← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/37497/2021dismissed

Varinder Kumar v. State Of Punjab

2022-05-17Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj14 pages



       

!!!  "# $ % !!!  ) &* +  , &    

-.-. +" /    0 1- !



'2!!'!!

/ 3, & 4/   

-.-. +" /   0 1- &  53&

 /+ /  6     



 !"#!$%$&'

 (  )

 *+, - 



.$$$%$&'

 / 0  + /  6  1),2 3( ,4 .$$$%$&(, "              "   3(

,((,4 !"#!$%$&(,"         "  33

'2- $ 1 ,    ,  5,      ,(  ,   , , 3  ,3 67

8( 3( , 4  .$$ ,,  ((     $"

% $%$&,, 9( -( , 3      $$!     3( 0&#!  ,: 

;

',+, ,67 4 <#&$ %.

$%&#,0(13( -,$$$#4=,0,   ,,&#.> ,:4=0;'3( 3,((,4  !"#!$%$&, ( ,,+ 5,67 4 %%<#&$ %.

$%&#()((,5( , 

/  &3 +/  2!!8!!

-( ,,67 5,), ,,37, ,3 ,,  0(?)),,

,  )+  3 (  4  0-<>=#%!%   7 @ ,  #">   ) ((  +A,)3(/3BC

,( /3 )( ,    ) ,  

( 9( -  67  4  &%%  && %!

$%&# ,  $$4=00( )), 9(+(A (,,3, @5  ,  ), ,  , (   &.<#  ,   ,  =0    ), (, 5, 

'3- (     ,  0 ),   , ( /3B) ),+, , ,  D   ,(, ,3  ( /3 B  ),)($ "%%% (,1( &%%    +  &% A,      9 ( 1, 3 03    (  (   ,3,/1,( 7),(, ),, ,3 ,+ (    , ,3 )  ,3 (   (,3,),,,,,-((

1,,3 ), (     ( (, )   ,  (, ,,),,, 1,(/3B   7,   &% A,  A  (, 3(( 3/1, D  A)&&! A,$%% (, 1,( $ "%%%A (,3+1(&%%) (( A, ) 3+ ) ( 3 ,  (, )   1 ,3((,),()+ ,,,,,(), 3,),,)(,   ?  7 6    , 

? &"

%.

$%&#   7, /3    , ( ),  ) ,,,( (A (, +,(+&&,3 (   $% ,3(, (,   3 (,  A (,3,$ .%),,( 1,(/3B ), ,,,3/,-(

'4- ,   *( E /3 ,   /3  

 !"#!$%$&'),3,, 7,, ,3/,-,(),(,)3E /3 0(3(/3),E /3 )    ?  /3 ,  ?



      

    

        

   

    

  "

'5- "

D(,,( &!  

 ), (   7((5 ,   3 ), 33(  ($$! 

),( (/3B,+, ),( ,  (9(- ,67 4 &%%&& %!

$%&#,4=0 ,,, ,,3),3    , (, ,  -,,  ), ,      )  ((     3 ,  3,,,, 1,((   ), ,3,,   9 (  (   ( 3( ,4 .$$$%$&

/  &3 +/  ($ > 1 3( 3,((, 4  !"#!  $%$&    ,(".$ 

(,"E/3,, 0 ,+5,67 ,5,, 3, 7,,,,  ((, ) 3  , ( /3 B    3),( ,(/3B 0

.$$$%$&'),( , 67 4 &%% && %!

$%&#  7 )(  (  ,  ( /3  3    ,3  0( 3   , ,  G  , 3 3 5  (3,  3 ,  )   A (, , (/3B)( ,3),)(,,,(/3B

'6-  7,0(,3(),  ( (,(  3( 3  , 67  4  ""  %"

%"

$%&# ,   $$  $#   4=0  ) ), (( ,, ()((/3 *%>3 ,,)3(,3 )  ,,,((  ,, (((33,3, H+366 3, 1 ),((5 ,67 ),( 3 ,(,03,((, ,3(01 ),3,-(( 4  &%% $%  $ % $%&#    (   ,  ( ),(,+ @) 3  13(  ),,) ),3, , (  ,3   @+3    $$ %!

$%&# @) )( ), ( ,@+3  ),  3,  (,  ),,,   (    ,

(2(,3((, 3(,)((, 3, (, 3(,, ,,,(,,33

/,-,( < * ,(   (   ,  ,3/,-,(),),,   %& %< $%&#  ), ,  / 1, - ) (,?30+,),/,-,( ,3 3   , ?3 0+,  , ,  /3 ),

'7- ,, E/3,(3 3  /, -,(  (3  &% (,   3 3-

, (3,3  ((/3),(( (( ,3 7, (/3,(,, ,3 ),33 @   ,  +)  /, -,(     , / 1,   -,,  ,  (, 03,  ,   ,,,3,(,3,,,H+,(C ,,3 1),,, 3+5 ),,3- 8

,/1,- 7,, 3 ),,,/,-,( ,/ 1,,/1, /3 ?30+,,,,),( ( 1,(3)((5 ),3 ,,(3  7,(( , (,( 3(,3/,-,(, 3,, (,, , , ,,3 !

