##% 8#",#*! "8 8+ 9$#*9%# &''#!$8$$&' 9', #% %$ ;*'#! 8$'#"' ';&*,# ./01202.!'8*&# *,;2<0=20.=3 4*527!

8+ $9';#% "'99,%#$9', ; # #% 9'-*'#$',' ; '$9';

8 $

+! %#!' # #% 9 '-*'# &$+#% &&9# &&9'$'#%#+ #*9 #;  *,;2<0=20.='#&'"'$ 
*# #&#"'%#*#;'$+#% ##;%'9',#% &&9! '&9! *!$#8$$& .2   ,     $#'#  #%     9  $#*9  %#   &''# *'%#$9'##% &''#&%8+ ;

*
$'#..3.7#% .=@. $!''99&',$#''#8%#  ')#99$#!.!:

! %#! ;*'#$#*9 # "8$'#!',';'&9$  $''#'   *'%'98+ ;*
$'#..3.7#% .=@. $' $$&$9', &''# # #% 9'-*'#! $+  $#$'#E;;  '     ;*'#  $  8  $9';   $'#* .>

&!'#8&#'#*  ,' #  ./01202.! 8+*'# #61@6   8 $'# ' %"#*  #%     ;  $ +!  *99&*  '85&#  #  @!

 &&9*
$'#.>#% .66/ $8%# ''$)#99$#!

,!# 9'&% '&',%# >00=202. 

*#+;+,' '#! '';&*,' & '&''#! "',8"'9! & '&''# #*9#8 ;''89# ',#*9#!  '&''#"';'9 .< ?"',99 &$&!''9&#&#''##%9 8+# '"'#*  *,; "8&8+ #A89
*&;)#*', %#; +,-.#/ 0"$1/ "  ".. 0"$1/2 .=@>
*&&93.7
)11%#99# 8+03 & 04,$""03 &

$ , 5+,2.==@ 3/7 
)160!64$

0"$1/"+6

0"$1/  8 -9 :#23.==/7/
)).>/!

0+,;

/$""$$!"6
33"##"

$ ,23200/7@
)).6@ 9#' *,;#% 
*&;)#*' 03 & /"3-"

</

53- ., 78

/, +1/ : " , /+,

3= ,

$ >= ,

3=$9 $

/ ,#2320.=7>
)).=.!
&$'9?"# &&93)7#1/<>#% 2020  '9   /

33"##"

$ , ,+/ / $16 ,

</$1, 6".

$ $

/ , " ,+66 5/$ $ $

/ ,!  $'  # 210.202.
&$'9?"# &&93)7#.>.<@#%202.'9 "

$ , 0"$1/"/



< /9 , #/ $

/ ,#2$'# 0@0=202.! '' 8 9 ;*'#+##$#% +', !'9#''%"#*#% &# ;*'#+' "*$#'#9+%# %'$9&*&# ', #% &' $#9+8$+9'B# 8'#% $''#8%# $#;& )#*#% *''$'# .1
#  %       '9  #%     &#&+  '  $#$!  '   $#$9*8+"'#* *,; '$#9+8$'8+$#;& )'"'9)#*

'"'  84&'

+ 3".3 0"$1/

'

$

/ ,#! .==<
*&;)#*.@1>!0+3$ ?

,3"$"

$

$ "!3200<7.2
))16F @,+ "$ " ;+ "$ 3200676
)).2F ;"$ , 0"$1/ " 0 

A5!  320067  = 
))  >@6F <+$"!"=6
,= , "

$2 +,$1- "0 

</,#/ ,2320.17.@
))@6=F &B"

"&
/"$$

,#"3/!320./7/
))><2F,/6 , /$ "0 $+ 5+3/,!320.=7.0
))21=F;"

5+,",#/$ 0"$1/!

320.=7.>
))/0 .@

', #% &''# "',#8%%$8+ ';&*,#./01202.!8#"! ##%'+ '99,9'+' ;$99',%#'"'##% ')#*' 4$'#% ' ' *''$'#&$'99+  '9'"%%$'"*#+ ;+#%&&9"'989*
$'#.>#% * 8?"* $!.66/ ;+9#'"# '&', ./ #     %#,#',  #!    #  #  %'  + ,#*  # '%' ;';'  '&''#

0

  <0 



05 5< ?<

 =

3- ,

=;

/

/ , #= ."$1C, # $ %  #C

/

/ ,  = , -6 %  #C