M/S Gazebo Developers Pvt Ltd v. Financial Commissioner Appeals Punjab And Others

 
  



!

 " 
! 


!

 # $$ % &'& '

(' ' 
 '

)
( *
 '

)



    &&&

             &&& +!+ 
(' 
 '

)
( 
 '

)  

    &&&

             &&& +!+


(', 
 '

)
( *
 '

)



    &&&

             &&& +!+ 
(' '
 '

)
( - 
 '

)



    &&&

             &&& +!+
 

 



 



  !"#   "$%&'(&!)&%   *+,-&"

./"(  +/!*&%/!0(  *+,-&"

1, "()"/"/,!

  (& &!) "/!0(   $!2&3

1, "("&"  &//!0((&$(&!

 *+,-&"

1, "(&))%/-&!"  ),!*!",  

 

   
( *
 '

( 
 '

( *
 '

( - 
 '

 &5 /!"( &))%/-&"/,! ,!3(&%1,1  ),!*!", 6 ,5&%!*$ "

/ /7/"*/ 1, )%&-/!0,! -, *&!&11/*&+/"","(11-"

"(&""(7&""

(& 3!-,7) ,7/ *3".!"()& "/  ,"/-,1"(&))%/-&"/,!    +/!*&%/!0(  *+,-&"

&--)" !,"/-,!3(&%1,1 "(!,!6&))%/-&!")"/"/,!

&!* "&" "(&"((& !,,32-"/,!","() &5

7&*/!"(&))%/-&"/,! !+/.,1"(&3,+ "( &))%/-&"/,! & &%%,.* $32-"", 2$ "  8-)"/,!    11/*&+/"  ,1   ),!*!"  ,  6  ,5&%  !*$ "

/ /7/"*/ "&'!,! -, *  !"(2,/!" 9$ "7&*35"(-,$! %1, "()& "/ "( (& /!0,1"(7&/!-& .(/-(& 1/8*1, 



 
:

/ ) ),!*&!* "( &7& "&'!,! ,& *
 & .

'-.

'*

'*

# 

,$! %  1,  "(  )& "/  $37/"  "(&"  /!  "(  %/0("  ,1  "( -,7) ,7/ .(/-((& 3!!"

*/!",3".!"()& "/ &--, */!0", .(/-( "(7$"&"/,!(& ",3 &!-"/,!*/!1&+,$ ,1"()"/"/,!



;

&<3,+%,) +""* $*(/&!&,!"(3& / ,1"(&%* & *"&/%*/!)& &6,1"(&11/*&+/"*&"* == 
:,1(& 3(&2&!/!0( ,!,1(& *(&/!0( &!&0/!0/ -", ,1  ),!*!",

"( .

/"

)"/"/,! 7&53&%%,.* "(& 1$ "( 3! "&"*/!"(&11/*&+/""(&"

/!/"/&%%5"( $/"1, *-%& &"/,!&%,!0./"("(&))%/-&"/,!1,  "&5$!*

* ;:$% 
> .& )

*.(!"() &5 1, 0 &!"/!0 "7), & 5/!2$!-"/,!.& *-%/!* &))&%&0&/! ""( &7.& )

* &!*/"/ &""(&" "&0,1"(&))&%"(&"&-,7) ,7/ .& !"

*/!", 3".!"()& "/  !)$ $&!-"( ,1 "(&))&%&!*"(-/+/% $/"

)

*35  ),!*!", (&+3!./"(* &.!,!
?
 
:&!*

 
:  )-"/+%5 !+/.,1"(&3,+ "( .

/")"/"/,! & &%%,.*& ) "( -,7) ,7/   .(/-(  (&  3!  !"

*  /!",  3".!  "(  )& "/    ( /7)$0!*, * *&"* 
 
?)& *35"(/!&!-/&%,77/ /,!

$!2&3  /  (  " & /*  ( / "&!"  ,%%-",

 $*(/&!&  (&%% ) ,-*  ",  &!-"/,!  "(  7$"&"/,!  &  )  "(  -,7) ,7/   !"

*  /!", 3".!"()& "/ 
(' ' 
 '

(' 
 '

(', 
 '

(' '
 '

!  +/.  ,1  "(  */ ), &%  ,1  "(  7&/!  . /"  )"/"/,!

 "( &))%/-&"/,! (&+3! !* */!1 $-"$,$ &!*"( &7& */ ), *,1& $-( +/012 .

'

3+   (+4


! @("(  )&'/!0 & ,!*# A , @("( ), "&3% # A ,