),(,(3&< % $%&& ,, ,  3( ,4 #>%$%&% ?F '(, "

        "3(  ,, ,37,?  3     3, (+   3( ((  

'87,?,),,3( 3,, 83(,        ,  ,  (   , 3, (()  63  ,  ,  , )(  )((  ,

 ), (, 3    ,,   @' ( 3

  3( ( 4  &$!   $%$& ( ,   )(F,,D7 1@ ( ,3,3 ,(3 ,,,, 1,),,, 3

  ,@ ),(  ,33 ,<!4=0 .

0, 3,,,   ,    (  ,(  3+     ,  (  )    ,)  00 = 0( =,(  71- 7, (/3B 3( ,4 .$$$%$&,  ,,,,)(,( 3,3 , ( C,-,0(  ,- 8 ,-, ,  5   A  (,  =(0  1,67 4 &%%&% %!

$%&#),,,3 0( $$$#4=0  =,&><"%%A (,)3 ,4 0-% 9#>&< 6)=(0  1,   ), (, , (      #&&"%% A  (, )       $%>>%

'9- A (,)30/3 (  ( &%.. >%  A  (,   +   3+ ) 3,,, 8(),,   , 67  4  &%%  &% %!

$%&#  , 3 ),   &$ %.

$%&#   ,   3( (  A (,,  $ "%%%A  (,   1(&%% ),     ,(,    3  )  / 1,  7 ),  +)( +( ,  (,31,)(+,( ,  ),    ,,,,   ((    3  1    5, ),   ,   ),,,  =    ), ,(,  ( /3 B     ,, 3E/3,/3 ,E(( 3=+(H+ 

 !"#!  $%$&'     (,  5, )  3 0(9(1,), (  7,(3 3,3 3   E /3  1  , E /3 ), (, 3,,== 4 $.&> %.

$%&# 3 /, -,( ,   *( ), (,   &> %.

$%&#

,) 3,3,,3,(    (   ),,  /3 (, (  (( )  3    (     ,3 ), 3,3  ( +,/3,   3,((=+(=, ( 7,(,((

'10- ,),((, 3(   3 ,'*( (  I = =, -,+ ',( ) -, =-   +,-,+-, (( / =, -,+    ,  5, ), ( (,3%<3, 6),  3, (+ ( ) 0( -3(-,42-,,),(,(  (, 1),,, ,,, (( (3,1(&%% (,34)1@(

0 * 4(=( ,,3(  - ,  = -    +, - ,  +- 3,,(,,,A (,  3, - ,  42 -  9 ( 1, 3,,,3,3(,(,(/3 B,- 6(( %!,,)3, ,(),(,3 7),(, ,(3,,3),, C, - 8 ,, ((),3,, ,  3,, (3  7),, , ,,  (   3  $"

% $%$&   %  ,),,,$<),,,(  A3 1 (,%#,,,,4=0 )(,3

'11- # 7  (,  ( ,(   (   , ,       )   ( ,,, &% 7,,)(3 ,   ,  3 0, ?  , (  (+    (( ,, ( , , 1,,,,,3,5 3,3 ),,A( ( , 1A,33() ,(3,33,,   1( (,,,)E /3

 !"#!$%$&,+,,33 ,( (( /3 B ,   ,   ((  )  ,  ,3,, +( 3((    4(,,3 $ "%%% (,     ,(,   ( /3  1,  ,(, ( A (,)( 3,, (, $!G 7, ,   ,   ,  ( /3  3  /, -( , (, ,3   /3  )  / 1,    )  ,  E /3  3  5    ,3  (3    (  3      , ,3  (,  (/3B 1,E/3,

'12- %& %< $%&#),,,((( +, 67 4 ""  %"

%"

$%&#   3  , $%&#  @     E/3(3,3 (3  (,(/3B 

.$$ $%$&'),,(,,3),((   ,,,, 1( ((  ()

.$$$%$&   , ( 3 ,((  )  ,   ,3 3(  '* * ,',( ,  A, 

4, , , (( G), ,,   , (( ,    , (,  1 , 3    ,  , 3,, ( 3  ,      ,  (  1 3C,   3(    ,   ,(,   , ( /3B,(3 + E /3 1,,,(  3   , (, 33  1  E /3  ,,((,3,3, A ,    ".$ 

  ,+ 5,  

7,(,)((, (,, 3, ,,((3,33         3  @ 

, ,(  3,  ,( A,  ,  A,  ,   ".$ 

 G   , ((,),,3( /,-,(,, ,,)3(  ,,),,,

'13- ,,,,3  ,3 )(  3+     ,(  + , ".$ 

5,, && 13),33,,   , 3 ,,,  3(3 ,3 08I,   3 , ,    ,  1    3,,,(,(+3(, ((   7,   ,   ,  ,  (3,5( 7)(  @ ,(,, , ,,3( 3( 3+,3, ,,(35( &$ 1 @  ,( ,  ,,  3    (   ((   7,     ,(((,,,)(3, 3,, ( , )(   ,  

()(((,( 1@ ,(( +,(,+( ( , 3 ( 5( & 1 , ,  (  ,3,,  @) +,(3,,,,, (,,),,/,-(,,

'14- ,,,,(73, ,)( )((,,( ,( ,A,(  ( ) ,A3,3AA (  , &"

1,,( ,3,,), ,, (VINOD S. BHARDWAJ) JUDGE MAY 17, 2022     69-917:.;<7< 69-91-7=> <